Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these things don’t matter and you should save money for dc instead?

256 replies

leapgro · 11/09/2023 09:52

Genuinely interested as to whether it affects them etc.

DC coming up to 1, lots of people having big parties, even balloons costs 20 quid let alone everything else. Hiring venues etc. Same with expensive baby clothes, trips to legoland etc. Surely unless you enjoy this yourself/have enough money to waste, it’s not actually beneficial for the child? Or is it? Am I wrong?

OP posts:
housethatbuiltme · 11/09/2023 13:06

Notjustabrunette · 11/09/2023 12:49

Haven’t read everyone’s replies, but I didn’t do parties for my kids until reception age. Before that we would have close family and friends round our house for a buffet and cake. Had a few balloons, but nothing fancy. Started going to theme parks when my oldest was 4 and youngest was 2. They are 7 and 9 now and have only been to 4.
I would say that for babies and toddlers they might enjoy these things, but there are cheaper alternatives which they would enjoy just as much.

Sorry to pick on you but several people have said similar to your post but you basically just posted.

'We don't do parties instead we just... THROW A PARTY'.

having guests, buffet, birthday cake with balloons is surely the very definition of a 'party'.

toomuchfaster · 11/09/2023 13:05

Maybe it came across as defensive but it's actually just pissed off at all the faux 'how can I possibly understand that other people have different opinions to me' posts.
It's bloody obvious that a first birthday party has no developmental impact on a child, but @leapgro has asked the daft question. It is generally considered a celebration, not a learning opportunity, and people celebrate in different ways.

needtofatoff · 11/09/2023 13:05

Its for the parents. But i would say that my first dc daughters first birthday party is up there with my best events / memories ever. And i have lots of children and have been fortunate to have been to lots of parties / events / travelled etc. it really was a really special day and i am so glad we did it.

housethatbuiltme · 11/09/2023 13:03

I'm curious what OP and the other judges do with their babies and toddlers?

I mean if you can't go out anywhere (no holidays or pumpkin picking or santa visits or day trips etc...) or have parties or even invite (summons) family members to anything etc... then what the fuck do you do for the 3-5 years until you finally view your child as a person?

With all the things listed here that are 'tacky' to do what do you ACTUALLY do... like where are your children actually at and what are they doing?

The 'they won't remember so it doesn't matter' is such a dodgy view too, millions of people suffer disabilities that effect memory formations are they not deserving of doing anything fun in life ever because they might not remember it at a later date? bit ablest.

Hereforsummer · 11/09/2023 13:02

These things aren't important to you, and that is completely fine. We all have different priorities, and choose to spend our money on different things. You could argue that beyond the absolute basics nothing is important to young DC, but as parents we get to choose what we want to spend money on according to what we as individuals consider important.

Hogisies · 11/09/2023 13:01

Dolores87 · 11/09/2023 12:55

It's for the parents mostly but to be honest I think that's completely valid if it makes people happy.

I agree. With one thing and another family life was very difficult when my son was 3-5… me, my sister and my mum had champagne for breakfast on my sons 5th birthday- he gained nothing from this since he was at school but we needed a way to mark the fact that we had got through and he was doing well and so was I!

Lamelie · 11/09/2023 13:00

My post? I was making the point that for a 1st it’s the memories that count, the child doesn’t remember but I treasure the picture. Ditto memories of a big soft play event.

Yesterdayyesterday · 11/09/2023 12:59

At 1yo went to the zoo and had cake at home with grandparents.

At 9 and 6 now I ask the kids what they want and do it if within reason. This year DS wanted to play football at the park with his friends and some cake - cheap. DD wanted a play centre party with most of her class - expensive, whereas last year she wanted a party at home with 5 friends which was cheap but more work for me. If we couldn't afford it I wouldn't do it, but we can so I don't overthink it and don't feel I need to justify it.

I don't know anyone doing anything more extravagant than a play centre or village hall with entertainer.

SouthLondonMum22 · 11/09/2023 12:57

DS turns 1 in December and we'll be having a big party because we survived the first year of parenting and feel like celebrating. Will DS care either way? No, will he remember? Also no but he will enjoy himself in the moment and it will also bring us all great joy to come together as a family to celebrate.

Of course it isn't necessary but it's fun. If we only did necessary things with our DC, it would all be very dull.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 11/09/2023 12:55

Notjustabrunette · 11/09/2023 12:49

Haven’t read everyone’s replies, but I didn’t do parties for my kids until reception age. Before that we would have close family and friends round our house for a buffet and cake. Had a few balloons, but nothing fancy. Started going to theme parks when my oldest was 4 and youngest was 2. They are 7 and 9 now and have only been to 4.
I would say that for babies and toddlers they might enjoy these things, but there are cheaper alternatives which they would enjoy just as much.

I am completely fascinated that you don't consider close family and friends coming to the house for a buffet and a cake with balloons to be a party. What would you call it?

MattyTeddy · 11/09/2023 12:55

Newbutoldfather · 11/09/2023 12:34

@MattyTeddy ,

’And I have seen lots of discussions about the helium in balloons is not the same as the helium you are talking about’.

I would love to read those discussions!!

Helium is Helium, 2 neutrons and 2 protons in the nucleus, 2 electrons orbiting in the first shell. There are isotopes with one less and one more neutron, but these are unstable and far rarer.

Balloons with air are rarer these days, and I think the arch relies on the balloons being buoyant. But, yes, those are far better (although we have a massive micro plastic and plastic waste problem that they still contribute to).

You could Google. Or just search helium balloons on MN.

Dolores87 · 11/09/2023 12:55

It's for the parents mostly but to be honest I think that's completely valid if it makes people happy.

Godwindar · 11/09/2023 12:53

The week my 3rd child turned 1, he was ill. So I cancelled the house party planned. The next week, my mate came round with her 2, my sister in law was there and a cousin and one younger sibling. We put some bunting up in the room and took a picture of him with his cake with the one candle in it and had lunch together. He has absolutely no idea that this was the case. My other kids who had house parties with loads of guests, similarly have no idea what happened on their first birthdays.

Notjustabrunette · 11/09/2023 12:49

Haven’t read everyone’s replies, but I didn’t do parties for my kids until reception age. Before that we would have close family and friends round our house for a buffet and cake. Had a few balloons, but nothing fancy. Started going to theme parks when my oldest was 4 and youngest was 2. They are 7 and 9 now and have only been to 4.
I would say that for babies and toddlers they might enjoy these things, but there are cheaper alternatives which they would enjoy just as much.

DoubleTequilaSunrise · 11/09/2023 12:49

Of course they can matter. Why wouldn't they be "beneficial" to the child? It's fun, there's loads to see often to do - even if it's just a massive ball pit, it's often a sensory heaven.
Of course normal life, and parties, are important in a child's development.

Chill.

Life is too short not to have parties when you can have them, or to take the kids on trips when you can! Change of scenery is good for them. And yes, it's for the parents too, but you know what they say, happy parents make happy babies!

LudicrouslyCapaciousBag · 11/09/2023 12:42

Newbutoldfather · 11/09/2023 12:34

@MattyTeddy ,

’And I have seen lots of discussions about the helium in balloons is not the same as the helium you are talking about’.

I would love to read those discussions!!

Helium is Helium, 2 neutrons and 2 protons in the nucleus, 2 electrons orbiting in the first shell. There are isotopes with one less and one more neutron, but these are unstable and far rarer.

Balloons with air are rarer these days, and I think the arch relies on the balloons being buoyant. But, yes, those are far better (although we have a massive micro plastic and plastic waste problem that they still contribute to).

This is hardly the point but balloon arches don't use helium. They are made of air-filled balloons fixed to a frame. A balloon 'cloud' attached to a wall or ceiling will again be air-filled balloons, affixed to a reusable strip of plastic punched with holes.

I'm not suggesting this makes for an environmentally responsible decoration but several pp seem to think that balloon arches are formed of hundreds of helium-filled balloons.

WandaWonder · 11/09/2023 12:38

Rosscameasdoody · 11/09/2023 12:35

Wow, that’s defensive. I don’t think the OP was criticising, just asking for opinions on whether the child would get any benefit, or whether it’s more for the parents.

OK be totally honest what actual benefits would a 1 year old get? Even the ones who can read Homer's Illiad at 6 months

Whiskerson · 11/09/2023 12:38

I do definitely think if you have a house and garden, parties are better at home than having the stress of carting everyone to a venue, setting up and packing away within your timeslot, etc etc etc. And the cost of bouncy castles, hiring entertainers and so on - no need, say I - small kids will be very happy with some small organised games and maybe a willing relative to "entertain" or get out the face paints! It does take slightly more thought, maybe, but on the other hand you are saved all the back and forth with venues, service providers etc.

It's like how babies prefer the wrapping paper to the present 🤣

I'd say - spend money if it's to save you stress and flapping around, as happy parents should = happy baby. Otherwise, take baby's lead to appreciate the small things in life!

Isometimeswonder · 11/09/2023 12:37

I agree, all a waste of time and money and is probably just for social media.
But I also think that of parents who take small children on holidays abroad... like they will ever remember them.

Robinni · 11/09/2023 12:37

Also regards expensive baby clothes. Depends on income..

Personally designer Burberry etc seems ludicrous to me.

Mainly buy next, M&S, jojo etc

Would not touch primark etc.

The reason being - the clothes don’t wash well, fabric isn’t that good quality and I can afford to pay more.

Secondarily - The mid range clothes and above you can sell on eBay/Vinted. Sometimes for more than you bought them when they were 70% off! 😊

If you can buy good quality clothes in sale at same price point, why on earth wouldn’t you?!

peachgreen · 11/09/2023 12:36

It is for the parents... but I think that's okay, really. I certainly felt I deserved a party for surviving DD's first year! (As it was, we only did a small family tea with a cake etc but still, I enjoyed it, and I wouldn't judge anyone who wants to go all out if they can afford it!)

Rosscameasdoody · 11/09/2023 12:35

toomuchfaster · 11/09/2023 09:54

I think you should do what you want and not be so judgemental.
1st birthday parties are often a celebration of the parents surviving the first year, I don't regret what we spent on DD's at all and I don't care what you think about that.

Wow, that’s defensive. I don’t think the OP was criticising, just asking for opinions on whether the child would get any benefit, or whether it’s more for the parents.

Newbutoldfather · 11/09/2023 12:34

@MattyTeddy ,

’And I have seen lots of discussions about the helium in balloons is not the same as the helium you are talking about’.

I would love to read those discussions!!

Helium is Helium, 2 neutrons and 2 protons in the nucleus, 2 electrons orbiting in the first shell. There are isotopes with one less and one more neutron, but these are unstable and far rarer.

Balloons with air are rarer these days, and I think the arch relies on the balloons being buoyant. But, yes, those are far better (although we have a massive micro plastic and plastic waste problem that they still contribute to).

verse · 11/09/2023 12:34

The dozens of balloons and fake flowers are for social media, and I hate to think of the environmental impact. Not just used for birthday celebrations though.

The trips and expensive clothes I understand more, and those were for ourselves. It was a rare person who could spot the more obscure designer brands I used to buy the DC. We had a lot more disposable income then, though.

Robinni · 11/09/2023 12:32

Hogisies · 11/09/2023 12:27

Not everything is done for show you know. We have a very elaborate Halloween party every year… no one would know except my sister, her 3 kids and my parents. It isn’t on social media and no one else is invited 🤷‍♀️ We doctorate the whole house to a different theme, have entertainers come, have a special cake, have an elaborate party tea, dress up and play games with prizes (like T-shirts/teddies etc) We do a giant piñata.

We do it because the 4 adults and 4 kids love it. We don’t decorate outside the house. only one of us has one social media account and we don’t put up pictures.. so where is the show for everyone?

@Hogisies your house for Halloween sounds brilliant!! 🎃

Swipe left for the next trending thread