Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS 'next of kin'?

61 replies

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 12:24

Bit of backstory, sorry for length: DS1(30)'s bio father left when he was a baby. It was an unplanned pregnancy and he basically couldn't cope with the commitment. A year later I met my DH, who has been dad ever since. We had two more DCs and have always treated all three entirely equally. Ex drifted in and out (mostly out) for a few years, has never paid a penny in any support, and then we lost contact for quite a while (I discovered he was living abroad, but has since moved back). For the last ten years we've been amicably in touch via social media, have spoken on the phone once and messaged a few times; same with him and DS - they've spoken and messaged but not met face to face since DS was a child. DS doesn't seem particularly bothered - he has his own very busy life, Ex lives a very long way from him, and myself, DH, and the other DCs are his family.

However, Ex did mention briefly at one point that DS was his 'next of kin'. I didn't pursue it with him at the time, but I think this would be correct as he had no further children and has been single for a number of years. He has one other sibling and some nieces/nephews, but that's it. I mentioned this to DS, but we are unsure of what that might mean in a practical sense, and neither of us feels particularly comfortable to ask Ex any more about it.

Also, I do wonder if this means Ex plans to leave his estate to DS, or if this would automatically happen anyway? If this is the case (and here's where I'm probably BU) I can't help feeling that would somehow be unfair on our other DCs after we've strived so hard to keep everything equal between them. In mine and DH's wills we have split everything exactly equally between all three. It doesn't seem fair if DS1 then might inherit a load from another 'dad' who was never in the picture.

DH thinks it's not our business and says if that happens, it is what it is. Also, there's a lot of 'ifs' involved - Ex might meet someone else (he's late 50s) and we know nothing of his business or finances, etc etc. I'm sure he's right, and know life isn't always fair and equal and all our DCs are making their own way in the world now, but still, I wonder if IAB entirely U to feel this way?

Also, can anyone shed light on what 'next of kin' might actually mean for DS?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EggInANest · 10/09/2023 17:47

The chances are his father will live another 30 years or so.

Who knows what life will look like when your Ds is 60. When he may be more or less in contact with his father.

It sounds like just a comment that your ex made. An observation. Your Ds doesn’t need to ask him more about it, and you certainly don’t.

Sleeping dogs.

Topseyt123 · 10/09/2023 15:37

I think your DH is right. This is something that you cannot control or influence.

Plus, your DS is 30 now. Very definitely an adult and harsh as it may seem, the time when you held much influence has gone. Whatever happens between him and his biological father is just that - between the two of them. The best thing you can do is stay out of it. They are under no obligation to share the information with anyone else anyway, including you.

I'm not saying this to sound nasty. I get that you want to treat all of your (now adult) children equally and I think that is great. You can do that only by dividing your own assets up equally in your wills as that is what you have to work with. Remember that although you brought your three children up all together, the circumstances surrounding your eldest DS are and will remain somewhat different. Presumably they all know and can understand that.

Do you actually know what sort of an estate your ex actually has anyway? He could be a billionaire or a pauper, or anything in-between. Not that I think it is a question you should be asking.

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 15:15

SleepingStandingUp · 10/09/2023 14:50

I'm an over thinker too so I get it. Yanbu to think about it but ypu're wasting your energy worrying about it.

Thanks, yes - I am an over thinker! And I do realise that this hypothetical situation is not something I have (or would want) any control over.

To be honest, it's been a relief to have it confirmed that I am BU, although it has made me realise I've been naive and simplistic about certain things. It's always good to reflect on your feelings, even when you're wrong.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 10/09/2023 14:50

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 12:45

Just to be clear, I wasn't suggesting in any way that DS or anyone else should share anything (if indeed it happens), and of course it's not our business. My question was really to ponder how far AIBU to feel this way? As a parent we do try and make things as fair as possible, but I guess it's a lesson in life to know this can't always be the case.

I'm an over thinker too so I get it. Yanbu to think about it but ypu're wasting your energy worrying about it.

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 14:34

This is exactly what happened to me when my uncle named me. The hospital phoned me to ask permission to turn off his life support

Medics may ask any named next of kin their OPINION on what they think the person's wishes may have been, but it should be made 100% clear that the next of kin is not and should not be the decision-maker.

The law is very clear:

https://healthtalk.org/intensive-care-experiences-family-friends/end-of-life-decisions#:~:text=Even%20if%20someone%20is%20'next,give%20a%20relative%20such%20powers.

