Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids today won't know anyone from the war

233 replies

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:22

Our grandparents or parents were children during the war, and they had stories from their parents or grandparents, who had lived experience of WW1.

So we had a direct connection with somebody with first-hand experience of the world wars. It just occured to me that babies born now won't have that.

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel as distant to them as the victorians do to us? Will it have some kind of subconscious impact on society?

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 09/09/2023 21:59

ColleenDonaghy · 09/09/2023 20:48

Exactly.

OP that's a really shockingly ignorant statement when there was a civil war IN the UK that only ended 25 years ago.

NI and the troubles, didn't really affect people outside NI and the forces.
There was the odd bomb scare elsewhere but it wasn't a major thing or something that affected people on a daily basis.

The World Wars affected everyone at a different level on a day to day basis from a conscription, rationing, raid shelters in the garden, blackouts, conscription, females being pulled in to working in traditionally male industries, steel & iron works, munitions factories, the women's land army, because the young men were called up to the forces.
Young men in 'reserved occupations' being called up to the Home Guard.

I get what the Op is trying to say. Other wars have happened but its not something most people will have direct experience of.

It's a bit like in 20 years time when children will learn about the pandemic in school they will ask parents/ grandparents about it. Everyone will have a different story on how it affected them.

Tinkerbyebye · 09/09/2023 21:40

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:26

Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war

Haven’t read the thread but of course they will. It may not be a world war but in my lifetime this country has been at war Falklands Afghanistan etc.

We are at present supporting Ukraine in their war against mad Vlad

KateyCuckoo · 09/09/2023 21:29

HappyAsASandboy · 09/09/2023 19:37

@KateyCuckoo really? That amazes me because I'm 44 and all four of my grandparent fought/worked in WW2 and my grandma has endlessly told me of the day her dad came back from WW1 (when she was 4).

I feel really connected to both world wars because people I knew, or their immediate family, fought in them and remember the feelings of the time.

I hope by telling the stories I heard as a child I can keep it real for my children.

OK congratulations?

I didn't know my grandparents.

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 21:28

@raindropbox Thanks for your response, it's helped me to understand your perspective somewhat; especially r.e Nation (as pertaining to a shared history, language, culture, tradition etc).

itsgettingweird · 09/09/2023 21:23

No I don't think they'll be forgotten.

So many references still to the wars. I don't think the holocaust will ever be forgotten which will also be a reminder of the atrocities.

I think many forgot we had a pandemic at the end of WW1 until recently but history does has a habit of repeating itself.

We may not have WW again but we've certainly got war on our doorstep and have many citizens here who have fled war who can tell stories to remind us of the horrors.

blackrabbitwhiterabbit · 09/09/2023 21:19

KateyCuckoo · 09/09/2023 18:37

No I didn't.

2 died before I was born, 1 lived abroad and 1 was estranged.

Same here.

DelurkingAJ · 09/09/2023 21:18

There’s something about it being the last time the U.K. experienced general conscription, isn’t there.

DM is American and said she wouldn’t have notified the US when I was born if I’d been a boy. I was confused until I realised that she’s the Vietnam generation…she knew boys who ‘never came home’. It makes a difference to a generation, I suspect.

NamaraMc · 09/09/2023 21:18

What is the subconscious impact on society you are worried about?
Trauma comes through generations so surely the bigger the distance from it the better?
Whilst nobody would want the personal sacrifices forgotten, surely part of the sacrifice was for the safety of future generations. And for it never to be seen again?

I'm Irish, the most significant war here was our war of independence in 1920's. So 20years/a generation ahead of wwll. It has not been forgotten or the sacrifices made lessened by time- even though everyone that died or involved long since dead.
It's a matter of perspective.
There have been thousands of wars down the centuries, all important in getting us here.
Surely we want our children born into a world they feel safe in so the farther away from war the better.

Beezknees · 09/09/2023 21:16

I am 33 and I don't know anyone from the war. My grandparents were born in the 1940s.

Presil · 09/09/2023 21:12

Are you kidding? It was all some people talked about during lockdown.

HuneyBuns · 09/09/2023 21:10

Presil · 09/09/2023 20:57

I wish it would mean that people in England stop banging on about it but sadly fear that won't happen. Chatter about it seems to be steadily increasing the further we get from WwII.

Banging on about it🫥

Fair enough if your not interested but this is a bit disrespectful. How often are people banging on about world war 2, realistically? November, maybe. Hardly banging on.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/09/2023 21:10

Possibly the number of films about WW1 & 2 will make young people more aware than say the Boer or Crimean wars?
I was born in the 60's, so both my parents had grown up in the war, and several primary teachers had fought in it (remember one of them breaking down on remembrance day, which was always observed with a mid morning assembly).
Didn't get taught anything about the war though - mostly Romans., neither set of Grandparents ever mentioned it, my Mum would occasionally talk about watching the fires of the blitz - she grew up in North London, born 1932.

CreeperBoom · 09/09/2023 21:08

I'm in my 40s, and don't feel I had any real family connection to the war. The men in local area were miners or farmers, so didn't have the large numbers of soldiers that other areas would have had. Also, there was no bombing anywhere near.

My grandparents didn't talk about it really, even when asked. They said it didn't really impact them. I am sure it did, in reality, but they didn't want to make it "their" story.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 09/09/2023 21:06

May patents were both born after the war however although it had ended after they were born, there was lots of after effects taken still being felt. There was the tail end of rationing, large derelict bomb sites that people were still living in, austerity but optimism for the future as there was lots of rebuilding. They had parents that were directly affected by it (one of their parental had malaria for example, one probably had mental health problems from being imprisoned) So although they didn't live through the war they were indirectly affected by it to a big extent.

And yes I agree that every generation since has been more removed. That's the way of things and it's good in some ways that we are approaching a generation who don't know such horrors. There are some things that we should never forget as a society but ita difficult to make it sound relevant when to them, it sounds like it was happening to people in history books.

NumberTheory · 09/09/2023 20:58

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 20:01

So @NumberTheory do you agree with this statement:
Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war

No living history of war. The entire generation. All these other wars, even the ones that occurred inside the U.K. were nothing and affected no one. There is no memory and no living history whatsoever, anywhere in the U.K. of war.

Because it looks like you are agreeing with it. This isn’t a debate on which war had the greatest impact.

I don’t agree with such an extreme interpretation, no.

I do think that culturally, it’s reasonable to talk about the impact of WWII as affecting generations as a whole and I don’t think that applies to the other wars mentioned in the post I responded to (though arguable on NI).

Presil · 09/09/2023 20:57

I wish it would mean that people in England stop banging on about it but sadly fear that won't happen. Chatter about it seems to be steadily increasing the further we get from WwII.

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 20:51

@DojaPhat
I think all national psyches are wedded to ceremony and tradition aren't they? It's not a specifically British thing. In fact ceremony, tradition, history and shared languages ARE "the national psyche". You wouldn't have the concept of a nation without one, you'd just have a state.

OP posts:
Seagullchippy · 09/09/2023 20:49

The worrying thing is if children don't grow up being taught about genocide, about how such evil begins with everyday acts between neighbours, with racism, with vilification of the less well off, the disabled, anyone used as a scapegoat as disabled people and immigrants are currently in the UK.

Also, how extraordinary a pinnacle of human endeavour were the post war achievements of the welfare state and the NHS and how beyond terrible and devastating their destruction by the current government and those who vote for it.

Of course, children today are growing up with the horrors of climate change and the wars (including the 90s oil wars) connected with it.

ColleenDonaghy · 09/09/2023 20:48

dressedforcomfort · 09/09/2023 18:48

Of course there have been terrible wars since, but not on the UKs doorstep.

I'm sure there are plenty of people in Northern Ireland who still vividly remember the Troubles....

Exactly.

OP that's a really shockingly ignorant statement when there was a civil war IN the UK that only ended 25 years ago.

Floopyfloop · 09/09/2023 20:41

I worked in education a few years ago and I went to have a nail appointment and was chatting to a girl in her early 20s about a trip we were taking to a WW2 museum.

I am not sure how we got into the topic of the holocaust but she had never heard about it!

I strongly feel that humans need to know about these things to stop such atrocities happening.

Floopyfloop · 09/09/2023 20:33

There are 11,500 WW2 veterans left in the uk.

CauldronOfLove · 09/09/2023 20:31

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel distant?

No. There are plenty of books, films, documentaries and recorded testimonies of those wars. I personally feel that as the time gap gets bigger, the more those wars get more fetishised and co-opted by the media and politicians to basically shut people up.

All this clap trap about the ‘Blitz Spirit’ to dismiss concerns about quality of life or public services. As if that generation were practically waltzing through the bombings, no acknowledgement that people suffered and died during the Blitz.

Or Holocaust memorials while demonising refugees. And don’t get me started on Poppy Watch.

I was born in late 80s and 9/11 and Iraq War / War on Terror has personally had a bigger impact on me. Especially growing up seeing politicians lie and sexed up dossiers.

I do find the reconstruction of the UK AFTER the war quite interesting, as well as how the British Empire crumbled post-war. I know very little about either topics.

HuntingoftheSnark · 09/09/2023 20:22

I'm 54 and my father was a German PoW. He never spoke about the war. My mother was nine when it started and she's often talked about it, to us and her grandchildren. My grandfathers were on opposing sides but never met.

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 20:16

@raindropbox No, I'm not assuming that. I too, am trying to understand the nostalgia behind it. My initial post mentions the British psyche being wedded to tradition and ceremony which might go some way to explain what you're describing because its memory doesn't evoke the same sense of 'togetherness' or nostalgia within me as it does in you.

Ted27 · 09/09/2023 20:10

I was born in 1965. Growing up in the late 1960s and 1970s all the kids played on derlict land which were still known as the bombsites, pre fab housing was still in use at the bottom of my street until the 1980s, I remember a lot of the kids were quite jealous because the prefabs had proper gardens. The bombed out church in town is still a landmark.
I live in Coventry now. A huge part of the housing stock still shows marks of the blitz. In my first house, the stone lintels of every single house had an identical crack - the houses basically lifted up during the bombing and cracks resulted when they settled.
My current house has visible shrapnel damage to brickwork. Only 10 years ago a house was built in a gap in the terrace -it replaced a house that was destroyed as a result of a direct hit. The owners have researched the people who lived there.
Our Cathedrals stand as memorials. Every tree in our local park is dedicated to a fallen soldier, with a plaque telling you who they were and when they died. It includes memorials to forces people from present day conflicts.
If you look for it, the history of our conflicts is all around us.