Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Physician’s associate introduced as Dr at GP surgery

192 replies

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 14:16

The man I saw introduced himself as “Dr fhdjdj” so I assumed that I’d seen a GP.
Then only after the appointment I found out that my prescription was awaiting approval from a GP and that i’d actually not even seen a GP

should I write and complain?
anyone else been misled?

OP posts:
Usernamen · 11/09/2023 15:02

It’s the misleading that was unacceptable, not that a patient might be seen by a nurse practitioner or physiologist or whatever.

There are obviously some things that these professionals are qualified to do, having a problem with it is a bit unreasonable.

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:02

user1497207191 · 11/09/2023 14:50

Hang on, I thought that Blair's new GP contract 20 years ago, basically more pay for fewer hours/responsibilities was supposed to "cure the shortage of GPs". Well that's what he claimed anyway!

Followed by 20 years of real terms funding cuts.......

hazelnutlatte · 11/09/2023 15:02

Physicians associates and nurses are not the same.
An advanced nurse practitioner within a GP practice will almost always be qualified to prescribe, but physicians associates will not.
Either way, neither should be introducing themselves as Dr!

Abeli · 11/09/2023 15:01

I'm very happy to see nurse practitioner as they have years of experience and often more thorough than GP.
However I was also misled and misdiagnosed by a PA and will not see one again.
It's a relatively new thing. They have a basic degree (often bio medical science which is a popular degree for those who are not accepted at medical school). Then a two year Physician Associate course. They cannot prescribe. Even more worrying are the PA staff being employed by hospitals instead of qualified anaesthetists.

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 15:00

I was only told afterwards that I’d need to wait for a bit for my prescription to be looked at because I’d seen a physician associate

But the man I saw definitely introduced themselves as ‘Dr’ so I thought I’d seen a GP.

I feel I was lied to so not sure I trust the opinion of whoever I saw

OP posts:
Bromptotoo · 11/09/2023 15:00

user1497207191 · 11/09/2023 14:50

Hang on, I thought that Blair's new GP contract 20 years ago, basically more pay for fewer hours/responsibilities was supposed to "cure the shortage of GPs". Well that's what he claimed anyway!

It might or might not have sorted the problem at the time. Seemed a bit like Bevan's fill their mouths with gold solution in the forties.

Twenty years on and the pay's been eroded again.

DiDonk · 11/09/2023 15:00

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:41

No it’s not if they have a doctorate.

but they should say “I’m Dr Nurse Practitioner name” and make it clear they are a nurse/what their role is.

The days of seeing a doctor just because you want to are over. It’s been like this in maternity for years - many women with a straightforward low risk pregnancy will never see a doctor.

Yes but being pregnant isn't a disease, being ill is and the type of people qualified to treat illness are doctors, not YTS trainees.

Somanycats · 11/09/2023 14:59

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 14:36

nope, locum doctors can prescribe

Sorry this is wishful thinking. Locums very often can't prescribe in new surgeries. They are professionally allowed to prescribe of course, but until they are set up on the system they physically can't. In the surgery DH currently works this annoyingly takes about a month. No one knows why.

Iwasafool · 11/09/2023 14:59

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:31

Why is it ridiculous? I was a nurse practitioner for years dealing with people with cancer and I knew much more than the patient’s GP about many cancer-related interventions- GPs used to phone me for advice. HCSWs do things like test urine, carry out vital signs, take bloods etc - a well run multi disciplinary service is more cost effective and frees up the GP to do the things only they can do.

I agree. I spent a year trying to get my GP to take me seriously, he kept telling me I was depressed. Saw the nurse practitioner she immediately said she thought she knew what it was and would take blood test to confirm. She was right. I was sorry when she moved on.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:58

user1497207191 · 11/09/2023 14:48

I once was seen by a nurse practitioner for severe stomach pain. I pointed to where the pain was, which was basically, my stomach! The NP arranged for me to be admitted to hospital for an ultrasound scan and other tests and told me to get myself to A&E where they'd triage me and arrange the admittance (apparently the only way to get admitted!). So I went along, went through triage, the NP notes were on their screen, so they knew what it was about and then directed me to the ward for admittance. It was the gynae ward! But I assumed they knew what they were doing, so presented myself and waited to be examined by the gynae consultant/registrar, who duly came along, went through a long medical questionnaire, etc., and finally when it came to examining me, I pointed to exactly the same place on my stomach, and the guy just laughed and told me it was stomach not gynae, and basically told me to go away as it was nothing to do with him! So apparently, the NP didn't even know the difference in location between the stomach and the "woman's bits", so directed me to completely the wrong department!

So you are complaining about the nurse practitioner who did an assessment of your severe pain and directed you to A&E for further assessment and possible admission but quite happy with the guy who laughed at you and told you to go away?! I know who I think did a better job here.
FYI - the nurse practitioner cannot arrange direct admission - they can only direct you to the hospital and provide information to the receiving hospital. They might relay information like “suspected ovarian cyst” or whatever but it is up to the receiving hospital to arrange the admission.

And there are an infinite number of cases where doctors have got things wrong - it’s not only NPs or any other health professional for that matter.

HelpMeGetThrough · 11/09/2023 14:55

The days of seeing a doctor just because you want to are over.

The days of seeing a half competent GP in the surgery I go to are gone as well.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/09/2023 14:54

I mean, I nurses who can and do use the title, to which they are entitled, professionally. Who would degree it was "not allowed"? There's no such policy in my Trust (nor, I suspect, in any others).

All of them would also be clear about their role though. But that is something everyone in the NHS should be doing.

GotMooMilk · 11/09/2023 14:52

PAs at present cannot be NMP to my knowledge.
Complain and keep complaining. I’d rather see a nurse practitioner who you know will have worked for some time and completed a masters etc rather than a PA who have done a 2 year course and are let loose seeing patients instead of a GP. It’s terrible.

user1497207191 · 11/09/2023 14:50

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 14:49

I hope you support the junior doctor and consultant strikes? because they are the only way to stem the flow of doctors out of the UK and mean that there might be more GPs in the future...........

Hang on, I thought that Blair's new GP contract 20 years ago, basically more pay for fewer hours/responsibilities was supposed to "cure the shortage of GPs". Well that's what he claimed anyway!

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 14:49

ShepherdMoons · 11/09/2023 14:38

I can't even see my GP anymore. Always intercepted by a nurse practitioner and she's not the best. Would rather see a doctor.

In answer to your AIBU I think you're right to deserve more clarity. If someone is called Dr in a GP surgery you would expect them to be able to prescribe!

I hope you support the junior doctor and consultant strikes? because they are the only way to stem the flow of doctors out of the UK and mean that there might be more GPs in the future...........

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:48

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 14:37

that's completely different - you were an expert in your particular area.

I assume you wouldn't have tried to see unfiltered patients at a surgery?

No I wouldn’t and nor would I be successful at a job interview which involved seeing unfiltered patients at a GP surgery.

there are two issues here - one is that the person OP saw appears to have failed to properly inform the OP of their role and thus gain consent to proceed which is 100% wrong.

The other is people saying nurse practitioners are “not adequately trained” and giving out wrong advice.

At the end of the day, the nurse practitioner has applied for the role, has the necessary experience and qualifications for the role, has been successfully at interview and completed any mandatory training for the role. So to be upset only because they are not a doctor is unreasonable.

user1497207191 · 11/09/2023 14:48

I once was seen by a nurse practitioner for severe stomach pain. I pointed to where the pain was, which was basically, my stomach! The NP arranged for me to be admitted to hospital for an ultrasound scan and other tests and told me to get myself to A&E where they'd triage me and arrange the admittance (apparently the only way to get admitted!). So I went along, went through triage, the NP notes were on their screen, so they knew what it was about and then directed me to the ward for admittance. It was the gynae ward! But I assumed they knew what they were doing, so presented myself and waited to be examined by the gynae consultant/registrar, who duly came along, went through a long medical questionnaire, etc., and finally when it came to examining me, I pointed to exactly the same place on my stomach, and the guy just laughed and told me it was stomach not gynae, and basically told me to go away as it was nothing to do with him! So apparently, the NP didn't even know the difference in location between the stomach and the "woman's bits", so directed me to completely the wrong department!

