Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not send child to a school just because it’s close

137 replies

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 16:50

i will be starting to look for a primary school soon for DS to start Reception next Sept. We have a primary school that is round the corner from us, less than a minute walk which DH says we should send DS to because its close, but even though it is ofsted rated Good, whenever I speak to other parents or the local Fb group, they all say ‘It’s fine’ or ‘It’s okay’. Isn’t that code for its not great but I don’t want to be rude? They also still have spaces for this september and have been advertising a lot that they have spaces open, where other schools all had theirs spaces filled

We have another school that is well recommended and about 15mins walk away so will probably put that as my first preference, but was thinking of putting a school that we would have to drive to as a second preference as they also seem highly recommended and have a good after school programme

Ds is very curious, loves learning and I have been told by nursery and others that he is very smart. I think we should send him to a better school as education takes priority over convenience, and I don’t want him to get bored at school if he is learning stuff he already knows. DH thinks convenience takes priority and primary school won’t make much difference

I will obviously visit all schools and have a look but think it’s quite hard to judge on an open day as everyone is on their best behaviour. And I know just because I put a school down, it doesn’t guarantee I will get a spot.

so what do you think?

YABU - Husband is right! Make your life easier and send him to the closer school
YANBU - Primary school is the foundation of learning and will have an impact on later education

OP posts:
user1497864954 · 09/09/2023 20:32

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 18:58

I’m not pressed for time on the way back. The thought of having to getting up extra early to allow him time to walk doesn’t fill me with joy 🙈🤣

You have admitted that the further school will probably end up being driven to so you will need to factor in parking etc. Also as others have stated above, if you have other children they may not get places at the more distant school. It sounds to me as though you need to visit a number of school and only discount the local school if it is really much worse than all the others. There is a LOT to be said for staying local when weather is bad or you are feeling a bit unwell but child needs to go to school. You are potentially risking making life a lot harder for yourself than you need to. I think you should fully consider your husband's point of view.

waterrat · 09/09/2023 20:24

There really are huge benefits to having school on your doorstep

We moved and went from being next door to school to one a 15 -20 min walk and its a real loss.

Having local friends goes beyond school. It means you are living in a community and your child is growing up knowing their neighbors

This will be helpful in many ways and is just nicer in terms of playdates etc

I agree primary schools v much all the sane !! If your child is bright (fairly unlikely your nursery mean anything by that other than he is developing normally!) He will flourish anywhere

Above all you would be mad to make this decision based on anythinf other than going in person and really gettjng a feel for it

Vitriolinsanity · 09/09/2023 20:17

Ime the only people that rave about a primary school are those whose children were accepted into a super over subscribed school to people that couldn't get in.

Choosing a school is like buying a house. You know it's right when you walk around.

kitsuneghost · 09/09/2023 19:49

PeggyPiglet · 09/09/2023 19:19

Depends. The small village schools are a nightmare because alot of the kids come from smaller nearby villages which don't have schools., so have to drive.

You're basically screwed if you want to live in a small, picturesque village.

No primary school in my village. Nearest one is 5 minutes drive.

I don't really understand why people don't just park somewhere 5-10 mins walk away, then walk. It would save hassle trying to park next to the school.
You can also drop your child off at a friend's house so they can walk together when older.

It would improve the situation for those that HAVE to drive too.
If the kid from the village 1 with school doesn't choose it and drives to different school then a kid living near this other school can't get a place and needs to be driven to village 1 school. That's 2 cars on the road that didn't need to be.

IsobelNecessary · 09/09/2023 19:46

for my first preference school we would have just missed out due to distance, but in previous years, we would have got in

If the Labour party gets in and sticks the axe into independent schools, there's no way you'll get in there, or at your second choice (unfortunately). Catchment areas and places at good state schools are going to be massively affected (if it actually happens, which I hope it won't).

PuttingDownRoots · 09/09/2023 19:45

If you are planning on bus... do a trial one morning this term. Theoretically the bus might be every 15 minutes and take 10... but reality maybe they are too full to get on, get stuck in traffic, run late etc. It will be best to check now.

Gingerlygreen · 09/09/2023 19:40

I agree with others that if people are saying the school is fine that they're happy with it, parents seem to love to criticise schools so if they had issues then they'd be quick to tell you about them.

Our nearest primary is at the top of our road, a two minute walk, however I'd heard so many reports about bullying and how it was never dealt with so didn't even put that one on the application.

I visited a few others and put one that is a 7 minute drive away in the next village as first choice, at the time it was in special measures and had a new head teacher. I loved the feel of it, the children were all happy and the head was amazing so I put that one and dd got in.

She's now in year 6 and it's a fabulous school, I can't think of a single bad thing and both dd's are exceeding expectations academically. It's since been rated as good and was very close to outstanding and I'm so glad I didn't let the 'requires improvement' rating put me off.

It's never been an issue to drive there and back, we set out at 8.30 and by the time we've driven there, parked and walked to the gate it's 8.45 so only a few minutes out of my day and worth it.

viques · 09/09/2023 19:30

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 17:07

Also, by ‘a drive away’ it’s only 5 minute drive on a good day, not including finding somewhere to park, or school traffic in the morning. But to walk it would be 25 mins. So I theory I could probably bus there with DS in the morning and walk hole by myself. I’m luckily not pushed for time in the mornings as I work later in the day, and part time. The days I can’t pick up, it would be my DM who would also have the time as she is off. DH would only have to do one school pick up and drop off

Which is a good plan, but as we all know plans don’t always work out.

Think of the days when the traffic is awful and the bus journey takes twice as long as usual, the snowy and rainy days when you have to walk home for over half an hour, the days when you are needed in work early,the days when you realise you have forgotten the packed lunch, the pe kit, the homework, the violin, the days when your regular pick up wants to go out for the day or has flu, the days when the school phones and says your child has a fever, or has thrown up and you need to collect them……. Or if you decide you want to have another child and up doing the journey with a bump, sickness, a buggy……

then rinse and repeat for 7 years!

The really great thing about local round the corner schools is that you can build up a support network of reciprocating parents who can help out with emergencies.

just a thought.😊

usererror99 · 09/09/2023 19:26

My dd went to a primary school that was amazing for sen children but absolutely shit for the more able students. You really need to judge the individual school for your own child.

Also this. I'll get flamed for saying it but it was obvious one of the schools in my catchment was well regarded for SEN support and had an above average number of pupils with SEN. When I compared statistics for schools it was one of the reasons I didn't put it first choice for my child. It was an ofsted outstanding and very fought over by parents out of catchment to get a place there.

APurpleSquirrel · 09/09/2023 19:25

My DC don't go to our closest primary. We visited it & hated it. DC go to the next closest, but it's semi rural so we have to drive (otherwise it's walking along a busy A road, across fields or on country lanes with no pavement. We're lucky in that the school is located opposite the village car park, so parking isn't an issue.
If someone asked me about DCs school I'd say it was fantastic. It has its cons, but the pro's outweigh them. So if parents are saying it's fine, its obviously not amazing.
Definitely visit them all. I'd advise arranging to visit on a normal day if you can - then you'll see a bit of reality, not a sanitised open day version.

PeggyPiglet · 09/09/2023 19:21

I'll also add that lots of parents drive to school even if they're two streets away, because they're dashing off to work afterwards.
I do this with nursery sometimes because I don't have time to walk home and then get to work.

onlylovecanhurtlikethis · 09/09/2023 19:20

I think ofsted ratings are a crock of shit - outstanding schools don't get visited for years after getting that rating. I chose a "good" school over an "outstanding" one - honestly the one we chose had a much better feel about it - the outstanding one sure had the latest gadgets and glitzy and expensive looking and my daughters looked a little tired around the edges but it had a much nicer welcoming feel - when we we visited we were shown around by a pupil. When we went to look at the outstanding one we were given a map and waved off. Very corporate and not welcoming.

I do personally think parents shouldn't be able to apply out of catchment and should go to the most local school to them

PeggyPiglet · 09/09/2023 19:19

kitsuneghost · 09/09/2023 19:12

Perhaps if all kids went to their nearest school the parking at schools and traffic at school hours and children inhaling exhaust fumes wouldn't be as much of an issue.

Depends. The small village schools are a nightmare because alot of the kids come from smaller nearby villages which don't have schools., so have to drive.

You're basically screwed if you want to live in a small, picturesque village.

No primary school in my village. Nearest one is 5 minutes drive.

I don't really understand why people don't just park somewhere 5-10 mins walk away, then walk. It would save hassle trying to park next to the school.
You can also drop your child off at a friend's house so they can walk together when older.

PuttingDownRoots · 09/09/2023 19:19

Re catchment areas... People use "catchment area" to mean two different things.

Some areas have fixed zones, within which children get priority. These zones can be odd shaped.

Other areas just use distance, and catchment just means the area in which children normally get a place.

kitsuneghost · 09/09/2023 19:12

Perhaps if all kids went to their nearest school the parking at schools and traffic at school hours and children inhaling exhaust fumes wouldn't be as much of an issue.

BusyBees1234 · 09/09/2023 19:04

We only applied to the schools that matched our needs (after school club)

We didn't apply to the only school in our catchment as it didn't have an ASC

We got our first choice which also happens to be the closest school but isn't in our catchment!

All three we applied for were out of our catchment but all three had ASC

Catchment areas can be strange, the nearest school (0.4 mile) isn't in our's

TaraRhu · 09/09/2023 19:03

Don't underestimate the convenience of round the corner. We had a similar dilemma. Convenience won and no I'm ' in it' I'm so glad we went for his school and not the 'outstanding' one a mile away. Ofsted isn't everything. Our school is 'good' but I've been super impressed with it.

dressedforcomfort · 09/09/2023 19:02

Speaking as a former Primary governor, you need to definitely visit both schools and see for yourself. All schools are very individual and suit different types of kids/families. You can pick up a good vibe for a school by talking to the staff. (I ruled out one school for my DS pretty quickly because the attitude of the Head towards DS's SEND needs was appalling.) I ruled out another because the class set up (mixed age groups) wouldn't have worked for my kid.

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 18:58

JanesBlond · 09/09/2023 18:33

That just sounds like walking distance to me 🤷‍♀️ especially as you’ve said you’re not pressed for time

I’m not pressed for time on the way back. The thought of having to getting up extra early to allow him time to walk doesn’t fill me with joy 🙈🤣

OP posts:
Balloonsandroses · 09/09/2023 18:38

It’s worth thinking about how the practicalities will work if things go wrong. My daughter goes to school a drive away because they had before and after school club provision when the village school didn’t and we both worked. Unfortunately since then I’ve become unwell, unable to work and not allowed to drive according to dvla guidelines so the school run is now a nightmare and I desperately wish she was at the school in walking distance.

Seashellies · 09/09/2023 18:38

We chose a school that was a short drive away because it had a better reputation, we switched to the closer walkable one for year 1 and I don't regret it for one second. Honestly unless a school is absolutely awful different settings suit different children better so it's worth looking at a few; but for us a few minutes walk plus having wraparound care was the best choice. Days me and/or DH haven't felt great it's been a nice easy walk for drop off, when we have had to rush back for work it's nice as simple, when the weather is crap its not been an issue and it was good for DS to walk with his friends in year 6.

UsingChangeofName · 09/09/2023 18:35

Like most, I wouldn't use distance alone as the sole criteria, but I would emphasize to you it is a BIG factor.
Remember this isn't for a few weeks, or months or even a year, this is for 7 years (if you have an only, a lot more if you have other dc). It is SUCH a bonus to live close by on so many occasions over that time.
Also don't take any notice of "what people say on Facebook". Honestly, I see people asking on FB for my line of work, and there is no correlation between the positive comments and the quality of the service they are asking about. If you have opinions from people you know and value, that might be different, although it is human nature to "justify" your choice.

As everyone has said - go and visit. See what you feel, but do factor in the convenience of a school that is close.

JanesBlond · 09/09/2023 18:33

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 18:19

It would be a 25mins walk for me (according to google) but in the mornings when DS is walking it would probably be more like 35mins

That just sounds like walking distance to me 🤷‍♀️ especially as you’ve said you’re not pressed for time

Bluevelvetsofa · 09/09/2023 18:25

The most important thing is to visit the schools and see what their ethos is and how you feel about it seeing the teachers and the head. Ask if you can visit during the school day too, so you can see how they function.

As well as admission criteria which can change year on year, remember that you aren’t choosing a school for your child, you’re expressing a preference for one over another. The criteria of ‘better’ school will depend very much on what you prioritise. For some, it will be academic rigour, for others, a nurturing community and pastoral care will be of great importance.

cansu · 09/09/2023 18:23

I think your husband is right. With every school there will be people who are happy, people who thinks it's OK and those who rant and rave. Ofsteds change quickly. Staff change and this can also make a huge difference. Your child will need local friends. You will soon get sick of travelling. What happens if your mum can't do pick up in a year's time or your hours change? What about parties? You should also consider that you won't get in. Would you get into the secondary close to this school? If not your dc may be upset that all his friends will but not him as he lives too far away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread