Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to buying a violin for my DC?

136 replies

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:48

DC is 9, Year 5.

School told us on Friday that we have to supply a violin for our DC to play in music. The school do not have any to lend out, it’s either we provide one or DC can’t take part in music lessons this year.

The cheapest one I can find that will arrive by tomorrow (lesson is on Tuesday) is £65.

I cannot afford £65. I’ve just spent £200 on uniform for DC as they’d completely wrecked everything else. And even if I did have £65 to burn on a violin we have nowhere to practise, I live in an upstairs flat and theres limits in our tenancy to what can be done when, instruments are not allowed after 5pm (DC is in ASC until 4.45pm everyday).

There is no second hand sale at school as the Year 5s last year played a different instrument.

I’m a single parent, DC is on FSM but school don’t use it for this sort of thing, they use it for the Year 6 residential and an individual subscription to 2 homework apps (everyone else has to pay I think £5 a year)

AIBU? And what will happen to DC if they’re the only one without a violin (which is likely as its happened before with trips, DC has been the only one not going on none compulsory trips when I couldn’t afford it)

OP posts:
Lalalalala555 · 12/09/2023 10:30

Wow. The school sounds awful.
I would definitely raise the issue. Because it should be be being made an issue.
Ie the school shouldn't put kids and parents in this position. If they knowingly are making it where poorer kids miss out and suffer.

Move school.

But in meantime try gumtree, free cycle, ring a music shop and see if they have any ideas.

It just sucks.
You're not being an asshole.

The school is being cruel to ciphen out kids of different wealth background s and prioritising richer ones and shaming poorer.

Its bigger than the violin issue. It's teaching your kid that's okay. And putting them in an environment that's not kind.

Gjendefloooo · 12/09/2023 10:24

I’d put in a complaint to the head and governors asking how your child will get their legally entitled music lessons as part of the curriculum. Ofsfed won’t like it

Yes, I think you should complain.
They cannot exclude a child from curriculum music because they don't have a violin. That means they can't send the child off to another year group because they can't afford an instrument.
I see they have now said your child will sit in the lesson and learn along with their friends. Probably realized they cannot legally dispatch the child out of curriculum music.
Your child just sitting there and watching is also not acceptable as they are not learning anything by doing that and therefore have been excluded from curriculum music.
It is discriminatory and absolutely definitely worth taking further.

Ffghhhbdbfb · 12/09/2023 09:43

If you are going to rent, hire purchase May be cheaper. Contact music shops. They may have a trade in 1/2 size violin.
maybe also write to the school and governors and point out what a barrier this is to participation.

TinyTear · 12/09/2023 09:38

@NoInstrument if you are in London I have a 3/4 violin for sale... I can't give it away but I have it listed for £25

Lovemyones · 12/09/2023 09:06

@Vermin since noone else has said it you're too kind. Hope the OP takes you up on your lovely offer!

ZadocPDederick · 12/09/2023 08:15

The whole idea is bonkers. If you must teach a whole class an instrument, the violin is possibly the worst one to go for. But if as a school you choose to do this, you have to be prepared to subsidise it, otherwise it is grossly discriminatory.

Could be worth taking this one up with the governors.

MercedesD · 12/09/2023 07:57

There are loads on Facebook market place for £20/£30. That’s not to pipe in on the moral question of if the schools should be making people buy violins just to highlight that there are cheaper options.

Welshmonster · 12/09/2023 07:31

I would read the curriculum policy on the schools website as no child can be excluded from the curriculum and this is their music offer. Do they have an additional music lesson that week? I doubt it.

being sent to another year group is not acceptable. Read every policy on their website and then quote relevant parts in a carefully worded email which copies in the headteacher and chair of governors. As your child is also FSM then you can ask what the funding for your child is being spent on. They don’t have to give a detailed break down but it needs to be spent appropriately.

All trips in primary are generally a voluntary contribution unless it is an extra like residential.

I’m Not FSM but could afford a violin.

most schools have a specialist music teacher come in for one term and then parents can choose to pay to continue lessons.

I would query the legality of excluding your child from lesson as that is what they are doing by sending him to another class. It’s a punishment.

Casperroonie · 12/09/2023 07:25

Look this up carefully on gov website. Your child cannot be excluded from the curriculum because of a charge the school forces upon you. It is illegal.

Take this up with the school as it is not acceptable, they have to provide a reasonable alternative, not send your child to another class where he won't be making progress.

whatnext3 · 12/09/2023 07:10

DD had whole class violin lessons in primary (loan instrument). I can say, my child gained nothing from the whole class tution on an untuned instrument. It was an utter waste of time.

I would not overthink it. Write to the head by any means but otherwise skip it.

Loving the Mumsnet suggestions to just buy a cheap one for £30 to someone who is hugely struggling financially or to just source the Facebook neighbourhood group for one. Really 🙄

SoSad44 · 12/09/2023 07:05

@NoInstrument there are child violin’s on vinted for £25-£45. Sure it wont arrive for his first lesson but can potentially save you a lot of money. You cna always try and sell it after a year (if he doesn’t continue).

Jcf1977 · 12/09/2023 07:00

Sounds like a school in a well off area with so few pupil premiums, apply to school, you have nothing to lose. But also if they do this every year there will be tens of violins sitting gathering dust in your area. Ask on freecycle, ask the school WhatsApp (you can just say to save waste before I buy one has anyone got… ) ask charity shops as it’s the kind of thing that will be in the back. Also write a strongly worded letter of complaint to the governors of the school as the usual is to buy a recorder which is a tenner. Violin is ridiculous. From a music perspective very hard to learn and not great for kids as it needs tuning every lesson / practice. Good luck

celticprincess · 12/09/2023 06:59

Music teacher here - and a violin player. School should be providing the instruments for the whole class music lessons. They used to be called wider opportunities and it was a great initiative as it meant those who couldn’t afford to sign up to individual peripatetic lessons got to try out some instruments. My daughters primary never even had a music teacher til after one had left and one was y6 and I was really annoyed that basically weren’t taught music. Music just be taught up to ks3 and is an entitlement so your child is being discriminated against and refused a lesson they are legally entitled to.

Cheap violins aren’t really worth it. I’ve a few in the house we bought the kids when younger. They don’t hold their tuning and sound awful.

I’d put in a complaint to the head and governors asking how your child will get their legally entitled music lessons as part of the curriculum. Ofsfed won’t like it.

ProudToBeANorthener · 12/09/2023 06:55

Where we live you can rent them from the Music Service of the local authority. Is that a possibility? Ask about reductions if your child is eligible for FSMs. Also, I thought that it was illegal to exclude children from compulsory trips on the basis of cost?

Rjh76 · 12/09/2023 06:44

Hi, so your child falls under the ‘pupil premium’ category with having FSM. Schools are allocated a certain amount of money and few people know this, I didn’t until a teacher friend told me. But you can speak to the school about how they use that money for your child and how you’d like it using. I know this because my friends daughter is ‘ pupil premium’ and her mum requested the money be used for an after school club. Hope this helps.

Ellmau · 12/09/2023 00:09

Yeah because a kid playing a vioin 5:30pm is the height of antisocial behaviour. 😅 Si ridiculous and not sure it would stand up legally. Regardless, I would just play and if anyone questions it I would just show the landlord my “Classical Violin” CD/DVD which I just love to listen to every day. Presumably in North KoreaBritain you are still allowed to listen to music after 5pm - problem solved.

A beginner practicing makes a sound rather a long way away from what most people would regard as music.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 11/09/2023 17:00

Floralnomad · 10/09/2023 21:04

What mad school is going to teach an entire yr group the violin , it’s ridiculous . I would imagine there will be lots of kids who won’t have one .

My dh school teaches the whole year group in y2 (2 classes) violin (peri teacher comes in and is free as part of curriculum) and after y2 they can continue in group lessons with the same peri but think they are asked to contribute towards costs.
The violins are provided by the school but I think when they wish to go further then they are encouraged to get their own.

crosstalk · 11/09/2023 16:39

I really would try calling a music shop and explaining the situation. They may either rent or know someone who's wanting to pass on a violin but check the size. My daughter started on a 1/2 at seven. It is a lovely lovely instrument if you get on with it. She practised in break time.

Littlefish · 11/09/2023 16:11

Sorry, crossed with @ThanksItHasPockets.

Littlefish · 11/09/2023 16:11

NoInstrument · 11/09/2023 16:06

Slight update

School have come back and said any child who doesn't have their own violin will still be in the lesson they'll just sit in the lesson and "learn" alongside their friends.

School have said PP funding has been allocated and theres no spare. It's going on Mental Health Support for all children on PP and on the Year 6 residential (which usually costs £2-300) and on the apps. They wouldn't budge when I bought it up so I think DC will be one of a very few in the class without one.

Current Year 6s learnt a different instrument so no old ones there.

According to class Facebook group majority are thrilled and are happy to provide the instrument. It's that sort of area.

Will look into rental options.

Contact the Local Authority. The school is breaking the law. Quote the link provided by a previous poster about curricular learning during the school day.

ThanksItHasPockets · 11/09/2023 16:07

NoInstrument · 11/09/2023 16:06

Slight update

School have come back and said any child who doesn't have their own violin will still be in the lesson they'll just sit in the lesson and "learn" alongside their friends.

School have said PP funding has been allocated and theres no spare. It's going on Mental Health Support for all children on PP and on the Year 6 residential (which usually costs £2-300) and on the apps. They wouldn't budge when I bought it up so I think DC will be one of a very few in the class without one.

Current Year 6s learnt a different instrument so no old ones there.

According to class Facebook group majority are thrilled and are happy to provide the instrument. It's that sort of area.

Will look into rental options.

Did you quote the DfE guidance that I linked upthread, OP?

NoInstrument · 11/09/2023 16:06

Slight update

School have come back and said any child who doesn't have their own violin will still be in the lesson they'll just sit in the lesson and "learn" alongside their friends.

School have said PP funding has been allocated and theres no spare. It's going on Mental Health Support for all children on PP and on the Year 6 residential (which usually costs £2-300) and on the apps. They wouldn't budge when I bought it up so I think DC will be one of a very few in the class without one.

Current Year 6s learnt a different instrument so no old ones there.

According to class Facebook group majority are thrilled and are happy to provide the instrument. It's that sort of area.

Will look into rental options.

OP posts:
Littlefish · 11/09/2023 15:38

ThanksItHasPockets · 10/09/2023 22:06

I was just about to search for that too.

If the lesson is curricular, and during the day, the school cannot insist on payment at all. They can ask for a voluntary contribution.

Swipe left for the next trending thread