Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids today won't know anyone from the war

233 replies

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:22

Our grandparents or parents were children during the war, and they had stories from their parents or grandparents, who had lived experience of WW1.

So we had a direct connection with somebody with first-hand experience of the world wars. It just occured to me that babies born now won't have that.

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel as distant to them as the victorians do to us? Will it have some kind of subconscious impact on society?

OP posts:
HappyAsASandboy · 09/09/2023 19:37

@KateyCuckoo really? That amazes me because I'm 44 and all four of my grandparent fought/worked in WW2 and my grandma has endlessly told me of the day her dad came back from WW1 (when she was 4).

I feel really connected to both world wars because people I knew, or their immediate family, fought in them and remember the feelings of the time.

I hope by telling the stories I heard as a child I can keep it real for my children.

HuneyBuns · 09/09/2023 19:36

Hardbackwriter · 09/09/2023 19:33

There is a certain group of society that fetishises war (especially ww2) - which include one of my older siblings (quite a bit older). It keeps the UK stuck in the past.

I really agree. People keep trying to expand the boundaries of what having lived through the war constitutes (it now seems to be widely claimed that having been a baby during peacetime rationing basically makes you a war survivor) to delay having to find a new locus of national identity.

Can we please stop using 'fetishising' whenever we wish to express disapproval fgs. Having an interest in something your parents or grandparents lived through is not 'fetishinging' Confused

Qilin · 09/09/2023 19:35

You never met any of your grandparents?

I'm 50y. My grandparents were children during the war. Neither had an active role. I vaguely remember my great grandparents but they didn't really have active parts in either war as well - generally too old for Ww2 and too young for Ww1. Also in occupations which meant their war effort would have been here at home.

I seem to have had grandparents and great grandparents who missed being the right age in both, though I had great uncles who were older who fought (and died) in the war. Didn't meet any of these though.

Hardbackwriter · 09/09/2023 19:33

There is a certain group of society that fetishises war (especially ww2) - which include one of my older siblings (quite a bit older). It keeps the UK stuck in the past.

I really agree. People keep trying to expand the boundaries of what having lived through the war constitutes (it now seems to be widely claimed that having been a baby during peacetime rationing basically makes you a war survivor) to delay having to find a new locus of national identity.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 09/09/2023 19:32

Comedycook · 09/09/2023 18:33

I remember as a child in the 1980s, every "old" person you encountered had been in the war. I think a lot of people still have the mentality that all elderly people have lived through the war.

My DGMs nursing home plays them music from the First and Second World War and thinks the reason they don't know the words is because they have dementia.

I said that might be true, but try some music from the 50s and 60s and they'd have a better chance!

Sushione · 09/09/2023 19:31

My youngest is 9 and has a grandparent that was born before WW2.

user1473878824 · 09/09/2023 19:31

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:26

Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war

Well this is one of the stupidest sweeping statements I’ve ever read

DappledThings · 09/09/2023 19:29

Smartiepants79 · 09/09/2023 18:29

My children met my grandfather. He was an ambulance driver as he was a conscientious objector. Was on the Isle of Dogs during the blitz.

Mine too, with the Friends Ambulance Unit. DC never met him but DD(5) likes to tell people about her great grandfather who didn't fight but drove an ambulance.

Ivebeentogeorgia · 09/09/2023 19:29

I’m 37 and don’t know anyone from the war. My grandparents were born after 1941 and so have no memories of it

EsmeSusanOgg · 09/09/2023 19:29

I'm 39. I am unusual in that my paternal grandfather was a child/ young teen in the first world war and a reserved occupation in the second.

My maternal stepfather, a couple of years older, fought in both WWI and WWII - but rarely spoke about the war, as it was 'an horrific but necessary experience' as he would say. I don't think many people my age (elder millenial/ xenial) knew people who lived through WWI, though we did know people who experienced WWII whether as children or adults. People just a few year's younger than me do not have that same link. Their grandparents may have been young children in the war, or not have been born (older boomers).

I think that does make it feel more distant, but the world changing impacts of the conflict do still reverberate through society. It does make it all the more inportant that we teach what happened, to try and prevent repeating the horrors of those times.

Hardbackwriter · 09/09/2023 19:29

I don't think looking at the world or even just domestic politics right now really confirms that there is something about growing up knowing people who lived through a world war makes you uniquely peace-loving and tolerant.

Exasperatednow · 09/09/2023 19:27

I'm 53. Me dad fought in ww2 and my Irish grandfather fought in ww1. We didn't talk about it much. The main belief my father had was that people did what they had to do and if you were German you would have been shot for not fighting whereas here you would just be made to contribute in another way.