PinkDaffodil2 · 11/09/2023 14:45

Please do feed back - it might be appropriate for you to see a PA depending upon your presentation, but absolutely not ok for them to be misrepresenting themselves. There was a terrible case recently where a PA missed a blood clot and the young woman believed she had seen a doctor so didn’t seek a second opinion, then passed away. Her mother thinks she would have asked to see someone else or gone to A&E if she realised it hadn’t been a GP she saw.
For those saying they might have a doctorate - plenty of medical students have a doctorate from their previous life - they obviously don’t go around introducing themselves to patients as ‘Dr x’.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 11/09/2023 14:45

Definitely complain, I wouldn't even start off with 'enquiring' or 'mentioning', and I never complain!

A person introducing themselves as Dr Smith, in a GPs surgery, while conducting a medical appointment knows exactly what the patient will think. Even if they've got a PhD, if they're not a medical Dr it's really not OK to be using that title with medical patients.

Can you look the person up on your GPs website and see how they are listed? Or Google them?

Bromptotoo · 11/09/2023 14:45

What exactly are this individual's qualifications?

It shouldn't be too difficult to find them on the practice's website. Or failing that by asking their name etc.

I don't think being seen by a Nurse Practitioner or similar as a 'gateway' and/or with a straightforward complaint is anything we should worry about. I've seen one locally a couple of times for two recurrent conditions - back pain and fungal toe nail infections. Both were just as thorough as the GP, now practice head, had been on previous occasions. Asked the right questions about back pain including ensuring poo and wee were appearing and being managed as normal - not always asked by the GP.

OTOH if somebody who has not passed the required medical training is passing themselves off as a Doctor then you have every reason to complain. However one can be a Doctor without having got GP status....

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 14:45

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:41

No it’s not if they have a doctorate.

but they should say “I’m Dr Nurse Practitioner name” and make it clear they are a nurse/what their role is.

The days of seeing a doctor just because you want to are over. It’s been like this in maternity for years - many women with a straightforward low risk pregnancy will never see a doctor.

Yes it is unacceptable Confused. A plumber with a doctorate calling himself Dr. causes no confusion because you aren't asking him for medical advice.
A non medical doctor in a doctors surgery calling himself Dr. is deliberate misrepresentation, because the obvious conclusion is that they're a doctor of medicine.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:41

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 14:37

They introduced themselves as Dr X. That's unacceptable.

No it’s not if they have a doctorate.

but they should say “I’m Dr Nurse Practitioner name” and make it clear they are a nurse/what their role is.

The days of seeing a doctor just because you want to are over. It’s been like this in maternity for years - many women with a straightforward low risk pregnancy will never see a doctor.

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 14:40

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:39

Nonsense! It’s not some random off the street doling out medical advice - nurse practitioners are “adequately trained” for the role.

It’s fair enough to highlight that the person did not properly explain who they were/their role but complaining that they weren’t a doctor will get you nowhere as this is the model being used across healthcare now.

Rubbish. She's complaining that they misrepresented themselves as a doctor,not that they weren't a doctor.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 14:39

YouHoooo · 11/09/2023 14:29

Please do complain.

I had a terrible experience with a physicians associate - like you I only discovered that they weren’t properly qualified after the event.

There’s potential for real danger here if people are following advice that has very little to back it up.

Nonsense! It’s not some random off the street doling out medical advice - nurse practitioners are “adequately trained” for the role.

It’s fair enough to highlight that the person did not properly explain who they were/their role but complaining that they weren’t a doctor will get you nowhere as this is the model being used across healthcare now.

ShepherdMoons · 11/09/2023 14:38

I can't even see my GP anymore. Always intercepted by a nurse practitioner and she's not the best. Would rather see a doctor.

In answer to your AIBU I think you're right to deserve more clarity. If someone is called Dr in a GP surgery you would expect them to be able to prescribe!