Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler at dog euthanasia

239 replies

Mr85 · 09/09/2023 22:07

Our dog is now approaching the end and it won't be long until we have to make the call we all dread 😔

Our 3.5 year old son knows what death is. My wife recently lost her grandfather, who he knew a little, but didn't attend the funeral. He did attend my Nan's burial, although he never met her, and acted impecebally.

We've explained that the dog is ill, might not get better and may soon die. When he heard this he teared up and gave him a hug saying he didn't want him to die and he'll miss him so we know he understands what is going to happen.

My wife and I have slightly conflicting views but which are close enough that we could do either with the others blessing. I think our son should be there as he is part of the pack/family and it's a part of life. My wife thinks he is a little too young and it might cause him too much additional upset.

We've already decided what to do as, let's face it, using MN to make big life decisions is not the best idea. I'm just curious as to what everybody thinks.

I think our 3.5 year old son should be there: AIBU?

OP posts:
Megifer · 10/09/2023 10:36

Tbh I know my last post was a bit shitty - I was a bit shocked- but honestly op you have to reconsider this.

The risk of it just being even more of a shit situation than it already is if your kid is there is just too big.

The dog is the most important being here. Second to that is you and your wife being able to say you did right by the dog at the end, so you have no regrets. I'll never get over how fast my dog went, she went down like a sack of potatoes, and I wasn't fast enough to get to her to hold her in literally the last conscious seconds - DP and the vet were holding her up so I was stood back a little. Even the vet was a bit surprised and even though it was fast it was really traumatic and I've never forgiven myself for not at least having a hand on her fur as she collapsed and being totally focused on her.

Your 3 year old might be quiet so you can both focus on your dog, but I've known a lot of 3 year olds and they are hard wired to be inappropriate in a lot of situations. Sometimes that's funny. But christ can you imagine if your kid starts babbling on asking what's for lunch, or "when doggie wakes up we can go for a walk" "what does that needle do" "so what's happening now" "can doggie have a biscuits now" or if the kid starts absolutely bawling their eyes out.....your attention will be drawn away from your dog when it literally needs you the most, and from you and your wife comforting each other.

Honestly this is such a bad idea its actually pretty upsetting to hear its being considered. Please think about your dog a bit more in this.

And OPs wife if you're reading this I think this is very much a valid "put your foot down" situation.

TheLadyInWestminsterAbbey · 10/09/2023 10:34

I'm old enough to have had several pets put to sleep over the years and they have all been very calm - it's upsetting reading about the traumatic cases - is there a reason why this happens in some cases?

Our last dog was put to sleep a couple of years ago, the vet was so lovely and it was very calm. The vet got a nice fleecy blanket and made a nest for her on the table and she just snuggled into it. She really was ready to go, in hind sight after the event I had underestimated her suffering and decline. The vet spoke beautiful words about her being a faithful loved member of the family and her spirit going on, it was lovely. And the dog just drifted off to her happy hunting grounds.

A small child would almost certainly have spoilt that calm atmosphere so apart from it being bad for the child it is also bad for the animal.

TheLadyInWestminsterAbbey · 10/09/2023 10:28

Hamserfan · 10/09/2023 10:05

At that age I think it would not be a good idea. I’m an anaesthetist and in a young mind worry that talk of an injection and going to sleep then watching the dog die may be confused with the process of an anaesthetic. What if he breaks and arm or gets a nasty cut that needs a GA for stitches really not good starting with an hysterical kid. I’d stick with sometimes old animals and people are too poorly for doctors or vets to save.

Exactly what happened to me!
My post from upthread:

"Also you never know what's around the corner.
We had a cat put down when DD1 was about five. She wasn't there obviously. But I explained it was like when doctors make people go to sleep for operations but they give a bit more drugs so they go to sleep forever and it's very peaceful.
The next week she broke her arm and had to have it set under anaesthetic - they initially thought it would need pinning. She said "what if they give me too much, like George?" I said "they won't".
"But what if they do???""

I work in the health service and half of me thought I should be checking the anaesthetic drugs in the anaesthetic room and half of me didn't want to be "that mother" (anyway I wouldn't have known the correct doses) so I didn't but I felt guilty about that. Thankfully she was fine, lovely anaesthetist and all very calm. But it was unfortunate timing with the cat.

Tinkerbyebye · 10/09/2023 10:21

Have you actually been there before when a dog is put to sleep? Whilst it’s best for the dog it’s not nice. It’s not them lying in a bed peacefully going. In out vets it’s in the consultation room, bleak as it is, but in your arms. Do you want your child to remember the dog like that! With I would imagine your wife if tears (not sure about you as it’s a ridiculous idea)

diditbark · 10/09/2023 10:19

NO.

dotdotdot3 · 10/09/2023 10:15

YABU, for all the reasons already mentioned but mainly because it's about the dog and not about you, your child, and their education.

Please focus on the dog.

TheInterceptor · 10/09/2023 10:14

Our retired greyhound's body fought the euthanasia. Suffice to say no child should be subject to that experience. I'm still traumatised by it years later.

Vavazoom · 10/09/2023 10:11

I grew up on a farm and now live on
one. I’m fairly laid back about what the children are exposed to in terms of dead and sick stock but I wouldn’t allow them to be there if the dog was being put to sleep. We always have it done at home and it’s usually very peaceful but still not pleasant.

Hamserfan · 10/09/2023 10:05

At that age I think it would not be a good idea. I’m an anaesthetist and in a young mind worry that talk of an injection and going to sleep then watching the dog die may be confused with the process of an anaesthetic. What if he breaks and arm or gets a nasty cut that needs a GA for stitches really not good starting with an hysterical kid. I’d stick with sometimes old animals and people are too poorly for doctors or vets to save.

LizzieSiddal · 10/09/2023 09:59

Megifer · 10/09/2023 08:52

Yea go for it sounds a great idea. You can ignore the dog who will need you in its last minutes - who gives a shit anyway this learning experience is more important to you- explain to Tarquin how the needle goes in, what happens next, explain the thrashing around can be normal, pissing itself is too, as are the barks/howling etc. All while your wife is in bits and the kid might be chattering on about when the dog will wake up it will be better - because of course your 3 year old has no clue how permanent death is.

Then you can smile satisfied that you have given your child this wonderful opportunity and explain to all your pals how wonderfully Liberal you are and a much better parent than those who deny letting their 3 year olds witness the death of their best pal. While your pals will no doubt think you are a total prat.

No, definitely not an absolutely fucking awful idea.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

Megifer · 10/09/2023 08:52

Yea go for it sounds a great idea. You can ignore the dog who will need you in its last minutes - who gives a shit anyway this learning experience is more important to you- explain to Tarquin how the needle goes in, what happens next, explain the thrashing around can be normal, pissing itself is too, as are the barks/howling etc. All while your wife is in bits and the kid might be chattering on about when the dog will wake up it will be better - because of course your 3 year old has no clue how permanent death is.

Then you can smile satisfied that you have given your child this wonderful opportunity and explain to all your pals how wonderfully Liberal you are and a much better parent than those who deny letting their 3 year olds witness the death of their best pal. While your pals will no doubt think you are a total prat.

No, definitely not an absolutely fucking awful idea.

SillyBillyMother · 10/09/2023 08:30

Just seen you're doing it at home.

Maybe involve him in the burial but avoid the actual procedure as it sounds like it can be less predictable with dogs. Good lucky

SillyBillyMother · 10/09/2023 08:26

I don't know.
On the one hand, I agree that it's important for children to understand and be involved. The end of life of pets is a good way for children to understand about death. I'm not necessarily opposed to the idea of your dc being with your dog when he is put to sleep. We had our cat put to sleep recently, and he just went very quietly, My dc are older but I would have liked them to have been there. I was very conflicted about the ethical side if putting my cat to sleep, and am still thoughtful about it. It isn't straightforward.
However, what happens after the death is quite important, and I would be thinking about that in your situation. I'm not sure any of the scenarios are nice for your dc. I carried my dead cat home in the carrier. Not was weird and not nice really. It felt too sad. I buried him at home though and that would have been a nice thing for a small child to be involved with. The alternative would be leaving the animal at the vets to deal with, which again I don't think is very nice for the child.

I think a a society we are misguidedly choosing to sanitise the experience of death, and I agree with your desire to involve your ex in this somehow, but have a think about the specifics and maybe there is a nice way to involve him without him having to deal with the unpleasant parts. Good luck

Pizzanight · 10/09/2023 08:03

What would be your motivation in doing this? It is not a 'facts of life' lesson it is a kinder death yes, but not a natural death. This would likely form your DCs first permanent memory. It is our job to gradually introduct DC to adulthood and protect them as children. Why? Did you have an abusive upbringing?

JussathoB · 10/09/2023 07:56

IMO it would be absolutely wrong to have your child present. It is traumatic. it will be bad enough coping with the grief of losing a much loved pet, even if it is ‘part of life’.
Most people seek to protect their very young children from traumatic events.

PostOpOp · 10/09/2023 07:49

My cat was PTS when DC were the age of yours. It was at home (nothing like the repetitive injections mentioned above and he lay in my arms) and was extremely sad but beautiful, if that's right to say.

DC came home from daycare/school and saw the cat's body. I'd put some flowers around his body. The 3 year old didn't really think much, just saw him, came close looked. And said bye bye. 5 year old rearranged flowers, patted him and spent some time with him. Both later drew a picture to be "buried" with him (he was cremated..) and dictated a little letter of goodbye to him that went with him in his box.

Neither were traumatised and both did what they wanted. I didn't make them see the body, I told them he was upstairs and he'd left his body, it was cold and they could see it if they wanted. They did but DC3 was less interested so that was that.

No WAY would it have been good for them to be there during the death, because I howled afterwards. I needed time to be with our pet, then time to get myself together so I was able to be there for the kids.

Bubop · 10/09/2023 07:26

I wouldn’t. Even without considering your DC’s feelings, I don’t think it’s fair on your dog.

What if DC gets upset? You’re naturally going to comfort your child, but your dog deserves your full attention during his last moments (and if he’s anything like my dog, he would want to get to DC to soothe them which could add unnecessary stress).

Do something lovely to remember your dog with DC instead Flowers

MariaVT65 · 10/09/2023 07:24

YABU.

As a previous dog owner, and someone who cried buckets at that scene in Marley and Me, I’d say this is even traumatic for an adult. Please don’t let your 3 year old be there. They have a lot of potential to be affected by it.

RunningFromInsanity · 10/09/2023 07:23

Can a family member have him out the room whilst it’s actually happening, and then bring him in to say goodbye once it’s over?

Nephthys21 · 10/09/2023 07:21

We took our 4 year old to the vet to say goodbye to our cat, who had already been admitted so wasn't home when we realised he wasn't going to get better. He didn't stay for the actual process, my husband took him to the waiting room, but we did let him give our boy a kiss and cuddle and say goodbye.

PollyPut · 10/09/2023 07:19

@Mr85 I think this is really unreasonable.

I'm also going to assume that the dog would be euthanised by injection - I'm not sure how else it might be done. Have you considered that if toddler sees dog injected and then they die, your child might develop a fear of needles/injections? They will have to have several immunisations themselves - one in the next year before they start school. At secondary school they have several on their own without their parent. These are traumatising enough for many families.

Don't do anything that might terrify your child around the use of medical needles (or possibly give them a fear of medical professionals)

WillowCraft · 10/09/2023 07:17

Don't do it. it's traumatic for your son - he is too young to understand and it's more likely to give him a fear of vets or even doctors.
It's traumatic for the dog if your child gets upset. You will have to focus on your child rather than your dog.
It's traumatic for the child if you get upset
You don't know how it will go - it's not always peaceful.

I would just tell him the dog has died and and answer questions in an age appropriate way.

Having seen children present at euthanasia it never ends well. They either scream and cry, upsetting everyone, or they misbehave, distracting the vet and parent, or they have to be taken out halfway through, or in one extreme case the child was so upset they vomited profusely.

Remember the dog does not know what is happening so it's best to stay calm . If the choice is between having a 3 year old present with parent, or having neither, I would choose neither.

Casiotoad · 10/09/2023 07:13

Washbasketcase · 10/09/2023 06:58

Not even sure about the suggestions of the child just seeing the body afterwards either - for me, that was the very worse part of an otherwise perfect, peaceful euthanasia - finished crying, making small talk and thanking the vet, heading out of the consulting room and then looking back to see a familiar, but dead dog lying there alone on the floor.

Yes same for me! The injection is quite peaceful but seeing them afterwards stays with you.

Casiotoad · 10/09/2023 07:12

I think some of the responses are a little harsh, I can see why this is a hard decision.

however I’m with the other commenters, it’s not a good idea. Let him remember doggo alive and have his last hugs. If he’s there he will be focused on the act not the saying goodbye, I don’t think kids can separate that.

owners should absolutely always attend but it’s not a nice thing and that’s your responsibility to bear not your kids

sorry, I hope all goes smoothly when the time comes

ColleenDonaghy · 10/09/2023 07:09

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 22:23

Our 3.5 year old son knows what death is.

He can’t. He’s too young to really know the permanence of it or that everyone and everything dies. Don’t have him present to watch the family dog actually die in front of his eyes. He’s too young to understand euthanasia as a mercy.

Another one backing this up. My eldest has known about death since she lost a grandparent at 2. She's 5 now and just about "gets" it but we still get lots of questions and she certainly didn't get it at all at 3.5.

Please please please don't do this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread