Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids today won't know anyone from the war

233 replies

raindropbox · 09/09/2023 18:22

Our grandparents or parents were children during the war, and they had stories from their parents or grandparents, who had lived experience of WW1.

So we had a direct connection with somebody with first-hand experience of the world wars. It just occured to me that babies born now won't have that.

Does that mean WW1/2 will feel as distant to them as the victorians do to us? Will it have some kind of subconscious impact on society?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WillowCraft · 10/09/2023 15:31

MoxieFox · 10/09/2023 14:04

Correct. It was more than threats and scares. Bombs in and outside London. As well as murders/assassinations.

That’s why I view it as a civil war.

It doesn’t have to be WWII to be a war or to be “living memory of war”

It was - and is remembered as such by those who lived through it. The generation immediately after don't have much awareness (excluding those in NI) whereas ww2 has entered the national psyche in a much bigger way. I do think it's partly or even mostly because ww2 is comfortable, clear cut, we are the good guys. We like to think about it. (Those who actually lived through it didn't but the fewer of those that survive the more fuss is made about ww2 it seems). Whereas the troubles and other more recent wars are messy, we feel guilty etc.

Goldencup · 10/09/2023 15:18

Sugarfree23 · 10/09/2023 08:49

So how often do your kids sre their 3 generations removed cousin?
Or their Great Uncle?

I'm similar age to you but my kids are primary age.
Oldest living relatives are in their 70s the boomer generation.
My oldest was 4 when his great-grandfather died at 96 so he won't have much memory of him, never mind any stories of what life was like during the war.

They have stayed with my aunt and uncle many times ( they have a place in Spain), apart from that probably 4 times a year ? DH's cousin twice removed we have met about every year, but remeber my DCs are late teens so are interested and ask questions and have for probrably the last 10 years.

Toddlerteaplease · 10/09/2023 14:14

I'm 31. My maternal grandfather served in Burma, my paternal grandfather had a reserved occupation as he had a skilled engineering job. Both died before I was born. But both grand mothers were in their 20's during the war. I interviewed my grandma about her memories as part of a primary school project.

MoxieFox · 10/09/2023 14:04

Awumminnscotland · 10/09/2023 08:07

In the early 1970s there were regular bombs going off in London, not the odd bomb scare.

Correct. It was more than threats and scares. Bombs in and outside London. As well as murders/assassinations.

That’s why I view it as a civil war.

It doesn’t have to be WWII to be a war or to be “living memory of war”

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 14:00

@Presil How do you know that?

I have lived and worked in all the UK home countries, been married to a Scot, now spend half my time in Wales, and have noticed absolutely no difference.

Presil · 10/09/2023 13:55

@Oakbeam because the preoccupation isn't as prevalent in other parts of the UK.

Thementalloadisreal · 10/09/2023 13:48

Not yet but will be true of our children’s children.
My 7 and 11 year old know their great Nan and grandad, both alive still, both children during the war who were evacuated.

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 13:43

It's also the last war that England has been involved in

Why single out England? It wasn’t involved in WW2 as sovereign state, just as one part of the UK as whole.

KrisAkabusi · 10/09/2023 12:43

Crapsummer2023

Very well said!

Presil · 10/09/2023 12:30

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 09:02

The obsession with those 2 wars and the way in which they are remembered and taught i.e ‘We won, we’re the best!’ Has been damaging.

If you speak to the people who were actually involved in it you don’t get any of that. In the mid 1960s I remember asking my father who won the war. His response has stuck with me ever since…

“Nobody wins a war”

Agree with both of you.

The sense of English exceptionalism seems to be bolstered by them focusing intently on WWII. It was of course the country's last experience of "total war" ie war that involved more people than the existing professional armed forces.

It's also the last war that England has been involved in that isn't politically or socially questionable. And the war that is adjacent to the decline of the British empire. I think those are the key reasons for the huge focus on it - because what's happened since is less straightforward and perhaps more difficult to deal with.

Although despite the attention on it as an identity defining event, people still do not see it clearly - for example, little of the popular narrative about WWII acknowledges that the conflict ended because Russia held the Eastern Front and because the USA dropped two atomic bombs on civilian populations - the first and last country to do so. Nothing to do with bunting, or keep calm and carry on, or spirit of the blitz, or god bless you ma'am, although to hear an English person talk about it you would think that these things were what defeated fascism.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 10/09/2023 12:23

KateyCuckoo · 10/09/2023 09:33

Because I've answered the same question 3 times now. People keep asking the same thing, like they can't believe I don't know anyone from WW2 just because they do....

Don’t worry, I don’t either. My grandparents did - they were born in the early 1920’s. But it was never a topic of conversation. My parents were true boomers, born 2 or 3 years after the end of WW2. They had no reason to talk about it. I had a normal middle class upbringing, as did they. We have no friends / friends relatives who were in the war, or if they were again it’s not a topic of conversation. So from my perspective the norm is not not to know any one, and it’s unusual if you do. I would think that was the case for anyone under 60.

Let’s be honest, remembrance day has become a bigger and bigger thing as time has past, for some reason. It doesn’t even register in my early memories. The first time I think I it did was once I’d started work and was commuting by train into London. So early 90’s. It’s definitely grown since then, but I couldn’t tell you the date. September 11th is imprinted on my mind - we were living abroad at the time. But WW1/2? Long forgotten. Unless perhaps you have friends/family in the military. Then I can see that it might have been a larger part of your life than society in general.

caerdydd12 · 10/09/2023 11:51

Goldencup · 10/09/2023 11:08

My kids do have that. Their kids will be the first generation not to.

Yes but my point in my previous post is taking into account average ages since the 40s for becoming a mother that actually the current generation are more likely to not have that connection, rather than the generation being born now.

Average childbearing ages in the 60s was 23, in the 80s it was 25 so a huge proportion of the population at 20-35 years old will have grandparents born after WW2.

Goldencup · 10/09/2023 11:08

caerdydd12 · 10/09/2023 09:27

Yes but the OP said parents or grandparents, so by that logic your kids are still the first generation not to have that. Just as I don't.

My kids do have that. Their kids will be the first generation not to.

zingally · 10/09/2023 10:49

My two grandfathers were late teens/early 20s during WW2. One was medically unfit as a severe asthmatic, but in the latter part of the war he went up to Hull as a scientist to design submarines. The other spent the war sailing in ships round the eastern med, and never saw a scrap of action. He looked back on it as a jolly adventure with his mates.
At least one great grandfather fought in the trenches at the Somme, saw a lot of action and got a medal for bravery. He also witnessed his older brother shot and killed by the enemy. I just about remember meeting him as a very young child, and now have his medals.

As for kids now not knowing anyone from either war, surely that's a good thing?

1stTimeMama · 10/09/2023 10:15

We have a lot of past family members who were in the military, on both sides, so it's always been quite a focus with our children. My grandparents were both active in WWII, and 4 of my children knew my Nan, only my little one didn't meet her. My 10yr old's special interest is the military, war, weaponry etc. so it's a focus of his education (home ed), and my husband served for 26 years, so for us, it's not something that will be forgotten easily. However, that's just an individual story, generally children being born now won't have that direct connection and it will be 'my ancestors from long, long ago fought in a war'.

MavisBeacon1234 · 10/09/2023 09:44

mummummummummummummmmmmy · 09/09/2023 18:56

What are you on about?

I'm 37 and neither my parents or grandparents had fuck all to do with ww2 let alone my kids.

Same I'm 39 both sets of grandparents were to young to be involved in ww2, one of my great grandads were building ships on the Clyde and I have no ideas what the rest of them did.

DojaPhat · 10/09/2023 09:39

@givemeasunnyday It's okay if you don't understand it, another poster also said 'bCoz ThEy W0z WoRlD wArZ!! Thë ClŪe Iz iN tHę nAmE!!!' Grin

Poorlymumma · 10/09/2023 09:38

I think Hitler and the holocaust/concentration camps will still be taught about in schools for years to come. I'm 30 and did it basically every year in RE at secondary school, and it's what I mostly associate ww2 with.
Ashamed to say I don't really know anything about ww1.

givemeasunnyday · 10/09/2023 09:36

DojaPhat · 10/09/2023 09:24

@givemeasunnyday It's nothing to do with those wars as 'world wars'. Try thinking about more critically about the question. It's been explained in other posts.

Your questions was "I wonder what marks those wars as uniquely different to the others?"

Maybe do a bit of critical thinking yourself.

KateyCuckoo · 10/09/2023 09:33

HuneyBuns · 10/09/2023 08:19

*Bloody hell, yes really! I didn't know my grandparents.

Did you think I just suddenly forgot about their existence?*

Op's question was about knowing anyone from the war, not specifically grandparents. It's unusual to not have grandparents and to not have encountered anyone who's been in the war. Im probably much younger than you, but I know/knew people

Don't know why you're snippy with Pp

Because I've answered the same question 3 times now. People keep asking the same thing, like they can't believe I don't know anyone from WW2 just because they do....

caerdydd12 · 10/09/2023 09:27

Goldencup · 10/09/2023 05:56

Not really I am 47, DS is 19, Dd 17. Both DH and I have living relatives who remember the war ( DH's grand mother's cousin is 96, still lucid, actually served) and my uncle age 90, so six at the outbreak of war and 12 at the end. There is also a man at church who was an evacuee. For us it is my GC who will have no living connection.

Yes but the OP said parents or grandparents, so by that logic your kids are still the first generation not to have that. Just as I don't.

DojaPhat · 10/09/2023 09:24

@givemeasunnyday It's nothing to do with those wars as 'world wars'. Try thinking about more critically about the question. It's been explained in other posts.

Oakbeam · 10/09/2023 09:02

The obsession with those 2 wars and the way in which they are remembered and taught i.e ‘We won, we’re the best!’ Has been damaging.

If you speak to the people who were actually involved in it you don’t get any of that. In the mid 1960s I remember asking my father who won the war. His response has stuck with me ever since…

“Nobody wins a war”

ColleenDonaghy · 10/09/2023 08:55

Great post @Crapsummer2023 .

Crapsummer2023 · 10/09/2023 08:51

I actually think this will be a good thing. WW1/2 (on the allies side) were necessary, however, I believe that in the long term they’ve held the UK back from its full potential. The obsession with those 2 wars and the way in which they are remembered and taught i.e ‘We won, we’re the best!’ Has been damaging.

When I was at school, history lessons boiled down to WW1/2, ‘we won!’, ‘a bit about the holocaust, King Henry the 8th and the Elizabeth 1st era. Even when they discussed American slavery, the crux was ‘we ended it, aren’t we great?!, apartheid in South Africa, ‘the English white people were nicer than the Dutch as we let the black servants into the house’. Zero contextual or world history. Look at the carry on in the run up to Novembers Poppy Day. WW1 was supposed to make us free but look what happens when anyone on tv doesn’t wear a poppy full time from Oct 1st.

All of this has created a strange jingoism which has meant a great deal of the population believe the UK is exceptional. This has stifled innovation and ultimately led to self harm with Brexit as many believe the UK is the best, can go it alone in the world and can be ‘world beating’ in all areas.

WW1/2 happened. Let’s learn the lessons from it but stop obsessions and triumphalising over it. It’s time for the UK to grow up and recognise its true place in the world today, then maybe we can unlock our true potential.