Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to buying a violin for my DC?

136 replies

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:48

DC is 9, Year 5.

School told us on Friday that we have to supply a violin for our DC to play in music. The school do not have any to lend out, it’s either we provide one or DC can’t take part in music lessons this year.

The cheapest one I can find that will arrive by tomorrow (lesson is on Tuesday) is £65.

I cannot afford £65. I’ve just spent £200 on uniform for DC as they’d completely wrecked everything else. And even if I did have £65 to burn on a violin we have nowhere to practise, I live in an upstairs flat and theres limits in our tenancy to what can be done when, instruments are not allowed after 5pm (DC is in ASC until 4.45pm everyday).

There is no second hand sale at school as the Year 5s last year played a different instrument.

I’m a single parent, DC is on FSM but school don’t use it for this sort of thing, they use it for the Year 6 residential and an individual subscription to 2 homework apps (everyone else has to pay I think £5 a year)

AIBU? And what will happen to DC if they’re the only one without a violin (which is likely as its happened before with trips, DC has been the only one not going on none compulsory trips when I couldn’t afford it)

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 11/09/2023 06:56

The amount of folk I've met who say they wish their parents encouraged them to learn an instrument when they were younger, or put them through lessons, gave them the opportunity to learn, is a shame, if I'm honest.

This is easy to say as an adult - but there’s a whole load of work from the parent beyond just buying the instrument and lessons. A very small percentage of people who say this actually realise (or would have been willing to do) the regular practice required to become proficient in an instrument (particularly something like violin, where you’re doing your own pitching without frets on the finger board).

MidnightOnceMore · 11/09/2023 06:35

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:54

@Yogazmum The letter says those without will be sent to a younger year group for the 45 minutes a week, they have a visiting teacher in doing the lessons.

This is disgraceful for a child on FSM. I would ask for financial help and see what they say.

This country is breaking my heart currently with the lack of education funding.

SallyLovesCheese · 11/09/2023 06:32

Is this party of the First Access scheme, OP, do you know? If so, then school (or the county music service) should provide the instrument. If it's an additional, opt-in music class then that's the only scenario where it would possibly be okay, but it doesn't sound like it is if everyone is doing it.

I'd be fighting this one. I've been a teacher for 15 years and learnt several instruments myself at school and I have never heard of people being asked to provide the instrument themselves.

Arrange a meeting with the Head. If that doesn't resolve it in a satisfactory way, write to the Chair of Governors. Also, you could find out contact details for your local music service on the county council website and get in touch with them (perhaps the head of the service), explaining the situation and asking for a loan instrument. Someone there may be able to help.

Basically, if it's a school request then they need to provide the instruments. If they can't, they need to choose a different instrument, it's a simple as that!

Ivebeentogeorgia · 10/09/2023 23:30

School cannot randomly demand that all children need a violin from home- that’s madness. If they don’t provide them, they can’t exclude children from music lessons with their peers. I would take this further with school. No you won’t be providing one and also your child is not to be excluded if it’s something their whole class is a part of.

InternetSafe · 10/09/2023 23:26

Hi op, I am a violin teacher and this is ridiculous! If it’s small group tuition, it will either be provided by a peripatetic from the local music service who should have a supply of instruments. I am a freelance peripatetic and provide violins for small group tuition and whole class strings projects (I own the violins and lend them out).

I wish I could help you I currently have 90 half / quarter size instruments in the house and about ten 3/4 size (yr 5 average height child will need a 3/4 size).

Where are you based? You are welcome to borrow one of mine if you want.

If not get a second hand one off FB marketplace/ gumtree or local FB groups.

Reasonable starter violins are makes like Stentor, Stagg, Eastar or Antoni.

mauveiscurious · 10/09/2023 23:13

We donated around 10 violins to a loan out scheme there are loads around the UK. It's madness to buy new when you don't know if a child will take to the music

AT345 · 10/09/2023 23:11

Request to speak to the pupil premium lead and ask for them to fund the cost of the violin. Due to receiving FSM, the school receives £1345 additional funding for your child. Although all the money does not need to be spent on them, the school needs to ensure they are using the funding appropriately, including preventing a child from missing out on an experience (such as learning the violin) due to costings. You are able to ask what your child's funding is going towards currently and to see if they can find the violin.

Extraordinarytimes · 10/09/2023 23:06

Another one seconding the complain! Completely unreasonable for you to make such a large purchase, and smacks of a very ill thought out scheme. I have heard of many whole class schemes; instruments are always provided and the class is split into small groups.

All county music services will have large stocks of violins for loaning to pupils. The school should have organised requesting some of these.

If things can’t be resolved, I would be amazed if the class progresses. The teacher will need to check sizing with 30 kids. Then tune 30 violins at the beginning of the lessons. That will essentially take up the lesson. I’m afraid to say only a poor teacher would take on such a crazy task so there is that to contend with also. When I started learning the violin at school (on a free violin) we were in a group of 5. I learnt very little until I had individual lessons. Ended up post grade 8 and a degree in music, so I did have aptitude, it’s just really hard in a group.

I know many professional classical violinists who teach. Their absolute max is 3 to a group. I have heard tell of groups of 10 in county services led by highly experienced teachers. 30 is simply insane. Larger than you would want of a group ensemble where they are having lessons elsewhere!

londonmummy1966 · 10/09/2023 22:42

I suggest that you send a letter to the Head (and cc the Chair of GOvenors) along the following lines

I have read the letter dated xxxx from teacher xxxx about the national curriculum classes for music in year 5. This indicates that unless I provide my DC with a violin they will be excluded from the curriculum provision for music this year as it is to be whole class violin lessons. As you know, my DC is in receipt of FSM and therefore our family circumstances are not such that will enable us to purchase a violin for them. I am sure that this cannot be the case as it is illegal for the school to exclude a child from national curriculum classes due to not having the necessary equipment. Can you confirm that, given the school is in receipt of FSM premium for my child, you will be prividing them with a violin so that they can participate in the curriculum music lessons this year. A secondary issue is that violins come in different sizes and I understand that it is important that children have the correct size instrument for their hands/arms as having an incorrectly sized instrument can lead to issues such as tendonitis due to overstretching etc. CAn you therefore ask the teacher to check that DC is issued correct size of violin to avoid any such issues.

StarDolphins · 10/09/2023 22:35

Oh op, I would be the same, school lunches up by £1 a day near us, trios, contributions for various things, it’s all so expensive to send them to school. I would be the same as you.

I would look into what others have said about if it’s curriculum etc & I would email the head & say you’re really upset that DC would have to be excluded but you simply can’t afford this.

musicalmrs · 10/09/2023 22:25

Have you got a local music shop or school music service? Normally they can both rent out instruments for very reasonable prices. I've rented a violin and a cello from each on separate occasions - the music service in particular was very cheap!

Your DC would gain a lot from whole class tuition, even if she isn't able to practise at home (you could talk to the school about practising there). You could also approach the school if you can't find an affordable option to help support it. They might have some available (or the teacher may!) for a few..

Toenailz · 10/09/2023 22:23

I meant to say though, I've no idea why you had so much short notice. I would definitely be speaking to the school about that.

towriteyoumustlive · 10/09/2023 22:22

Mine was £25 on Facebook!

A second hand one is far better than a cheap new one.

ellesbellesxxx · 10/09/2023 22:22

handmademitlove · 10/09/2023 21:03

If this is a whole class lesson as part of their national curriculum provision for music then schools cannot expect parents to provide for it. In our area, schools borrow a class set of instruments from the local music service as part of the provision. I would query this with the headteacher if that is what the class teacher is telling you.

Same here, I am horrified that they are asking you to provide one at such short notice! Surely other people are in the same boat of not being able to conjure one up with less than a weeks notice?

