Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nut free schools

86 replies

JustACountryMusicLoverInCowboyBoots · 10/09/2023 21:14

I we've just had the back to school reminder that our school is nut free and that 10% of the pupils have severe allergies requiring an epipen. Pupils are not allowed anything containing nuts or seeds or that may contain them like cereal bars. No hummus etc.

My question is what happens when children with severe allergies go to high school where there are no such policies (not at the high schools that our primary feeds into anyway) and it would be more difficult to police? What happens at college and in the work place? What if a child has Nutella at breakfast or seeded toast or similar and has residue on their clothes or skin?

Severe allergies can be fatal so I understand school's stance. It's impossible to eradicate the risk completely so is it a case of minimising as much as possible? That brings me back to what happens at high school etc though?

Snacks have to be fruit or vegetables for break although many take in cereal bars despite the weekly reminders in the newsletter. My child has school dinners just in case anyone thinks I'm saying the rule is ridiculous.

OP posts:
JustACountryMusicLoverInCowboyBoots · 10/09/2023 22:37

I think nuts and seeds are quite easy to avoid having at school. Not all people will realise that products do contain tracées of nuts or have seeds in them. Look at how bags of peanuts have to declare that they contain nuts! I'm sure I've read that there are people that don't realise Nutella contains nuts. If there were fatal milk/fish/egg/soya/ allergies then it would be impossible to manage.

OP posts:
BoringConstance · 10/09/2023 22:34

ElfAndSafetyBored · 10/09/2023 22:22

No one polices it and I’m sure some people do eat nut products but the posters stating nut free environment must have greatly reduced the risk.
I have a friend with nut allergies so I understand how dangerous it is. Seems like a small price to pay for another human being safe/comfortable in their workplace.

It's not about the inconvenience. But other side effects, like creating a false sense of security.
One of my former workplaces had very strict safety standards for handling equipment, own life at risk if not followed and still every other week we to remind people of the guidelines.
Where I currently work we have thousands of people and no amount of posters, emails, etc etc can ensure compliance for anything, but this is possibly because we get so many, nobody bothers to read any of it. One day certain sections were closed for construction/repairs and the number of people who just ignored the massive red signs...

The other thing is to what extent 'nut-free' is effective, of course the ban will prevent loads of people from bringing in obviously nutty foods but what about things that 'may contain' traces of nuts?

That's why a nut ban is ineffective and your attitude that it creates a 'safe and comfortable' workplace is actually quite dangerous. Risk may be reduced but not eliminated completely, which is why the main adjustment from work should be ensuring in case of a reaction appropriate medical help in the form of the designated first aid officer being trained in what to do, and clearly marked access to an EpiPen. Of course, this is more difficult to do (and places the responsibility on the shoulder of a specific person) compared to just putting up a few posters and, in the event of an issue, claiming that they have done everything possible.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 22:24

This is the guidance from Allergy UK.

Nut free schools
RebeccaCloud9 · 10/09/2023 22:23

The latest advice from Allergy UK, as a pp said, is NOT to enforce nut free schools.

I am happy that most primary age settings we use are happy to ask for no nut packed lunch/snack.

But no one should be asking you to avoid 'may contain'. This is absolutely ridiculous - it would only be effective if they banned every pupil from having any nut product in their own homes too.

ElfAndSafetyBored · 10/09/2023 22:22

No one polices it and I’m sure some people do eat nut products but the posters stating nut free environment must have greatly reduced the risk.
I have a friend with nut allergies so I understand how dangerous it is. Seems like a small price to pay for another human being safe/comfortable in their workplace.

BoringConstance · 10/09/2023 22:12

@ElfAndSafetyBored @BendingSpoons Out of curiosity what other contingencies are put in place? And how strictly is it enforced? Have any incidents actually occurred?
Having a surface 'nut ban' may make things safer insofar as fewer people will bring nuts but there will always be people who forget or ignore the ban. As Allergy UK has stated a ban lulls people into a false sense of security.

It would be nigh on impossible where I work (large site with thousands of staff) to police everything people bring in.

lanthanum · 10/09/2023 22:10

In many secondaries, packed lunches are eaten outside, which probably reduces risk further.

None of DD's friends have serious allergies (which surprises me) but I'm pretty sure that if one of her crowd had said "I've got a nut allergy, can you avoid having nuts near me", they would all have either gone nut-free, or at least made sure that the person with peanut butter was furthest away from the sufferer and washed their hands afterwards.

UkeleleUnicycle · 10/09/2023 22:09

As a parent of child with anaphylactic allergies I'd just like to say a huge thank you to those absolute stalwart parents who just follow what school asks and treat my DC with kindness and care.

The worry that comes every day with being that child and having the child with life threatening allergies is probably unimaginable to those who don't live this life

There's always parents who think their DC having nuts at school should trump my DC's ability to stay alive and safe but I just want to thank those who don't vocalise how hard this is for them. .

RandomButtons · 10/09/2023 22:02

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 21:59

It often contains seeds, however, and OP said the rule is nut and seed free with no “may contains”.

Ah I missed the “seeds”. Still traditionally granary bread didn’t have seeds in it beyond oat/wheat/rye/barley - many brands do t have seeds (I can’t digest seeds myself but love granary).

The rise in allergies is very alarming.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 22:00

Dragonwindow · 10/09/2023 21:59

The last two secondary schools I've worked in have been nut free. I think it's something terrifying like 1 in 5 fatal anaphylaxis incidents happen in school. (although kids probably spend about 20% of their lives in school, so maybe that's not a surprising stat)

How did you enforce this?

ElfAndSafetyBored · 10/09/2023 21:59

My office is nut free and we’re adults.

Dragonwindow · 10/09/2023 21:59

The last two secondary schools I've worked in have been nut free. I think it's something terrifying like 1 in 5 fatal anaphylaxis incidents happen in school. (although kids probably spend about 20% of their lives in school, so maybe that's not a surprising stat)

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 21:59

RandomButtons · 10/09/2023 21:53

Granary bread doesn’t have nuts in it. Least not the ones I buy. So easy to find nut free alternatives.

It often contains seeds, however, and OP said the rule is nut and seed free with no “may contains”.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 21:58

Azurehawker · 10/09/2023 21:50

@DrMarshaFieldstone as a parent of a child with a life threatening allergy I do actually agree with you. It’s impossible to police may contains, and banning them makes life difficult for everyone, while the risk from airborne exposure from them is negligible. Although my dd doesn’t eat may contains herself we do have them in our home and never had any issues. I always taught her never to eat food given to her by anyone but me and certain trusted adults so I’ve never been worried about her taking food from other children at school.

i guess if schools used a case by case approach there may be times when they would have to ban May contains depending on children’s individual needs but as a blanket policy it’s over the top.

Yes, I am a parent of a child with allergies too. I should have mentioned that.

Allergy UK take the view that ‘nut free’ schools breed complacency and make it much less likely that other contingencies will be followed. It is far more effective to ensure children wash their hands before and after eating, wipe down all surfaces, and enforce a strict ’no food swapping’ rule.

RandomButtons · 10/09/2023 21:53

gogomoto · 10/09/2023 21:28

So they ban healthy granary bread, that's new as my dc always had that as it's all I buy. My dd also had permission for peanut butter as she has food issues and it's one of the only things she ate then (she started school in America and every kid has peanut butter sandwiches there it seems, unlike actual peanuts it doesn't transfer into the air)

Granary bread doesn’t have nuts in it. Least not the ones I buy. So easy to find nut free alternatives.

WhamBamThankU · 10/09/2023 21:52

I can confirm that not all secondary schools are nut free, as my DD has peanut/tree nut allergy and her school isn't nut free.

Azurehawker · 10/09/2023 21:50

@DrMarshaFieldstone as a parent of a child with a life threatening allergy I do actually agree with you. It’s impossible to police may contains, and banning them makes life difficult for everyone, while the risk from airborne exposure from them is negligible. Although my dd doesn’t eat may contains herself we do have them in our home and never had any issues. I always taught her never to eat food given to her by anyone but me and certain trusted adults so I’ve never been worried about her taking food from other children at school.

i guess if schools used a case by case approach there may be times when they would have to ban May contains depending on children’s individual needs but as a blanket policy it’s over the top.

JustACountryMusicLoverInCowboyBoots · 10/09/2023 21:50

I've just thought about all the PTA events where there are homemade or shop bought cakes brought into school. No one polices that.

The secondary school definitely isn't nut free. No mention at all on the website or communications sent home.

I agree that a secondary age child is likely to be more able to manage their allergy.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 10/09/2023 21:46

It's their fault if a child dies? Really?

Alopeciabop · 10/09/2023 21:45

Primary school kids also suck their thumbs, get very up close to their friends and sneeze/cough/drool/don’t wash their hands properly/wipe their sticky food hands on their school jumpers.

even secondary schools when I went to school decades ago went nut (or whatever) free if there was someone with a severe allergy there.

but by secondary, as an allergy sufferer, you know not to kiss a boy who’s eaten recently without knowing whether it contains an allergen, you likely don’t hold hands and hopefully don’t drool or sneeze everywhere. You also know not to take bites of other people’s food.

it’s hard hard hard to spend every day having to be frightened and defensive of food - the thing that you need to live and a thing others just take easy joy from. It’s also hard knowing a whole institution/all your friends and enemies/bullies have to adhere to something that inconveniences them just because of you.

its good there’s more knowledge but there’s still discrimination and it sucks

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 21:39

mycoffeecup · 10/09/2023 21:29

Both my kids senior schools are nut free - I suspect they all are. And senior kids should be able to avoid any illicit nuts themselves.

They are not. Your children’s schools are fairly unusual. I would be very interested to know how they police that.

CallieTR · 10/09/2023 21:39

One of DC’s friends has a severe nut allergy - including ‘airborne’. The risk of a severe reaction is much lower through inhalation so whilst their primary school is nut free, by secondary school he should be to deal with any reaction quickly himself and alert school staff swiftly.

DrMarshaFieldstone · 10/09/2023 21:38

Its important that secondary schools give children with allergies the chance to learn to live with their allergy in a relatively controlled environment with responsible adults on hand.

Overly draconian practices in primary schools really irritate me. Banning ‘may contains’ is unenforceable and an unenforceable rule is meaningless. Allergy UK do not advocate nut-free schools; I agree with them but saying this earned me a flaming on allergy groups.

Azurehawker · 10/09/2023 21:37

My dd has a life threatening airborne peanut allergy and I’m worried about her going to secondary school, I’m not sure if they are nut free but my older dd says she has never been told not to bring nuts to secondary school so even if it is nut free they aren’t making it clear or policing it.

She is 9 now and getting good at checking labels etc which is something that we will continue to work on. I’m not sure when I would be confident that she would administer an epipen herself though which is really the crucial step to independence with an allergy.

Sprogonthetyne · 10/09/2023 21:37

Lot's of secondary schools are nut free, though as you say they can't police it 100%. Secondary pupils are also much less likely to go out with breakfast remnants on them, and the child with the allergy is more likely to be aware of minimising there own risk. Children/teenagers are also generally quite happy to make sure they don't kill their friend. I've only ever seen parents complain about nut free rules.

Swipe left for the next trending thread