Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that dogs are not born anxious

131 replies

bonbon2023 · 10/09/2023 12:52

And that their owners make them the way they are?

I'm on a couple of Facebook groups for the breeds of dogs I own and the amount of reactive/anxious dogs is getting ridiculous now. I'm seeing countless posts a day to the point I've left the groups. Dogs are not born this way it's what you do in bringing them up. The not ever leaving a dog to settle/be alone. Thinking a dog won't survive home alone if you leave the house for 5/6 hrs. A normal dog can be but the helicopter dog ownership is not helping them at all. And they are creating a rod for their own back, therefore ending up with a dog they can't control (or is controlling them) and then they are ending up rehomed. The final straw for me was a woman asking if she could give her dog a raw chicken wing that the butcher had given her saying her dog would love it, the comments went wild saying she shouldn't give her dog it, to the point she just threw it away. Some even telling her to freeze it first for two weeks 🤦🏻‍♀️
Dog ownership has changed massively in the last 10/15 years (since socially media) it's like dogs aren't treated like dogs anymore or aren't allowed to be because their owners are an anxious mess themselves 😬

I can't be the only one who thinks like this?

OP posts:
andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 10/09/2023 14:46

Breeding is important, but being rude to other dog owners and not letting dogs greet will cause reactivity, and then it’s always the other owners fault.

I don't let my dog greet others because he's reactive. And he's reactive because too many "friendly" dogs have run up to him and pinned him to the floor, or humped him or pestered him to the point where he had no choice but to snap at them.

PaperDoves · 10/09/2023 14:42

OP, what kind of dogs do you breed? Some breeds are more prone to anxiety and need much more extensive socialisation than others. I have border collies and used to have Australian Shepherds, and both can be prone to anxiety. They need a lot of socialisation.

That said, I've also noticed more reactive dogs when traveling than there were a couple years ago. I'm inclined to blame lockdown. My younger border collie was 18 months when lockdown happened and despite plenty of positive socialisation as a youngster, spending nearly a year without meeting new dogs up close definitely knocked him back. He's fine with people but very nervous around strange dogs.

SpareHeirOverThere · 10/09/2023 14:40

Babyroobs · 10/09/2023 14:34

My working cocker spaniel has always seemed to be anxious despite us doing all the right things exposing him to different noises etc. He is afraid if anyone raises their voices even slightly, so you can't even have a heated conversation or swear in frustration without it affecting him. He is afraid of anything buzzing - a tiny fly, mosquito or wasp. terrified of motorbikes, gunshots, fireworks and motorcycles, hairdryers or hoovers. It's a difficult life with him !

I have one of those, too.

And I've never seen a greyhound that didn't look like it feared someone was about to give it a thrashing. Even when accompanied by clearly very devoted owners. They are sensitive souls, bless 'em.

CandyLeBonBon · 10/09/2023 14:38

Breeding is important, but being rude to other dog owners and not letting dogs greet will cause reactivity, and then it’s always the other owners fault.

I have a collie cross. She was beautifully socialised as a pup/young dog and she lived quite happily with my other dog for many years and was fine. But she has a typical collie nature and really isn't that bothered about other dogs that she's not bonded with.

As she's got older she's got more intolerant of 'oh they're just being friendly' type dogs who bound up and get in her face/chase her when she's minding her own business. She avoids their 2/3 attempts to engage and when they don't get the hint she'll snap at them.

This was made considerably worse when a dog walker out with 6 or so dogs let them all off lead and the surrounded her and were all over her.

Her nature, her age and her experiences over time have seen her turn into a more anxious dog who prefers solitary walks and not to be chased by idiotic pooches with no manners.

I avoid dog walkers because I enjoy the solitude in an otherwise busy life. Neither of those factors are the cause of my dog's anxious personality.

That doesn't make me rude or her defective. It means I understand my dog and will do what works for her/us regardless of others' ideas that we're somehow doing it wrong!

