Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed by DP's salary cut

257 replies

Lemonsugarhigh · 10/09/2023 07:17

DP lost his job in April (a job he hated) and has been doing nothing since, just living off savings/decent redundancy money. Totally fine, because he needed a break. I wasn't concerned. He applied for several jobs but was rejected at final stage for all of them, and he was becoming disheartened. So he felt compelled to take a job that's MUCH more junior, paying significantly less than he was on before. Less than half his last salary in fact. He's now earning half my salary too. I know it shouldn't but it bothers me. Everyone else moves jobs and gets raises. Even DP's brother who's 8 years younger and doesn't have a single qualification recently got a new job paying more than what DP will be on now. DP doesn't seem bothered.

We were supposed to be trying to buy our first home together, but not financially possible now. Aibu to be disappointed? Should he have held out until he got a better offer?

OP posts:
Greenberg2 · 12/09/2023 15:40

It doesn't sound to me like you're compatible. I think it's very unkind to be disappointed all the time that your partner doesn't measure up to your expectations. It's different being encouraging and supportive but that's not how you come across at all.

Why don't you find yourself a go-getter? You might find out they're more focused on their career than you but that's the choice you need to make.

herewegoagainfriends · 12/09/2023 15:35

People often link ambition to earning capacity because quite often, those two things go hand in hand. However, you can be ambitious without chasing a high-earning job.

Ambitious is wanting a better life for yourself and your loved ones. The OP isn't just earning twice as much as her DP now, she is ambitious about wanting to create a home for them both. A better future.

Her DP doesn't seem to be thinking about buying a property, and in unilaterally deciding to take a low paid job, he doesn't see to be thinking about how much financial pressure that puts on her either. He is not showing signs that he is thinking about wanting a better life for them.

It is the attitude that is getting the OP down, and it's unsurprising she is comparing her DP to others in her life and wanting him lacking. She doesn't deserve all the horrible comments in this thread - she wants someone who, like her, wants to create a better life for their partner.

Ultimately, I don't think this is a one-time loss of confidence. I think the writing has been on the wall for a long time. You cannot change someone to make them feel more ambitious - it's a personality trait. They either have it or they don't. I don't think they are compatible, unfortunately.

Incidentally, in my line of work, it would not be better to take 'any job' following a redundancy. It would make more sense to live off the redundancy and wait out a role at the right level. This is not the case in all lines of work, but it should be noted that OP and her DP have worked together previously, so her insights into what is normal should be accepted. If she thinks he should have waited it out, she's probably right. Why do we have to assume she's wrong?

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 12/09/2023 15:28

Depends how you look at it.....I mean my boss lost his job as a bank manager during the last recession, took a minimum wage, low level job at my place of work to pay the bills. Within 18 months he was running the place.

The situation with money isn't great but it won't be forever, he probably isn't feeling too positive either, now's the time to boost his confidence, not treat his efforts as a disappointment.

Nam3chang384 · 12/09/2023 15:22

Hmm - this is a tough one. In some ways I can understand you being disappointed but on the other hand I think you need to accept the character of the person you are in a relationship with (or leave). It's fine to try and help our OHs to be the best version of themselves that they can be, but they have got to want the help, otherwise YABU pushing your ideals onto them. You say he is a content creature and it sounds like you are not. You need to decide whether you are ultimately compatible. A life spent nagging someone to be someone they are not doesn't sound very appealing to me.

Tessabelle74 · 12/09/2023 14:50

Half what he was on is better than living off savings. As long as he's still actively looking for something else I'd suck it up for now

Notjustabrunette · 12/09/2023 14:41

you feel disappointed, and I understand that. However on the plus side, he does now have a job. A friend’s brother lost his job years ago and refused to get a job that was lower paid than his last, which was a big mistake. at least he is earning money and laying about at home.
I’ve read your posts and confidence does seem to be an issue with him. Why is that? Maybe he needs to go on a course or counseling to build his confidence up so that he is more likely to get a promotion or a better paying job?

Flakey99 · 12/09/2023 14:39

I can appreciate that you’re worried about your current financial situation but maybe step back and stop comparing your DH negatively to other people? That won’t help his confidence if he knows you think this way.

Most people’s working lives rarely follow a steady uphill trajectory and there can be many kinks in the road and career changes along the way.

Many years ago I changed jobs and went part-time and at a lower pay grade in order to get a foot in the door to another career. It worked out well and I quickly established myself in the new career.

Thankfully, my DP at the time was willing to support me taking that risk but if you feel that he’s not as committed in the way that you are to improving your joint finances, then maybe the relationship needs to come to an end?

