Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS 'next of kin'?

61 replies

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 12:24

Bit of backstory, sorry for length: DS1(30)'s bio father left when he was a baby. It was an unplanned pregnancy and he basically couldn't cope with the commitment. A year later I met my DH, who has been dad ever since. We had two more DCs and have always treated all three entirely equally. Ex drifted in and out (mostly out) for a few years, has never paid a penny in any support, and then we lost contact for quite a while (I discovered he was living abroad, but has since moved back). For the last ten years we've been amicably in touch via social media, have spoken on the phone once and messaged a few times; same with him and DS - they've spoken and messaged but not met face to face since DS was a child. DS doesn't seem particularly bothered - he has his own very busy life, Ex lives a very long way from him, and myself, DH, and the other DCs are his family.

However, Ex did mention briefly at one point that DS was his 'next of kin'. I didn't pursue it with him at the time, but I think this would be correct as he had no further children and has been single for a number of years. He has one other sibling and some nieces/nephews, but that's it. I mentioned this to DS, but we are unsure of what that might mean in a practical sense, and neither of us feels particularly comfortable to ask Ex any more about it.

Also, I do wonder if this means Ex plans to leave his estate to DS, or if this would automatically happen anyway? If this is the case (and here's where I'm probably BU) I can't help feeling that would somehow be unfair on our other DCs after we've strived so hard to keep everything equal between them. In mine and DH's wills we have split everything exactly equally between all three. It doesn't seem fair if DS1 then might inherit a load from another 'dad' who was never in the picture.

DH thinks it's not our business and says if that happens, it is what it is. Also, there's a lot of 'ifs' involved - Ex might meet someone else (he's late 50s) and we know nothing of his business or finances, etc etc. I'm sure he's right, and know life isn't always fair and equal and all our DCs are making their own way in the world now, but still, I wonder if IAB entirely U to feel this way?

Also, can anyone shed light on what 'next of kin' might actually mean for DS?

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 10/09/2023 13:31

Equal isn't the same as fair. If your first child's life was equal to his siblings' then his dad would've stuck by him.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 10/09/2023 13:31

Treating children fairly doesn't always mean treating them in the same way.

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 13:28

I'm dhs next of kin. When he went to hospital and I wasn't aware in an emergency I didn't get a phone call. Dh was in and out quite quickly thank fully and he didn't want to worry us. It would only be if dh asked the hospital or maybe if he was at the point of passing or passed I believe.

ImustLearn2Cook · 10/09/2023 13:27

Your son is a 30yr old adult. I am presuming his siblings are adults too (considering that you met your dh a year later).

It’s good that you as parents made sure that they were all treated equally.

But, any one of your children could come into a significant amount of money through a variety of ways: marrying a billionaire, winning the lottery, making an investment that profits massively, writing a best seller that gets turned into a movie, helping someone who rewards them or leaves them money in their will, getting a promotion with a massive pay increase etc.

They are adults now. They will lead independent lives and have independent opportunities.

Your husband is right. It is not anyone else’s business and it is between them. Just as it would not be anyone else’s business if one of your other adult children decided to marry a billionaire and be left a significant inheritance from their spouse.

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 13:26

I imagine that if your ex goes to hospital or has an accident where medical decisions need to be made, your DS will be the first person who is called by the hospital or emergency services

This only happens on TV. Next of kin (outwith power of attorney) do not make medical decisions in the UK, doctors do.

KateyCuckoo · 10/09/2023 13:26

Plus he's 30, he doesn't even need to tell you if he inherits from his father. It is literally none of your business and you are being very unreasonable to have any thoughts on the matter.

NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 10/09/2023 13:25

I imagine that if your ex goes to hospital or has an accident where medical decisions need to be made, your DS will be the first person who is called by the hospital or emergency services. As for any inheritance, it would be weird if DS didn’t inherit.

babbscrabbs · 10/09/2023 13:20

YABU, kindly, your ds has had to live with his father dipping in and out of his life, you can't always make everything exactly equal and you're overthinking it.

saoirse31 · 10/09/2023 13:20

Given your post at 12.45 , you're cleatly determined to regard your ds inheriting anything as not being fair to your other children. Your poor ds.

saoirse31 · 10/09/2023 13:17

Im actually shocked that you're thinking it would be unfair to your oldest ds. He had lived knowing his father has little interest in him, for his entire life. And yet all that seems important to you is that your other two children who have lived with their two parents all their life are somehow being disadvantaged by ds possibly inheriting from his father. I'd wonder how much your ds knows about feelings about him as opposed to your feelings about your other children. Whether you've said anything or not I'd imagine that he's a very good idea how you feel.

MammaTo · 10/09/2023 13:17

If your ex was to pass away without a will (and name an executor) then your son would have to follow the rules of intestacy and I believe (I could be wrong!) if he doesn’t remarry or have a civil partner then children would be next of kin to deal with his dads estate.

Shinyandnew1 · 10/09/2023 13:16

You can’t just make things ‘fair’-two of your kids grew up with their dad, but one didn’t-that’s not fair.

What if one of your kids gets a really well paid job/marries a billionaire/ gets hurt in an accident. How could you make that fair for the others? I think you need to be realistic.

Next of kin could just mean he gets a phone call if his dad is in an accident.

blendedfamly · 10/09/2023 13:12

I thought you were going to ask will dc be responsible for funeral arrangements etc. but your worried he might 'bonus ' an inheritance from his dad? I'd say the money would be well deserved for having a shit dad. One of your other children might 'bonus' by marrying a millionaire. Or win the lottery or one might end up losing a load of money and be bankrupt. There are so many scenarios but the fact is it's highly unlikely all of your children will be of equal financial status when u die. The fact is do you want to treat them equally or not? It would be reasonable for your dh to leave his half to your joint children but really to be fair yours should split across all kids. I'm f you don't have a will that is what would happen

itsgettingweird · 10/09/2023 13:08

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 10/09/2023 12:38

But things aren't equal between your three children. Two have their biological father as a resident parent, and one has been rejected by their biological father. If your ex has not had any other children and has never married then your son will automatically inherit everything if there is no will. It's not his fault, it's just the way it is. The thing is, this idea of keeping things fair isn't necessarily the best thing anyway. Children have different needs, and sometimes one will need more support than the others. Things being fair or equal doesn't mean things being the same.

This.

I think the fact you keep saying "tried really hard to keep things fair" shows that deep down you know they cannot ever be. However wonderfully your DH was a dad to ds he was still abandoned by his biological father.

Fwiw I know someone who walked away from a late teen pregnancy. He regretted it but couldn't change things as was too immature to do so and she was rightfully furious with him. Once he'd matured enough to step up and have the courage to do so the mum had met someone else. It killed him to walk away again but he knew the step dad could provide security and felt it wrong to interfere in his kids settled life.

He worked his whole life into an early grave to make a decent inheritance to give his kid. He never stopped feeling guilty and said he got what he deserved but his child didn't. He also left a not insignificant amount to the mum and stepdad with a letter saying he could never undo his wrongs or show his gratitude for them for raising his child amazingly but could ensure their retirement was one they'd earned and deserved.

He didn't leave anything to the half siblings. But I guess their parents could do what they wanted with what he left them.

You have to allow whatever his biological father decides to be between them. Abandonment is a complex thing to navigate for all involved.

Redglitter · 10/09/2023 13:07

You feel its not fair your son should benefit financially from his Dad. Why not? Your other children have benefitted from living with & being brought up by their 2 parents

Honestly though your ex is in his 50s why are you thinking so much about something that might not happen for another 30 years. God knows where you & your family will be at that point

Shinyandnew1 · 10/09/2023 13:07

He might not even have an ‘estate’! He might have no house, no money and just debts.

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 13:01

Literally nothing to do with anyone but ds and his Dad.

You can't tell him to not leave anything to ds as its not fair to.other kids and you can't ask him to split it between your dcs as they aren't anything to do with him.

It's a good thing if he leaves estate to DS especially as he hasn't been a present kf financial stable input.

I wouldn't give it another moments thought and hope ds will benefit from him in the future

Bearonthestair · 10/09/2023 13:00

Will you feel its unfair if one son becomes very wealthy and the others do not through success or marriage? Where does the fairness stop with adult children? It's a very strange mentality.
Inheritance is never a given. I could die before my mother. What use is it then. Focus on the here and now.

LolaSmiles · 10/09/2023 12:58

You and your DH have done an admirable job of raising a blended family that sounds happy and healthy.

All things aren't the same for the children and that's the reality of their circumstances.

Yours and your DH's decisions are totally separate to your son's father and have no impact on yours and your DH's decisions regarding fairness in your family unit.

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 12:56

I should also add that there was never ever any question of us dividing our wills unequally, whatever happens (and I'm aware could be long dead anyway). As I said, it was more of a feelings question really, but in hindsight - and seeing it written down and the answers here - it does seem an odd thing to worry about.

OP posts:
outsurance · 10/09/2023 12:54

Next of kin doesn't mean anything except in mental health legislation where it's called the nearest relative and there's a hierarchy.

You can't stop your ex leaving his estate to your DS - and why would you want to stop him doing that?

gamerchick · 10/09/2023 12:49

Your husband's right OP. Things are as they are. You can't make it fair on all of them, they don't have the same dad and there's nothing you can do to change that. YOU keep things equal if you're thinking of favouring the others will wise. What goes on with your first and his bio dad is nothing to do with you.

It's fine to feel emotions. Just keep them to yourself

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 12:45

Just to be clear, I wasn't suggesting in any way that DS or anyone else should share anything (if indeed it happens), and of course it's not our business. My question was really to ponder how far AIBU to feel this way? As a parent we do try and make things as fair as possible, but I guess it's a lesson in life to know this can't always be the case.

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 10/09/2023 12:44

Your DH is right; it’s none of your business.

Also you don’t even know what he meant by ‘next of kin’. It can be a legal term, but it can also just be shorthand for ‘closest blood relative’ or ‘the person who gets a call if something goes wrong when you’re in hospital’ or other non-legally binding things. It doesn’t necessarily mean that your ex has left anything to your son in his will, or that he hasn’t made a will and that everything would go to your son as default. If the latter was true he could easily get married between now and his death which would mean everything went to his wife anyway.

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 12:43

Medical-wise, hospitals may contact your son as next of kin, but only if his bio father has given them his details as a contact, and he wants them to keep him informed.

Your son wouldn't be asked to make medical decisions on his behalf. This only happens on TV.

Swipe left for the next trending thread