Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two minds school shoes. Vivienne's

114 replies

Eddyraisins · 08/09/2023 22:00

metro.co.uk/2023/09/06/girl-sent-home-from-school-for-wearing-vivienne-westwood-shoes-19456363/amp/

I am in two minds about this. Speaking from the experience of a teacher with a y11 in my school. My school would not care. All they care about is pupils actually wear shoes. We have a fair few pupils in Viviennes. I would not have known what they are if I didn't have a child in y11.

However I do see the argument that a lot of parents cannot afford £100 on shoes. I guess it's like the kickers of the 90s.

For PE lessons we can't discriminate and dictate labels for trainers.

I am not sure what to think. My dd would like some Viviennes. She is Asd and Adhd and has missed a lot of y10. My school allows them.

Should they? Is the school in the linked article too far or is it fair? I could be persuaded either way.

OP posts:
UpendedPineapple · 09/09/2023 00:16

I'm sorry, Nike Airs for PE?! You're an absolute fool.

It's not about money for me - it's reasonableness. My Dc have Nike airs at home. They do not have them at school to wear two hours a week as they know it's not reasonable. And the kids that do either have parents who can't say no or/and parents who can't really afford them but are determined to spend bizarre amounts on footwear.

Ella31 · 09/09/2023 00:07

As a teacher I can understand the uniform policy, I did find the punishment strange though, removal from class and isolation.......in my school, there's a warning system in place, this seemed ott.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 23:57

My kids school actually names these shoes in their policy
Day one, their tutor did a "unform standards" talk and said "so if you insist on wearing these, please don't make your parents buy the branded ones, it's ridiculous money. Just get the knock offs instead"

So they clearly don't enforce their own policies!

DoItAgainPlz · 08/09/2023 23:57

Discussions about these horrible shoes just cheapens the very valid and important concerns raised by the standards of uniform demanded in general.

I fully support schools having a uniform. But it needs to be practical, comfortable, replaceable and affordable.

Too many schools impose ludicrous regulations where they measure the length of a child's hair (either too short or too long), put kids in isolation because they wear navy socks instead of black, or charcoal trousers instead of dark grey.

Others insist on every item being embroidered, on multiple pairs of trainers for PE and only allow black coats in the winter - a great idea when its dark at 4pm when kids are walking home.

These demands really ought to be curbed.

But complaining about a very expensive pair of designer flats with a prominent logo is just vanity.

If they were complaining about the soles of a student's shoes having a bit of colour underneath them, or a tiny Kickers tag, then yeah, I'd be pissed off. But thats not what's happening here.

Vitriolinsanity · 08/09/2023 23:52

This sort of shit drives me doollally.

The parents have presumably selected the school and one of the very, very easy to understand is the uniform code.

Wilfully deciding to not follow a very simple requirement, and in a world where there are hundreds of black shoe options, is just asking for a shit load of completely avoidable aggro.

Those particular shoes are a completely unnecessary purchase. The only people at fault are the parents that bought them, and having Insta'd their child's first day sent them in for an inevitable and totally avoidable consequence.

BathingBeauty · 08/09/2023 23:48

There is zero reason for them except to stand out. It’s not like they are the only shoes in the shop. Even my fairly lax school uniform of the 80e wouldnt have allowed them.
ive worked in schools where the staff have a dress code too. The HT would tell you the point is to prepare the students for work life, which is kinda true. DH had a professional job and has a dress code, some for safety reasons.
Although I still think polyester blazers in summer are ridiculous.

GriseldaChop · 08/09/2023 23:39

I just don't understand how parents can't follow the rules! The uniform policy seems to be very clearly laid out and I'm sure it wasn't changed the day before they went back!
I understand 'shoes don't affect your education' blah blah, but surely it is about following a rule and encouraging your child to respect that.
If you work in asda and your uniform is a green polo shirt you can't turn up in something else you prefer, it just wouldn't happen. Why should school be any different?!

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 08/09/2023 23:38

There are plenty of stupid and unreasonable rules for uniform, this is not one of them.

maddening · 08/09/2023 23:29

Zoflorabore · 08/09/2023 23:12

Dd is in year 8 and her school has a very strict uniform policy to the point they have weekly inspections including their pencil cases/equipment and are only allowed a school backpack.

Dd chose Doc Marten patent Mary Jane’s for year 7 which cost £89 and were pretty immaculate when she broke up for the summer but her feet grew from a 5 to a 6. This was the first time she’s got through a school year in one pair of shoes.

For year 8 we left it quite late to get shoes and the Doc’s she wanted had sold out everywhere and were £124. School shoes are not cheap!
she picked a lovely pair of Kickers instead which cost £85 and with her Air Force one’s for PE we spent £155 on footwear.

Vivi’s are lovely but not at all practical for school and are banned in dd’s school but her best friend turned up on Tuesday with them on ( genuine ones ) and isn’t the only one apparently. The issue is with the orb, not with the shoes so much.

The same school then asks for donations for second hand uniform for families that are struggling but is so precise and insistent on what the kids can have and wear. They can’t wear earrings and have to have a certain colour hair bobble/ribbon. Is this really that important?

sorry for essay, am confused now on what I think is right and wrong!

"They can’t wear earrings and have to have a certain colour hair bobble/ribbon. Is this really that important "

In that case if it is so unimportant take off the jewellery and get a black bobble.

maddening · 08/09/2023 23:28

My sons school was also in the news for similar arguments around shoes and uniform - all the parents arguing about it are stressed out that tarquin can't wear £115 airforce ones - fuck all do with being able to afford shoes (and the school have made it clear they will help students who cannot afford uniform and shoes). It is cheaper to just buy plain black shoes ffs - all the parents are doing is undermining the school, giving a.shit lesson to their kids and what a hill to die on - just wear the uniform -sometimes in life you can't tantrum like a fucking toddler over clothes.

The school also made it clear that parents of dc that require reasonable adjustments should get in touch and in the hot weather allow the dc to wear pe kit
The parents here are acting like brats!

maddening · 08/09/2023 23:17

You can have the Viviennes for own wear and a cheap pair of shoes for school - if you have £100 to fling around on ballet pumps then you can have both.

£100 on shoes that will get fucked by everyday wear seems daft.

Zoflorabore · 08/09/2023 23:12

Dd is in year 8 and her school has a very strict uniform policy to the point they have weekly inspections including their pencil cases/equipment and are only allowed a school backpack.

Dd chose Doc Marten patent Mary Jane’s for year 7 which cost £89 and were pretty immaculate when she broke up for the summer but her feet grew from a 5 to a 6. This was the first time she’s got through a school year in one pair of shoes.

For year 8 we left it quite late to get shoes and the Doc’s she wanted had sold out everywhere and were £124. School shoes are not cheap!
she picked a lovely pair of Kickers instead which cost £85 and with her Air Force one’s for PE we spent £155 on footwear.

Vivi’s are lovely but not at all practical for school and are banned in dd’s school but her best friend turned up on Tuesday with them on ( genuine ones ) and isn’t the only one apparently. The issue is with the orb, not with the shoes so much.

The same school then asks for donations for second hand uniform for families that are struggling but is so precise and insistent on what the kids can have and wear. They can’t wear earrings and have to have a certain colour hair bobble/ribbon. Is this really that important?

sorry for essay, am confused now on what I think is right and wrong!

Netflixninnie · 08/09/2023 23:06

Sigmama · 08/09/2023 22:58

It's massively wanky, what sort of adult is that kid going to grow up to be

Agreed. Shoes seem to be more important to this family than education. Says a lot.

the uniform said brogues, as did my kids school. My kids both got start rite brogues for £50 each. They may not be to the child’s fashion tastes, but they fit the bill, are designed for kids feet, and are adequate for jogging around the playground in.

Septemberdaysarehere · 08/09/2023 23:05

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 22:34

There is already a very long thread on this.

My opinion is, if a school has a policy they should enforce it. Parents should accept the policy as part of the act of selecting schools. Don't like it? Don't put that school on your form. Get allocated that school? Follow the policy.

