Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Physician’s associate introduced as Dr at GP surgery

192 replies

Elenor444 · 11/09/2023 14:16

The man I saw introduced himself as “Dr fhdjdj” so I assumed that I’d seen a GP.
Then only after the appointment I found out that my prescription was awaiting approval from a GP and that i’d actually not even seen a GP

should I write and complain?
anyone else been misled?

OP posts:
Blondewithredlips · 12/09/2023 03:05

FixTheBone · 11/09/2023 17:00

Misrepresenting themselves as a medical practitioner is actually a criminal offence under the medical act 1983.

There's a pretty good argument that introducing themselves as doctor, whilst in a medical setting, most people would assume they are a medically qualified doctor registered with the GMC.

So, potentially a criminal offence, and I'd therefore argue that they are not legally entitled to use Dr in a medical setting, unless they qualify the difference, and in fact are legally obliged not to use the term Doctor, unless they explicitly explain that they are a medical doctor.

This

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 12/09/2023 02:56

The point is, a clinical psychologist, for example, is a protected allied health profession Their skills are to be respected. That does not make them medical doctors, and they don't have a medical qualification or registration. If they call themselves doctor in a clinical setting, to giver the impression that they are medically trained (which is what they would in effect be implying), they are breaking the law.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 12/09/2023 02:46

A psychologist is an allied health professional, in the same way as a physiotherapist is. Not a doctor.

www.hcpc-uk.org/news-and-events/blog/2023/understanding-the-regulation-of-psychologists/

Yazz1212 · 11/09/2023 22:27

Yes but this is an unusual circumstance. A GP in general is definitely more likely to pick up on heart failure than a midwife as they are more qualified. Just as a midwife is more likely to spot complications during labour as they are more qualified.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 22:24

Yazz1212 · 11/09/2023 22:19

I'm a doctor and I find this very concerning. My younger sister attended the GP and was met with a PA who incorrectly diagnosed her. She attended for chest pain related to anxiety and the PA diagnosed reflux. Honestly I was astonished. She introduced herself as a doctor and my parents would have thought twice if she introduced herself correctly.

People treat doctors as though they are more qualified because they are more qualified. This does not discount the job of others. I personally feel that most PAs are not supported enough in their job roles and unfortunately do not know what they do not know.

My GP misdiagnosed my heart failure - it was a midwife who urgently referred me to A&E after twice being told by my GP that I had an infection (I was 4 days post partum). Mistakes happen in all professions.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 22:21

Oblomov23 · 11/09/2023 19:15

It all Comes down to money. It's a disgrace. They get non qualified people to fill in, fill a gap
In the nhs. The cost is to us!

ACP

See this article. It's just a money cutting thing by nhs. Disgraceful.

GPs (more so in England) are essentially self-employed and GP practices follow a small business model. So if you are not happy with the use of APs or ANPs or whatever, they are employed at your practice because the GP/practice has implemented this model. It’s not “the NHS” forcing it onto GPs. It may be that the practice is having difficulty attracting/retaining GPs or it may be that the use of nurses/PAs has been deemed a cost effective way to run the practice/business. But either way, the GPs have permitted it.

Yazz1212 · 11/09/2023 22:19

I'm a doctor and I find this very concerning. My younger sister attended the GP and was met with a PA who incorrectly diagnosed her. She attended for chest pain related to anxiety and the PA diagnosed reflux. Honestly I was astonished. She introduced herself as a doctor and my parents would have thought twice if she introduced herself correctly.

People treat doctors as though they are more qualified because they are more qualified. This does not discount the job of others. I personally feel that most PAs are not supported enough in their job roles and unfortunately do not know what they do not know.

2023forme · 11/09/2023 22:10

HarrietJet · 11/09/2023 16:06

Most of those patients would be seen by a nurse, though, not a non doctor introducing themselves as a doctor.
It's not a "must be treated by a doctor" thing at all, it's an ability to be fully aware of exactly who you're being treated by thing.

I agree and said so in my previous posts.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/09/2023 22:08

Coffeewinecake · 11/09/2023 21:43

Psychologists may use the title Dr but they are not a doctor.
Can you really not see the difference? The training, the qualifications and the job is completely different.

They are not a medical doctor but they are a doctor.

It's a field I work in, I clearly understand the difference between the roles, I am only pointing out that there is no way to move to a world where only medical doctors use the title doctor, as other professional groups also use this title.

So the only feasible solution is professionals saying who they are as part of their introduction. Which is what I believe all healthcare professionals should do.

TrishTrix · 11/09/2023 22:00

As an anaesthetist who introduces herself as Dr Trish Trix the anaesthetic doctor (given up on using consultant) and then gets called nurse regularly I have concluded patients haven't got a clue about who does what in a healthcare setting and what training we have. I was once asked about whether or not my patient (post GCSE) could apply for "anaesthetic" training and when I mentioned needing to go to medical school the parent said "well that would be a huge waste of time to just be an anaesthetist". Laugh. Inner cry.

I'm genuinely very very concerned about PAs using their PhD (or lesser DMSc titles) to introduce themselves as doctors. I've only really heard about this in GP but it may well be happening in hospitals too.

As a patient if you are in any doubt at all ask who you are seeing - it's probably worth knowing that the protected term is registered medical practitioner. Using that if you aren't GMC registered is illegal.

OP I would definitely complain and it is high time the PAs were registered to a code of practice.

I've had one atttempt mislead me too and it was only after I clarified whether or not she was actually a GP that I understood my phone appt was with the PA. In this case I was happy to consult with them but I did expect to know who I was consulting with.

My medical records are plastered with my job role (I live in a deprived area and I know from previous conversations with one of the actual GPs it's a bit of a novelty for the practice to have a doctor patient) and so is the most recent correspondence about my as I sustained an injury that had implications for my job so it was mentioned a lot in the letters from the hospital specialists/ rehab people I saw.

Coffeewinecake · 11/09/2023 21:43

Psychologists may use the title Dr but they are not a doctor.
Can you really not see the difference? The training, the qualifications and the job is completely different.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/09/2023 21:13

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 21:02

A psychologist is not a psychiatrist. The latter is a doctor. To call a psychologist a doctor is ridiculous. And have you seen the variety in psychology degrees? Added to which, there are 6 or more branches of psychology after degree level, and they all lead to different jobs. None of which is a doctor.

Really, this thread is getting silly now. Why not call everyone a doctor, including the hca, and have done with it?!

But psychologists are doctors and that is their standard title.

That's what I'm trying to say, this is an area I work in and it is absolutely normal for the title doctor to be used. You can dislike it, but I doubt it is going to change.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/09/2023 21:09

ThingthatgoesFFSinthenight · 11/09/2023 18:43

Stompythedinosaur · Today 18:00

Because all psychologists are doctors? That's their title?

Clinical Psychologists have Dr as title as they do an undergrad degree in psychology and the a Doctorate of Clinical Psychology.

Some graduate psychologists might do an academic PhD in which case they can use ‘Dr’.

Some educational and counselling psychologists have doctorate level training too now.

An undergraduate degree in psychology doesn’t give you Dr as a title.

‘psychologist’ isn’t a protected title and anyone can use it.

You can only call yourself a Clinical Psychologist with doctorate level specific training.

I'm aware psychologist isn't a protected term, nor is nurse or doctor for that matter (though registered nurse and medical doctor are).

However I think it's fair to assume someone employed in the NHS as a psychologist is a clinical psychologist, forensic psychologist or educational psychologist. They are a doctor.

A graduate of a psychology degree is not the same thing at all.

All I'm saying is that there are clearly multiple profession's who use the title, so clarity in describing your role is vital.

Equally, both an F1 and a medical consultant can use the title dr, but you need to know which one is treating you. They aren't the same.

If everyone introduced themselves by name and role, this wouldn't be an issue. That's what I think we need.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 11/09/2023 21:02

A psychologist is not a psychiatrist. The latter is a doctor. To call a psychologist a doctor is ridiculous. And have you seen the variety in psychology degrees? Added to which, there are 6 or more branches of psychology after degree level, and they all lead to different jobs. None of which is a doctor.

Really, this thread is getting silly now. Why not call everyone a doctor, including the hca, and have done with it?!

HermioneKipper · 11/09/2023 19:59

ChimpyChops · 11/09/2023 19:10

But I am assuming you wouldn't tar all paramedic practitioners with the same brush? - it isn't a case of them being a paramedic, a GP could also have missed it.

I am also assuming they didn't introduce themselves as 'Dr Paramedic'.

I clearly said it was a paramedic.

I mentioned it as there’s clearly a trend for less GPs similar to many other experiences on this thread.

A doctor would be much less likely to miss double pneumonia I suspect.

Oblomov23 · 11/09/2023 19:47

"ACPs are experienced healthcare professionals who are state-registered (eg nurses, physiotherapists, paramedics, pharmacists). We undergo a clinical and academic training."

Many of them are nurses. Who go through extra training. I'm not disputing they are good at what they do. But don't ever EVER pass yourself off as, imply, suggest that you are a Doctor. Because you aren't. And to infer that you are, anything close, is insulting to both Doctors, the training they do go through. And more so, to the intellect of us as nhs patients.

It's an absolute insult to my fucxing intellect as a human being. AngryAngryAngryAngryAngryAngryAngryAngryAngryAngry

MillyMollyMardy · 11/09/2023 19:46

@Stompythedinosaur dentists can use the title as a courtesy but our guidelines are very clear. The GDC, the Advertising Standards Authority and Trading Standards believe that the use of the title carries the risk of misleading patients into believing that the user is a medical doctor so it must be made clear that we are dentists not medical doctors.
Maxillofacial consultants are usually qualified as both dentists and doctors.

Seashellies · 11/09/2023 19:20

ChimpyChops · 11/09/2023 18:00

Absolutely this.

I find it very insulting to the many health care professionals who have undergone extra training (master's degrees/clinical examination competencies and so forth) to be told that they only people who can treat illnesses are 'doctors'. Advanced clinical practitioners are fully competent in diagnosing and treating illness. Many can also prescribe.

YTS trainees indeed 🤔

I'm a nurse and I've worked with very competent and knowledgeable ACPs. I would always want to see a GP myself unless it was ongoing management of an existing condition, even then it should be very clear of the title of who you are seeing without ambiguity; that doesn't mean I don't respect other healthcare professionals or that it's an insult to suggest that for some things doctors and the training and experience they have is better.

Only a doctor should be using the title Dr in a clinical setting, even if they are a PHD.

I agree. I used to work with a midwife who had a PhD who insisted on referring to herself and getting others to refer to her as Dr. Fine outside of a hospital/healthcare setting but misleading in front of patients and colleagues.

Oblomov23 · 11/09/2023 19:15

It all Comes down to money. It's a disgrace. They get non qualified people to fill in, fill a gap
In the nhs. The cost is to us!

ACP

See this article. It's just a money cutting thing by nhs. Disgraceful.

ChimpyChops · 11/09/2023 19:10

HermioneKipper · 11/09/2023 18:17

I’d complain about this too - they shouldn’t be introducing themselves as doctors if they aren’t.

My mum was seen by a paramedic at the GPs surgery a while ago as there were no GPs in that day?! And he missed that she had pneumonia in both lungs 😡

But I am assuming you wouldn't tar all paramedic practitioners with the same brush? - it isn't a case of them being a paramedic, a GP could also have missed it.

I am also assuming they didn't introduce themselves as 'Dr Paramedic'.

LivStanshall · 11/09/2023 18:56

Coffeewinecake · 11/09/2023 18:11

Yes, dentists also

but in a medical setting the title Dr is automatically equated to the noun doctor.

Lastly, as you know, Dr Psychiatrist is different from Dr Psychologist

Of course psychologists should use title Dr. You would just say I’m Dr Stanshall and I am your psychologist. It tells the patient their status and that is important.

Grmumpy · 11/09/2023 18:50

Definitely complain. There was a case recently in north London. A young woman died. Her parents raised a big fuss. The girl was seen twice by a person who called themselves a medic..she assumed gp…wrong diagnosis resulted in her death.

ThingthatgoesFFSinthenight · 11/09/2023 18:43

Stompythedinosaur · Today 18:00

Because all psychologists are doctors? That's their title?

Clinical Psychologists have Dr as title as they do an undergrad degree in psychology and the a Doctorate of Clinical Psychology.

Some graduate psychologists might do an academic PhD in which case they can use ‘Dr’.

Some educational and counselling psychologists have doctorate level training too now.

An undergraduate degree in psychology doesn’t give you Dr as a title.

‘psychologist’ isn’t a protected title and anyone can use it.

You can only call yourself a Clinical Psychologist with doctorate level specific training.

SingingKlingon · 11/09/2023 18:36

I think a lot of posters are getting confided between physician associates (PAs) and advanced nurse practitioners (ANPs).

My GPs surgery has a PA and patients seem to be very confused and think they are seeing a real GP. Personally I think it's an awful model.

Coffeewinecake · 11/09/2023 18:35

Stompythedinosaur · 11/09/2023 18:20

Dentists are another good example, they use the title dr.

Yes, I said that in my previous post
I also have issue with them using introducing themselves with the title Dr in a hospital setting.
It’s less of a concern when they are in specific dental department within a hospital and quite obvious in a general dental practice

Swipe left for the next trending thread