Anna79ishere · 12/09/2023 13:20

You write he was underpaid in his previous job, but when he applied to what I assumed similar jobs with similar pay he was not hired. So he was probably paid too much? Or in a senior position he actually did not merit?
I am not sure which field you are in the job sector is very dynamic and competitive and if he is complacent and does not keep on learning and evolving, skills become old and redundant, so you get actually paid less. It sounds a new job with half pay is probably too low, but if he just was after quiet living and never evolved, stretched let’s say in 2-3 years, probably a 30% cut is expected. Depending on the sector in his case it was 50% which might be possible if the sector moves very quickly

BlossomOfOrange · 12/09/2023 11:14

Not wrong to be disappointed. Not wrong to take a more junior job.

Starting in a more junior job may actually help his confidence, from being able to do a job well with less stress. And from there, draw on skills he already has to progress up the ladder.

Katbum · 12/09/2023 11:02

This sounds like you need a bigger conversation about relationship goals, and where you are headed as a couple. Does he share your dreams of homeownership? Does he want to ‘climb the ladder’, or is he happy with his lot (not necessarily a bad thing)? If children are in your room plans then that will impact the finances of the relationship down the line (in my relationship, it’s been my partner who has stopped working to do the lion’s share of the childcare, as we weren’t happy for a stranger to take care of her. It helped that I was earning significantly more than him already, as it made the choice and the impact of it easier).

If this is your life partner you need to like him and respect his choices about how he lives his life. If you don’t and this compromises what you want for your own life, maybe time to move on?

NDWifeandMan · 12/09/2023 09:59

ItsNotRocketSalad · 12/09/2023 09:32

Probably not always, no, but as OP works in the same field it’s likely she has more insight into the field that she has not disclosed to us on this thread.

I think it's pretty clear from the OP's posts that she doesn't have a lot of insight into recruitment and is making assumptions based on her own criticisms of her partner.

How is that clear?
OP if the degree's an issue then he should make getting one a priority. The job market is bad now, employers have lots of choice, why would anybody choose him over someone who has a degree and is 'just as' good, unless he's in a shortage profession?

I also have no idea how you're always #fighting fires' related to your DP and your lives are on a 'perpetual' downward trend. He just got made redundant but made 60K with no degree prior to that. How is that fighting fires? Unless you mean stagnating, which isn't ideal yes but it's definitely not fighting fires.

If you want an ambitious go-getter then that's what you have to go for. I did, and I got what I wanted. Someone with no degree btw wouldn't be high on my list, it's so easy to get one these days it will hold you back sooner or later if you don't get one eventually! Or at least, an NVQ level 6 qualification.

NDWifeandMan · 12/09/2023 09:54

Castleview6 · 10/09/2023 18:49

What a patronising attitude towards refuse collectors…they deserve decent wages because of the essential role they do for society. You’re ‘even doing the bins…” is horrible. I hope your job contributes to everyone’s lives as much as theirs does.

Where did PP say that?
40K is a massive salary for a largely automated process.
I wonder why female dominated professions like caring who actually have to deal with human shit etc get paid minimum wage. Even teachers don't get paid 40K unless top of band.
Also binmen never have to take any work home!

ItsNotRocketSalad · 12/09/2023 09:32

Probably not always, no, but as OP works in the same field it’s likely she has more insight into the field that she has not disclosed to us on this thread.

I think it's pretty clear from the OP's posts that she doesn't have a lot of insight into recruitment and is making assumptions based on her own criticisms of her partner.

Middlelanehogger · 12/09/2023 08:26

I see the PP's point in some industries though, and particularly in some professions and senior roles. If you got laid off from an investment bank and took a job as, idk, a corporate finance manager, in some areas that would be seen as "you couldn't hack it in the intense world of IB, you've stepped off the accelerator" etc.

Whereas if you said you took six months off to travel South America and go scuba diving you'd still be "like us" because investment bankers like going scuba diving and see it as intense and exciting. You could spin it as "I took the money and had the holiday of a fucking lifetime #workhardplayhard. I'm fucking great and I knew I'd get another gig as soon as I got back", which is both a class and confidence signal.

Starwind74 · 12/09/2023 00:27

Could he do a degree while working perhaps with Open University. I know this would take some time, but at least he would hopefully be in line for a better paid job in his field. Alternatively if it is because you want him earning more money so you can buy a house, could he get an evening or weekend job?

