Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed by DP's salary cut

257 replies

Lemonsugarhigh · 10/09/2023 07:17

DP lost his job in April (a job he hated) and has been doing nothing since, just living off savings/decent redundancy money. Totally fine, because he needed a break. I wasn't concerned. He applied for several jobs but was rejected at final stage for all of them, and he was becoming disheartened. So he felt compelled to take a job that's MUCH more junior, paying significantly less than he was on before. Less than half his last salary in fact. He's now earning half my salary too. I know it shouldn't but it bothers me. Everyone else moves jobs and gets raises. Even DP's brother who's 8 years younger and doesn't have a single qualification recently got a new job paying more than what DP will be on now. DP doesn't seem bothered.

We were supposed to be trying to buy our first home together, but not financially possible now. Aibu to be disappointed? Should he have held out until he got a better offer?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lalalalala555 · 14/09/2023 12:02

Tricky.

It depends what he wants and what he is willing and is doing.
And also what you want.

Its fair enough you're frustrated. But equally taking out that frustration on him vs talking about it and exploring it and wanting to understand his angle is v different. There is no such right or wrong.

As partners you should both be advocating for the others happiness. If buying a house is important to you that should be something he is supportive of, but equally you should be supportive he has a job? You are both in your own right to make decisions about your own lives. But it's important for a relationship to talk about them, and have consideration for the impact and understand how the other person will receive it.
And then keep evaluating if the relationship is right for you.

Effectively is he planning and taking action to get a better paid job. Is that important to him. Is he happy to stay put. How long for. Are you happy to accept that or do you want a more financially rich aprtner. Is he willing to step up to meet your needs or not. Then you can decide from there.

It is probably not easy for him to magically get any job. It's unfair to judge him on his success when it's not his decision if he gets picked for a job. But it is fair to hold him accountable for his effort, especially if he has said and promised he is going for a salary that is more than what he's on.

Really you just need to talk. To understand what his angle is, where he's at. And what his plan is. What he cares about investing in you and how his career choice effects your relationship. And then evaluate if it's going to be a place where your happy or if it doesn't meet your needs.

Its not fair to harbour resentment for someone without raising your concerns. And it's not good to stay with someone and make them feel inadequate. If he isn't going to step up to what you need, you should consider leaving him. If he isn't able to step up, but wants to that's more tricky. Maybe you allow a time frame or try and rough it for a bit.

People say love should be there without money. But as an adult paying your own way or having open discussions about who's bringing what to the table and both being valued is important. Happiness relates to health.

Maybe you're at peace paying for yourself and him also. Maybe you're not and you want a partner with ambition and action.

Lemmony · 13/09/2023 19:46

Money honestly isn't everything.

bulletproof1979 · 13/09/2023 13:45

Dgrl04 · 13/09/2023 13:38

Honestly it seems maybe there's somwthin else going on. Why would he keep getting rejected at the last point? But also you have every right to be concerned and upset especially since you all had plans to buy a house. Why didn't he find a new job before leaving that one? Idk there's a lot of things there but your feelings are your feelings and it's okay to feel that way!!!

You may want to re-read the OP - he was made redundant.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 13/09/2023 13:44

Held out for how long OP? My husband was let go in 2014 and held out for a better paying job - its 2023 and he still has not found a full time job, but freelancing. So - how long do you think your partner should be holding out for?

Dgrl04 · 13/09/2023 13:38

Honestly it seems maybe there's somwthin else going on. Why would he keep getting rejected at the last point? But also you have every right to be concerned and upset especially since you all had plans to buy a house. Why didn't he find a new job before leaving that one? Idk there's a lot of things there but your feelings are your feelings and it's okay to feel that way!!!

bulletproof1979 · 13/09/2023 12:51

determinedtomakethiswork · 10/09/2023 14:06

It's really not easy to look for a job where the salary is twice as high though.

Your assuming the partner discloses their current salary to the new employer. There's no requirement do so.

bulletproof1979 · 13/09/2023 12:07

I think you are perhaps over reacting - as others have mentioned psychologically job interviews are 100% easier when you're in a job than when you're not. The pressure is off. You should encourage him to be applying for and wide for jobs that interest him (and perhaps even a few he's not) - real word interview experience is valuable and will help him nail something that's a better fit, even if it takes 6 months.

HeidiHunter · 13/09/2023 09:08

It's not a great time to be buying a house right now anyway. Easier to get a job if you're already in employment. I'd back off a bit. Once he gets his confidence back he can try for promotions etc or apply to another firm.

Hereforaglance · 13/09/2023 06:41

He has a job what do u expect him to do sit on benefits untill the perfect job came along getting rejected time and time again have you any idea what that does to a persons self esteem i think u need to grow up and support him he is having a hatd time and you are not helping with your attitude i hope you have not told him of your disappointed that he is not earning enough to keep you in the lifestyle u r used to

NDWifeandMan · 12/09/2023 22:35

*one of you has no choice meant to say. and there's no guarantee the lower earner will pick up the slack

NDWifeandMan · 12/09/2023 22:28

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/09/2023 17:24

Yes but be careful what you wish for. Then you'll be on here saying your "D"newP is always working, never helps with the kids and it's all very well earning lots of money, but...

The grass isn't always greener.

My DH has never earned particularly well but has had good perks and flexible working. And has never had to bail on an evening out or cancel a holiday.

We also need to get away from the idea that husbands have to earn more than wives. I've nearly always earned more than he has.

I once took a paycut for a job I thought I'd prefer - it didn't really work out because of working patterns, but gave me a springboard into the job I have now, so that might also happen for him.

Oh and it's ridiculous for people to suggest using up all your savings. If he has a job take it and earn money. What on earth would the point be of earning nothing and using up all the savings? It makes no sense whatsoever.

Like all other things this depends on your life plan. DH and I prioritised earning well quite early in our careers, in a cheaper city are ready to take the next step with DC. With a nice family home, in a 'ok' area and small mortgage. We have the freedom to decide if one or both of us goes PT, or remain working FT with paid childcare depending on how we (well, mainly I), feel.

Women bear the brunt of pregnancy and childbearing, you really cannot predict the impact it will have on you until it happens. I know a few who had birth injuries/mental impact etc needing quite a while to recover beyond the mat pay period covered by the company. And obviously if you are the main earner you need to go back sooner, you ability to save is reduced by having only one 'good earner'.

Even if I don't work for a few years my higher salary NOW, pre-kids has made all the difference. We certainly couldn't have had all our ducks in a row like this had only one of us made 'decent' money. Neither of us have any family help driving lessons, car, house deposit and our wedding all have been 100% financed out of our joint incomes.

Look at it this way - 2 higher earners, one can always step down later. If there is already a big disparity one of you already has no choice. There is no value judgement on whether or not this is something you choose to accept. I wouldn't, and my DH agrees. OP and her partner don't share the same view, so they need to sort that out.

Btw this would have been impossible in London. You either need to earn loads more or get out. I choose the latter. Maybe OP will have to make a similar choice if she wants to stay with her DP AND get the life she wants. There's plenty of life outside the M25. Just saying.

RedToothBrush · 12/09/2023 19:43

Lemonsugarhigh · 10/09/2023 16:36

And also @LovesJaffaCakes He was made redundant because they cut two departments entirely. 40+ jobs gone I believe. He had the option to fight it out with someone else for a similar role elsewhere in the org, but it wasn't a project he wanted to work on and his redundancy package was pretty lucrative, having been there for 8 years.

If he was as good as you say he wouldn't have been made redundant, surely?

Especially since he'd been there eight years.

The job market is funny at the minute. Certain industries have had a fair number of redundancies so the competition for decent jobs is fierce and salaries have actively dipped as a result.

He has had the foresight to get a job, rather than aimlessly hunt for a job he might struggle to get.

Lemonsugarhigh · 12/09/2023 19:35

beautifuldaytosavelives · 11/09/2023 22:48

Hmm. There are practical truths to the ‘any job is better than no job’ school of thought and if you can’t pay the bills, it’s particularly true. But if you can hold off for the right level, organisation, grade, salary…whatever it is, it’s a better plan for your career. I took a massive drop in status and salary after being made redundant and I don’t believe my career will ever recover. Couldn’t get back into my own industry quickly enough and I haven’t got the experience in this one to progress. I’m often gripped by ‘what if I’d just waited for the next one?’, and of course I’ll never know.

Exactly this. I hope you eventually do get to where you want to be.

OP posts:
Fidgety31 · 12/09/2023 18:07

It sounds like you think you have settled for a second best man - not him settling for a second best job .
You are critical and compare him to others .
Maybe live off your own money rather than trying on him to bankroll you .

LT1982 · 12/09/2023 17:47

It would be impossible to buy a home if he wasnt earning anything at all!

Good on him for taking paid employment and not letting his pride get in the way of a lower paid role. It may just be a stopgap whild he continues looking to progress elsewhere.

Mumto2kids86 · 12/09/2023 17:26

It’s better than no job! He can still look for something better paid. Won’t have gaps on his CV then either.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/09/2023 17:24

BotterMon · 12/09/2023 16:08

Is he happy? If he hated his last job then redundancy must have been a positive. If you don't like his lack of ambition and feel it's a deal breaker, then find someone who matches you better in terms of career goals.

Yes but be careful what you wish for. Then you'll be on here saying your "D"newP is always working, never helps with the kids and it's all very well earning lots of money, but...

The grass isn't always greener.

My DH has never earned particularly well but has had good perks and flexible working. And has never had to bail on an evening out or cancel a holiday.

We also need to get away from the idea that husbands have to earn more than wives. I've nearly always earned more than he has.

I once took a paycut for a job I thought I'd prefer - it didn't really work out because of working patterns, but gave me a springboard into the job I have now, so that might also happen for him.

Oh and it's ridiculous for people to suggest using up all your savings. If he has a job take it and earn money. What on earth would the point be of earning nothing and using up all the savings? It makes no sense whatsoever.

bonzaitree · 12/09/2023 17:11

My partner quit a job he hated in Jan. I told him repeatedly (and forcefully!) thag he was not taking another job with crappy pay. We waited and it massively paid off. Better job now.

He feels better as a man that he is providing more. He is more confident and feels equal in the relationship.

I would be very disappointed if he took a lower paying job again, especially without an « end goal » in mind such as retraining etc.

So YANBU.

You know this is going to create an unhealthy dynamic in your relationship. It already is because of the way you’re describing him on this thread.

JimnyTCat · 12/09/2023 16:52

Strictly in answer to your question - YANBU. I'd be disappointed with job loss, job offers not coming through and the household income dropping. However, I put YABU because the tone suggests you are disappointed in him, not at the situation. What would continuing to 'hold out' and burning through redundancy money achieve? What exactly do you want him to do, except what he is, the best he can manage?
You've mentioned you don't think he's good in interviews because he's a quiet, nervous type. He can't press a button and change that, and if he did, there would still still be no guarantee of landing the job. He might potentially do interview training.

Cucucucu · 12/09/2023 16:41

I can see why you mean so well … my partner got a job during covid so he wouldn’t be without a job to long and is still there now despite being half the wage of his abreviou job , simply because he hates change and hates being told no so he gets very low if he doesn’t get selected . It’s very frustrating as I know he q n do much better

Angrycat2768 · 12/09/2023 16:30

Greenberg2 · 12/09/2023 15:40

It doesn't sound to me like you're compatible. I think it's very unkind to be disappointed all the time that your partner doesn't measure up to your expectations. It's different being encouraging and supportive but that's not how you come across at all.

Why don't you find yourself a go-getter? You might find out they're more focused on their career than you but that's the choice you need to make.

Yes this is what it sounds like to me. If you think he wont be looking for another job, but just be content to be in this job forever ( nothing wrong with that, apart from how you feel about it). Will you, in the future feel like he is holding you back and not allowing you to have the things you want, like a house? If thats the case, it will only get more and more frustrating. YOu may be happier on your own or with someone who has more get up and go, and he may be happier not being pushed all the time to do a better paid job. If hes not relying on you having a higher salary, he may be more motivated to get a better job.

BotterMon · 12/09/2023 16:08

Is he happy? If he hated his last job then redundancy must have been a positive. If you don't like his lack of ambition and feel it's a deal breaker, then find someone who matches you better in terms of career goals.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 12/09/2023 16:08

YABU - he was becoming disheartened. Men can get depression when out of work and if I were in your position, I'd be proud of my husband for not being precious about position and salary.

He's back in the workplace, he's earning some money - be pleased for him.

Gemst199 · 12/09/2023 15:49

It depends what you mean by disappointed - of course you're disappointed that your plan have to change and that your budget is going to be tight. Totally reasonable.
Blaming your husband for the situation, probably unreasonable and unhelpful. My husband was ina very similar situation about 10 years ago, he worked in IT support and ended up going to university to get a degree in his 40s as every job he got following his original redundancy was lower pay and worse conditions than the one before. Not his fault, just part of the whole industry wide move to outsourcing abroad.

adriftinadenofvipers · 12/09/2023 15:47

I totally get how you feel, but there's a lot of positives in this too.

At least he is in a job. He can get back into the routine of working without huge pressure. If a degree is necessary, then he should get one. Does the company he's joined sponsor people to take degrees? Probably not this year as he's only in the door, and it's likely too late to apply for a p/t degree anyway.

He could look at applying for next year, whether he has to fund it or not. With any luck, he could have moved jobs anyway.

I also think he could benefit from coaching - working on his applications, his interview skills etc etc. Did he get feedback from the posts he didn't get? It's really important to do that. Surely you can help him too? Could he work as a contractor as you did?

Get him on LinkedIn too if you haven't already and build up contacts within the industry. You must both already know people if you've been working in the same field for a number of years.

Talk to him, encourage him - tell him how proud you are of his resilience that he stuck out unemployment and kept trying, and that he didn't just accept something he didn't want to do in his old employment. Talk about plans for the future, buying a house etc and make sure you are both on the same page, otherwise this will cause issues long-term.

Short-term, can you get a higher paying job to fill the gap in household income?