Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler at dog euthanasia

239 replies

Mr85 · 09/09/2023 22:07

Our dog is now approaching the end and it won't be long until we have to make the call we all dread 😔

Our 3.5 year old son knows what death is. My wife recently lost her grandfather, who he knew a little, but didn't attend the funeral. He did attend my Nan's burial, although he never met her, and acted impecebally.

We've explained that the dog is ill, might not get better and may soon die. When he heard this he teared up and gave him a hug saying he didn't want him to die and he'll miss him so we know he understands what is going to happen.

My wife and I have slightly conflicting views but which are close enough that we could do either with the others blessing. I think our son should be there as he is part of the pack/family and it's a part of life. My wife thinks he is a little too young and it might cause him too much additional upset.

We've already decided what to do as, let's face it, using MN to make big life decisions is not the best idea. I'm just curious as to what everybody thinks.

I think our 3.5 year old son should be there: AIBU?

OP posts:
sjj28358 · 10/09/2023 01:03

Distressing for the dog (and takes your focus away from him) if toddler is crying which previous reaction suggests he might - and also potentially distressing for your toddler if his mum and dad are upset. Don't do it.

Your son doesn't need to be there at the actual moment of death. It might not be nice, the dog might struggle, void his bowels, etc.

Why not compromise by letting your DS see / stroke the lifeless dog to say goodbye? See how he looks the same, but is cold and stiff. Maybe you could curl the dog up in a box or his basket and pick some flowers to lay around him.

Thatladdo · 10/09/2023 01:02

It sounds like an exellent idea, if you want to give you child PTSD!

This is nearly as ridiculous as Hyacinth Bucket hiring a car earlier on, must be something to do with the sun or heat today...

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 10/09/2023 01:02

PrtScn · 10/09/2023 00:15

Nah, I’d rather have a well adjusted child that has a basic understanding of life and death than a molycoddled smothered one. Children the world over experience far more disturbing shit than seeing their dog peacefully die.

I can't think of anything worse than a mollycoddled preschooler. Did he have to get time off work to come?

Ericaequites · 10/09/2023 01:00

It’s inappropriate. That covers so many situations.

tianabiscuit · 10/09/2023 00:58

egowise · 10/09/2023 00:50

It was actually very traumatic for me as an adult as my beloved dog didn't pass peacefully from the injection.

He howled in pain the whole time. I'm crying now, just thinking about it. This was 8 years ago.

Do not do this.

I've just had a tear writing about our cat, who was similarly squealing and fighting. 12 years ago for us.

tianabiscuit · 10/09/2023 00:56

Dotcheck · 09/09/2023 22:14

Nope.

I’ve been in that situation with 2 dogs recently. One went very peacefully, the other fought it. It was really traumatic and I’ve never told my children how their beloved pet went, and they were over 18.

Being there for a pet when it is the end is really hard, even for grown ups.
It would be irresponsible to take a small child.

A similar experience here. Our cat reached the end and we made the decision to euthanise at home when our daughter (then 3.5 years) was at nursery.

On the day DD was running a temperature and had to stay at home. My mum took her to play in her room while it happened and I'm glad she did because our poor cat fought it. It upset me terribly to witness that and I would never want a small child to see it.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 10/09/2023 00:55

This has got to have been a wind up, surely? In what fucked up parenting world would you do this?

My eyesight isn't great and I've just (slightly) misread the OPs name as MrBS...

egowise · 10/09/2023 00:50

It was actually very traumatic for me as an adult as my beloved dog didn't pass peacefully from the injection.

He howled in pain the whole time. I'm crying now, just thinking about it. This was 8 years ago.

Do not do this.

tianabiscuit · 10/09/2023 00:49

Not a chance. It's not always peaceful and simply going to sleep. I wouldn't want to risk a young child witnessing that.

TheLadyInWestminsterAbbey · 10/09/2023 00:48

Definitely not.

Also you never know what's around the corner.
We had a cat put down when DD1 was about five. She wasn't there obviously. But I explained it was like when doctors make people go to sleep for operations but they give a bit more drugs so they go to sleep forever and it's very peaceful.
The next week she broke her arm and had to have it set under anaesthetic - they initially thought it would need pinning. She said "what if they give me too much, like George?" I said "they won't".
"But what if they do???"

So that was a silly explanation I had given at the time.

StEtienne93 · 10/09/2023 00:45

Dotcheck · 09/09/2023 22:14

Nope.

I’ve been in that situation with 2 dogs recently. One went very peacefully, the other fought it. It was really traumatic and I’ve never told my children how their beloved pet went, and they were over 18.

Being there for a pet when it is the end is really hard, even for grown ups.
It would be irresponsible to take a small child.

I agree with this.

I had a dog that fought it too and it was really awful. Played on my mind for years, even though I knew it was the right thing. It's not as uncommon as people think. I wasn't a peaceful end, and it would be awful for a young child to witness.

HappiDaze · 10/09/2023 00:42

Bloody hell absolutely not

Trauma

Nightmares

A whole host of MH issues

Dillane · 10/09/2023 00:41

Excited101 · 09/09/2023 22:25

Massively inappropriate, I’m floored that this is actually being considered.

This

It’s an appalling idea.

cokezero26 · 10/09/2023 00:40

I went with my gran to get her cat put to sleep when I was 9 years old. I ran out crying. I have no idea why she allowed me to witness it, and I still remember it very clearly to this day.
Just no. Children remember traumatic things, and your child especially wouldn’t be able to process it as an adult would. It’s not worth it.
But if you want your child to be scarred, by all means go ahead.

stayathomer · 10/09/2023 00:40

Children do not need to know absolutely everything and definitely don’t need to be involved in everything.

Ellie1015 · 10/09/2023 00:37

Someone should be there for the dog. As long as one person willing to be there to support the dog then the rest are optional. I would not be having a 3 year old there unless you and wife both desperate to attend and no alternative childcare.

There is no benefit to the dog or the child.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 10/09/2023 00:29

I have had pets all my life and have been present at 3 euthanasias (the others were taken by parents or died naturally at home). One of them was actively unpeaceful (my cat was terrified of the vet and jumped down from the table despite no longer being able to walk, he had no nurse and I had to catch her and bring her back to the table). The most recent was in June. It was my dog; he had been losing weight for weeks, lots of tests had been done but were inconclusive, he was also getting to an age where they find it hard to keep weight on. As it turned out, it was a very fast developing cancer; he went from limping slightly on the Friday afternoon to tentative diagnosis on the Saturday to dying at 5am on the Monday. Even though it was "peaceful" (quick, kind, over very quickly), I had to carry him to the car, he had to travel half an hour to the emergency vet, he was obviously in pain, he hated injections and flinched when the needle went in, he had wet himself on the floor because he couldn't stand. Overall it was devastating. I was in absolute bits, doing everything I could to hold it together for my dog. I could not have managed my child's emotions on top of my own. My child is nearly 6 and it didn't even occur to me to take her because I knew that these things can be chaotic and stressful for the dog. But I explained it to her beforehand and talked it through with her again afterwards as many times as she needed.

If I had had to take my child with me (eg because I did not have childcare - my dog was in extremis and I had been up with him all night before deciding at 4am that I could not wait for the confirmatory scan that was booked for 12pm), I would not have taken her into the room. If there was no one there who was willing to mind her, I would have sat outside with her rather than take her in. Out of hours, my vet is literally the vet himself plus the nurse, both needed for clinic euthanasia: no receptionist.

I would not have appreciated being told that I had abandoned my dog by a bunch of strangers on the internet because I had not spelt out that the only alternative to sitting outside would have been to take my child in.

NotMyFinestMoment · 10/09/2023 00:27

You should be doing what is best in the dog's interests, not your 3.5 year old's. His departure and passing should be calm, quiet and stress free. You cannot guarantee that with a small child in tow.

FictionalCharacter · 10/09/2023 00:26

God no, not a 3 year old. Even my husband and teenagers found it shocking because they weren’t expecting our old boy to fall so abruptly. The process of euthanasia can be very distressing for the owners on top of the distress of the pet’s death, even though it’s painless for the pet and they aren’t aware. You need to be there as a calm, strong, loving adult presence for your dog at the end. This isn’t about your child being a pack member ffs. Your family isn’t a wolf pack.

Your son understands that the dog will die and he won’t see him again. That’s enough.

SilverCatStripes · 10/09/2023 00:24

Even the most precocious of 3 year olds are unable to understand death as a permanent cessation of life- and this wouldn’t go anyway to explaining it.

Children learn about death by the absence of the loved one - not by watching death occur.

Not to mention how unfair this would be on your DDog - you need to be 100% focused on DDog in the run up and during the euthanasia process.

Emdubz · 10/09/2023 00:21

As others have said, it’s not always peaceful when done at home, or at the vets. You just never know. I won’t go into detail but I still cry and feel guilt when I think back on a couple of euthanasia experiences even though they were done with the best intentions. They aren’t the kind of memories you want for your child although I appreciate why you have considered it.

Mr85 · 10/09/2023 00:21

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 09/09/2023 23:47

In that particular situation, I think the poster made a very hard choice, but on balance, the right one, @Mummyoflittledragon. The only other option would have been to have her two-year old actually witness the dog’s distress and death.

Of course the owner should be with their beloved pet at that point, if it is possible - but in this case, it simply wasn’t, and I don’t think the poster should be guilt tripped for the choice she had to make.

@Mr85 - I really hope you aren’t just looking for posts that support your plan, though your comment that a somewhat positive post was the sort of answer you were looking for, speaks volumes.

I honestly can see no benefit to your child to be there while the dog is out to sleep - it could be very traumatic for them - and you might end up having to deal with a very upset child at just the point where your dog needs your sole focus the most. Plus you would also have to control your emotions at a time when you probably need and want to be able to express them.

And even if you do take your child out if they become upset, the damage would already be done.

As to why I've posted this. It's not so that I can prove I'm right (or wrong). A reasonable person should always be willing to change what they think and admit that they are wrong.

My wife has full access to my phone and I asked her to read the OP before I posted it as sharing this kind of thing with strangers on the internet is not something we would normally do, and it involves her.

Some of the responses have been genuinely helpful so I'm glad I did it.

OP posts:
cimena · 10/09/2023 00:16

You can really tell who’s been at a bad PTS and who hasn’t in this thread.

Ive been at two and both were horrible. The dog was so far gone, he was basically a limp shell. I don’t know where he got the strength to fight it but he fought like hell. I was 16 and mum couldn’t bring herself to take him so I did and I’ll never get over it - like, it’s fine, Im not broken as a person but it was fucking traumatic and not peaceful and not nice for him. So there’s that.

Cat was different, she also fought but the bad part of that was how I was about it cos she was my wee babe. Im not sure I would’ve wanted my kid to see me how I was as that was happening, I think that would’ve been quite upsetting for them, more so than the PTS bit.

would def say given either of these possibilities, having a pair of hands to hand your son off to last minute if things don’t go to the ideal plan would be wise. And I don’t really see any benefit to him being there other than, as a pp said, you get to tell the family story about it. Not sure that’s worth it

TyneTeas · 10/09/2023 00:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Do you feel good about this post OP, trying to making a poster who is taking the time to reply to your question feel like shit about how their experience was? Why would you post this?!

UnsolicitedOpinions · 10/09/2023 00:15

PrtScn · 09/09/2023 23:58

You can’t live your life in fear of what ifs

So you shouldn’t consider what-ifs when thinking about whether to take a toddler to a euthanasia?!

What exactly do you think you would lose by the toddler NOT being there?

Swipe left for the next trending thread