Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids today won't know anyone from the war

233 replies

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:22

Our grandparents or parents were children during the war, and they had stories from their parents or grandparents, who had lived experience of WW1.

So we had a direct connection with somebody with first-hand experience of the world wars. It just occured to me that babies born now won't have that.

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel as distant to them as the victorians do to us? Will it have some kind of subconscious impact on society?

OP posts:
Luciferspickles · 09/09/2023 23:19

I want whatever you're smoking, OP. The Irish war of Independence? The Irish Civil War? The war which was later called 'the troubles' but was actually another civil war? What are you on, love?

KrisAkabusi · 09/09/2023 23:16

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 22:03

Sort of reminds me of a caller on LBC who said when she's out and about she barely recognises the country her grandparents or great grandparents fought so hard for. That sort of togetherness in adversity and its lasting nostalgic legacy.

A) why would she. It was over 65 years ago. Of course things have changed.

B) That's usually code for "there's too many brown people now".

MammaTill2Pojkar · 09/09/2023 23:10

My grandfather wasn't a child during WW2, my Nan was maybe 10 when it started and my grandfather was in the war, he lost his brother in the war. My grandfather passed away some years ago but my nan is still alive and my children know her and she was still old enough at the time to have memories and stories to share. I think there is still a generation to go yet before no-one in that generation has any connection with anyone who lived during WW2. I admit I don't know much about WW2 and have no real passed down direct knowledge on it, I recall a little story about my grandfather having bumped in to his brother on his birthday (my grandfathers I believe) and having had a drink with him to celebrate whilst abroad, which as his brother didn't survive it is kind of bittersweet.

Karen398 · 09/09/2023 23:06

I'm 42 and my grandparents were around 10-16 during the war, so had a few stories to share but didn't fight in it. For our ww2 project people brought in their grandparents rations books , and the remembrance parade still had many old vetrans.

TrixieFatell · 09/09/2023 23:01

My children have their great grandad who was very much involved in WW2, who was taken to a labor camp, escaped and then joined the Army. They've all had a chance to hear his stories and they have all used his story at school. We also have letters that his wife wrote to her brother who was serving in France during WW2 but sadly died in a car accident after the war ended. I have experience from my own dad who served in the British Army.

JockTamsonsBairns · 09/09/2023 22:55

YANBU

I'm a care worker, and this is something that's been on my mind for quite a few years now.

When I first started in care work, 28 years ago, it was commonplace for me to look after elderly people who had direct experience of both World Wars.

As time has gone on, those elderly people have now passed away - there is now nobody left who can give first hand experience of WW1.

I have known hundreds of people who can give first hand experience of their time in WW2, but this has dwindled down very quickly over the past ten or fifteen years.

During the Spring of this year, I contacted the HT of a local primary school and asked if the Y6 cohort might enjoy a visit from Jean.
Jean is 102, born in 1921. She is sharp as a tack, and was herself a HT at a primary school.
It was my thought that this might be the last chance we get for clear minded old people like Jean to be able to come into a primary school and share her experiences first hand.
Jean was incredibly keen to get involved with this.

I got a reply from the HT saying that Jean would need to have a current enhanced DBS check in place before she would be allowed to enter school premises.
Ok, I understand the rules. But Jean didn't have any utility bills in her name, as her 81 year old son dealt with this online - and he struggled to know how to forward these on.

What a missed opportunity.

DeeKavCoffee · 09/09/2023 22:51

DinnaeFashYersel · 09/09/2023 22:41

When I was a child (70s & 80s) many of my school teachers would share personal stories of having been children during the war. They would talk about their personal experiences of air raids and rationing and so on.

My grandfathers both served in the army and my grandmothers both worked in munitions factories

It felt connected and real as it was only 30-40 years previously.

My grandparents would also share stories they'd heard from their own parents of WW1

For my on children it's just black and white movies.

Although have to say, Dunkirk was an amazing movie - felt like I was there in the trenches!

Mocara · 09/09/2023 22:46

Well said , a lot of selective memory syndrome on here.

LuciferRising · 09/09/2023 22:45

NRTFT so may have been said. In about 120 years everyone on this earth today will be dead. This is why history lessons exist. There were worse times than the wars from the 1900s.

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 22:42

JudgeJ · 09/09/2023 22:31

We were working with the Forces when the Falklands conflict was on and one of our Regiments went down to the South Atlantic. A friend's husband was going and I commiserated with her, she replied 'He's been drawing his salary for almost thirty years and it's the first time he might have to fire real ammo'.

It was probably thie first time that rolling news had been available 24 hours and it was awful hearing what was happening and not knowing all the details.

According to my living memory of that war, I was a school child in rural England and we started every morning assembly off with a news update and a prayer for all the regiments sent to the Falklands and all the islanders being held hostage by the Argentinians, including a baby.

DinnaeFashYersel · 09/09/2023 22:41

When I was a child (70s & 80s) many of my school teachers would share personal stories of having been children during the war. They would talk about their personal experiences of air raids and rationing and so on.

My grandfathers both served in the army and my grandmothers both worked in munitions factories

It felt connected and real as it was only 30-40 years previously.