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 10/09/2023 14:34

On the topic of inheritance, the next of kin thing is a red herring.

Your ex could have written a will leaving everything to your son, or the cats home, and that would be unaffected by the next of kin thing.

If he dies without having made a valid will it would follow the laws of intestacy.

Of course he could die with very little to his name - especially if there was no home ownership and / or a lengthy stay in a care home.

Anonymouseposter · 10/09/2023 14:30

If his biological father names him as next of kin on his medical records he will be contacted if his father becomes ill. If his father is in hospital and requires social care and support on discharge your son would also be contacted about that situation.

EggInANest · 10/09/2023 14:25

Treating your children equally means that you, their parents, treat them equally. Damage is done when you give on Dc a big house deposit and not the other. Etc, all the things we see causing upset on MN threads.

Beyond that it is a lottery for all. One of your Dc might land a top paying job / one might have to downsize following divorce, one might win £1m on Premium Bonds, one might become ill.

If one gets an inheritance from a bio relative, just another source of luck.

Otherwise your Dc could possibly be called upon to make a decision in an end of life situation, but they can’t be forced to accept any duties or responsibilities they don’t with to take on or carry out.

If this man dies intestate and doesn’t own a house with a partner or have other kids etc yes your DC would inherit a chunk

But he could marry, have kids, need everything he’s got for a care home, anything could happen.

No point in you thinking about it.

MissingMoominMamma · 10/09/2023 14:25

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 12:43

Medical-wise, hospitals may contact your son as next of kin, but only if his bio father has given them his details as a contact, and he wants them to keep him informed.

Your son wouldn't be asked to make medical decisions on his behalf. This only happens on TV.

This is exactly what happened to me when my uncle named me. The hospital phoned me to ask permission to turn off his life support.

TaigaSno · 10/09/2023 14:17

Regarding inheritance, you are being unreasonable. However much you believe you have kept things equal, they are not equal. Life is not equal. One of your children may or may not inherit something from their biological father. One of your children may win the lottery one day. One may get a job that pays significantly more than another. One may marry someone much wealthier than another. And so on. You can raise them however you want. But you cannot control what happens in their life.

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 14:02

Appleofmyeye2023

I am informed, thank you. Next of kin has no automatic legal rights / power in and of itself, whatsoever.

NOK should not be asked to make or influence on medical decisions. This was made very clear to me by the doctor who turned off my father's life support. It was made extremely clear that I had no responsibilty.

Nobody may be compelled to act as executor/administrator of an estate. They simply return form PA15 and send it to the court.

Your link decribes how the nearest relative can decline to act.

There is nothing about being someone's NOK that legally compells them to do anything they don't want to do.

zeibesaffron · 10/09/2023 13:54

I agree with your DH - its none of your business what his bio dad leaves/ doesn’t leave your son in his will - or from his estate. Many things can happen between now and then so why are you worrying about something you have no control over. You cannot make this equal for all 3 kids.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 10/09/2023 13:52

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 13:26

I imagine that if your ex goes to hospital or has an accident where medical decisions need to be made, your DS will be the first person who is called by the hospital or emergency services

This only happens on TV. Next of kin (outwith power of attorney) do not make medical decisions in the UK, doctors do.

They are notified and they are consulted on medical matters (if time permits) . When my mum died, my dad was asked to confirm he was in agreement to turn off her life support. It is one of most difficult things to do. Usually NOK don’t disagree with doctors- but court cases do come up (usually NOK loose as doctors and ethical committee usually know what they are doing)

The “nearest relative” DOES have legal rights under the mental health act . Those rights extend quite far. Im nearest relative (as NOK given it is same thing) , for my 87 dad, with LBD. He’s sectioned. Previously he was deprived of liberty . They have to keep me informed . I’m invited to weekly ward rounds for instance, which is standard for nearest relative. I could theoretically apply for him to be discharged under mental health act- but that’s usually a rare and extreme thing.

yes, I agree a LPOA gives a lot more rights to attorney. I’d always, and do always, recommend it to anyone. I’ve had them since they became LPOA and am in my 60s. My DSs are acting together, and they know where my expression of wishes is that details a lot of stuff about how I would want to be cared for and how to manage my finances.

.

daytriptovulcan · 10/09/2023 13:47

What a ridiculous post. You can't control or influence who the Ex might leave his estate to upon death... it might be a small compensation to DS for having had a useless father over the decades. As to whether you think it's unfair, I image thats no concern of your Exs.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 10/09/2023 13:46

I've never wanted my DS to feel ANY different to his siblings, but perhaps that was naive of me.

With respect - yes, it is naive. He's not the same as his siblings because his dad wasn't in the picture and he was raised by his step-dad. No matter how lovely your DH is and how wonderful your DS's childhood was, he still didn't have his dad in the same way the others did.

ThreeLittleDots · 10/09/2023 13:43

Appleofmyeye2023

None of this is true

janeaustensstuntdouble · 10/09/2023 13:42

Thanks for everyone's replies - certainly food for thought. I'll ignore those who assume what I'm thinking this somehow reflects badly on how I feel about my DS - this absolutely couldn't be further from the truth, but I may not have given enough information and I nor wouldn't want to here. It's precisely the opposite - I've never wanted my DS to feel ANY different to his siblings, but perhaps that was naive of me.

Suffice to say that it's not about any real or imaginary inheritance (I've stated a number of times that I know this is not my business) but the feelings involved, which I know make no sense. I'm going to have to leave it there while I think it through some more, but thanks for all the replies.

OP posts:
ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 10/09/2023 13:41

One of your children could end up much richer than the others by having a lucrative career, marrying into money, or even winning the lottery. It's just the way life works out sometimes.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 10/09/2023 13:39

Aside form inheritance…next of kin does have some legal meanings your son needs to be aware of

  1. if his dad becomes mentally incapacitated at some point in future, and needs to be detained under mental act, or even “just” deprived of liberty (eg develops certain dementia behaviours) then your son become “nearest relative” by default. He will be asked for his opinion about his dads wishes etc. he can refuse, in which case this will pass to next nearest relative
  2. similalry as next of kin he may be contacted and asked to make key medical decisions like do not resuscitate or withdrawing life support. Again he can refuse to get involved.
  3. if he dies intestate, and with no executor, your son will be responsible for a whole raft of admin exercises to do with registering the death, funeral arrangements, and applying for the grant of register. That’s needed even if his dash as nothing but debts - those still need to be resolved to right off .
  4. he’ll also be first to be notified in event of his dads death,

However, none of those things are stuff you want to be dealing with in heat of moment. It’s also not helpful for nhs, local councils trying to deal with someone who can express their own wishes at critical crisis points. It needs to be resolved now.

The best way is for your ds to look up all stuff he may be contacted for and decide now if it’s something he’d even want to do or feel capable of doing. If not he needs to write a letter to his father saying he will not be acting as next of kin, and to tell him explicitly not to use his name with nhs etc as NOK. and that his dad is best advised to put a LPOA in place (both types) and a will with nominated executor, to ensure he (dad) knows who will manage these decision- attorneys and executor nominated need to agree they’ll undertake roles, when it’s signed ahead of needing it.

if you talk to your ex again, make this point too, say unless he puts LPOAs in place, and has a will, next of kin is meaningless if son can’t or won’t be involved for whatever reasons. And that’ll just cause his son unnecessary distress at time. Ex needs to nominate attorney with attorneys consent and get it formalised into LPOA. He needs to get an executor as well. Some people appoint solicitors in absence of other relatives, wanting to do it, or being capable of doing it.

I believe Scottish law is different, and is different about children’s inheritance . So look that up if it applies.

Takacupokindnessyet · 10/09/2023 13:35

Either ask your ex outright what goes intentions are or keep out of it and what will be will be.

CecilyP · 10/09/2023 13:34

Also, I do wonder if this means Ex plans to leave his estate to DS, or if this would automatically happen anyway?

If ex is on the birth certificate and he dies intestate, your DS would inherit everything. So what difference for it make if he writes a will to say the same thing. You cannot expect him to leave anything to children that are not his just because they are part of the same family,

Workawayxx · 10/09/2023 13:31

your dh is right, you can’t worry about this as who knows what will happen. Your dc (all 3) will see that you’ve kept things equal from your side and that’s all that will matter. Even if things do become “unfair” due to ds inheriting from his bio dad, as a pp said, he has had the rejection from his dad to deal with his whole life so has had that “unfairness” to deal with.

Swipe left for the next trending thread