Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two minds school shoes. Vivienne's

114 replies

Eddyraisins · 08/09/2023 22:00

metro.co.uk/2023/09/06/girl-sent-home-from-school-for-wearing-vivienne-westwood-shoes-19456363/amp/

I am in two minds about this. Speaking from the experience of a teacher with a y11 in my school. My school would not care. All they care about is pupils actually wear shoes. We have a fair few pupils in Viviennes. I would not have known what they are if I didn't have a child in y11.

However I do see the argument that a lot of parents cannot afford £100 on shoes. I guess it's like the kickers of the 90s.

For PE lessons we can't discriminate and dictate labels for trainers.

I am not sure what to think. My dd would like some Viviennes. She is Asd and Adhd and has missed a lot of y10. My school allows them.

Should they? Is the school in the linked article too far or is it fair? I could be persuaded either way.

OP posts:
DistantSkye · 09/09/2023 20:36

I commented on the last thread about this, and granted I'm in Scotland and not originally from the UK so I don't really get it, but why can't kids just wear stuff like trainers to school?

I ask this on every thread and noone ever answers. Countless posts about no logos preventing bullying but I grew up in Spain where we generally don't have uniform. I live and teach in Scotland (where there is dress codes but not insane prescriptive ones like England). As far as I am aware uniform has not magically solved bullying.

So my question is the same - everyone that keeps going on about no logos/super strict uniform reducing bullying, what do you think other countries do? Do you honestly think England is just...better somehow because of this?

And even if it is, how do you make sure everyone has equal costing phones/coats/haircuts... Kids aren't stupid. They know there's a difference!

MimsyBorogroves · 09/09/2023 20:23

Ex pastoral lead here.

These shoes were a nightmare. Often rubbed, cause blisters so then the wearer "had" to come to school in trainers.

On busy staircases only took someone to catch the back of them with their foot and the wearer would be out of them and potentially stumbling down concrete stairs.

In rainy weather there would be wet feet. Late to lesson because they were "drying their feet" under the hand dryers. Or "couldn't" go to lesson because of wet feet, then parents complaining because we wouldn't let them go home to change their shoes. Or wouldn't let them wear the pair of non-policy fitting trainers that were always in their bags.

Etc.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 20:13

Eddyraisins · 09/09/2023 18:47

No way would we use acid if a molarity to scar at GCSE level.

We are told in CPD that if we sweat the small stuff like blazers in the corridors, nails and any other idea that doesn't really affect learning or health and safety. Then research shows that results improve.

If you sweat the small stuff the bigger things are easier school of thought.

Not looked into the study myselfor if indeed there is one. Maybe anecdotally.

I would imagine that if a study proves that being strict about uniform gets better results behaviourally or academically then it’s due to correlation rather than causation - ie a school that is really strict about uniform is likely to be really strict about everything else anyway (because what school does it the other way round?!). It often happens that a school introduces a new uniform policy, everything improves, and everyone thinks it’s due to the uniform…when actually the school introduced a new behaviour policy at the same time.

I did read a study once that “proved” that uniform was beneficial for pupils because it gave them a sense of belonging and pride in the school…it was funded by a company that made uniforms.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 19:56

NameOutTheBin · 09/09/2023 18:51

It sounds like a similar way of thinking to parenting. If you have a grip of discipline over the mundane bits of life - bedtimes, meal times, personal hygiene etc then it's easier to get a grip over the more rebellious stages. Put that into school terms of uniforms and it sort of makes sense.

But you often hear the opposite - that it’s better to pick your battles, because if you’re just as strict about the little things as you are about things like not running across roads then a) your child will never know which things actually matter and b) you’d be permanently exhausted…

(I’d argue that bedtimes, meal times and personal hygiene all have far greater consequences than uniform in any case though…)

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 19:53

We are told in CPD that if we sweat the small stuff like blazers in the corridors, nails and any other idea that doesn't really affect learning or health and safety. Then research shows that results improve.

If you don’t sweat the small stuff, or if you do? As in results improve if you do make a fuss over things that don’t affect health and safety?

DisquietintheRanks · 09/09/2023 18:51

@Eddyraisins this was A level and years ago. We used to play with mercury too.

Im pretty sure chemistry still allows burning things and boiling liquids, even at gcse. Tech certainly involves the use of sharp or heavy tools.