XelaM · 11/09/2023 23:25

beautifuldaytosavelives · 11/09/2023 22:48

Hmm. There are practical truths to the ‘any job is better than no job’ school of thought and if you can’t pay the bills, it’s particularly true. But if you can hold off for the right level, organisation, grade, salary…whatever it is, it’s a better plan for your career. I took a massive drop in status and salary after being made redundant and I don’t believe my career will ever recover. Couldn’t get back into my own industry quickly enough and I haven’t got the experience in this one to progress. I’m often gripped by ‘what if I’d just waited for the next one?’, and of course I’ll never know.

Actually a CV gap is much worse. It's much easier to embellish a job on your CV to make it look like you had more responsibilities than to explain a CV gap. The onboarding/background check process at some large international firms (at least in my industry) actually doesn't allow you to leave any gaps on your CV.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 11/09/2023 23:06

beautifuldaytosavelives · 11/09/2023 22:48

Hmm. There are practical truths to the ‘any job is better than no job’ school of thought and if you can’t pay the bills, it’s particularly true. But if you can hold off for the right level, organisation, grade, salary…whatever it is, it’s a better plan for your career. I took a massive drop in status and salary after being made redundant and I don’t believe my career will ever recover. Couldn’t get back into my own industry quickly enough and I haven’t got the experience in this one to progress. I’m often gripped by ‘what if I’d just waited for the next one?’, and of course I’ll never know.

You don't have to put every job you've ever had on your CV. If you need the money but think it looks bad from a "they only look at the most recent job" perspective, then lead your CV with the most recent relevant job. If they ask what you're doing now, you can honestly say that you are working to keep the wolves from the door but your passion and career goals lie elsewhere. Your CV is a showcase of relevant skills and experience. You can't lie on it but you don't have to include irrelevant stuff that isn't part of the focus.

beautifuldaytosavelives · 11/09/2023 22:48

Hmm. There are practical truths to the ‘any job is better than no job’ school of thought and if you can’t pay the bills, it’s particularly true. But if you can hold off for the right level, organisation, grade, salary…whatever it is, it’s a better plan for your career. I took a massive drop in status and salary after being made redundant and I don’t believe my career will ever recover. Couldn’t get back into my own industry quickly enough and I haven’t got the experience in this one to progress. I’m often gripped by ‘what if I’d just waited for the next one?’, and of course I’ll never know.

anon666 · 11/09/2023 21:26

YABU he's been through a horrendous experience and getting into any job is a good thing for his confidence and future prospects.

caringcarer · 11/09/2023 20:43

Surely any job is better than no job. He can still look for and apply for better paying jobs.

Peachtails · 11/09/2023 20:34

YABU in my opinion.

It certainly doesn't sound like you are compatible and sadly you sound embarrassed of your partner. If you feel he is holding you back, if your values are so vastly different, it's a different conversation you need to have.

My DH and I are both qualified in our own fields, but due to our different sectors I'll never earn his type of wage. It's not an issue (nurse vs. business man). He's inspired me to change careers when I wanted but the (slightly better) money was a bonus, not a condition.

I would never judge or value him on his income, nor him me, whether it goes up or down throughout life.

I wish you luck and hope you can sort things through.

angelfacecuti75 · 11/09/2023 20:14
  1. Perhaps this role will be less stressful and therefore he will be more content and happy? Money is handy , yes and you need to think practically ...i guess but surely being in work is better than not & they say it is easier to find work when you are in work...
  2. Communication is key here.
Justanothercatlady · 11/09/2023 20:13

It’s worth him investing some money into a good decent coach (not a life coach as such more industry specific) to help with presentation and networking. He’s inside a company and can find new opps

Abs2010 · 11/09/2023 19:51

I can completely relate to you. I have a partner who has way more earning potential than me, currently at least, who doesn't have the drive when it's needed. Had a £120K a year contract job that came to an end. He was so relaxed about finding another job, he took a month or so off and then surprise surprise, spent 6 months unable to find a job when he wanted. He now works at a supermarket on minimum wage! I think like other posters have said its definitely a tough job market at the moment. However, I can completely sympathise with you. Frustratingly we had lots of plans (mostly clearing debt), but since he is terrible with money and we have multiple debt payments we now struggle to even cover the basic costs each month.

Fireangels · 11/09/2023 19:50

He applied for several jobs but was rejected at final stage for all of them,

From what you say, I don’t think his lack of a degree is what is holding him back. If it was an essential requirement for the job he’d have been rejected at the shortlisting stage.
You say he has the skills knowledge and experience for the roles he’s applying for so maybe he needs to work on any tests he may have to do (psychometric, presentation skills etc), and practice interview skills. As you are in the same industry you could probably help him with this.
good luck. I hope he finds what he’s looking for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread