Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a school shoe spot the difference thread!

220 replies

TheUnstoppableWindmill · 10/09/2023 11:35

Can you work out which of these shoes is NOT an acceptable school shoe for a policy which states that students must wear black shoes of polishable leather in a non-trainer style?

I've got a year 7 child just starting secondary school. We were encouraged to email the Head of Year to check that shoes are acceptable under the school policy if we had any doubts. Thanks to a helpful Mumsnet thread I sent a handful of pictures in the style that I know if comfortable for my son. I was told these were "all perfect."

The ones I bought have now been rejected. I genuinely can't tell the difference.

So, AIBU to think that if 3 out of 4 of these shoes are perfect, then they should all be acceptable?
And can you guess which ones are too "trainer-like"?!

It's a school shoe spot the difference thread!
It's a school shoe spot the difference thread!
It's a school shoe spot the difference thread!
It's a school shoe spot the difference thread!
OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Britneyfan · 10/09/2023 13:21

I would have guessed the hush puppies but it’s a very close thing and I honestly don’t think they look like trainers. I do think the school are being unreasonably fussy here, especially for a child with the additional needs you mention.

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 10/09/2023 13:21

Regardless of your view on whether school uniform's a good thing, this level of pettiness over small details is a waste of time for teachers, a waste of money for parents, and causes children unnecessary anxiety.

gawditswindy · 10/09/2023 13:21

I'm just imagining Mumsnetters at the gym - if so many people think these shoes are trainers. Grin

Alwayswonderedwhy · 10/09/2023 13:20

I can't believe the head has nothing better to do!
These are all perfectly acceptable shoes for school. None of them stand out as being different.

NotAgainBrian · 10/09/2023 13:18

There's absolutely nothing wrong with any of the shoes you have posted photos of. There's no chance I'd be spending more money on another pair of shoes. If school are so unhappy with the ones you bought they can bloody well pay for a new pair. Honestly, it's ridiculous.

ScissorsPaperStone · 10/09/2023 13:18

TheUnstoppableWindmill · 10/09/2023 12:15

I am very grateful for all of the opinions- thank you! It is the Hush Puppies that I bought, so I am climbing down from my outrage a little.
I am glad that some people thought that the Clarks and Startrite were more trainer-like though, as that was what I thought. My logic when I bought them was 'these must be fine because surely these are less like trainers than the Clarks ones'. I thought they were basically identical to the Next ones except with 2 straps rather than 1. I clearly don't pay enough attention to the nuance of footwear to notice these subtle differences!

Thank you all!

I think the hush puppies are the least trainer-like and thought the start-rite were the most! Blimey, what a minefield.

TheUnstoppableWindmill · 10/09/2023 13:17

Mildmanneredmum · 10/09/2023 13:07

I don't understand - you sent them pictures of the shoes you wanted to check were ok, got the ok, then went and bought others?

I sent 3 pictures to check not the specific shoes I was buying but the style. I then went to the local specialist uniform shop that stocks all the school-branded uniform items and my son tried a selection of what I thought were the same style of shoe, and we bought the ones that were most comfortable and fitted best.
We were 2 days before the start of term by this point (yes, I should have done it earlier) so I didn't have time to get the specific ones we chose approved.
I should have bought one of the specific ones they had checked but I was over-confident in my ability to judge what would be ok as they had called all of the others "perfect".

OP posts:
Flakey99 · 10/09/2023 13:07

My son has dyspraxia so his shoes have either elastic stretch laces, Velcro fastenings or elastic stretch sides.

In your shoes, pardon the pun, I wouldn’t back down and I’d tell the school where to go with their ridiculous footwear policy. Thankfully, the school my DS goes to is fairly low key on uniform policy and so providing the shoes are black, more or less anything goes.

I’m often surprised by how many Mumsnetters are willing to roll over and accept any batshit over zealous uniform policies for fear of being thought a difficult parent. Weird!

Mildmanneredmum · 10/09/2023 13:07

I don't understand - you sent them pictures of the shoes you wanted to check were ok, got the ok, then went and bought others?

LuluBlakey1 · 10/09/2023 13:06

I speak as a school improvement advisor and ex DH in a secondary school and I can not understand why schools have a problem with any of those shoes. I can understand the next step which is children turning up in black trainers and parents arguing the toss.

The issue really is that too many parents (not you OP) simply don't want their child to conform to any uniform - so whatever the rule is they push the boundary and once a few get away with it, more do it.

So black school trousers slip to black jeans or cords, or black leggings or black trackie bottoms or cropped style trousers.

Black sweatshirts become trackie tops, or have sports logos, or other logos.

I can not think there is any argument presented by parents about school uniform that teachers have not heard before. Schools bend over backwards with leaflets, letters home, newsletters, parent evenings, meetings, website photos, school brochures etc to illustrate what is expected and what isn't acceptable. It ends up as seeming like nit-picking but the problem is almost always parents- who will not say no to their child or could not care less and just like a row. If all parents did as the school asks, there would be a handful of misunderstandings and that is all. As it is, schools keep 'refining' the wording to close down the gaps and wriggle room and it becomes ridiculous- as in this instance. There should be no problem with any of these shoes.

ActDottie · 10/09/2023 13:04

The hush puppy ones are definitely black trainers rather than school shoes I think

CecilyP · 10/09/2023 13:04

Spinkey · 10/09/2023 12:46

I would say all of those are unacceptable because they have a flat trainer sole with no defined heel. I’ve attached an example with a defined heel which imo makes it a “shoe” not a “trainer”.

No, you’re thinking of a wedge sole that exists on a variety of shoes and sandals that are not trainers. Clarks were even doing a wedge sole school shoe years before trainers were a thing.

LolaSmiles · 10/09/2023 13:04

But I would say if you emailed the other three but then bought the hush puppies you’ve gone for a different style.
I'd say the same.
They look more trainer style to me, but that's from knowing what sort of line many of our local schools would take.

Personally though I think all of them should be okay and the school are being unreasonably fussy. It's not like the OP has done what some parents do and tried to buy the cool trainers in black and then is moaning that school don't accept trainers.

LakieLady · 10/09/2023 13:03

All this stuff gives me the utter rage, and I'm not even a parent. It seems to me that many schools have their priorities all wrong and that heads/governors/SLTs/whoever makes these decisions are little more than control freaks.

Schools should be focussing on education, and last time I looked, what you wear on your sodding feet has bugger all to do with it.

I went to a rather snooty girls' grammar and our uniform rules were nowhere near as strict as this. Although we did have to wear brown shoes, which imo look shit with a navy uniform.

SoupDragon · 10/09/2023 13:02

BlooDeBloop · 10/09/2023 13:00

Do have a look. I got ones with small screw type toggles. They are discrete. We couldn't get on with velcro as we have a hairy dog whose fur clogged up the teeth in about a month of wear.

I used to find picking the fluff out of Velcro with a pin oddly satisfying 😂

Shutuptrevor · 10/09/2023 13:01

The Hush Puppies are the most trainer-like, but they aren’t a HUGE outlier in my opinion.

Honestly, after the shitshow that formal education has been in this country the last few weeks, it makes me furious that this is what they’re choosing to fixate on.

SoupDragon · 10/09/2023 13:01

It is the Hush Puppies that I bought

I guessed these because I think they look like a canvas shoe in style.

BlooDeBloop · 10/09/2023 13:00

Mountainhowl · 10/09/2023 12:18

I'll have to have a look at the options again, we tried some elastic ones a few years ago but they had a big toggle and then a loop of elastic which looked much less smart than velcro!

Do have a look. I got ones with small screw type toggles. They are discrete. We couldn't get on with velcro as we have a hairy dog whose fur clogged up the teeth in about a month of wear.

misskatamari · 10/09/2023 13:00

Utter madness! I’d have picked the Clark’s as most “trainer like” too, if pushed. But these are all black shoes that look very similar and are practical for school. Ugh I hate this shoe nonesense! None of those are trainers, or actually like trainers!

Runnersandtoms · 10/09/2023 13:00

This kind of thing have been great for my lace-hating kids, they look smart on smart shoes. They can do laces but they come undone all the time so they do triple knots which they then can't undo. So it makes kife easier to avoid them.

TheUnstoppableWindmill · 10/09/2023 12:59

JimJonesLivesInMyHead · 10/09/2023 12:52

That school is batshit. I'd be inclined to email them and ask why they are wasting time on such utter trivialities when it could be far better spent on actually supporting your son.

I hope he settles well into secondary school, and wish him good luck

Thanks for the good wishes @JimJonesLivesInMyHead . Much appreciated!

OP posts:
TheUnstoppableWindmill · 10/09/2023 12:56

Snittle · 10/09/2023 12:44

I’d email the head with all four pics and ask if any of these are acceptable. They’re all so similar I’ll be astounded if he picks out the hush puppies as not allowed when the others are!

I was thinking this but seeing as the majority on this thread identified the Hush Puppies I'm going to climb down from my fight response and have ordered the Next ones for delivery tomorrow.

Nothing has been said about the branding btw- rather that the Hush Puppies are trainer-like while the other ones aren't.

OP posts:
JustEatTheOneInTheBallPit · 10/09/2023 12:56

I know from school gate conversations that I’m in the minority re: uniform and shoes. I think it’s nice for children to look smart and I am not fond of the move towards “sporty” attire in schools.

These all look trainer-y to me. They would pass at my son’s primary but not at my daughter’s secondary school where they do not accept Velcro unless ASN. Slip ons are the lace free shoe of choice there.

Moonsoup · 10/09/2023 12:54

KindleAndCake · 10/09/2023 12:48

They all look the same to me.

We've just moved from Scotland so I'm dealing with this just now.
It's much more relaxed up there. In primary school my dc's wore any shoes to school because they changed into 'indoor shoes' once in school, kept the school cleaner, and the kids all the same. They all wore black pumps inside.
In secondary it's just black shoes, just not trainers or heels. But it's not strict like I'm reading here.

I remember the days of indoor shoes at primary in Scotland! Is it still common now? I can see in general carpets getting muddier and wetter than in England, where I've never known indoor shoes to be a thing, but as a teacher I shudder at the thought of shoe changes several times a day.

Bromptotoo · 10/09/2023 12:52

Have the school explained clearly WHY the Hush Puppies are not OK?