NameOutTheBin · 09/09/2023 18:51

It sounds like a similar way of thinking to parenting. If you have a grip of discipline over the mundane bits of life - bedtimes, meal times, personal hygiene etc then it's easier to get a grip over the more rebellious stages. Put that into school terms of uniforms and it sort of makes sense.

Eddyraisins · 09/09/2023 18:47

DisquietintheRanks · 09/09/2023 16:01

@sleepyscientist I'm guessing you are a grown up right? Schools have a duty to safeguard teenagers even if their parents are too fuckwitted to. I'm also guessing you are well trained in handling the chemicals you do.

A friend of mine has a 3 inch scar on the top of her foot from an acid burn she got in a chemistry class back in 1986. That wouldn't just be shrugged off these days.

No way would we use acid if a molarity to scar at GCSE level.

We are told in CPD that if we sweat the small stuff like blazers in the corridors, nails and any other idea that doesn't really affect learning or health and safety. Then research shows that results improve.

If you sweat the small stuff the bigger things are easier school of thought.

Not looked into the study myselfor if indeed there is one. Maybe anecdotally.

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 18:35

@DoItAgainPlz Talking of Covid… I remember absolutely despairing in the winter of 2020 when the SLT at my school sent an email round saying that lots of pupils were wearing hoodies because classrooms were colder with all the windows open and it was absolutely imperative that we didn’t let them.

It was 12 degrees in my classroom, everyone’s mental health was all over the place, and their biggest priority was not wearing hoodies.

I think there's a lack of emotional maturity in some who apply no critical thinking or sensibility, and just automatically assume that if something is within the rules it's good, and if not then there must be "some" reason for it and woe betide if you don't follow them.

There was a thread over the summer where someone was trying to start a philosophical discussion by asking whether the reason why we don’t steal stuff is because we empathise with the victim or because we don’t want to get caught. I would say 90% of the responses were just “neither of those, I don’t steal because it’s just wrong”. I was really surprised by how many people a) completely missed the point and b) just accepted that rules were rules and never thought about the reasons behind them.

DoItAgainPlz · 09/09/2023 18:10

IsitChristmasyet23 · 09/09/2023 18:07

The thing is - they are horrifically tacky.

If they weren't horrifcally tacky, the kids wouldn't want them!

IsitChristmasyet23 · 09/09/2023 18:07

The thing is - they are horrifically tacky.

DoItAgainPlz · 09/09/2023 17:32

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 01:13

Too many schools impose ludicrous regulations where they measure the length of a child's hair (either too short or too long), put kids in isolation because they wear navy socks instead of black, or charcoal trousers instead of dark grey.

Others insist on every item being embroidered, on multiple pairs of trainers for PE and only allow black coats in the winter - a great idea when its dark at 4pm when kids are walking home.

Plenty of people seem to be in favour of this though. You read these stories about kids spending a day in isolation because of the wrong sock colour and all the comments say “Quite right, rules are rules”. Absolutely baffles me how few people question how strict adherence to uniform impacts anyone’s learning or behaviour.

(It also absolutely baffles me how teachers have the time or the mental energy to be arguing with pupils about their socks or their backpacks anyway - I mean, they could be using that time to, I don’t know, teach…?)

Quite.

I used to know a man who used to work in a school, though he wasn't a teacher. He would say "there's no point in having rules if you're not going to make people follow them", and was absolutely, unquestionably in favour of any uniform policies the school had in place.

He was a complete wet blanket.

I think there's a lack of emotional maturity in some who apply no critical thinking or sensibility, and just automatically assume that if something is within the rules it's good, and if not then there must be "some" reason for it and woe betide if you don't follow them.

I have no doubt this man would have refused to allow the kids to have taken their blazers off in the recent heat, if he hadn't been explicitly given permission to.

It came to the forefront with covid, where some were wringing their hands over the miniature of the guidelines and would literally not leave their house for more than an hour a day.

x2boys · 09/09/2023 16:19

I don't why some schools have these daft rules but if you are going to.send your child to.a school.with such rules you should abide by them

DisquietintheRanks · 09/09/2023 16:01

@sleepyscientist I'm guessing you are a grown up right? Schools have a duty to safeguard teenagers even if their parents are too fuckwitted to. I'm also guessing you are well trained in handling the chemicals you do.

A friend of mine has a 3 inch scar on the top of her foot from an acid burn she got in a chemistry class back in 1986. That wouldn't just be shrugged off these days.

sleepyscientist · 09/09/2023 13:39

DisquietintheRanks · 09/09/2023 10:51

Sigh. Open top shoes are not safe for chemistry or for tech subjects. Are you really suggesting girls don't take these subjects if their parents can't be arsed to buy them the correct footwear? Or is this yet another thing schools should provide?

What if they are willing to take the risk? Health and safety has gone mad, I work in a lab with worse chemicals than what you play with in school. Yet for us pumps are fine. We aren't allowed sandals but if you asked any of the leadership team they would be happy to say at your own risk if they could.....and them wear as-well.

I'm the same scientist in my Pj's, sport wear, scrubs or a suit.

Oiyouoverthere · 09/09/2023 11:28

Most are fake - you get the for £10 in the corner shop around near my work (behind the counter, obviously). And teenagers are more about fashion over function!

neilyoungismyhero · 09/09/2023 11:01

I wore dark green DMs for my part time personal shopper job. They looked fine to me but was advised I had until next pay day to get a pair of black footwear. Company policy. I didn't argue I wore black DMs.

itsgettingweird · 09/09/2023 10:59

The only thing about the uniform that I agree with is the skirt.

If schools insist on dressing females up in typical men's office wear to "prepare them for the world of work" then it doesn't surprise me they get all stupid over shoes either.

The sooner schools go back to polos, open neck shirts, knitted or sweatshirt v necks and worrying about actual teaching and learning the better.

And I work in education!

DisquietintheRanks · 09/09/2023 10:51

Sigh. Open top shoes are not safe for chemistry or for tech subjects. Are you really suggesting girls don't take these subjects if their parents can't be arsed to buy them the correct footwear? Or is this yet another thing schools should provide?

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 10:49

DanceMumTaxi · 09/09/2023 10:43

The teachers are directed by SLT. I’m a year 11 form teacher. I’m directed by SLT what to check for during form time and send the child to the designated member of staff if their uniform doesn’t comply with expectations. If I don’t do this, and they’re picked up later in the day, SLT will know that I saw them in the morning but didn’t do my job of checking uniform. We are regularly reminded of this during morning briefing, so ultimately I’d end in trouble and I’m not prepared to do that.

As a form tutor, it’s absolutely not your fault if you correct their uniform at the start of the day and they mess it up again later, and your SLT should recognise that. Also, like you haven’t got enough to do without scrutinising every detail of what they’re all wearing…

CecilyP · 09/09/2023 10:47

DanceMumTaxi · 09/09/2023 10:43

The teachers are directed by SLT. I’m a year 11 form teacher. I’m directed by SLT what to check for during form time and send the child to the designated member of staff if their uniform doesn’t comply with expectations. If I don’t do this, and they’re picked up later in the day, SLT will know that I saw them in the morning but didn’t do my job of checking uniform. We are regularly reminded of this during morning briefing, so ultimately I’d end in trouble and I’m not prepared to do that.

It must be really hard to be caught in the middle of this. I do sympathise.

fireplacetiles · 09/09/2023 10:46

This school is near to where we live, it is run by an ultra conservative Christian group who have form for teaching creationism (but that's another story) but have very high exam results from their other schools. The uniform rules are very strict and part of the ethos which is basically conform and we will get you good exam results. There are other secondaries nearby so parents have made a choice to send them there, it's not hidden what they are and represent.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 10:45

jusdepamplemousse · 09/09/2023 10:37

Schools seriously need to just wise up and massively chill out about uniforms. It’s always struck me as bloody odd how invested some teachers are in policing it. What the hell does it actually matter what they’re wearing as long as it’s basically safe and appropriate? I remember being yelled at in the early noughties over some ridiculous infraction like wearing a jumper but not a blazer - like properly yelled at - and just thinking god you sad bastard. I was an intelligent and peaceful pupil and relatively well behaved. I still think that teacher was a sad bastard 🤣

I’m a teacher and I couldn’t agree with you more.

DanceMumTaxi · 09/09/2023 10:43

The teachers are directed by SLT. I’m a year 11 form teacher. I’m directed by SLT what to check for during form time and send the child to the designated member of staff if their uniform doesn’t comply with expectations. If I don’t do this, and they’re picked up later in the day, SLT will know that I saw them in the morning but didn’t do my job of checking uniform. We are regularly reminded of this during morning briefing, so ultimately I’d end in trouble and I’m not prepared to do that.

NameOutTheBin · 09/09/2023 10:40

Ballet pumps should be banned as school shoes. They're impractical and offer no support to growing feet and skeletons. I don't care if they're designer or not, they're shit.