Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Physician’s associate introduced as Dr at GP surgery

192 replies

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 14:16

The man I saw introduced himself as “Dr fhdjdj” so I assumed that I’d seen a GP.
Then only after the appointment I found out that my prescription was awaiting approval from a GP and that i’d actually not even seen a GP

should I write and complain?
anyone else been misled?

OP posts:
mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:36

@mycoffeecup usually in F2 I believe. They have to do a community based rotation at some point.

tt9 · 11/09/2023 15:36

health care professionals have a duty of candour- i.e to be honest with patients not just about any mistakes but about the remit of their specialisation. so they should always introduce themselves as name and role to avoid confusion. most of the doctors I know, many of them senior consultants never refer to themselves as Dr so and so when introducing themselves- instead they say hello I am first name I am one of the surgical/medical etc. doctors. nurses/PAs/advanced care practioners I know do the same. I know quite a few pHDs and none of them introduce themselves as Dr as it makes them sound like a twat show off.
one would think given the recent issues with PAs, they would be more careful?! definitely complain OP

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:35

F1 doctors, who are qualified, after 5-6 years training, do not need to get their prescriptions signed off. They do the job of a doctor as that is what they are.
PAs are not. They have 2 years post grad training, can not prescribe or order certain scans. Unfortunately a few seem to think they are better qualified than the doctors. And the NHS is starting to think this too, giving PAs roles that doctors should be doing. It's not even like they are cheaper (£40,000 starting salary against £29,000 for a doctor). It seems someone wants our staff to be less trained in the NHS. Because then they can't leave to go abroad (as their qualifications are not recognised).
Nurse practitioners are very different and are highly qualified nurses with many year's experience in certain fields. They can prescribe.
It is a criminal offence in this country to represent yourself as a medical doctor if you are not.

GadgetArms · 11/09/2023 15:34

I am a non medical prescriber. I always make my title clear to patients (also wear a clearly identifying uniform).

There are two things that concern me about PAs:

  1. The lack of regulation. They are not currently regulated by a professional body, genuinely don't know what happens in cases of clinical negligence, it's not like they can be struck from a register.
  1. Seeing undifferentiated patients. I see clearly differentiated patients within my scope of practice. Seeing patients with any condition with any number of comorbidities takes training, skill and experience. I'm not convinced it can be taught it 2 years.
mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:34

Toytransportemergency · 11/09/2023 15:32

FY1s can prescribe in hospitals.
I’m not sure you would get them in a GP surgery as it is very much a training grade although they are qualified doctors.

Many years ago I did a GP PRHO job (the equivalent of FY1) - but I had to get my prescriptions counter-signed. I'm pretty sure FY1 jobs in primary care aren't a thing now.

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 15:33

Oh, who cares whether he had a PhD or not? By that logic, the window cleaner could sit behind a desk and mislead a patient into believing he was qualified to treat them by introducing himself as Dr. X.
Ridiculously disingenuous...

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:33

nerdandgeek · 11/09/2023 15:16

I have a complex medication regime for my bipolar (stable for years). A physicians assistant wanted to change it- I said no thank you the mental health team do that you are not a dr.
They are a cheaper way for the NHS to bring in clinicians and they shouldn't be calling them drs

Govt like them because the qualification isn't recognised abroad, and no-one would pay privately to see them, so they can't leave the NHS.

Toytransportemergency · 11/09/2023 15:32

FY1s can prescribe in hospitals.
I’m not sure you would get them in a GP surgery as it is very much a training grade although they are qualified doctors.

morelippy · 11/09/2023 15:31

All qualified doctors spend several years as doctors in a hospital. They undergo GP training only after they've gained some hospital experience.

While they are training to be GPs they are of course supervised. It just means their practise is being overseen by your more experienced general practitioners. No
Doctor would introduce someone as a doctor unless they were.

SpringNotSprung · 11/09/2023 15:30

It isn't just GP's and Physician's assistants is it though. There's also a huge issue in relation to HCA's presenting themselves and being presented as nurses. My GP practice refers to the HCA as the nurse.

It's high time there is absolute consistency across the NHS in the context of uniforms, name badges and introductions.

"Hello, I'm Jane Smith, GP Partner"
"Hello, I'm Susan Jones, salaried GP"
"Hello, I'm Fred Brown, Physician's Associate"
"Hello, I'm Mary White, Practice Nurse and/or Nurse Practitioner"
"Hello, I'm Ann Davis, HCA/phlebotomist"

I think it would help and it would also sweep away some of the patriarchy of doctors using patients' first names whilst introducing themselves with a title. It's just so mid 20th Century.

ChocHotolate · 11/09/2023 15:26

This is really bad. I am a nurse practitioner and I always make it very clear to pt's when I introduce myself at the beginning of the consultation. You cannot give informed consent if you do not know who you are talking to

Ozziedream · 11/09/2023 15:22

Please do complain. I work with (medical) Drs who would also like you to complain. It is misleading and leads to a breakdown in trust and confidence which is essential in a healthcare setting.

the gentleman may well have had a PhD in which case he should have said “I am Dr [Smith], I have a PhD in [pharmacology] and work in the practice as a physicians associate”

I think in future there will be a lot more PAs with science PhDs (as it is a well remunerated profession and often better paid than scientific post doc work) and the nhs needs to understand how these professionals can introduce themselves without misleading people

MsRosley · 11/09/2023 15:22

I'd put in a formal complaint.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 11/09/2023 15:21

Throwncrumbs · 11/09/2023 14:27

i think there’s no such thing as a GP anymore, my service seems to be run by nurse practitioners and hca…it’s ridiculous!

Edited

I actually think that it is better this way.

A lot of what GPs were doing was admin and routine tests.

Wishiwasatailor · 11/09/2023 15:20

Faircastle · 11/09/2023 15:03

Was it definitely a physician associate?

Many GP practices have doctors who are in the foundation stage of their training. They have an MBBS therefore have the title Dr. They are not yet fully registered so their prescriptions need to be signed off by someone who is. I have been treated by couple of different ones and have been happy with the care I have received.

This. Does the receptionist actually know who is the PA/FY1 and know the difference between the types of training etc.

I’ve met many receptionists who don’t know what a GP/doctors training is. they know that PAs can’t prescribe ergo all staff who can’t prescribe are PAs

Banaltra · 11/09/2023 15:19

Please try and refrain from mixing Nurse Practitioners in with Physicians Associates in arguments about PAs. The former are registered to a professional body and are either non medical prescribing or able to prescribe under Patient Group Directive.
PA are not registered to any professional body yet and are not allowed to prescribe or PGD.
Only a doctor should be using the title Dr in a clinical setting, even if they are a PHD.

nerdandgeek · 11/09/2023 15:16

I have a complex medication regime for my bipolar (stable for years). A physicians assistant wanted to change it- I said no thank you the mental health team do that you are not a dr.
They are a cheaper way for the NHS to bring in clinicians and they shouldn't be calling them drs

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 11/09/2023 15:14

That isn't acceptable. I have had similar issues with having to see the "nurse"; only it turns out, she wasn't a nurse, she was a healthcare support worker. As I thought she was a nurse (she introduced herself as one and the receptionist said she had booked me in with the nurse) I asked her a couple of questions regarding my potential condition and she gave me medical advice. Advice which she wasn't qualified to give and advice which wasn't entirely accurate.

I'm a nurse myself although mental health qualified, so it wasn't my area of expertise. But how she was relaying information to me and acting got my suspicions up so I did a little digging. I brought it up with the surgery (I didn't complain however I did advise them that I didn't think it was appropriate that an unregistered member of staff was masquerading as a fully qualified nurse and giving out medical advice that she isn't qualified to) and I did hear back from them. However they simply stated that she was qualified to do what she was doing that day. Yes, taking my blood and advising me on what would happen if the results flagged up an issue, but not qualified to give me the advice that she did give me!

As patients, we are entitled to know who we are being treated/being given advice by. If we aren't treated honestly and respectfully then we need to flag it up.

ColleenDonaghy · 11/09/2023 15:14

YANBU, please complain.

There have been a few threads about this and as someone with zero medical training I find it quite worrying. A nurse practitioner may well have a doctorate, but I'm sure they're introducing themselves as nurse practitioners, and the presence of the word "nurse" makes it clear to the patient. My understanding is also that they have far far more training than a PA.

You should never be left in any doubt about who you have seen.

AnSolas · 11/09/2023 15:13

Glovesandscarf · 11/09/2023 14:20

It is possible the person you saw has a phd which does mean they can use Dr, although in the circumstances it seems a bit off. Maybe not complain (if you were otherwise happy with the care) but enquire?
having said that I’m Astonished a PA isn’t a non medical prescriber.

Not in a professional medical appointment that is deception and not getting informed consent from the person.

The HCP may be able to deal with the person's medical needs but has not been truthful and in the OP'a case will have undermined her confidence in the pratice as a whole.

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:13

Somanycats · 11/09/2023 14:59

Sorry this is wishful thinking. Locums very often can't prescribe in new surgeries. They are professionally allowed to prescribe of course, but until they are set up on the system they physically can't. In the surgery DH currently works this annoyingly takes about a month. No one knows why.

That's extremely unusual - any locum with an NHS smart card should be able to prescribe instantly. Does your DH's surgery not have a competent practice manager?

slopsan · 11/09/2023 15:06

@2023forme

I am in exactly the same situation.
I never introduce myself to patients as Dr Slopsan

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 15:03

jolaylasofia · 11/09/2023 15:02

just because they are not a gp doesn't mean they aren't entitled to use the title Dr. They probably have a phd

I found it very misleading and don’t think it’s right. They’ve lost all my trust

OP posts:
Faircastle · 11/09/2023 15:03

Was it definitely a physician associate?

Many GP practices have doctors who are in the foundation stage of their training. They have an MBBS therefore have the title Dr. They are not yet fully registered so their prescriptions need to be signed off by someone who is. I have been treated by couple of different ones and have been happy with the care I have received.

jolaylasofia · 11/09/2023 15:02

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 14:16

The man I saw introduced himself as “Dr fhdjdj” so I assumed that I’d seen a GP.
Then only after the appointment I found out that my prescription was awaiting approval from a GP and that i’d actually not even seen a GP

should I write and complain?
anyone else been misled?

just because they are not a gp doesn't mean they aren't entitled to use the title Dr. They probably have a phd