Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not send child to a school just because it’s close

137 replies

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 16:50

i will be starting to look for a primary school soon for DS to start Reception next Sept. We have a primary school that is round the corner from us, less than a minute walk which DH says we should send DS to because its close, but even though it is ofsted rated Good, whenever I speak to other parents or the local Fb group, they all say ‘It’s fine’ or ‘It’s okay’. Isn’t that code for its not great but I don’t want to be rude? They also still have spaces for this september and have been advertising a lot that they have spaces open, where other schools all had theirs spaces filled

We have another school that is well recommended and about 15mins walk away so will probably put that as my first preference, but was thinking of putting a school that we would have to drive to as a second preference as they also seem highly recommended and have a good after school programme

Ds is very curious, loves learning and I have been told by nursery and others that he is very smart. I think we should send him to a better school as education takes priority over convenience, and I don’t want him to get bored at school if he is learning stuff he already knows. DH thinks convenience takes priority and primary school won’t make much difference

I will obviously visit all schools and have a look but think it’s quite hard to judge on an open day as everyone is on their best behaviour. And I know just because I put a school down, it doesn’t guarantee I will get a spot.

so what do you think?

YABU - Husband is right! Make your life easier and send him to the closer school
YANBU - Primary school is the foundation of learning and will have an impact on later education

OP posts:
madnessitellyou · 09/09/2023 17:44

Pay no attention to anything anyone says on Facebook about a school. Our local page goes like this:

What are people's thoughts about x school?

It's great. So supportive.
Its not bad
Crap school
Full of bullies and that's just the teachers
The best
Go to y school It's better
X school was terrible for my ds
My dd loved it there but it's gone downhill since then.
Worst school ever we took our dd out.

DaisyWaldron · 09/09/2023 17:43

I'd look around the schools and get a feel for them. My children went to an Ofsted "good" primary school, and an "outstanding" secondary school and the primary school was far and away the better school. Creative, supportive leadership and teaching, inclusive, welcoming to parents, loads of extracurricular activities, always looking to improve, and with a strong community feel. The outstanding school has some great teachers and some bad teachers, has a head teacher who is ambitious for his own career and has an intake from mostly wealthy families.

StillWantingADog · 09/09/2023 17:41

Re the SEN concern, that’s a fair point but otoh schools round here that are considered good with SEN seem to get swamped with SEN kids which annoys the non-SEN parents as they feel their child is not getting enough attention

I would say our school is not great with SEN having spoken to some other parents but it’s not part of a wider problem

wraparound provision (if you need it) and extra curricular stuff are other things to consider when you visit schools. Usually the bigger the school the more scope for this kind of thing but not always.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 09/09/2023 17:40

You haven't actually been to look at any of them though!

You need to visit. Then consider issues such as distance. I think you're putting the cart before the horse!

There are other factors too - eg onsite wrap-around provision, if you work, commute times etc.

TheSoapyFrog · 09/09/2023 17:40

Mixed thoughts about this tbh.

A short bus ride and a 25 minute walk may seem doable, but, (and this isfrom experience) the buses are usually packed during the school runs. It's sweltering in the summer, and then in snowy weather, they get cancelled or are really late. And the walk isn't so much fun in those instances either.

My son goes to a school which is quite far from us, as we moved during reception, and the nearer schools were fully subscribed with lengthy waiting lists. He gets transport as there's no public transport and I'm unable to take him myself. He doesn't have any friends nearby to play with, and he can't go to after school clubs. I also can't go to a lot of the events held by the school, which I could if it was a few minutes walk away.

But I also wouldn't pick the nearer school if there was a better one for my son.

PollyPut · 09/09/2023 17:39

Put them in the order you want. Make sure the one next to your house is on the list, even if it's last. That way you will get one of your options and remain on waiting list for all of the ones above it - at least for a few months

jamdonut · 09/09/2023 17:39

What is it you think he will learn at another school that will not be something he already knows? The National Curriculum teaches similar things to each year group, but elaborates on them, year by year. So you will always know something already, and hopefully be able to build on that knowledge by re-visiting it and learning a bit more.

The biggest mistake people make is with reading. They say " OH, my child can already read, they are reading Harry Potter!" etc etc, but when it comes down to it, although they may be fluent readers, their actual understanding (comprehension and inference) of what they are reading can be quite poor, in comparison. There is always something more to learn.

Boredom happens in children who THINK they know it all.

My own 3 children went to the nearest schools to us. They were OK schools. They came out of them just fine (despite both their primary and senior schools going into special measures at various times) and easily reached their universities.

A 'clever' child should get on just fine wherever they are.

Monster80 · 09/09/2023 17:38

We didn’t go for the primary school on our doorstep (religious). DC and I walk 12 minutes to a wonderful school, the other school was a 3 min walk. I think walking chills kids out and gets them ready for the day, same for end of the day, we use as an unwind session and talk about what’s happened while we have been apart. I would prioritise setting over location; but longer than a 20 min journey could be annoying for you all.

TheWrenTheWren · 09/09/2023 17:38

NumberTheory · 09/09/2023 17:24

YANBU to look at other schools rather than automatically go for the closest. But I think you might be underestimating the value of one round the corner.

In my experience, when people don’t think the school is good they say so, they don’t call it “fine” or “okay”, but the parents clearly aren’t raving about it, so if parents of other schools are very complimentary about the other schools, those schools are probably doing significantly more that the parents like. And the biggest factor in a child’s education is the parents - who will obviously still be you wherever you end up sending him.

I think you’re right to look around, but I wouldn’t ignore the advantage of a close school, and I don’t think that advantage is mainly about the school run. Being in a school that you are close to with lots of other kids all living close is a big advantage socially for you kids. It make seeing friends easier, it helps them feel more secure in their local neighborhood as they will recognise more people when out and about and more places if they have spent time visiting friends houses, etc.

The school run is a factor, though. Logistically young kids in school are difficult to deal fit in to working weeks. Your work or your DH’s work might change in the 7 years your kid’s in the school. A school run that’s virtually hassle free (and that he might be able to do himself in later years, could be a boon. I probably wouldn’t pick the round the corner school over the 15 minute walk school on this basis, but it might be an edge against the car drive/25 minute walk school.

I think that's fair.

Stompythedinosaur · 09/09/2023 17:37

I might do that if the school was failing, but it isn't.

Don't ignore the massive benefit socially of being in the same area as school friends for social development.

MysteriousShopper · 09/09/2023 17:37

You can't judge a school by its Ofsted report. Visit, meet some of the staff and get a feel for it. Don't underestimate the convenience of being so close to school, driving might not sound like a big deal now but your circumstances may change ................new job. more dc, poor health.
I live opposite the primary my dc went to - it's amazing just being able to pop out a minute or two before pick-up and not have to worry about parking. Great for concerts/school events too.

newfriend05 · 09/09/2023 17:36

And that was on a bus

CruiseOver · 09/09/2023 17:36

We used to live close to our primary school (10 minute walk) and moved further away (10 minute drive). Much preferred it when we lived close and could walk to and from school.

But, just visit tends schools and go from there.

JollyGoodWine · 09/09/2023 17:35

Definitely visit, and listen to your gut instinct. But we're like you, we have a primary round the corner, but it felt like it was struggling a bit, whereas we were really impressed with one that is a 20-minute walk away, and that's where the DCs went, and we never regretted it. (Actually, we mostly drive there.) But they're not the only kids who live that distance away, so it's not like all the other kids apart from ours are on the doorstep.

newfriend05 · 09/09/2023 17:35

Have you visited the schools ? If not go to their open days .. your know which one is right for your child., I was in an area with lots of primary schools iI pasted at least 6 to get to my sons but it was an amazing primary and was absolutely worth it

StillWantingADog · 09/09/2023 17:33

I think you need to visit them all.

not sure what you mean by “they also seem highly recommended”, by who? Other parents?

consiser all three but do not underestimate the convenience of having a school very closeby- this will mean that friends are closeby too. And when they are y5/6 they can get themselves to school.

I wouldn’t necessarily be put off because there are “spaces”. My son’s school is fantastic and in two year groups there are spaces but that’s just because of a catchment birth rate blip.

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 17:32

Just to clarify. I am not making my judgements on online research and what people say alone. I will be visiting the schools before I make any judgements but since schools have just started, they are not doing open days until a little later.

I was thinking more on would you send your child to a better school that would involve a drive or bus (5mins/20mins) or an ‘okay’ school that is very close

Also, does anyone live very close to a school or know of someone who did, and they became the ‘since you live so close, can you look after my child until I can get there’ person? I know I can say know but I have struggled growing a backbone and saying no is easier said than done sometimes

OP posts:
HerMammy · 09/09/2023 17:30

I am always mystified by the English system, here in Scotland you go to your catchment area school unless you have good reason for a placing request.

Tuxedomom · 09/09/2023 17:28

I would visit, talk to staff and get the vibe. You can ask them what the biggest challenges in their school are.

When we moved house, DS moved from a school which went from good to special measures while he was on roll, to an outstanding school (more affluent area, nicer facilities). He was happy and had good friends in both. The trips and activities were better in the outstanding school, probably because parents could pay for them, but academic rigour and behaviour management were much better in the inadequate school.

Sprogonthetyne · 09/09/2023 17:28

I'd put the other two, then the one round the corner as a safe third, assuming distance is the main criteria. However I would not tell DS that you have done this, or big up/ say anything negative about any of the schools until you get your offer.

Danascully2 · 09/09/2023 17:26

Go and do the drive at school drop off/pick up time and see what the parking/traffic outside the school is like. I am so glad I can walk to school and don't have to battle for a parking space. Also take other parent's comments with a large pinch of salt. Everyone is looking for different things. Also, our class Whatsapp group is full of parents moaning about all sorts of random stuff that is nothing to do with the actual education. Many of the moans are based on a 5 year olds report of what the teacher said... I have been very happy with our school but I'm sure you could find people who aren't... and most people don't have experience of more than one school so don't have any comparison to judge what the school is like.

DixonD · 09/09/2023 17:26

I agree with you. There’s four primary schools closer to us than the school my daughter goes to. Ours is 15 minutes away by car.

NumberTheory · 09/09/2023 17:24

YANBU to look at other schools rather than automatically go for the closest. But I think you might be underestimating the value of one round the corner.

In my experience, when people don’t think the school is good they say so, they don’t call it “fine” or “okay”, but the parents clearly aren’t raving about it, so if parents of other schools are very complimentary about the other schools, those schools are probably doing significantly more that the parents like. And the biggest factor in a child’s education is the parents - who will obviously still be you wherever you end up sending him.

I think you’re right to look around, but I wouldn’t ignore the advantage of a close school, and I don’t think that advantage is mainly about the school run. Being in a school that you are close to with lots of other kids all living close is a big advantage socially for you kids. It make seeing friends easier, it helps them feel more secure in their local neighborhood as they will recognise more people when out and about and more places if they have spent time visiting friends houses, etc.

The school run is a factor, though. Logistically young kids in school are difficult to deal fit in to working weeks. Your work or your DH’s work might change in the 7 years your kid’s in the school. A school run that’s virtually hassle free (and that he might be able to do himself in later years, could be a boon. I probably wouldn’t pick the round the corner school over the 15 minute walk school on this basis, but it might be an edge against the car drive/25 minute walk school.

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 17:20

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 09/09/2023 17:15

YABU for talking about 'my first preference '. It should be 'our first preference '. Your ds's father has an equal say.

Of course he gets a say in it. DS is our child and we make decisions together, but he has already told me that he won’t be visiting any schools, so it will be mainly up to me to make a decision.

OP posts:
Vandhana1986 · 09/09/2023 17:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.