Cosyblankets · 10/09/2023 14:38

There is no doubt that dogs have different temperaments.
There is no doubt some are more naturally anxious than others.
However there is also no doubt that treating them like babies creates issues that may never have been there otherwise

Babyroobs · 10/09/2023 14:34

My working cocker spaniel has always seemed to be anxious despite us doing all the right things exposing him to different noises etc. He is afraid if anyone raises their voices even slightly, so you can't even have a heated conversation or swear in frustration without it affecting him. He is afraid of anything buzzing - a tiny fly, mosquito or wasp. terrified of motorbikes, gunshots, fireworks and motorcycles, hairdryers or hoovers. It's a difficult life with him !

SnowflakeCity · 10/09/2023 14:33

When we got our dog she would shake uncontrollably when you tried to walk her, like as soon as she was outside the gate she was vibrating. It took months to get her to walk like our other dog did straight off the bat. We have treated her the same as our other chilled out, friendly with every other dog dog but she is just afraid of everything. She has been this way since she came to us at 12 weeks old. Visiting other people's houses leaves her with diarrhea for 2 days straight, if she had her way she would stay within the confines of our house/garden for the rest of her days. She has never ever been aggressive but I have never seen a dog vibrate with fear like she does on the regular.

I might have been judgey too before she came into our lives but I don't see how you think it is so implausible that a dog is born with a certain personality, some personalities are great, others not so much.

ExtraOnions · 10/09/2023 14:31

I think bad breeding is part of it, there needs to be much better regulation around needing at all levels.

BackToOklahoma · 10/09/2023 14:26

We've fostered lots of pregnant dogs and looked after their pups. Within the same litter, there are lots of different personalities, including ones that are quite anxious and more reactive.

Prescottdanni123 · 10/09/2023 14:23

In terms of the chicken wing - if it had bones in, then no it shouldn't have been given straight to the dog

lightinthebox · 10/09/2023 14:23

I find that refusing to talk to other dog owners and actively avoiding other dogs when younger doesn’t help. The dogs where I am are socialised at a young age and none are reactive or anxious, 99% of them are well trained (one is a pain and everyone hates the owner).

Breeding is important, but being rude to other dog owners and not letting dogs greet will cause reactivity, and then it’s always the other owners fault.

LaviniasBigBloomers · 10/09/2023 14:09

I think you're both right and wrong. Clearly some dogs are born with different temperaments, and the rise in backyard breeding and crossing breeds with traits that probably shouldn't be crossed has meant more anxious dogs being born. I mean, I only know a couple of pure-bred cockers and one poodle, but in there's no way I would have thought 'yeah, they'll make great, chilled out kids'.

And the way dogs are brought up and socialised plays into this too.

That said, there's absolutely no way I'd leave any dog alone for six hours and expect them to be OK with it. That's an unrealistic and unfair expectation.

needtonamechangeforthis1 · 10/09/2023 14:01

misssunshine4040 · 10/09/2023 13:10

People need to stop infantilising dogs and treating them like children. So disturbing.

Dogs are pack animals who feel secure with a well established leader and clear boundaries.

Pack theory was rubbished decades ago! It's utter bollocks! Even the guy who came up with the theory says so!
Perhaps do some research before spouting rubbish!

Poshjock · 10/09/2023 13:34

Respectfully I disagree. My Labs came from a litter of 8 (actually 10 but 2 were lost). One was different from the get go, his litter handle was The Gentleman. He never played with his litter mates, he stayed on the perifery, he would sleep to the side of the pack and sat in the corner of the kitchen just quietly watching. We took him and his brother, who had been the runt of the litter. He grew into a lump of a dog who was laid back and devil may care. Our little shy boy never had inherent confidence. He was never reactive as we trained him well and gave him some resilience, he hid behind his brother a lot. But when anything was wrong he was under my legs like a shot, or up on the sofa/bed for a lean. There was one other pup in that litter that the breeder kept. She was a difficult dog, reactive and aggressive. The owner told me he thought maybe she was attacked when in the garden because he couldn't understand why whe was like this. The others were all solid dogs. I told him about mine and I think with a different owner he may have been worse. No doubt in my mind he was born this way. Polar opposite of his chilled brother. That pair never had a day apart and as I said - the signs were there from about 3 weeks old.