Toenailz · 10/09/2023 22:21

As a violinist, the only one losing out if if you choose not to, is your DC.

I got free lessons at school, didn't have much opportunity to practice at home. Whilst the lack of practice can be limiting, it doesn't mean they will not be able to play, as children pick things up much quicker than adults. DC may also choose to play over breaks and lunch, as I did. I found it a healthy and wonderful emotional release and escape, during difficult times. My parents scrimped for the violin (I gave it away free to another child wanting to learn, when I outgrew it), even back then childrens violins (new) were cheap. You could also resell it easily if it's kept in nice condition, if DC decides after a while that it's not for them.

I still play now, as a result of those lessons.

If you cannot afford it just now, you cannot afford it. But if DC wants to learn, it's a wonderful opportunity. Perhaps you could tell school you can't get DC one just now, but will when you can and then dc can rejoin lessons? Sooner the better though, obvs, joining a class where most are ahead of you is not pleasant. Also, I struggle to imagine anyone would genuinely have a problem with 20-30 mins of practice at 5pm. Rather that than 7am.

The amount of folk I've met who say they wish their parents encouraged them to learn an instrument when they were younger, or put them through lessons, gave them the opportunity to learn, is a shame, if I'm honest.

BrightLightTonight · 10/09/2023 22:19

You can get a child's violin for £32 on Amazon.

Boomboom22 · 10/09/2023 22:15

I thought you meant you signed her up for individual lessons where they get pulled out of class, in which case you provide or rent from the visiting / peripatetic teacher.
If you mean whole class violin lessons this seems unlikely as beginners will be awful! And no school or teacher will have 30 violins available at once, it is not a whole lesson type of instrument like a recorder or ukulele!

Skeldale · 10/09/2023 22:13

My DS has just completed a year of class violin lessons. They were all taught in the hall with another class who were learning the cello. So all class lessons do happen. The school leant out violins to all participants and we were given websites where we could rent or buy one if we chose.

BadlydoneHelen · 10/09/2023 22:09

They certainly can't do this! If this is a school music lesson within school hours your child can't be excluded if they don't pay. Challenge this immediately with the head teacher

StillWantingADog · 10/09/2023 22:09

i’m a violinist.
school is totally unreasonable. Parents are ours complained when we were all
requested to pay £10 towards a recorders.

our council loans instruments for around £20 per term which is very reasonable but should not be compulsory.

ThanksItHasPockets · 10/09/2023 22:06

Just found the relevant DfE guidance for you, OP. They cannot do this.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/706830/Charging_for_school_activities.pdf

To say no to buying a violin for my DC?
marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 10/09/2023 22:00

Have you ever heard a child playing a violin badly? It's beyond ear splitting, it really is. When dd learned (or tried to) years ago, everyone in the house ran for cover. Discreetly, of course.

Boomboom22 · 10/09/2023 21:57

Sounds very cheap. Last year my year 5 did trumpet, I rented it. What a funking con, cost me about 120 quid could have got a cheap one off ebay for that.
Try a wanted post on your local nextdoor and freecycle.

Piglet89 · 10/09/2023 21:57

Music learning (musicianship) via Kodaly methodology is MUCH more sensible. Voice as first instrument and singing/ clapping games to practise pitching, steady beat and rhythm, before progressing to an actual instrument.

plus no initial outlay like this.

But sadly only pockets in the U.K. teach music this way.

lanthanum · 10/09/2023 21:56

If they told people on Friday that they need a violin on Tuesday, I think a lot of people will be without. 90 people all looking for the same instrument in one weekend - Facebook marketplace won't be that much help!

Was there any advice on size?

I wonder whether the teacher is assuming that the school is providing the instruments, not the parents. If I were teaching whole-class violin (I'm trying to imagine how anyone could persuade me to), I'd at least want to be able to get at the instruments before the start of the lesson.

If there are three classes, could your child share with someone in another class?

Swipe left for the next trending thread