In many ways I think its a good thing that were at this generational cross roads (and my dad would too). There is a certain group of society that fetishises war (especially ww2) - which include one of my older siblings (quite a bit older). It keeps the UK stuck in the past.

gogomoto · 09/09/2023 19:26

Unfortunately there has been many conflicts since. I know a Falklands veteran myself

Ghosttofu99 · 09/09/2023 19:26

There were a ridiculous amount of domestic terror attacks in the decade before the pandemic (pandemic seems to have calmed it down for a bit) so clearly the ‘War on terror,’ Afghanistan, Syria etc are Wars on our doorstep that have affected us directly so UABU in that regard.

NumberTheory · 09/09/2023 19:25

I think it’s really significant, OP.

My grandfather served in the RAF in WWII, my grandmother had children billeted in her home, both of the lost siblings. My mother (born 9 months after my grandfather got home) grew up with rationing. The impact of the war was immense, the trauma they lived through and the subsequent attitudes to mental health and hardship, the rapid adaption to massive social change that brought about, amoung other things, the emancipation of women at a rate unimaginable before the war. The development of the NHS in its wake.

I grew up knowing, at least to some extent, how these factors shaped our society because my grandparents and parents were living examples and embodied many of the values that had been tempered under the force of war. My kids don’t have that, and though I try and talk about it in a way they will understand, it’s really distant to them. They aren’t going to have the same outlook. In someways this is good but I worry about what might be repeated because we have lost the horror of where politics that demonizes can lead.

Mrburnshound · 09/09/2023 19:24

Im in my 30s and my DGPs told me lots about their experiences. My DGD used to go into schools and give talks about his life. It's the passing of time and all that. It is odd though as everyone I know had DGDs who fought, it's a sort of collective experience.

I have told many of my DGD'S child friendly stories to my own kids. He had a not too traumatic time so easier to tell the stories vs their other DGGD who had PTSD

MrsAvocet · 09/09/2023 19:22

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 19:12

But it seems the issue is very specific to WW1/2. I wonder what marks those wars as uniquely different to the others?

Well they were much bigger, impacting many countries. We tend to think only about the European impact, particularly for WW1 where most of what is taught in schools, pictured in films etc is focused on the Western Front, but there were many more theatres of war involving people genuinely from all over yhe world.
Plus the wars this country has been involved in since the end of WW2 have only involved professional servicemen and women, not the general public either volunteering or being conscripted for war service. The world wars impacted on almost evety aspect of daily life for people in this country but whilst we are aware of other wars and sadly of course some families have recent experience of losing loved ones in wars, the impact on our lives has been nothing like the same. It's been more that our forces are in a war, not that the country is at war hasn't it?

Stripeypyjamas · 09/09/2023 19:19

I'm 40, my grandparents were all 'active' in the war effort so it feels close to home and I think of them and the friends they lost on armistice Day. My parents were born 1947 and 1949 and obviously they don't have memories of war but they did live through rationing which went on for several years post war. I think that does influence your perspective on life especially around things like food waste and materialistic consumption.

Soontobe60 · 09/09/2023 19:18

In my school, I’d say over 50% of the children have escaped from war torn countries.

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 19:18

@DojaPhat
What makes them different is that because they were major global events occurring on the UKs doorstep, literally every single person in the UK was affected by them. They became part of each person's personal story, whether they liked it or not. This inevitably then became folded into the national psyche as you can see from continued memorials and countless films, series, etc. I'm just wondering whether it will fade from the national psyche as the generations pass, and whether this will influence future generations' vision of war.

Of course there are some posters who aren't getting this and seem to think I'm talking about their personal circumstances. And I'm getting the impression that you're trying to extrapolate from my post that I don't think war matters if it happens "elsewhere".

OP posts:
Almahart · 09/09/2023 19:17

My grandparents were all adults during the war. It wasn't a topic of conversation though.

Like pp, I find it astonishing that I was born only 25 years after the war. Same amount of time between Blair coming to power and today.

I recently read a fascinating book about the state of Europe at the end of the war. It's incredible how quickly it was rebuilt. I remember family holidays to Germany in the mid 1970s and everything seeming normal to me.

UnfortunateTypo · 09/09/2023 19:17

My daughter is 20, she met three of her Great Grandmothers. One lived through WW1 and WW2, the other two were born in the 1920s. Not sure how much she remembers about them though? Everything becomes history eventually, even the 1950s and 60s are starting to become distant now to the young.

CaptainMyCaptain · 09/09/2023 19:16

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 19:12

But it seems the issue is very specific to WW1/2. I wonder what marks those wars as uniquely different to the others?

Because they were WORLD wars - genuinely not being sarcastic - they were fought in various places around the world and soldiers, sailors, airmen, nurses etc from all around the world were involved.

Maxus · 09/09/2023 19:14

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 19:08

@Maxus
Yes, babies born today will be the first entire generation not to, who your kids specifically did or didn't know isn't the point

Plenty of teenagers and early 20s have never known a family member in the war. One of my son's mentioned it's unfair that our of his entire history class no one had a relative they could talk to alive from the war also true for the early 20s kids. My kids are certainly not unique in this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread