Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids today won't know anyone from the war

233 replies

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:22

Our grandparents or parents were children during the war, and they had stories from their parents or grandparents, who had lived experience of WW1.

So we had a direct connection with somebody with first-hand experience of the world wars. It just occured to me that babies born now won't have that.

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel as distant to them as the victorians do to us? Will it have some kind of subconscious impact on society?

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 10/09/2023 08:49

Goldencup · 10/09/2023 05:56

Not really I am 47, DS is 19, Dd 17. Both DH and I have living relatives who remember the war ( DH's grand mother's cousin is 96, still lucid, actually served) and my uncle age 90, so six at the outbreak of war and 12 at the end. There is also a man at church who was an evacuee. For us it is my GC who will have no living connection.

So how often do your kids sre their 3 generations removed cousin?
Or their Great Uncle?

I'm similar age to you but my kids are primary age.
Oldest living relatives are in their 70s the boomer generation.
My oldest was 4 when his great-grandfather died at 96 so he won't have much memory of him, never mind any stories of what life was like during the war.

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 08:49

My grandfather was too old to serve in WW2, except as an ARP warden. He volunteered for WW1. His reasoning being that if you volunteered, you got a choice in what you did.

givemeasunnyday · 10/09/2023 08:48

DojaPhat · 09/09/2023 19:12

But it seems the issue is very specific to WW1/2. I wonder what marks those wars as uniquely different to the others?

Can you really not see the answer to that question? If not then I genuinely despair. Hint - the clue is in first word of both those wars!

MrsMoastyToasty · 10/09/2023 08:40

DUncle is 99, so was 15 when war broke out and he served as soon as he was old enough.
In the 1980s I was volunteering in a hospital and got talking to a 100 year old patient and he had served in the Boer war.

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 08:39

Ww2 ended 78 years ago didn’t it 🤔 those in the 80s now were children then so may have a limited memory of it.

My mother remembers a fair bit. Especially traumatic things like the sound of doodlebugs. Nights in air raid shelters etc.

She doesn’t remember being hungry or undernourished, and her growth wasn’t stunted by rationing! Working class too, so no silver spoon.

PastelLilac · 10/09/2023 08:38

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 08:25

I.must have my dates mudled up. She was still pretty small. Loved in the South East and won't remember much of it.

She would've been around 6 years old when WW2 ended so yes, she very likely does remember the war and was affected by it. I have strong memories of when I was 3 years old. I bet your life has been a lot easier than hers.

Sugarfree23 · 10/09/2023 08:37

Floraltears · 10/09/2023 08:27

Ww2 ended 78 years ago didn’t it 🤔 those in the 80s now were children then so may have a limited memory of it.

Yes you'd need to be 92 to have been an adult (18) at the end of the war so actually have good memories of what life was really like

Awumminnscotland · 10/09/2023 08:36

I am 52. I have a 7 yr old. My Dad was born in 1925 and served in the 2nd World War in the Royal Navy. My mum was born in 1933 in London and was a schoolgirl during the war.

My Dad had malaria which he had recurrent illness from and terrible nightmares. He had a terrible raging temper that flew out from nowhere and affected us all but especially my mum. Other times he was kindhearted but lived in his head. He never talked about the war specifically but said he and his pals were desperate to be of age to join up before the war ended. They were young and wanted in on the action.
He was an intelligent man with a kind heart but when he had a drink his "irrational" hate of the Japanese during the war would occasionally surface. From what I can gather the ship he was on transported back prisoners of war from Japanese camps around the Pacific. What those men endured stayed with him forever and challenged what he thought of life and humanity.
My mum was a resilient strong Woman but until she died would go quiet and get tears in her eyes at any sound similar to an air raid siren or a whistle that sounded like the buzz bombs from the blitz. When people talked about the blitz spirit she'd roll her eyes and laugh scathingly.
What I'm saying is that as previous posters have said War leaves intergenerational memories and trauma. I remember and relate to my parents memories and the mental scars it left for them. Also it's important to remember that the people who lived what we only see as history were the people voting and shaping the world we now live in. We have to remember so that we are living and shaping the world consciously trying to not repeat ourselves and perpetuate the prejudices and lived traumas from before.
My daughter was definitely the only child taking in war medals to school during armistice day. She learns from stories handed down and this peaks her curiosity to question and learn in life. She watches the news and is aware of War in Ukraine and we chat about the effects.
Those posters talking about people banging on about the war really must live in a self absorbed shallow bubble.

Thisbastardcomputer · 10/09/2023 08:36

My maternal grandfather fought in both WW1 and WW2 but never spoke of either, he was Scottish and grumpy so you knew better than to ask. He was much more free with his opinion of Mick Jagger when he appeared on Top of the Pops 😂

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 08:29

@Floraltears that's what I mean. I'm seriously burnt out at the moment so have got my dates muddled up. She doesn't remember anything really.

Laurama91 · 10/09/2023 08:29

My grandparents were born just after ww2 ended. They were the youngest of their siblings. Im 32 so had no stories of war

Floraltears · 10/09/2023 08:27

Ww2 ended 78 years ago didn’t it 🤔 those in the 80s now were children then so may have a limited memory of it.

givemeasunnyday · 10/09/2023 08:27

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:34

Of course there have been terrible wars since, but not on the UKs doorstep. I'm just wondering whether with time certain things will fade, for example the memorial events, poppies, things like that. Is it inevitable that as generations progress, the memory of war fades to the point it stops being marked?

I'm also wondering whether jn the future, say in 2100, the disconnect from this "lived experience" of war will make society generally more or less prone to starting them.

And if you're reading this from 2100: hi! 😁

I'm not in the UK, but here there are a lot of young children who have an interest in the World Wars. They learn about them at school around the time of ANZAC Day, and I see many attending the dawn commemoration I attend, as well as the ones later in the day. Here at least I don't think the memorial events are in any danger of fading, attendance has only increased in recent years.

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 08:25

I.must have my dates mudled up. She was still pretty small. Loved in the South East and won't remember much of it.

Tumbleweed101 · 10/09/2023 08:25

Yes, for the British public - not just the soldiers and others directly involved in the actual conflict - these wars had a massive effect on society that has stayed in our collective experience. Things like better housing and the NHS arrived because they realised how many in poverty had such poor health they couldn’t fight. Those wars had a huge impact, even perhaps grandparents who were only children who remember being evacuated.

There will be disconnection emotionally with time and there isn’t that person in a household who can remember it directly but we had films and movie clips and photos which will keep it visually alive.

PastelLilac · 10/09/2023 08:24

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 08:16

I mean my nans 83/84 she was born after the war. Hasn't really known many struggles and is a bit out of touch with reality and doesn't understand why we shouldn't have letlft Europe or why I can't afford to buy a house as I spend all my money on rent. She always goes on about how life was difficult after the war but she was born 6 years after it finished..... so bu the time she was old enough to understand what difficulties after a war was it wasn't a huge impact on her life any more. But as a PP said most people think all old people where in THE war.

If your nan is in her 80s then she was born during WW2, which ended in 1945. Mine are in their 70s and were born after WW2 ended.

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 08:21

I mean my nans 83/84 she was born after the war

That’s weird. My mum is just a year older and was born before it started.

HuneyBuns · 10/09/2023 08:19

*Bloody hell, yes really! I didn't know my grandparents.

Did you think I just suddenly forgot about their existence?*

Op's question was about knowing anyone from the war, not specifically grandparents. It's unusual to not have grandparents and to not have encountered anyone who's been in the war. Im probably much younger than you, but I know/knew people

Don't know why you're snippy with Pp

Movingandlooking · 10/09/2023 08:16

I mean my nans 83/84 she was born after the war. Hasn't really known many struggles and is a bit out of touch with reality and doesn't understand why we shouldn't have letlft Europe or why I can't afford to buy a house as I spend all my money on rent. She always goes on about how life was difficult after the war but she was born 6 years after it finished..... so bu the time she was old enough to understand what difficulties after a war was it wasn't a huge impact on her life any more. But as a PP said most people think all old people where in THE war.

JaiynDough · 10/09/2023 08:14

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:26

Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war

Surely that's a good thing.

But we need to keep the memory of wwI&II alive though, to prevent it happening again and to remember all those lost.

Awumminnscotland · 10/09/2023 08:07

MoxieFox · 09/09/2023 22:17

So all the racist hate crimes including the murders of Northern Irish British Citizens and Irish citizens living in Great Britain don’t count as it “didn’t really affect anyone outside NI and the forces”? Shocking how little you know of your own history.

In the early 1970s there were regular bombs going off in London, not the odd bomb scare.

FriedasCarLoad · 10/09/2023 07:32

Yes. Mostly. .

I have three under 5s, and an 102 year old grandmother who was in her 20s in the war. Realistically she may not live long enough for the baby to remember her, but my eldest will.

And keeping old family stories alive helps to bridge the vast gap. My own great grandmother (whom I remember well) was born in 1895 and that made the Victorians seem less distant and more connected to me.

CurlewKate · 10/09/2023 07:26

@raindropbox "Basically the babies being born now will be the first generation ever to not have a living history of war"

Kind of depends where they're born, I'd say....

SprinkleOfSunak · 10/09/2023 06:51

I find this very sad too.

The spirit of those who were living during WW2 was/is tremendous. They were/are just so different to the majority of the rest of us, and I really miss that, and think wider society will too/is missing this.

I’m delighted that my children had their Great Nanny around in their lives for a few years, although obviously I wish she was still here with us all, imparting her wisdom and strength, and being good humoured at all times. My children talk about her all the time, and really miss her too, and adore our elderly neighbour who is in her 90’s, always wanting to spend time with her.

ColleenDonaghy · 10/09/2023 06:34

Presil · 09/09/2023 22:34

There's a reason the troubles are not referred to as a "war".

Oh my. Yes, you're right, there is a reason. Chilling, isn't it?

Precisely.

Again, I have no issue with OP excluding the Troubles when she's talking about wars that had a massive impact across the UK. But, A) it does well to reflect on why that is, are there many other examples of long and bloody conflicts so readily dismissed by the rest of the population of the country they happened in? And B) I stand by saying OP's statement was grotesquely offensive.