Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To share the price I want with viewers?

66 replies

Hana89 · 09/09/2023 16:55

I am selling my house and have already found a property that I love and had an offer accepted. Initially I accepted an offer from a cash buyer that was quite a bit over my asking price of £220k. For personal reasons the cash buyer pulled out and my house is back on the market. I don't want to be greedy, but I do need my asking price which is a little below market average for a speedy sale.
At two viewings today with first time buyers who really loved the house, I told each of them outright that I want to get £220k and when they asked if there was room for negotiation, I said that honestly there really isn't because I can't afford to drop below my asking price and also with all the work I've done here, selling for less isn't really worth my while.
The estate agent seemed really annoyed with me about being so open about the price I want/need.
Was I being unreasonable? I didn't see the point in letting people try to make a low offer I know I won't accept and I don't need anyone to offer too much and stretch themselves too thin. It seems to me that if house sales were more transparent everyone could have a less stressful time but I've never sold a house before so I might be being naive or have made a blunder.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wereonthemarket · 11/09/2023 19:28

FawltyTower · 10/09/2023 01:07

Properties are selling for under asking nowadays. An agent today told me that 15% under asking is average. You need to price higher than what you want

This is often what leads to houses being stuck for months.

15% feels huge?!

If advertised at £500k then 15% would be £75k? Do you think people advertising for £500k are accepting offers of £425k? That really surprises me.

When Im looking on rightmove with a budget of £450k I'm only looking at houses up to £475k thinking they'd maybe accept £25k under at the v most!

yesMans · 11/09/2023 19:05

@Hana89 the estate agent probably though that if someone offered a bit less, they could convince you to accept it. That saves them more viewings/organisation etc and increases their revenue more quickly. You’ve done nothing wrong with telling viewers this. However, I’d only offer that information if you’re asked if there is room for negotiation. I say this because people who really like a house (like your cash buyer) may go in higher to secure it, so you could be doing yourself out of a higher offer.

Alternatively I wouldn’t market it at the price you want, especially if it’s worth more on a marker analysis?! Why not put it on a little above market rate and then you’re likely to get what you need?

Hana89 · 11/09/2023 19:00

For anyone who was interested, I ended up with both buyers offering asking price, it then went to best and final bids, and I've settled very happily on £224k.
As some people said, it might have gone for more if I hadn't been so forthright, but I'm really pleased with the result and I hope the buyer I settled on feels the same!

Best of luck to us all on all future moves everyone! X

OP posts:
MarySmit · 10/09/2023 20:33

FawltyTower · 10/09/2023 01:07

Properties are selling for under asking nowadays. An agent today told me that 15% under asking is average. You need to price higher than what you want

This is often what leads to houses being stuck for months.

Houses are stuck for months nowadays as vendors want more than they are worth, and are not willing to accept lower offers.

AdobeWanKenobi · 10/09/2023 01:52

MarySmit · 09/09/2023 20:56

Properties are selling for under asking nowadays. An agent today told me that 15% under asking is average. You need to price higher than what you want. In the end though, people are only willing to pay what a property is worth, and don't care about your personal circumstances.

Not everywhere they aren’t, and OP hasn’t mentioned the area she’s in. The housing market is not created equal.

As for her showing people around, again, this is not something done everywhere. I’ve sold three houses and the area where they were, houses are marketed and logistics dealt with by the agent, but viewings almost always done by the homeowner. Only one viewing was done for me by an agent and only because I was away at the time.

FWIW OP I admire your honesty. DD has just purchased a house in one of those weird little pockets where the market is different. She had one agent send her to view a couple of houses out of budget and telling her and her DH there was room for negotiation, when all of them actually went under offer at above asking and were never achievable. It’s just stress and disappointment that could be avoided.

FawltyTower · 10/09/2023 01:07

Properties are selling for under asking nowadays. An agent today told me that 15% under asking is average. You need to price higher than what you want

This is often what leads to houses being stuck for months.

Saracen · 10/09/2023 01:01

OP, I chose an estate agent who recommends your approach. It feels more honest to me, and she was easy to work with. It was successful with our house sale. Slightly different circumstances: we don't need to sell right now, and there is no practical minimum we can accept. But we put the house on for what we expected to get, and asked the EA to tell buyers we wouldn't accept much less. We were pretty sure the survey wasn't going to identify any real problems. We accepted an offer of 3% under asking price.

I really did not like the game playing advocated by the other two estate agents I interviewed. FGS, they wouldn't even tell me upfront what commission they charged! Both were also very pushy and were not good listeners.

Hana89 · 09/09/2023 23:36

Some really interesting differences of opinion on this topic!

It seems like it absolutely depends on the buyer as some people clearly value this approach and others think I'm naive at best, outright bonkers at worst! Haha!

For what it's worth I don't think selling a house should have to be a series of psychological tricks or a mine field of asking for more to settle for less, and I still think bidding wars are horrible.
After reading all the replies I don't think I did anything wrong at all, especially as I was asked a direct question so gave an honest answer, but I appreciate it perhaps isn't the norm and might have been a bit strange for the EA.

Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond thoughtfully and fairly.

OP posts:
PinkRoses1245 · 09/09/2023 22:01

Honestly, I bought recently, and if I went to a viewing with the agent and the vendor was there and said what you said - I’d be totally put off the property. I’m surprised the agent allows you to be there. It’s up to the agent to handle negotiations.

Sunshine997 · 09/09/2023 21:57

You are not unreasonable as long as you are comfortable that you may not sell it. You are entitled to ask for 220k and over however you need to let go of the previous offer, whether they offered over asking or not it didnt complete so its neither here nor there.
Interesting tho that the estate agent works for you and you should have had this conversation so that they were clear that it is offers over 220k. So poor on them not to have done so.
Good luck.

dinoice · 09/09/2023 21:51

I think you should have set it at whatever the over offer was at, and been prepare to drop to the £220.

As others have said.

Plus it's the spin isn't it. I was taking 228 but if you offer today 220 will get it off the market.

I think you have an agent issu

Montydin · 09/09/2023 21:16

If you’re directly asked by viewers I think it’s fine to say something on the lines of ‘I’m looking for the asking price, as I previously had an offer on the property at this’. I’ve done my own viewings after a sale had fallen through, a lot of people asked why it was back on the market and what price I had agreed. Otherwise I would leave the negotiating up to the agent, but obviously let them know you want the £220k

BrightLightTonight · 09/09/2023 21:04

Your job is to present the house in the best possible way. The EA’s job is to get the best price.
If you have told the potential buyer the lowest price you will accept, tbst is what they are going to offer.

MarySmit · 09/09/2023 20:56

Properties are selling for under asking nowadays. An agent today told me that 15% under asking is average. You need to price higher than what you want. In the end though, people are only willing to pay what a property is worth, and don't care about your personal circumstances.

Bodgejobvendors · 09/09/2023 20:52

I just think you’re naive. People want to feel like they’re getting a good deal. Your agent should have either set the asking price at £230k or marketed it as offers over.

Frances0911 · 09/09/2023 20:51

My sister bought a house that was over priced but in immaculate condition inside and out. They did ask for a reduction but the owners refused and said they would hold out on the price for as long as it took to sell.

Flyingalone · 09/09/2023 20:44

'No one cares about the sellers personal circumstances. Buyers care that they're getting a good deal. '

☝🏻 ☝🏻 ☝🏻

I think it was rather inappropriate for you to comment. Negotiations/price talks are left to the estate agent.

Hana89 · 09/09/2023 20:32

Thank you @cimena ❤️

OP posts:
Hana89 · 09/09/2023 20:25

@Thelittleweasel That's a good idea! I'll see what happens early next week with offers and if it is still on the market, I might ask the EA to do that.

@Magicisuponus No, it hasn't. It's really only been up a couple of weeks. It was snapped up straight away by the cash buyer who had to drop out due to her circumstances, and I've just had some more viewings on it yesterday and today. There are so many options for marketing! I do find it all a bit overwhelming! Really hoping this is the last house move I make! Haha!

OP posts:
Magicisuponus · 09/09/2023 20:17

We’ve bought a house in the last few months which was marketed as ‘offers over £…’, not asking price. So buyers know what is the minimum you are willing to accept. Has your house been marketed this way?

Ponderingwindow · 09/09/2023 20:16

If your last offer was over asking, the EA was probably hoping to replicate that. You just made that impossible.

headcheffer · 09/09/2023 20:15

I know you're supposed to go through the agent but that aside, we did this with our last house sale. And actually, the viewer had been gazumped on their last house and appreciated the honesty. We said we need X amount to be able to move, and want to proceed ASAP and said if you offer exactly that we will not accept any more viewings. They did, and the sale proceeded really quickly and smoothly.

Thelittleweasel · 09/09/2023 20:14

@Hana89

It is perfectly possible to get the estate agent to mark the sale details

£XXXXXX - fixed price. We have always sold with that proviso and it rules out silly viewers. We also pay the asking price [or not buy]/ It saves so much aggro!

cimena · 09/09/2023 20:11

Id love it if a seller told me this. House buying is such a weird terrifying mystery - you don’t know if there’ll be a bidding war or what the seller wants, last time we did it there were several where I just wanted to ask them straight up ‘how much can we buy your house for please’ but apparently that’s not allowed, as you seem to be finding!

I say carry on, and I hope you find a buyer as decent as you sound.

AngelinaFibres · 09/09/2023 20:10

You have to bear in mind that your buyer will almost certainly have a survey . The survey will bring up issues, they always do. I have moved 19 times in my adult life and each time the offer I made initially was reduced after the survey. The same happened to me as the seller. Its perfectly normal. If your buyer asks for a reduction, but has already offered exactly what you need, you may lose the sale if you refuse to reduce. If you can't proceed without the initial amount you may find you can never move. Your EA knows this. That I why he is trying to get more so you have scope for reducing after the survey. Listen to him. It's his job.