Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that ‘just feed them what you eat’ when weaning is much harder than it sounds unless you already make everything from scratch?

132 replies

AliceinSlumberland · 10/09/2023 21:20

I’ve got a 6 month old and we’re doing a bit of a mixed BLW/mushed up approach which is working for us, but I’m struggling with the ‘just feed them what you eat’ advice. I hate cooking, I should start by saying, so I have become a bit more reliant on easy to make meals, especially after a long day at work, but these just aren’t comparable with BLW. For example, I make a hotpot every so often but I use one of the packet mixes and I just feel overwhelmed about how to make it without that? Same with sausage casserole - but the baby can’t have these things as the packets have too much salt for him.

Sometimes I’ll make a pasta bake with a jar, and I do know how to make the sauce myself but it takes a lot longer. I feel like I’m having to rejig our entire menu and find new meals to have, so it’s not anywhere near as simple as ‘just feed them what you eat’ unless you’re already making everything from scratch?

Any simple hotpot recipes with less salt appreciated!

OP posts:
prescribingmum · 11/09/2023 08:41

FoodFann · 10/09/2023 21:43

Precisely why I’ve used Ella’s kitchen pouches. I cook fresh everyday for me and DH, but it is not suitable for babies and it is not organic.

Ella’s pouches have 10+ ingredients in each one, all organic, no rice flour, no oil, no salt, no added sugar. I worked out how much it would cost me to make some of the Ella’s meals I buy, it would be well over £5 per portion as it’s all organic, and there are loads of good ingredients. My DD is 9mo and has 4-5 pouches a day plus milk.

Also, I want to expose DD to as many flavours, and different plants as possible because it is very good for tummies and gut bacteria to have a greater variety of plants. She still gets finger food too, and knows exactly what to do with it.

I think you’ve been misinformed on a number of things here. Yes the pouches don’t contain oil, salt, sugar etc but they exploit the taste of the cheapest and sweetest item to form the overall taste of the pouch. There is a significant amount of water in them - our health visitors would actively advise against them because they were watered down so much Due to these two factors alone, you could make your own for a fraction of the price. Using pouches means you predominantly expose your child to sweet food, not multiple flavours

The pouches do not contain enough of the beans/lentils etc that are so good for our guts and the heat treatments involved in preserving the food take away the nutrients and benefits.

The benefits of making your own food far outweigh the benefits of a pouch being organic - don’t be convinced by their marketing

prescribingmum · 11/09/2023 08:30

As you’ve realised, you actually do a lot more than you give yourself credit for and it sounds like you are far from clueless in a kitchen. Don’t blame you for feeling like doing anything but cooking at the end of a day of work and juggling baby.

I found threads like this, recipe books and fb pages great for inspiration and ideas. Meal planning is what worked for me. Like a pp said, I would often spend a while one day batch cooking a heap of food with music on and filled the freezer to make evenings easier. If you’re making food at home, you can relax a bit with salt requirements too. We generally aimed for salt free but sometimes they just ate our food and I didn’t worry because I don’t make salty food whereas I wouldn’t have been comfortable if it were a jar sauce/ready meal.

Also, use frozen veg! It is a massive timesaver as generally pre-prepped but still has all the nutritional value that fresh does. The freezer aisle is my best friend!

It is worth the effort as they’re only babies for a while and if you can get yourself into the habit of making a good family meal, life is much easier when they’re children and eating the same as you. My children never ate a single savoury pouch because the taste did not compare to homemade food (we bought them for travelling and all ended up wasted). As primary school children, they will not touch nuggets/fingers/waffles for exactly the same reason.

AliceinSlumberland · 11/09/2023 08:29

@TwoShades1 I guess I thought they could have it really, I don’t really know. I thought a pasta bake sauce once a week or so would be okay, we had it as kids.

@Ariela its easier if you know how to make
it, if you don’t, and you’re bad at cooking and find it hard to cook something new, it’s really bloody hard.

OP posts:
Clefable · 11/09/2023 08:03

Have you actually tried any of those things on your 18mo? You might be surprised, although if he's had a year of mushy food then it might take him a little to adjust.

Ariela · 11/09/2023 08:02

Parker231 · 11/09/2023 06:39

I’m assuming you’re joking. It’s not time consuming to add jars and pouches to the weekly shop and then warm it up? What’s the comment about taking it to the recycling bank for?
Thankfully past this stage now but when you drop six month old DT’s at nursery by 8am and collect by 5.30 or 6pm you need every time saving method possible - jars and pouches.