I'm not against campaigning for change, but actively defying policy then running to the press, stressing your 11/12yo during an already stressful process is not the solution.

This and also the parents are telling porkies - kid was year 11 and knew the rules and the parent ranting about the cost - £35 m and a or Charles - done

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 08/09/2023 23:03

OMG, just leave them too it. They have shoes on their feet, who cares. If it's not shoes they will find ways to show their individuality (or not) - coats, hair, piercings, tattoos.....

MinnieMouse0 · 08/09/2023 23:02

https://www.gracecollege.org.uk/student-and-parent-hub/academy-uniform/year-7-11-day-wear-uniform/

Here is the uniform policy. In addition to the branding, the school requires the top of the foot to be fully covered by the shoe. I think a lot of people have missed this in the pile on..

You are being redirected...

https://www.gracecollege.org.uk/student-and-parent-hub/academy-uniform/year-7-11-day-wear-uniform/

Chocolatesandroses · 08/09/2023 23:02

I know it isn’t the point of this thread but I don’t like them . I just don’t think they look nice at all .

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 23:02

Sorry just saw - three pairs of trainers!

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 23:01

sleepyscientist · 08/09/2023 22:55

@LittleBearPad flannels is quite good for shoes, it has better sales than DS favourite JD.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz how long do you expect shoes to last? DS has just gone up a size so picked Nike Huarches (£120), air force ones (£80), Nike all blacks for school (£70), his crocs still fit. School shoes were footasylum and around £70 so not much cheaper than the Vivs.

Why does he need two pairs of trainers though? Why can't the ones for school also be the ones he wears at weekends? 120quid on a pair of weekend trainers is obscene.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 23:00

sleepyscientist · 08/09/2023 22:55

@LittleBearPad flannels is quite good for shoes, it has better sales than DS favourite JD.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz how long do you expect shoes to last? DS has just gone up a size so picked Nike Huarches (£120), air force ones (£80), Nike all blacks for school (£70), his crocs still fit. School shoes were footasylum and around £70 so not much cheaper than the Vivs.

Once they've stopped growing, I'd expect them to last til they fell apart. Year seven I don't anticipate them lasting longer than the school year. £100 for a pair of shoes is only palatable when you know they won't ever be outgrown. It's unaffordable for most.

I booked at the £60 Geox shoes my Y7 chose. But at least they look supportive and robust and cover most of her foot so good in all weather's. But it's painful to know that she will outgrow them before they ever wear out.

Sigmama · 08/09/2023 22:58

It's massively wanky, what sort of adult is that kid going to grow up to be

Movingandlooking · 08/09/2023 22:58

Regardless as to whether they are viviennes or ben and Jerry's. They just aren't suitable for school and will get ruined and will be awful when it rains.

GuardiansPlayList · 08/09/2023 22:57

sleepyscientist · 08/09/2023 22:32

I'm 33 and we were wearing similar pumps without issue. £100 is relatively cheap for a pair of shoes that last ages, similar approved shoes that kids like will be £100+.

If the vivs are banned they will just find another shoe to all wear like the black and white Nikes. Something like

www.flannels.com/hugo-kris-moccasins-240818#colcode=24081803

I am shocked that anyone thinks £100 is “relatively cheap”. £100 is crazily expensive for a pair of school shoes. Some people must be made of money.

sleepyscientist · 08/09/2023 22:55

@LittleBearPad flannels is quite good for shoes, it has better sales than DS favourite JD.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz how long do you expect shoes to last? DS has just gone up a size so picked Nike Huarches (£120), air force ones (£80), Nike all blacks for school (£70), his crocs still fit. School shoes were footasylum and around £70 so not much cheaper than the Vivs.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 22:43

Schools are public institutions. Their policies should be the matter of a public debate and arranged with the parents of the school, not a 'take it or leave it

I agree. But using your child as a puppet to contest them is cruel imo.

I bet not a single one of these parents have done any separate campaigning to their MPs about uniform policies.

There is also a non-uniform school just up the hill from this particular secondary - I'd bet a hundred quid not a single parent put that non uniform school down in their options.