My grandparents would also share stories they'd heard from their own parents of WW1

For my on children it's just black and white movies.

jellybe · 09/09/2023 22:38

My grandfather who was a young teen in WW2 is still alive and my kids and their younger cousins have a close relationship with him. His youngest great grandchild is due this month.

Presil · 09/09/2023 22:34

There's a reason the troubles are not referred to as a "war".

Oh my. Yes, you're right, there is a reason. Chilling, isn't it?

DeeKavCoffee · 09/09/2023 22:33

My hubby's grandfather was in the war and sadly just passed before eldest was born. We've his photo around the house and have talked to the kids about him. I reckon it's also about keeping the conversation going. Scary how facism is starting to rear its head again.

JudgeJ · 09/09/2023 22:31

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 19:39

Rubbish. We’ve had lots of wars.
What about the
NI Troubles?
Falklands War?
Bosnia & Yugoslavia?
Iraq wars I and II?
Afghanistan?
Ukraine?

I’m sure I’m missing a few wars. There isn’t a generation of British forces that haven’t seen war yet.

We were working with the Forces when the Falklands conflict was on and one of our Regiments went down to the South Atlantic. A friend's husband was going and I commiserated with her, she replied 'He's been drawing his salary for almost thirty years and it's the first time he might have to fire real ammo'.

It was probably thie first time that rolling news had been available 24 hours and it was awful hearing what was happening and not knowing all the details.

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 22:30

@ColleenDonaghy
I'm half Irish thanks so I don't need your moralising. And I stand by my point. There's a reason the troubles are not referred to as a "war". You'll find many terms used but rarely that one.
If you'd like to play the shame game, I might suggest I find it pretty horrific and a quite shocking statement that you would compare the troubles to the holocaust. Is that what you meant to do?

OP posts:
annahay · 09/09/2023 22:22

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:26

Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war

I have friends in their early 30s that have been to war.

JimnJoyce · 09/09/2023 22:20

i'm 57 and my last direct contact with somebody who was in WW2 has just died

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 22:17

Sugarfree23 · 09/09/2023 21:59

NI and the troubles, didn't really affect people outside NI and the forces.
There was the odd bomb scare elsewhere but it wasn't a major thing or something that affected people on a daily basis.

The World Wars affected everyone at a different level on a day to day basis from a conscription, rationing, raid shelters in the garden, blackouts, conscription, females being pulled in to working in traditionally male industries, steel & iron works, munitions factories, the women's land army, because the young men were called up to the forces.
Young men in 'reserved occupations' being called up to the Home Guard.

I get what the Op is trying to say. Other wars have happened but its not something most people will have direct experience of.

It's a bit like in 20 years time when children will learn about the pandemic in school they will ask parents/ grandparents about it. Everyone will have a different story on how it affected them.

So all the racist hate crimes including the murders of Northern Irish British Citizens and Irish citizens living in Great Britain don’t count as it “didn’t really affect anyone outside NI and the forces”? Shocking how little you know of your own history.

ColleenDonaghy · 09/09/2023 22:14

Sugarfree23 · 09/09/2023 21:59

NI and the troubles, didn't really affect people outside NI and the forces.
There was the odd bomb scare elsewhere but it wasn't a major thing or something that affected people on a daily basis.

The World Wars affected everyone at a different level on a day to day basis from a conscription, rationing, raid shelters in the garden, blackouts, conscription, females being pulled in to working in traditionally male industries, steel & iron works, munitions factories, the women's land army, because the young men were called up to the forces.
Young men in 'reserved occupations' being called up to the Home Guard.

I get what the Op is trying to say. Other wars have happened but its not something most people will have direct experience of.

It's a bit like in 20 years time when children will learn about the pandemic in school they will ask parents/ grandparents about it. Everyone will have a different story on how it affected them.

Sure, I agree with you that it didn't have anywhere near the impact outside of NI. But nonetheless there WAS a civil war in the UK within our lifetimes and I think it's pretty horrific to be so ignorant and dismissive of it to write that there have been no terrible wars on the UK's doorstep since WWII. It's a really awful statement to make.

Ted27 · 09/09/2023 22:10

@Sugarfree23

so it doesnt count that ‘it only’ affected people in NI?

which isnt true anyway. There were many bombs on the mainland, some of which led to some of the greatest miscarriages of justice we have seen - Birmingham 6, Guildford 4 ring any bells, what about the Warrington bombing?
growing up in Liverpool we had many bomb scares and bomb practices in school.

PinkRoses1245 · 09/09/2023 22:07

Honestly I don’t see why it matters. Weird how school curriculum is so focused on ww1 and ww2. They should focus on more relevant and recent events. And also teach how bad Britain has treated the rest of the world during colonial times

Hawkins0009 · 09/09/2023 22:05

maddening · 09/09/2023 22:01

I think that the cold War is also am interesting time and is also v relevant to how the world has developed globally

thats very true

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 22:03

Sort of reminds me of a caller on LBC who said when she's out and about she barely recognises the country her grandparents or great grandparents fought so hard for. That sort of togetherness in adversity and its lasting nostalgic legacy.

maddening · 09/09/2023 22:01

I think that the cold War is also am interesting time and is also v relevant to how the world has developed globally