Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to buying a violin for my DC?

136 replies

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:48

DC is 9, Year 5.

School told us on Friday that we have to supply a violin for our DC to play in music. The school do not have any to lend out, it’s either we provide one or DC can’t take part in music lessons this year.

The cheapest one I can find that will arrive by tomorrow (lesson is on Tuesday) is £65.

I cannot afford £65. I’ve just spent £200 on uniform for DC as they’d completely wrecked everything else. And even if I did have £65 to burn on a violin we have nowhere to practise, I live in an upstairs flat and theres limits in our tenancy to what can be done when, instruments are not allowed after 5pm (DC is in ASC until 4.45pm everyday).

There is no second hand sale at school as the Year 5s last year played a different instrument.

I’m a single parent, DC is on FSM but school don’t use it for this sort of thing, they use it for the Year 6 residential and an individual subscription to 2 homework apps (everyone else has to pay I think £5 a year)

AIBU? And what will happen to DC if they’re the only one without a violin (which is likely as its happened before with trips, DC has been the only one not going on none compulsory trips when I couldn’t afford it)

OP posts:
Beamur · 11/09/2023 15:24

Where are you based OP?
https://music4themany.com/#:~:text=music%20for%20the%20many%20%E2%80%93%20equal,1185526
I think your school is putting your son in a ridiculous position with this but maybe investigate whether you can borrow an instrument for him to learn on. There may be other charities or bodies that can help.

music for the many – equal musical opportunities for our children – Registered Charity no. 1185526

https://music4themany.com/#:~:text=music%20for%20the%20many%20%E2%80%93%20equal,1185526

CruCru · 11/09/2023 15:18

It’s not all that helpful but I can’t think of a better way of putting a child off playing music than giving them an hour’s lesson on a £60 violin. I’d be amazed if it would stay in tune

randomsabreuse · 11/09/2023 14:46

It's madness to have parents provide instruments in this situation. A stock of well set up basic stentors would be way more use than Amazon violins which are likely to come with bridge and soundpost down and be nigh on impossible to keep in tune because the pegs aren't well made. Also new bows need a lot of rosin to get started. Setting everything up for failure really!

GentrifiedLDN · 11/09/2023 14:36

You can rent violins

tootyflooty · 11/09/2023 13:05

Never heard anything so ridiculous, and violins are sized for the player, so you can't just grab the first cheap /freebie you might spot on line, as other have said I would speak to the head, I absoultely would not tolerate my child being put in another class while the group lesson is going on. If you do decide to play the game with the school, then pop to a local music shop, they can advise on size and if they have any reasonably priced rental schemes, additionally they may have access to resales, where younger childern have outgrown their instruments. I think it's brilliant that they are given the opportunity to learn an instrument, but it should be made financially accessible to all.

ChocoBanana · 11/09/2023 12:38

This is totally ridiculous - it sounds like a scheme thought up by someone with zero knowledge of musical instruments. They are asking parents to spend thousands of pounds between them on instruments that are likely to be discarded once the course is finished many of which even a professional violist couldn't get a decent sound out of. No one should be asked to source and pay for a violin for whole class lessons and I would be surprised if many turn up with one. If you can, then contact the teacher running the lessons to find out whether this is what they were expecting to happen and whether they can source a violin for your child to borrow.

GU24Mum · 11/09/2023 11:45

The scheme is clearly not properly thought-out. We have local schools which do this but much of the point of it is that they lend the instruments as well as providing the lessons! In fact I donated our two violins to the scheme rather than try and get £10 for them on Ebay.

It's not a good use of PP money either - i'd they run a scheme (which is great albeit I'd choose anything over a violin....), they need to resource it properly.

80skid · 11/09/2023 11:09

This sounds like exactly what the pupil premium funding is for. Maybe you could ask the school how they are spending it and how it benefits your child?

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 11/09/2023 11:06

Does this mean there are a loaf of parents with dc in the year above who have violins they want to get rid of?

DS and DD had whole-class violin lessons in Y3, but the school had a set of violins to use for that initial year.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 11/09/2023 11:05

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:55

@misssunshine4040 Not private, it's a VA CofE.

From what I can tell they can use the Pupil Premium funding however they choose and it doesn't have to benefit directly the child on it. They only have less than 1% of the school population on FSM so I doubt it'd cover a violin.

In my view this is even more reason why it should be being spent on ensuring that your child can participate fully. They have a generally ‘advantaged’ cohort and therefore will have relatively fewer challenges to manage and can draw on more parental resources (financial and otherwise). The school I work at is similar: very low PP (and most are services rather than FSM). Max of only 1 or 2 kids per year group on FSM. PP funding is used to cover extra-curricular sports clubs, private (in sch) music lessons, trips (including ‘voluntary’ ones) and residentials so that all children have the opportunity to participate in everything we offer. I think it’s shocking that your school aren’t doing this and I would be kicking up a stink with the governors and then the LA/my MP, tbh.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 11/09/2023 10:58

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/09/2023 10:31

The school CANNOT insist you pay to provide equipment for a national curriculum lesson OR exclude the child from that lesson if the parents cannot or will not pay.

I suggest you immediately contact the local authority OR academy Trust (according to which us the overall body for the school) and make this point.

Also this.

theresapossuminthekitchen · 11/09/2023 10:56

They get £1,455 additional funding a year for your child. £10 worth of homework apps is barely scratching that. It is not the case that you can dictate what the money is used for, however, it should be being used for this kind of thing and for any trips that you can’t afford. Ask what it has been spent on over the last few years.

anotherside · 11/09/2023 10:53

live in an upstairs flat and theres limits in our tenancy to what can be done when, instruments are not allowed after 5pm

Yeah because a kid playing a vioin 5:30pm is the height of antisocial behaviour. 😅 Si ridiculous and not sure it would stand up legally. Regardless, I would just play and if anyone questions it I would just show the landlord my “Classical Violin” CD/DVD which I just love to listen to every day. Presumably in North Korea Britain you are still allowed to listen to music after 5pm - problem solved.

NowYouSee · 11/09/2023 10:44

I feel for you OP, very tough when your child is being othered due to your comparative means and lack of consideration by the school.

My council does the whole class tuition through their music service for some schools including violin. One class performed at a concert I was at after a term or so of lessons and I have to say though it was quite basic - I think they were just playing the 4 open strings. If you’d been doing private lessons or even small groups I’d have expected you’d progress further.

My Dc school participated in the scheme with other instruments. I thought it was quite a good scheme tbh in encouraging all children to think musical instruments could be for them. Everyone got a loan instrument though without charge.

Regardless of cost issues though I’d be thoroughly pissed off to be told on a Friday night my child needed a violin by the Tuesday. It’s not like you can pop down to asda to get one. I would put posts on local Facebook groups, there are likely plenty around outgrown or abandoned ones around you can get for free or very cheap. Unless she is particularly small I would expect she would want a 3/4 size. If that fails I would also speak to the pupil premium lead.

I’ve also never come across a lease that restricts playing of musical instruments from 5pm, that is bizarre. That’s hardly late at night.

ThanksItHasPockets · 11/09/2023 10:32

In primary schools around here the ukulele seems to be gradually replacing the recorder as the instrument of choice for whole-class teaching. It is very easy to pick up and the overall effect is genuinely pretty melodic!

VickyEadieofThigh · 11/09/2023 10:31

handmademitlove · 10/09/2023 21:03

If this is a whole class lesson as part of their national curriculum provision for music then schools cannot expect parents to provide for it. In our area, schools borrow a class set of instruments from the local music service as part of the provision. I would query this with the headteacher if that is what the class teacher is telling you.

The school CANNOT insist you pay to provide equipment for a national curriculum lesson OR exclude the child from that lesson if the parents cannot or will not pay.

I suggest you immediately contact the local authority OR academy Trust (according to which us the overall body for the school) and make this point.

WonThisNameInARaffle · 11/09/2023 10:30

Your local council should have a music team that can lend out instruments. You don't even know what size they'll need so to ask for one before the first lesson is daft!

RosaGallica · 11/09/2023 10:27

^ This. The option of recorders is there if you want to give everyone the chance to learn music. They were used because they are cheap and easily replaceable - I am wincing at the thought of all those unwanted violins being bashed about.

Another option if inclusivity is to be taken seriously is not to impoverish your entire nation of people by unhitching wages from the real cost of living and pushing the cost of that most basic of human rights, living space, beyond the realm of anyone without rich parents.

It’s a total joke. As someone from a poor background, free school meals and hand me downs, I can assure you that there is no way of pursuing musical or other artistic, or sporting careers for that matter, from poverty. The only realistic aim is to allow more to enjoy it by understanding it, and that is best achieved using cheap and easily replaceable recorders. No matter how much the sound is disliked by delicate and poncy middle class ears.

LittleSleepingDog · 11/09/2023 08:15

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/09/2023 07:51

It'll be the school seeking to fulfill the NC requirements for all pupils to have the opportunity to learn an instrument, through the local music service. They've been doing this for at least ten years in large groups and it sent a large number of children towards wanting to eventually take music at GCSE who otherwise wouldn't have realised they had ability in the subject, because the parents couldn't afford private lessons (or had ever considered their children might be interested).

The music service should be able to give details of rentals.

What you're saying is exactly why they do it. To widen participation and opportunity, rather than keep it elite and not for the poor to consider.

Edited

This isn't widening participation and opportunity, though. This is, at best, the tick-box approach to widening participation and opportunity, and nothing like the experience the 'elite' children get. They haven't participated if they don't learn anything worth knowing, which is likely given the amount of time they will get and the number of students in the group. They haven't had their opportunity widened if they don't get given skills that will take them places, and this type of teaching on the violin is not going to set them up with decent skills.

It is possible to teach violin in large groups - Shelia Nelson did it very successfuly in Tower Hamlets in the 80s. But it cost absolutely shedloads of money and was defunded in the end as unsustainable. See the documentary 'Beginners, Please' i think it's called, on youtube. This is the system you need if you actually want to widen opportunity, as opposed to paying lip-service to it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/09/2023 07:51

Mirabai · 11/09/2023 07:41

As a violinist I assure you the whole thing is a waste of time and money. You cannot teach the violin in groups of 30 in 3 lessons a term. It’s totally clueless.

A £65 violin will be shit anyway and you’d never buy someone an instrument if they don’t specifically want to play, have weekly individual lessons, and commit to regular practice.

I fully support the school teaching music but they should start with an introduction to the different types of instruments (and potentially have 1 of each of students to try), and listening to different kinds of music. They could start students on cheap instruments owned by the school such as recorder etc.

It'll be the school seeking to fulfill the NC requirements for all pupils to have the opportunity to learn an instrument, through the local music service. They've been doing this for at least ten years in large groups and it sent a large number of children towards wanting to eventually take music at GCSE who otherwise wouldn't have realised they had ability in the subject, because the parents couldn't afford private lessons (or had ever considered their children might be interested).

The music service should be able to give details of rentals.

What you're saying is exactly why they do it. To widen participation and opportunity, rather than keep it elite and not for the poor to consider.

Mirabai · 11/09/2023 07:43

And btw at 9 years you don’t use a full size violin, you’d need a half or three quarter size depending on your son’s size.

Mirabai · 11/09/2023 07:41

As a violinist I assure you the whole thing is a waste of time and money. You cannot teach the violin in groups of 30 in 3 lessons a term. It’s totally clueless.

A £65 violin will be shit anyway and you’d never buy someone an instrument if they don’t specifically want to play, have weekly individual lessons, and commit to regular practice.

I fully support the school teaching music but they should start with an introduction to the different types of instruments (and potentially have 1 of each of students to try), and listening to different kinds of music. They could start students on cheap instruments owned by the school such as recorder etc.

2weekstowait · 11/09/2023 07:14

i think it’s ridiculous, but you might be able to find one. I gave a violin to the charity shop recently because I couldn’t be bothered to list it anywhere. I’m sure you could get a second hand one and sometimes they are better quality.

Vettrianofan · 11/09/2023 07:10

mauveiscurious · 10/09/2023 23:13

We donated around 10 violins to a loan out scheme there are loads around the UK. It's madness to buy new when you don't know if a child will take to the music

OP please please look into this option. You should not be getting yourself into debt.

Vettrianofan · 11/09/2023 07:07

We are in Scotland and instruments are given out on loan by the local authority. Fees are waived for lessons.

I feel sad that children are missing out, possibly children with lots of potential, on learning due to cost of instruments. Music is an important part of a child's education.

DS 16 is learning electric guitar and there's no way a year ago that I could have afforded to buy one. He has a loan of one from the local authority.