Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to buying a violin for my DC?

136 replies

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 20:48

DC is 9, Year 5.

School told us on Friday that we have to supply a violin for our DC to play in music. The school do not have any to lend out, it’s either we provide one or DC can’t take part in music lessons this year.

The cheapest one I can find that will arrive by tomorrow (lesson is on Tuesday) is £65.

I cannot afford £65. I’ve just spent £200 on uniform for DC as they’d completely wrecked everything else. And even if I did have £65 to burn on a violin we have nowhere to practise, I live in an upstairs flat and theres limits in our tenancy to what can be done when, instruments are not allowed after 5pm (DC is in ASC until 4.45pm everyday).

There is no second hand sale at school as the Year 5s last year played a different instrument.

I’m a single parent, DC is on FSM but school don’t use it for this sort of thing, they use it for the Year 6 residential and an individual subscription to 2 homework apps (everyone else has to pay I think £5 a year)

AIBU? And what will happen to DC if they’re the only one without a violin (which is likely as its happened before with trips, DC has been the only one not going on none compulsory trips when I couldn’t afford it)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 20/01/2024 18:02

Have you got any cash converter type shops near you, I bought a good bass guitar in our local one for dd about 10 years ago she still plays it, they had loads of violins too all at reasonable prices, I had a good look around the shop while she was trying a few out.
I was going to buy myself a saxophone from there too.

mrsmamoa · 15/09/2023 14:48

@NoInstrument have you seen the question @Vermin has asked you?

Katbum · 15/09/2023 14:38

Just email back and say it’s discriminatory to ask for families to provide a violin and that you will be making a formal complaint if they don’t find a way to accommodate your son. Find your inner Karen.

listsandbudgets · 13/09/2023 16:54

Floralnomad · 10/09/2023 21:04

What mad school is going to teach an entire yr group the violin , it’s ridiculous . I would imagine there will be lots of kids who won’t have one .

Presumably one that issues ear plugs to all staff!!

Recorder is bad enough at early stages but violin is something else again

OP is it for actual violin lessons or just mai stream music lessons? I.could understand if.the first was an issue but the second is crazy.

paulthepython · 13/09/2023 16:09

I think I would put in writing a question to the school to clarify - are they advising you that they intend to exclude your child from music lessons, the curriculum for all other children, because you don't own a violin? Be clear that if that's the case then you don't think it's a comfortable or fair position to put children and their families in and perhaps the school should opt for an instrument for their curriculum lessons which they are able to provide. Take it up with the board of governors and advise that you'll be escalating it above them if they support this decision because it is discrimination and shouldn't be accepted,endorsed or in this case created!

1mabon · 13/09/2023 15:48

When we were at the grammar school in Liverpool in th 1950s, it was like a Public school. We could choose any instrument (s) to learn, elocution lessons and deportment classes all for no fee at all. How times have changed.

Cocolebombom · 13/09/2023 01:22

NoInstrument · 10/09/2023 21:25

@Setyoufree Group lessons, the whole year is being taught in classes (30-32 per class, 3 classes per year) the other classes will be doing either PE or Computing while one class is having music.

3 classes a year in a class size of 32. The kids will learn nothing. Don't waste your money on an instrument.

BoringConstance · 12/09/2023 21:58

Floralnomad · 12/09/2023 17:15

@NoInstrument , as I said not everyone was going to buy a violin , partly because they don’t want the racket indoors .

But also because the child may very well already play another instrument, why spend on something they're not going to use again?
Great outcome OP!

ScottishWaylander · 12/09/2023 21:42

Most music shops hire instruments out for reasonable price. You can find out if your son gets into playing or not before buying.

The one we hired from sold out to us at a reduced rate after we had hired it for a year.

NightSkyStars · 12/09/2023 20:12

Do they follow the national curriculum? If so they legally have to provide a music education as part of this and should be making provisions to ensure all children have access to that education. My year 5 class are learning the violins this year but the school have rented them from the music company that runs the lessons and we are not asking any parents to pay towards this.

Glittertwins · 12/09/2023 17:47

NoInstrument · 12/09/2023 17:02

So DC says they had music today.

Less than 50% of the class had violins. The others where given electric keyboards and played tunes on that instead, school have said anyone who doesn't have a violin will use those instead which DC is thrilled with!

All happy. I won't be buying a violin and don't need to worry.

Best outcome all round then!!

zingally · 12/09/2023 17:38

Music is part of the national curriculum. They can't ban a child from the subject because he can't afford to buy an instrument!
That's bonkers as well. I'm a 15 year teacher, and have NEVER heard of a primary aged child being asked to purchase ANY musical instrument for class lessons.

I think you need a conversation with the Head, and failing that, the chair of governors.

Floralnomad · 12/09/2023 17:15

@NoInstrument , as I said not everyone was going to buy a violin , partly because they don’t want the racket indoors .

