Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Physician’s associate introduced as Dr at GP surgery

192 replies

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 14:16

The man I saw introduced himself as “Dr fhdjdj” so I assumed that I’d seen a GP.
Then only after the appointment I found out that my prescription was awaiting approval from a GP and that i’d actually not even seen a GP

should I write and complain?
anyone else been misled?

OP posts:
FixTheBone · 11/09/2023 17:00

JaneTheVirgin · 11/09/2023 16:04

I'm also an Advanced practice Nurse Practitioner who xan prescribe, with a PHD, so could go by Dr. TheVirgin, and do in my non-work life.

However at work (Hospital, not GP) I introduce myself as 'Jane TheVirgin, the Nurse Practitioner caring for you today'. My photo ID is clearly visible and says Nurse Practitioner though I do have a sticker over my surname.

I do think it's misleading. But I'm also not sure what the answer is, because they are legally entitled to use their title and knowing some of the attitudes, wouldn't agree not to.

Maybe if they are a PHD, we change it so they have to have their ID visible, which it should be anyway, and they must introduce themselves as 'Dr. Smith, the Physicians Associate'. Though I do also see if someone isn't clear on the new positions they'd still assume qualified medical Dr, GP and just not know what a Physicians Associate is.

I really don't understand WANTING to be mistaken for a medical doctor in a hospital. I got my PHD for knowledge, I do not want to be as responsible as a medical doctor at all.

Misrepresenting themselves as a medical practitioner is actually a criminal offence under the medical act 1983.

There's a pretty good argument that introducing themselves as doctor, whilst in a medical setting, most people would assume they are a medically qualified doctor registered with the GMC.

So, potentially a criminal offence, and I'd therefore argue that they are not legally entitled to use Dr in a medical setting, unless they qualify the difference, and in fact are legally obliged not to use the term Doctor, unless they explicitly explain that they are a medical doctor.

Cloudysky81 · 11/09/2023 16:59

You should complain it's intentionally misleading. You should know who you are seeing and their role.
Some PAs( I don't know if this one) do a one year online doctorate so they can use the Dr title. Being wiling to mislead people to that level does raise probity concerns for me.

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 16:51

Let's hope so. It's scary to think we will not be treated by doctors in the future, but people with a 2 year thing.
We need qualified staff to stay. And they won't if this is not sorted. Fast.

kittensinthekitchen · 11/09/2023 16:44

So strange there's been so many of these threads lately, always started by a 'new poster'. Is there some sort of campaign going?

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 16:42

I think @HarrietJet is right. So many of the roles and skills which could be pushed down the line were shifted years ago-we've had 25 years of role and skill mix, and the roles exist. PAs is a different case, and with a different political mindset behind it.

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 16:20

@mycoffeecup 😊 that makes sense. Can see I'm not a doctor, just the mum of one.

GadgetArms · 11/09/2023 16:07

A PP made the excellent point about training non exportable prescribers. It seems that this is what it is about.

My qualification as a healthcare professional is exportable but my prescribing qualification is not. Many countries do not allow my profession to prescribe at all.

Doctors are bound by no such hindrance and their skills are open to the highest bidder (which is not currently the UK). The issue will only get worse as we lose doctors to countries who value them more.

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 16:06

2023forme · 11/09/2023 15:51

Not everyone who goes to the GP is ill/has a disease. Could be they need their ears syringed or be looking for a referal for genetic counselling or something. Even something like a 'sore back' will not necessarily be seen by a doctor- could be a physiotherapist. And it is very insulting to call highly qualified nurse practitioners YTS trainees.

Most of those patients would be seen by a nurse, though, not a non doctor introducing themselves as a doctor.
It's not a "must be treated by a doctor" thing at all, it's an ability to be fully aware of exactly who you're being treated by thing.

Sodthebloodypicnic · 11/09/2023 16:04

Report complain flame on Google reviews. Even if they have a PhD it's completely unacceptable and misleading to call yourself doctor, in a GP SURGERY if you aren't one.

Absolute scam artists.

JaneTheVirgin · 11/09/2023 16:04

I'm also an Advanced practice Nurse Practitioner who xan prescribe, with a PHD, so could go by Dr. TheVirgin, and do in my non-work life.

However at work (Hospital, not GP) I introduce myself as 'Jane TheVirgin, the Nurse Practitioner caring for you today'. My photo ID is clearly visible and says Nurse Practitioner though I do have a sticker over my surname.

I do think it's misleading. But I'm also not sure what the answer is, because they are legally entitled to use their title and knowing some of the attitudes, wouldn't agree not to.

Maybe if they are a PHD, we change it so they have to have their ID visible, which it should be anyway, and they must introduce themselves as 'Dr. Smith, the Physicians Associate'. Though I do also see if someone isn't clear on the new positions they'd still assume qualified medical Dr, GP and just not know what a Physicians Associate is.

I really don't understand WANTING to be mistaken for a medical doctor in a hospital. I got my PHD for knowledge, I do not want to be as responsible as a medical doctor at all.

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 16:02

Diospyros · 11/09/2023 15:37

FY1 doctors can prescribe even though they only have provisional registration with the GMC for the first year. Prescribing drugs is pretty much one of their main drudge jobs on the wards in hospital...

Medical students can't prescribe and it is possible that you could have been seen by a medical student on clinical placement who took your history then scuttled off to present it to a doctor. I hope that isn't the case for OP though as a medical student would be in serious trouble for misrepresenting themselves as a doctor.

It was definitely a physician associate. I’ve double checked the name on the practice website

OP posts:
YouOKHun · 11/09/2023 15:59

jolaylasofia · 11/09/2023 15:02

just because they are not a gp doesn't mean they aren't entitled to use the title Dr. They probably have a phd

But using the title “Dr” in a medical setting when you have, for example, a philosophy PhD, is highly misleading and presumably they would be aware that the patient before them would be taking that to mean they are a medical doctor because of the setting. I’ve been in a non medically qualified clinical role and we were always very clear with patients about exactly what are role was and exactly where are expertise started and stopped. It’s really important.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 15:59

SpringNotSprung · 11/09/2023 15:30

It isn't just GP's and Physician's assistants is it though. There's also a huge issue in relation to HCA's presenting themselves and being presented as nurses. My GP practice refers to the HCA as the nurse.

It's high time there is absolute consistency across the NHS in the context of uniforms, name badges and introductions.

"Hello, I'm Jane Smith, GP Partner"
"Hello, I'm Susan Jones, salaried GP"
"Hello, I'm Fred Brown, Physician's Associate"
"Hello, I'm Mary White, Practice Nurse and/or Nurse Practitioner"
"Hello, I'm Ann Davis, HCA/phlebotomist"

I think it would help and it would also sweep away some of the patriarchy of doctors using patients' first names whilst introducing themselves with a title. It's just so mid 20th Century.

They already do in my health board - can't speak for everyone though. Interestingly in our place, the staff least likely to wears theirs are the senior medial staff.

Physician’s associate introduced as Dr at GP surgery
2023forme · 11/09/2023 15:51

DiDonk · 11/09/2023 15:00

Yes but being pregnant isn't a disease, being ill is and the type of people qualified to treat illness are doctors, not YTS trainees.

Not everyone who goes to the GP is ill/has a disease. Could be they need their ears syringed or be looking for a referal for genetic counselling or something. Even something like a 'sore back' will not necessarily be seen by a doctor- could be a physiotherapist. And it is very insulting to call highly qualified nurse practitioners YTS trainees.

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:46

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:43

Some days there is no consultant to be found, as they are busy in surgery. When on call they just get on with it on their own. I assume the consultant gets his stamp and just adds it to hers late in the day ?
Supervision seems to mean there is someone somewhere in the hospital to help you.
If you can find them !

they don't literally supervise each script - just medicolegally the consultant holds some of the responsibility

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:45

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 15:43

The more PAs we have, and the fewer doctors, we will get to a position where there are so many of them that they cannot be properly supervised by the very qualified doctors who are supposed to be supervising them. First, there won't be enough doctors to supervise , second, they'll be too bloody busy with their own complex cases and , third, they'll be clearing up and prescribing for the PAs. The dismayed doctors I know say that they will not sign off on plenty of PA work unless they've seen it, as "Ive prescribed antibiotics for Bills rash" could easily mean " Ive prescribed antibiotics for a guy who in fact has a blood clot". For which the doctor is legally responsible.

I expect hospital management will be keen, though. What a fuck up. Even more doctors are bound to leave as a result.

That isn't quite the same as advanced practice nurses working with people with stable long term conditions.

yes, I won't sign for a PA unless I've seen the patient myself

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:44

Faircastle · 11/09/2023 15:37

F1 doctors can prescribe, but their prescriptions are supervised by a fully registered doctor.

Many foundation training programmes these days include a primary care placement.

Edited

F1 doctors can prescribe and do so in hospital, with the nominal supervision of their consultant
An F1 doing a GP placement would have to get their scripts signed by someone else.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 15:43

The more PAs we have, and the fewer doctors, we will get to a position where there are so many of them that they cannot be properly supervised by the very qualified doctors who are supposed to be supervising them. First, there won't be enough doctors to supervise , second, they'll be too bloody busy with their own complex cases and , third, they'll be clearing up and prescribing for the PAs. The dismayed doctors I know say that they will not sign off on plenty of PA work unless they've seen it, as "Ive prescribed antibiotics for Bills rash" could easily mean " Ive prescribed antibiotics for a guy who in fact has a blood clot". For which the doctor is legally responsible.

I expect hospital management will be keen, though. What a fuck up. Even more doctors are bound to leave as a result.

That isn't quite the same as advanced practice nurses working with people with stable long term conditions.

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:43

Some days there is no consultant to be found, as they are busy in surgery. When on call they just get on with it on their own. I assume the consultant gets his stamp and just adds it to hers late in the day ?
Supervision seems to mean there is someone somewhere in the hospital to help you.
If you can find them !

Faircastle · 11/09/2023 15:37

Toytransportemergency · 11/09/2023 15:32

FY1s can prescribe in hospitals.
I’m not sure you would get them in a GP surgery as it is very much a training grade although they are qualified doctors.

F1 doctors can prescribe, but their prescriptions are supervised by a fully registered doctor.

Many foundation training programmes these days include a primary care placement.

Diospyros · 11/09/2023 15:37

Faircastle · 11/09/2023 15:03

Was it definitely a physician associate?

Many GP practices have doctors who are in the foundation stage of their training. They have an MBBS therefore have the title Dr. They are not yet fully registered so their prescriptions need to be signed off by someone who is. I have been treated by couple of different ones and have been happy with the care I have received.

FY1 doctors can prescribe even though they only have provisional registration with the GMC for the first year. Prescribing drugs is pretty much one of their main drudge jobs on the wards in hospital...

Medical students can't prescribe and it is possible that you could have been seen by a medical student on clinical placement who took your history then scuttled off to present it to a doctor. I hope that isn't the case for OP though as a medical student would be in serious trouble for misrepresenting themselves as a doctor.

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:37

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:36

@mycoffeecup usually in F2 I believe. They have to do a community based rotation at some point.

yes exactly - F2, by which time they are fully registered - in F1 they are only provisionally registered.

mycoffeecup · 11/09/2023 15:37

mumsneedwine · 11/09/2023 15:35

F1 doctors, who are qualified, after 5-6 years training, do not need to get their prescriptions signed off. They do the job of a doctor as that is what they are.
PAs are not. They have 2 years post grad training, can not prescribe or order certain scans. Unfortunately a few seem to think they are better qualified than the doctors. And the NHS is starting to think this too, giving PAs roles that doctors should be doing. It's not even like they are cheaper (£40,000 starting salary against £29,000 for a doctor). It seems someone wants our staff to be less trained in the NHS. Because then they can't leave to go abroad (as their qualifications are not recognised).
Nurse practitioners are very different and are highly qualified nurses with many year's experience in certain fields. They can prescribe.
It is a criminal offence in this country to represent yourself as a medical doctor if you are not.

They would do if working in primary care. In a hospital, their scripts are all done under the supervision of a consultant - in effect the consultant countersigns them all, but they don't actually follow them round the ward and sign them all!

A first year dr cannot prescribe in primary care as they aren't fully registered and I think that's why GP posts for first year doctors died out.

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 15:36

It's not even like they are cheaper (£40,000 starting salary against £29,000 for a doctor)
That's appalling 😱

Swipe left for the next trending thread