I'm talking about 'the whole process' involved with jars, which is often forgotten. They might seem convenient, but there's a hidden time cost of storing them in the cupboard, then when you need it finding the one you want, opening the jar (sometimes not as easy as I'd like), emptying it, getting all of it out (otherwise it's a waste), washing them up and disposal vs a bit of prep chopping the items, adding a shake of herbs/spices as it cooks, chucking the veg scraps in the compost bin. Not much difference in convenience of my time (may be different for others, but I'm very much 'bung it in no measuring' cookery, but you need a certain amount of confidence).

Frankly I hate jars because I ALWAYS forget to take them to the bottle bank - time consuming, as its out of the way - and they mount up and I have little space to store them.

I always fed mine on the extra I cooked us the night before - used to hive it off and keep in the fridge for the next day's meals. So long as you're careful if you heat it, you can warm gently in the microwave or in a pan. Just as quick as a jar or pouch.

Clefable · 11/09/2023 08:02

Yeah after the first two-three months of weaning mine have pretty much eaten anything! Their gums are super hard.

ShadyPaws · 11/09/2023 07:48

babyproblems · 11/09/2023 07:20

I’ve also never really understood this approach because seems to me they literally can’t eat many things until they have decent teeth. We eat a lot of salad - how on earth can a 18mo eat that?? Soups and mushy ok. But what about steak, salad, stir fry! My child can’t eat those things now even let alone at 6m! He only has 7 teeth!!

Their gums are really solid so they can eat pretty much anything suitable, steak should be fine

violetcuriosity · 11/09/2023 07:22

They literally eat such a tiny amount of those things I'd just serve it with extra veg

babyproblems · 11/09/2023 07:20

I’ve also never really understood this approach because seems to me they literally can’t eat many things until they have decent teeth. We eat a lot of salad - how on earth can a 18mo eat that?? Soups and mushy ok. But what about steak, salad, stir fry! My child can’t eat those things now even let alone at 6m! He only has 7 teeth!!

TwoShades1 · 11/09/2023 07:16

I’m not here to tell you how to cook now. But what are your plans going forward? Once your child is fully onto solids what is your plan then? What are planning to feed them when they are 2? When they are 4 or 5? What about 8? If it’s completely not suitable to give the child a small sample of the food now, why would it be appropriate for a 5 year old to have a full meal of it?

Parker231 · 11/09/2023 06:39

Ariela · 11/09/2023 00:52

I agree with you.

Yes, preparing veg from the garden as I have all summer can take a fair bit of time if you include digging the potatoes and carrots, but you can do frozen veg!
But realistically faffing about with jars (shop for jar, bring home put away in cupboard, find correct jar I'm looking for in cupboard of other jars, open jar with a bit of a struggle, poor it out, rinse out jar into cooking, then wash up jar, take it to the glass bank for recycling) doesn't take much longer than chopping up a bit of meat &/or veg and slinging it in the oven/microwave/slow cooker with a sprinkling of herbs and some garlic.
And as other posters say, cook what you're having without salt or the sauce you're going to use, hive off baby portion, then add salt or whatever jar of sauce to the rest (if you like salt that is)

I’m assuming you’re joking. It’s not time consuming to add jars and pouches to the weekly shop and then warm it up? What’s the comment about taking it to the recycling bank for?
Thankfully past this stage now but when you drop six month old DT’s at nursery by 8am and collect by 5.30 or 6pm you need every time saving method possible - jars and pouches.

NoSaladThanks · 11/09/2023 06:34

We're very much a meat / fish and two veg type, so each time I made a meal I would make a little extra.
Then I would mash it together and freeze it in individual tubs, so there was always something to hand if we were having something like a hot curry or we were eating out.
Otherwise they ate what we were eating that day.
As they got a little older and past the initial weaning stage, I'd just make it fork mashable instead of blended.

Nicole1111 · 11/09/2023 06:18

AliceinSlumberland · 10/09/2023 22:57

@Nicole1111 one for the fridge one for the freezer makes sooo much sense to me, thank you for that. Yes we eat a lot later than him at the minute to be honest but I keep seeing all this stuff about eating as a family, just not sure how I can fit that in by the time my husband finishes work.

I make sure I eat breakfast with her every morning which makes me feel better about that. We have porridge and fruit, toast or she sometimes has overnight weetabix (mash a weetabix with a dribble of milk, mash half a banana in with it, add a big spoon of Greek yoghurt and a little bit of nut butter on top) then it’s literally got to be pulled out of the fridge in the morning.

Simonjt · 11/09/2023 06:14

FoodFann · 10/09/2023 21:43

Precisely why I’ve used Ella’s kitchen pouches. I cook fresh everyday for me and DH, but it is not suitable for babies and it is not organic.

Ella’s pouches have 10+ ingredients in each one, all organic, no rice flour, no oil, no salt, no added sugar. I worked out how much it would cost me to make some of the Ella’s meals I buy, it would be well over £5 per portion as it’s all organic, and there are loads of good ingredients. My DD is 9mo and has 4-5 pouches a day plus milk.

Also, I want to expose DD to as many flavours, and different plants as possible because it is very good for tummies and gut bacteria to have a greater variety of plants. She still gets finger food too, and knows exactly what to do with it.

Yes no added sugar, but they rely on cheap veg to bulk them out, which is why carrot, tomatoes and sweet potatoes are often the main ingredient, with anything that isn’t savoury relying on apple puree.

The average pouch has 4g of sugar, so 4-5 pouches a day is giving your baby 16-20g of sugar assuming she isn’t given any fruit or pudding based pouches, which are typically around 5g of sugar. 20g of sugar is 5 teaspoons.

Goldbar · 11/09/2023 04:55

Freezer veg, eggs and toast are what are offered in this house when the alternative is to liquify shop-bought pizza or chicken nuggets.

If I'm cooking one night, I tend to save a couple of baby-sized "meals" in little pots for the next couple of days. So a mushed up mini roast dinner, stir fry without the sauce, chilli and potato etc. I'll usually aim to get at least 3 baby meals out of each home-cooked meal for the days when my older one is having beige freezer muck.

It only takes a couple of minutes to boil some veg so everything gets a side of veg in this house, even if it doesn't go with the meal.

user1492757084 · 11/09/2023 04:54

For a baby just starting you are right about low salt and no sugar.
Staples I used .. canned fruit in own juce, fresh fruit, plain yoghurt and Hommas, rolled oats made into porridge, whole meal bread and butter, spreads, whole wheat crackers, weetabix, tastes of adult food served (meat, rice, pasta etc.), cheese and eggs (when appropriate), coupled with plain steamed vegetables and salad.
It's the addition of vegetables and salad, that becomes part of family meals, which makes the food very baby friendly.
Vegetables can be canned or fresh. Aim for preparing two or three vegetable types that can be steamed, microwaved, boiled or roasted to add as sides to any meals. Cold slices of capsicum, cucumbers, tomato etc also suffice.
I recently saw a smaller bench top slow cooker and steamer that would be perfect for preparing vegetables for children.

Hot Pot can be any vegetables, any chopped up meat, any stock (low salt) to cover and slow cooked.
Take out baby's portion before adding extra salt, herbs, spices, curry, gravox, soup mix commercial type flavours that your adult palate prefers, to the final cooking.
Frozen low salt children's crumbed fish, sausages and any roast meat are tolerated by kids when adults are having tastier, spicier or more processed meats with pastas or vegies.

MixedCouple · 11/09/2023 04:52

I have always cooked from.scratch but throw a baby in and I struggled as your said it takes extra time. The only thing that worked was once a week I batch cook and then wack everything into the freezer.
Lasagne, curry, pasta sauce, shepards pie, chill I concarni, soup etc.
Even LOL snacks now and then I would bake a batch of baby suitable Muffins, pancakes, pinwheels and then freeze

SeulementUneFois · 11/09/2023 04:48

@PleaseUseTheSanitaryBinsProvided
I realise that now so I looked it up - that link I shared was saying that there's very little actual evidence for it though (the kidney theory).
But again

Bunnycat101 · 11/09/2023 04:15

I’m all honesty at 6 months they eat so very little you’re really overthinking it. Don’t worry about the eat what you eat thing unless it actually helps you (eg you’re doing veg anyway and give some to the baby). I used to batch cook things like courgette muffins that were easy finger foods but I was never going to be eating those….

I’ve got photos of both of mine at 6 months and really they were just having tastes of sticks of fruit and stuff and gradually moved to 3 meals a day by 9 months. With my second it was much easier as it was a case of eat what the first one was having which was always suitable, low salt etc. I’m not sure we’ve ever had a week where we’ve all eaten the same evening meal. I reckon we’re about 50:50 through the week even now mine are older just because of timings re work, different food preferences etc.

Ginann · 11/09/2023 03:21

Start simple and don't expect top standard- aim for edible lol!

Have a couple of easier days like jacket potato and filling like cheese/ beans or salad and rice/ cous cous with oven cooked or pan fried chicken- baby can have plain or a mild flavour and you can have a sauce/ spice on. They used to sell paper wraps that you put chicken on and fry (still in paper) 10 mins each side which was very easy to do then in time make your own.

When you do a big meal like a tray bake or hotpot and you've spent a bit longer on a baby friendly version, make extra and freeze some in tubs to use on days when you're not having baby friendly food.

Balanced is the key. It might be baby has the jar version of a meal sometimes but you can water it down or mix with other food like veg/ rice/ pasta so it's not full on flavour.

I say this and my 2 closest friends literally fed babies whatever's on their menu from 6 months, 1 big family meals like spag Bol and the other pizza, chips or pouches.

Don't overthink it op. You have a busy life.
Google baby food ideas for easy wins, like sandwiches, toast, soft veg and where possible save some to freeze or for the next day.

Still enjoy real life too lol

phoenixrosehere · 11/09/2023 01:27

Did BLW with our second because I didn’t want to waste money on pouches like we did with our first or waste space in the cupboard. Definitely fed him what we ate because most of it was food that could easily be made into a little meal, steamed veggies, mash potatoes, tender meats pulled apart into tiny pieces. Pasta is a staple and a light coating of sauce is easily made with a bit of the hot leftover pasta water mixed with grated cheese. Bits of soft fruit that I would have cut up anyway for myself and the oldest. I still seasoned our food as normal with herbs and not a heavy salt or sugar user anyway nor use jar sauces and packets. Mess was minimal and could be easily wiped up in seconds.

Ariela · 11/09/2023 00:52

ChevyCamaro · 10/09/2023 21:42

Sorry I just can't really comprehend the problem. What people call " cooking from scratch" I would just call " cooking"..you need to learn! You shouldn't be eating food every day that you can't feed to your baby! Maybe my culture is not very British, but honestly, it's just as easy to make quick, nice food without resorting to packets. So, things I am never without, to add flavour to food: lemon juice, garlic, fresh herbs, olive oil, butter, vegetables etc. You will feel better for eating fresh food, and it doesn't have to be complicated.

I agree with you.

Yes, preparing veg from the garden as I have all summer can take a fair bit of time if you include digging the potatoes and carrots, but you can do frozen veg!
But realistically faffing about with jars (shop for jar, bring home put away in cupboard, find correct jar I'm looking for in cupboard of other jars, open jar with a bit of a struggle, poor it out, rinse out jar into cooking, then wash up jar, take it to the glass bank for recycling) doesn't take much longer than chopping up a bit of meat &/or veg and slinging it in the oven/microwave/slow cooker with a sprinkling of herbs and some garlic.
And as other posters say, cook what you're having without salt or the sauce you're going to use, hive off baby portion, then add salt or whatever jar of sauce to the rest (if you like salt that is)

PleaseUseTheSanitaryBinsProvided · 10/09/2023 23:48

SeulementUneFois · 10/09/2023 21:35

I'm amazed at the anti salt attitude re babies in the British isles.
But I think it might be a cultural difference...
I'm known by my partner/ex/ friends here for liking my food very salty. What I would call normal coming from abroad.
Today I'm in my home country and I found the food in restaurants extremely salty. So even my taste has at least partially adapted to the British Isles way

You’re an adult. What babies’ kidneys can handle is completely different.

incredible it needs to be pointed out

Nearlyspring23 · 10/09/2023 23:40

I’m currently at this stage and agree with other posters that things can often be adapted, e.g. if I’m doing a quick pasta with a pre made sauce I will give the baby plain pasta with a few bits of grated cheese and possibly a veg such as cucumber or avocado on the side.

Also, once I have cleared all the uneaten food from the floor, high chair, tucked inside the baby clothes I am estimating only about 10-20% of what I am giving is actually being consumed. If a small amount of saltier food is being given it is unlikely with blw that much actually goes in at this age. If you are spoon feeding where the baby is eating larger portions I would be much stricter with salt and sugar content.

ShadyPaws · 10/09/2023 23:34

AliceinSlumberland · 10/09/2023 23:03

I just want to say a huge thank you for all the links and suggestions - I’ve saved them all to my notes app so I’ve got somewhere to go when I need a new recipe! And you’ve put my mind at rest, I was being to rigid, and actually if he has the same as us most nights, I can do him from frozen veg pasta sauce on my beloved pasta bake night 😂

You could always take out a handful of the pasta and add something else to it
Tuna, sweetcorn and mayo to cold pasta
Creme fraiche makes a quick creamy sauce, tiny bit of chopped ham, or some cheese plus veg
It doesn't have to be complex though, even just the pasta with a little olive oil or butter on it, a bit of shredded left over chicken off the hot counter and some cucumber is great