Balloonhearts · 10/09/2023 13:32

It's the same as with children or any other animal. There's a genetic component to it, some people are just more predisposed to a nervous temperament than others but in my not expert opinion it's 80% upbringing.

We've had a lot of dogs and various pets but the ones spring to mind for me are my hamsters. One was very frightened when we got him. Terrified to the point that if he was eating or drinking I'd crawl on my hands and knees past his cage so as not to frighten him, otherwise he'd go hungry for hours as too scared to come back out.

After a few months of gentle handling and interactions he was a happy, confident little guy who came running at the sound of our voices.

Another one was bold and curious and interacting with us from day one.

Totally different little personalities but both raised the same and both turned out friendly.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 10/09/2023 13:28

Temperament can absolutely be genetic in a dog. That’s why you should insist on meeting both parents if buying a puppy from a litter. Nothing to do with helicopter dog-rearing (lol).

Surely as a dog breeder yourself you know this? You’ve presumably never had an anxious puppy because you’ve chosen the parents carefully with regard to their temperaments. A lot of breeders don’t.

FOJN · 10/09/2023 13:21

Dogs are pack animals who feel secure with a well established leader and clear boundaries.

Pack theory has been debunked. Dogs do like routine and consistent expectations.

I also think poor breeding practices are a factor in canine anxiety and this maybe exacerbated by inexperienced owners.

CandyLeBonBon · 10/09/2023 13:20

You've clearly never met a border collie!!

Hopinghonestly · 10/09/2023 13:19

I think they must do..we had two twins boy and girl puppies, one was confident and the boy had IBS..same training.
Although as he got older, about a year he was fine.

Lou670 · 10/09/2023 13:16

I disagree. The dog I have now I have had since she was 8 weeks old and was nervous from day one. She is now 17. I had at the same time (now passed away) a rescue dog that I took on at the age of 2. This dog was the most laid back dog ever despite having been abused in his first home. He came with some behaviour problems which we did overcome with him. Their personalities could not have been further apart. If anything I would have expected the rescue to have been of a nervous disposition. Same with people, some people are just naturally nervous, timid and introverted whilst some are the complete opposite.

misssunshine4040 · 10/09/2023 13:10

People need to stop infantilising dogs and treating them like children. So disturbing.

Dogs are pack animals who feel secure with a well established leader and clear boundaries.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 10/09/2023 13:10

YABVU.

Dogs can be born with problems just the same as humans can be.

It's also worth remembering that not all puppies are born to dogs of sound temperament, with good breeders and good socialisation opportunities.

WhatWhereWho · 10/09/2023 13:08

You are very wrong to say that dogs cannot be born with certain problems. Backyard breeders and people breeding dogs without caring about the health of the parent dogs (mental or physical) has created a massive problem -it has for years.

However, that does not mean owners do not create problems too. And some people do create problems in their pets through poor and ill-informed choices Sounds like you need to educate yourself on the matter.

CreepingCrone · 10/09/2023 13:06

We have a rescued greyhound who was mistreated before we adopted him. He is covered in scars. He is a spook (a form of canine autism than can be hereditary in some of the racing grey family lines). He is anxious and struggles with new situations and people. None of this is due to helicopter dog ownership or us treating him like a precious flower. It's partly genetic and partly as a result of mistreatment. He is not a typical dog. Nobody wanted to adopt him as he is male, very large, older, and had been in kennels for a really long time. He has really bloomed in a loving family home but there will always be things he struggles with. Oh and greys have to wear coats in winter because they have very fine fur and virtually no body fat. Their breed originated in Egypt.

bonbon2023 · 10/09/2023 13:05

@KrisAkabusi funny you should say that, I'm a dog breeder and have been seen lots of litters (one lot left me yesterday) yes they had different personalities but all were confident lively pups. Never had a quiet anxious one and been doing this for years.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread