Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not send child to a school just because it’s close

137 replies

CCW14 · 09/09/2023 16:50

i will be starting to look for a primary school soon for DS to start Reception next Sept. We have a primary school that is round the corner from us, less than a minute walk which DH says we should send DS to because its close, but even though it is ofsted rated Good, whenever I speak to other parents or the local Fb group, they all say ‘It’s fine’ or ‘It’s okay’. Isn’t that code for its not great but I don’t want to be rude? They also still have spaces for this september and have been advertising a lot that they have spaces open, where other schools all had theirs spaces filled

We have another school that is well recommended and about 15mins walk away so will probably put that as my first preference, but was thinking of putting a school that we would have to drive to as a second preference as they also seem highly recommended and have a good after school programme

Ds is very curious, loves learning and I have been told by nursery and others that he is very smart. I think we should send him to a better school as education takes priority over convenience, and I don’t want him to get bored at school if he is learning stuff he already knows. DH thinks convenience takes priority and primary school won’t make much difference

I will obviously visit all schools and have a look but think it’s quite hard to judge on an open day as everyone is on their best behaviour. And I know just because I put a school down, it doesn’t guarantee I will get a spot.

so what do you think?

YABU - Husband is right! Make your life easier and send him to the closer school
YANBU - Primary school is the foundation of learning and will have an impact on later education

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Seashellies · 10/09/2023 19:40

AlvaLane · 10/09/2023 18:51

@Seashellies @Onelifeonly Ofsted set out timings of inspection. There has been a change to inspect outstanding schools, but for a long time they were exempt.

Summer update.
https://educationinspection.blog.gov.uk/2023/06/12/when-will-my-school-be-inspected/

Ah thanks, knew the school wouldn't have been able to do anything to get around the inspections so figured some sort of exemption, seems better as so much can change in a decade! The school we chose for DS was 'good' but scored super well on the things we as parents were most interested in, I'd encourage people to read them if they're bothered at all by Ofsted ratings rather than just going by the overall grade.

DragonFly98 · 10/09/2023 14:44

If it's only a 25 minute walk can't you both just walk there and back ?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/09/2023 14:31

Yanbu

wherethedevildontgo · 10/09/2023 13:56

I don’t want him to get bored at school if he is learning stuff he already knows

I wouldn't worry about this. All schools follow the same curriculum. What matters is his peers and their attitude to learning. A lot of this is just down to luck, especially in one form entry schools (as they don't have the luxury of mixing classes to even out ability levels). I would worry if a school was in a rough area and most parents didn't seem to care much about their children's education but that doesn't sound like it will be the case for you.

Also factor in that your child will live close by to lots of their friends if you choose the one nearby. This is a really big plus IMO.

I have a 10 minute drive to school and I absolutely hate it, but I have another child plus work so depends on your circumstances. It's not just 10 minutes. It's over an hour per day once you've done it 4 times (there and back twice) plus factor in all the faffing about. Also find out about parking. Not too bad at my son's current one but at his first school you had to get there 10 minutes early in order to get a parking spot that was a 10 minute walk away. Just awful.

Thementalloadisreal · 10/09/2023 13:04

Have a look round them when you can and then decide which is a better fit. Parents have so many opinions, it’s best to form your own.
Also, I cannot overstate the value of being able to walk to school. It makes the day so much less stressful. We walk 15 mins every day and it’s really great, we can chat, decompress after a busy day, no stress over parking (which is usually horrendous around schools!)
Plus having a close community and very local friends is great for kids, and parents, for play dates etc.

ColleenDonaghy · 10/09/2023 13:00

It is lovely to be at a local school - we pass the door of my DD's best friend on the way to school, and another one's road and at least two more walk past our road. It's a really nice sense of community, especially for us since we're not from the area.

Guiltridden12345 · 10/09/2023 12:54

dinmin · 09/09/2023 17:02

Read the actual reports, don’t just look at the ratings. And consider how old they are.

Actually look round the schools!

I honestly think there’s a lot to be said for having friends nearby at primary age.

This - last sentence.

primary school is not rocket science. they are rarely staffed by academic high hitters even at outstanding schools. Their jobs are to nurture and develop, protect and encourage, in accordance with a fairly pedestrian national curriculum. The main decider of a child’s outcome is home life/input. Send him round the corner with local friends and short commute. He’ll be able to get up later and sleep well. He’ll be able to play after school with buddies without needing lifts. Be an inquisitive household if you aren’t already - watch and talk about the news, current affairs, world issues, geography history yada yada. That’s way more important to intellectual curiosity than a primary school with a box ticked outstanding ofsted from 8 years ago.

Onelifeonly · 10/09/2023 12:46

Seashellies · 10/09/2023 10:18

I don't understand when a school is rather outstanding that they then don't have an inspection for years and years? One around here hasn't had one for over a decade, I expect tonnes of the staff has changed as well as other aspects they're marked on?

I don't either. A lot of recent OFSTED have downgraded many to good and some to requiring improvement.

TheGoogleMum · 10/09/2023 11:30

We had to enroll DD in a further away school because of lack of wraparound provision in nearest ones. It helps it seems a little better based on now very out of date performance data

AlvaLane · 10/09/2023 11:25

Monster80 · 09/09/2023 17:38

We didn’t go for the primary school on our doorstep (religious). DC and I walk 12 minutes to a wonderful school, the other school was a 3 min walk. I think walking chills kids out and gets them ready for the day, same for end of the day, we use as an unwind session and talk about what’s happened while we have been apart. I would prioritise setting over location; but longer than a 20 min journey could be annoying for you all.

I agree. When I look back, I have fond memories of the school walk home.

In the summer, buying an ice-cream, calling at the park to play, in the autumn collecting conkers. New to an area my long term friends are these same parents.
My DC’s also loved the independence it gave them in being able to walk to and from.

Seashellies · 10/09/2023 10:21

Rated*

Seashellies · 10/09/2023 10:18

I don't understand when a school is rather outstanding that they then don't have an inspection for years and years? One around here hasn't had one for over a decade, I expect tonnes of the staff has changed as well as other aspects they're marked on?

Onelifeonly · 10/09/2023 10:07

Most schools are rated 'good ' these days as schools have worked out the expectations to get that. Few are outstanding and really the difference is minuscule and not easy to define. My kids' primary achieved outstanding and the head himself told me it was the luck of the draw on the day.

I work in a primary school and our head doesn't want us to be outstanding as it's a poisoned chalice in some ways. Good is good enough. But every school is different, so visits are a must.

I agree with many others that local is best. You have a minimum of 7 years in going to this school - and that includes for parents evenings, meetings and community events. Walking locally means you regularly see other families and get to know a lot of local people. Party venues are usually in the neighbourhood too - other parents can help facilitate pick ups and drops offs to those. If there are after school intetest clubs and you have a second child, going twice to pick up within the hour is no fun if it's a long walk (ours was only 10 minutes and I still just waited in the park or the library sometimes as they were closer than our house).

Wrap around care is helpful too if your working hours change. My Dh worked away from home on occasion and the school allowed last minute bookings of the breakfast club, which we didn't usually use, which meant I could drop them off and still get to work on time.

The ASC was until 6pm. My Dh worked from home so he usually collected them but, if he couldnt, I had time to drive home from work to collect them. In fact I'd say the ASC, which was well run and the kids loved, and much cheaper than a childminder, was a major plus for us (though it didn't exist when our first started there.)

Fallenangelofthenorth · 10/09/2023 09:37

You've got to bare in mind that schools with higher exam results/Sat's scores attract parents who perhaps value education more and are more likely to pay for extra tuition. My eldest two went to a school like this, but I didn't find the school did much at all with my daughter with Dyslexia, Dyspraxia and Discalculia. It was me who paid for 4 years of private maths and dyslexia tutoring. Me who did toe by toe every evening, helped with the extra homework, extra reading. Plus my daughters hard work of course.

My youngest went to a "lower performing" school which I actually much preferred.

I'd look around all the schools and get a proper feel for them rather than just look at league tables.

ColleenDonaghy · 10/09/2023 09:29

The lukewarm parent feedback would concern me more than anything.

Fifteen minutes walk is fine, we're that far from our closest school. Personally, I'd be considering that over the further school.

I know I'll probably get flamed, but I'm quite surprised that his dad has no intention of getting involved in that decision, and I suspect that probably is a bigger factor in a child's future success than a choice of primary school or being thought of as bright (which I think has zero correlation with future success).

mrsed1987 · 10/09/2023 09:18

I didn't put our closest school as an option at all. I'd suggest do the open days and then the one you like the most start asking around for opinions.

Flo84 · 10/09/2023 08:57

The school closest to me is an 8 minute walk and I put it last on my list due to being an infant school and not as good as others in the area but I had to put it on as it is our catchment school. I wanted my son in a primary school so put two primary schools that are both a 20 minute walk (25/30 with my 4 year old) as preference 1 and 2 and both of of it catchment area. We got our second preference. We don't mind walking and I don't have to worry about him having to move when he becomes a junior.

Reugny · 10/09/2023 08:43

onlylovecanhurtlikethis · 09/09/2023 19:20

I think ofsted ratings are a crock of shit - outstanding schools don't get visited for years after getting that rating. I chose a "good" school over an "outstanding" one - honestly the one we chose had a much better feel about it - the outstanding one sure had the latest gadgets and glitzy and expensive looking and my daughters looked a little tired around the edges but it had a much nicer welcoming feel - when we we visited we were shown around by a pupil. When we went to look at the outstanding one we were given a map and waved off. Very corporate and not welcoming.

I do personally think parents shouldn't be able to apply out of catchment and should go to the most local school to them

Were I am we don't have catchments we do it by distance.

Even then due to where the schools are there is an overlap. So on one street you can see children who live within 10 houses of one another going to 3 different primary schools as two are next to each other in one direction and the other is the same distance in the other direction. Then we have the overflow school which unless your child has SEN they will get into if they can't get into any other school or end up having to move schools.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 10/09/2023 00:04

yoshiblue · 09/09/2023 17:06

We're nearly at the end of primary for our only child and tbh I think primary schools are much of a muchness. I see secondary schools differentiate much more and I'm keen to prioritise a couple of schools that are further away but much better for results and other reasons like sports facilities and ethos. There are major differences here that justify travelling, facilities/primary results are generally similar across our local primary schools.

Personally I would choose your preferences between ones that are walkable if possible. Remember he will be close to his school friends for parties/playdates and can walk to school himself and gain independence when the time comes.

Agreed. Unless it’s an absolute shithole school it will be fine. Mine are now near the end of secondary and the primary they went to has no relevance to anything now.

Plus schools and their leadership and perception about which is “best” can change a lot in the 7 years your kids are there.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 09/09/2023 23:55

Jesus it’s only a primary school. It’s a bit of an assumption that he’s going to get “bored” when he hasn’t even started school and there will be plenty of other kids equally if not smarter than your kid there, which I am sure the teachers in a good school will be used to dealing with. I’d send him to the nearest school and be done with it. Certainly wouldn’t be arsed with the fuckery of driving past it for 15 mins to go somewhere else that’s unlikely to be much if any better.

Silveroriole · 09/09/2023 23:49

Stay close and local..
Nobody realises how much time and effort the school run takes until they do it day after day, term after term, year after year.
Also you may have another baby who will have to be put in and out of the car seat eight times a day (can't be left in a parked car outside the school).

Vettrianofan · 09/09/2023 20:40

If you have a bright child he will be able to settle anywhere. I would actually argue getting secondary choice right first time is much more important.

Vettrianofan · 09/09/2023 20:38

Sigmama · 09/09/2023 17:06

The thought of putting kids in a car every morning is my idea of hell

Same. Our DC have all went to the local primary a two minute walk from the front door. Children from more affluent areas come to the school so it can't be that bad. Also think of their friendships in nearby streets. Handy for the summer holidays.

Lelophants · 09/09/2023 20:33

15 mins walk is still pretty good so I’d put that first if it’s your preference. Definitely do open days! You may be surprised. You might get a totally different feel.