NoInstrument · 12/09/2023 17:02

So DC says they had music today.

Less than 50% of the class had violins. The others where given electric keyboards and played tunes on that instead, school have said anyone who doesn't have a violin will use those instead which DC is thrilled with!

All happy. I won't be buying a violin and don't need to worry.

OP posts:
Glittertwins · 12/09/2023 17:00

It's posts like this that make me wish I'd not given all our old ones to charity so you could have had one of them OP

HideousKinky · 12/09/2023 16:52

Is it a full size or half size violin you need OP?

CynicalToad · 12/09/2023 16:31

What's the point in being a school linked to a church if they can't tap up the congregation for a supply of old musical instruments.

Wrongsideofpennines · 12/09/2023 13:36

This is so absurd. I understand that schools are strapped for cash but then they shouldn't choose to run lessons like this. They should have chosen the recorder or something cheaper, or the same instrument as last year so they can be passed down or the schools music service should be providing the instruments.

Your child will not learn to play the violin without being able to touch a violin. That's like saying he can learn to write without a pen, or play football without a ball. Instead the school are singling him out and excluding him infront of his peers. I would ask to meet with the head or write to the governors.

yoshiblue · 12/09/2023 13:10

I find the treatment of your son appalling. I am a primary school governor, and if this was going on in our school I'd want it to be raised to the governing board as a complaint.

It's completely unreasonable to expect you to pay for a violin given you are eligible for FSM. I would expect our school would have put a plan in place for low income families by sign pointing to rental options or recognising the need to fund a small no of instruments for families in this situation.

My son plays the violin and we have a council run music service where you can hire an instrument for a term. I think you may also find cheap second hand instruments on Facebook/Gumtree, but I would be pushing the issue with the school in the first instance.

Womanofcustard · 12/09/2023 13:07

Retired music teacher here. Please don’t buy a cheap violin! If it’s for a year of once a week for 45 minutes, the lea should be providing the violins. He will not learn to play violin from these lessons anyway, they’re just for box ticking.
if your son wants to learn music, get him a recorder or tin whistle and a tutor book.

Catza · 12/09/2023 12:59

It's a sad state of affairs that schools cannot provide learning materials for their own curriculum. But to your last question "What will happen to DC if they are the only one without a violin", I want to give some reassurance. Nothing of note will happen. I grew up in absolute poverty until the age of 12. I didn't do anything extracurricular. Yes, a lot of the time I remember with sadness all the missed opportunities but I always had a core of good friends which really made all the difference. As an adult, I have a diverse set of interests and invest money into learning new things and having new experiences all the time. Maybe, I could have become a famous dancer or a musician had my parents had more money for activities but I don't feel that it took away from my childhood at all. Your kiddo will also be just fine. Please don't worry about it.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/09/2023 12:37

NoInstrument · 11/09/2023 16:06

Slight update

School have come back and said any child who doesn't have their own violin will still be in the lesson they'll just sit in the lesson and "learn" alongside their friends.

School have said PP funding has been allocated and theres no spare. It's going on Mental Health Support for all children on PP and on the Year 6 residential (which usually costs £2-300) and on the apps. They wouldn't budge when I bought it up so I think DC will be one of a very few in the class without one.

Current Year 6s learnt a different instrument so no old ones there.

According to class Facebook group majority are thrilled and are happy to provide the instrument. It's that sort of area.

Will look into rental options.

That's so discriminatory, horrible policy singling out your DS like this.

sparkleshin · 12/09/2023 12:36

Maybe they could practise at the weekends but if you cant afford one you cant afford one

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/09/2023 12:35

Skimmed a bit so apologies if this has already been mentioned, but would an organisation like this be able to help? I'd ring them and ask so you could get a recommendation for your area.
https://benslowmusic-ils.org/index.asp?pageid=85

Benslow Music Instrument Loan Scheme - Additional Funding & Assistance

A regularly updated list of organisations, trusts, and charities giving help with funding, instruments, courses, professional development and performance opportunities

https://benslowmusic-ils.org/index.asp?pageid=85

Pythonesque · 12/09/2023 12:10

Where to start? If I were going to be teaching this class I'd want to have some oversight of the instruments they were using - to check they were playable, tunable, and not too big. I'd expect 1/2 and 3/4 sizes at that age - far more on 1/2 though. I've a couple of students just started year 5 and neither have moved from 1/4 to 1/2 size yet. (having said that, my sister and I were certainly on 3/4 in year 5, and my daughter was ready for a full size just turning 10 - but we are all tall and my daughter reached her adult height at about the age of 11).

OP, definitely try to contact your county music service and find out what they can or can't do. I wonder if a different school might have had whole class violin tuition and changed.

I also agree that "no instruments" after 5 pm sounds utterly unfair in your tenancy agreement.

Good luck finding a sensible way forward.