Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two minds school shoes. Vivienne's

114 replies

Eddyraisins · 08/09/2023 22:00

metro.co.uk/2023/09/06/girl-sent-home-from-school-for-wearing-vivienne-westwood-shoes-19456363/amp/

I am in two minds about this. Speaking from the experience of a teacher with a y11 in my school. My school would not care. All they care about is pupils actually wear shoes. We have a fair few pupils in Viviennes. I would not have known what they are if I didn't have a child in y11.

However I do see the argument that a lot of parents cannot afford £100 on shoes. I guess it's like the kickers of the 90s.

For PE lessons we can't discriminate and dictate labels for trainers.

I am not sure what to think. My dd would like some Viviennes. She is Asd and Adhd and has missed a lot of y10. My school allows them.

Should they? Is the school in the linked article too far or is it fair? I could be persuaded either way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ZebraDanios · 16/09/2023 10:08

Redbrickrebel · 16/09/2023 08:07

Because the 'telling off' is nothing but a badge of honour for the child, whilst they still sneer and mock kids who do obey the uniform policy and who's family can't afford these Viviennes or £100+ trainers.

If that’s what’s happening, then you put that child in isolation/send them home/send a letter home from the Head for sneering and mocking - that actually affects other pupils.

Surely it‘s better to address the bullying than the perceived cause of the bullying - after all, kids are going to be picked on for a thousand other things that the school can’t do anything about.

Redbrickrebel · 16/09/2023 08:07

ZebraDanios · 10/09/2023 20:27

@DoItAgainPlz I do think that the reason these stories make headlines because of
parental outrage is mostly to do with the scale of the punishment. Which is why it annoys me when people say “the school is absolutely right, they’re there to learn” in response to a story about a school sending a child home over a minor uniform infraction. If they’re “there to learn” then why not just tell them off and then let them get on with learning?

Because the 'telling off' is nothing but a badge of honour for the child, whilst they still sneer and mock kids who do obey the uniform policy and who's family can't afford these Viviennes or £100+ trainers.

Redbrickrebel · 16/09/2023 08:03

Again, another bunch of parents in this thread not realising uniform rules are there to cut down on economic bullying and poor shaming amongst pupils.

If you want to spend hundreds of pounds on footwear for your child, make sure it meets school policy that is there for a bloody good reason, or let your child show off their stupidly expensive Nike trainers at weekends and in the evenings.

benoticanarsed · 16/09/2023 07:41

@ShellySarah @BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz
Do you have secondary age children?

What would you expect to pay for a pair of black trainers?

The decent ones that everyone is wearing such as Nike Air, Max Plus, 270s Huarache etc are all £120 plus.

ZebraDanios · 10/09/2023 20:27

@DoItAgainPlz I do think that the reason these stories make headlines because of
parental outrage is mostly to do with the scale of the punishment. Which is why it annoys me when people say “the school is absolutely right, they’re there to learn” in response to a story about a school sending a child home over a minor uniform infraction. If they’re “there to learn” then why not just tell them off and then let them get on with learning?

LolaSmiles · 10/09/2023 19:08

Michaela's approach isn't for everyone. It was certainly a trailblazer in challenging some of the low expectations that were present in schools.

Whether we would choose her approach for our own children or school to work at, I do think she needs to be given credit for saying what many people knew about the state of behaviour in many schools and then doing something practical about it.

From what I've seen Michaela has what some of the imitation chains don't: a culture of academic excellence and staff who genuinely care. Our local wannabe zero tolerance schools don't seem to have the level of pastoral care or the staff who value academics. They'd never have a Michaela style curriculum in a million years.

CecilyP · 10/09/2023 18:34

It’s seems to have been given the epithet, ‘the strictest school in London’ but if you read the requirements for schools in some of the academy chains, it has some very strong competition! It sounds more eccentric than anything.

Tinkerbyebye · 10/09/2023 18:32

Whatever you may think the child needs to be taught to follow rules. That’s the parents job and they should not be buying non uniform stuff

DoItAgainPlz · 10/09/2023 18:30

I think one of the reasons for a uniform is that it gives the kids something relatively minor to push back against, without having too much of an impact.

But that only works if the kids have some leeway, and the response to breaking these rules isn't on a par with more serious rule breaking.

In recent years, this balance has been lost completely.

What used to be a quick "fasten your top button, tuck your shirt in and pull your tie up" before sitting down at the start of an hour of English, is now being handed a detention with the head of year, a letter home and a possible being sent home.

DoItAgainPlz · 10/09/2023 18:22

Is Michaela actually a particularly special school?

Or is it just a token Tory talisman and an indulgant vanity project for the headteacher?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 10/09/2023 17:35

I suppose taking it to the very very extreme you end up with schools like Michaela which would not suit a lot of kids but works for others.

Tbf that school wouldn't suit me as staff either.Grin

Eddyraisins · 10/09/2023 13:15

ZebraDanios · 10/09/2023 01:01

I would really like someone to do a proper peer-reviewed study on whether uniform alone actually improves any measurable outcome - it seems like most of the studies that have been done on this have fallen short of proper research standards, or the results haven’t been reproduced in similar studies.

Interestingly one study I’ve come across found that pupils reported feeling less connected to their teachers and peers in schools with uniforms. As counter-intuitive as that feels, it totally fits with my own experience. It’s generally assumed that pupils who violate uniform codes are entitled troublemakers who are indulged by permissive parents; I was a model pupil but I deeply resented my school’s strict uniform policy and felt no pride in or connection to my school as a result. It’s not always the kids who just want to break the rules anyway who object to rules about uniform.

I suppose taking it to the very very extreme you end up with schools like Michaela which would not suit a lot of kids but works for others.

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 10/09/2023 01:01

I would really like someone to do a proper peer-reviewed study on whether uniform alone actually improves any measurable outcome - it seems like most of the studies that have been done on this have fallen short of proper research standards, or the results haven’t been reproduced in similar studies.

Interestingly one study I’ve come across found that pupils reported feeling less connected to their teachers and peers in schools with uniforms. As counter-intuitive as that feels, it totally fits with my own experience. It’s generally assumed that pupils who violate uniform codes are entitled troublemakers who are indulged by permissive parents; I was a model pupil but I deeply resented my school’s strict uniform policy and felt no pride in or connection to my school as a result. It’s not always the kids who just want to break the rules anyway who object to rules about uniform.

ell87 · 09/09/2023 23:57

They're hideous shoes my girls wouldn't be seen dead in them. I'm not a fan of clothing that's been overpriced just because they have a funky branded label.

NameOutTheBin · 09/09/2023 23:19

Have there been any studies about parental involvement and student success/behaviour? Or permissive parenting and behaviour at school? I feel if they were researched first there would then be an argument that there is no purpose to school uniform

DistantSkye · 09/09/2023 23:17

Eddyraisins · 09/09/2023 21:49

Yes apparently they improve. Well behaviour does so then results.

Like the zero tolerance police initiative in Middlesbrough years ago.

What research is this? I've been a teacher for 15 years and have never been told this in a CPD.

I wonder how the research accounts for all the countries that manage ok without spending hours telling children when they can and can't wear a jacket, or obsessing over trainers?

Kissmas · 09/09/2023 23:11

Can't imagine sending my 11 year old for their first day at high school, knowing full well that I'd ignored the uniform policy.

Talk about setting them up to fail. No fucking way were my kids going to be the ones held in the hall upset and nervous while their peers got to do all of the first day/week settling in over a pair of shoes.

Whether I agree with the policy or not is irrelevant.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 22:03

Eddyraisins · 09/09/2023 21:49

Yes apparently they improve. Well behaviour does so then results.

Like the zero tolerance police initiative in Middlesbrough years ago.

It’d be interesting to see if this was done in a controlled way - as in, did they compare schools that were really strict about the small stuff and also strict about important stuff with schools who were more lax with one or the other? Or is it just that a school that sweats the small stuff also sweats the big stuff by default, and that’s what has the improving effect?

Floopyfloop · 09/09/2023 21:53

I have been a massive fan of Vivienne Westwood for 30 years. I have a pair of the shoes in question and as lovely as they are they have not much support and they make my feet sweat! I didn’t even realise they were that in style 😆

Add opaque tights and you have a funky feet fest!

Eddyraisins · 09/09/2023 21:49

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 19:53

We are told in CPD that if we sweat the small stuff like blazers in the corridors, nails and any other idea that doesn't really affect learning or health and safety. Then research shows that results improve.

If you don’t sweat the small stuff, or if you do? As in results improve if you do make a fuss over things that don’t affect health and safety?

Edited

Yes apparently they improve. Well behaviour does so then results.

Like the zero tolerance police initiative in Middlesbrough years ago.

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 21:42

Aren’t the parents in these stories usually more annoyed about the disproportionate severity of the punishment than the fact that their child got in trouble? I think the girl in this story was made to sit on a floor for four hours then wasn’t allowed a drink at lunch or something, wasn’t she? And very often kids are put in isolation or sent home, which just seems entirely self-defeating. Why can’t the school just tell them to wear the right shoes tomorrow and get on with their day?

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 20:57

I may be wrong, but I strongly suspect that the parents who buy their 11 year old children expensive designer shoes that are outside the uniforms probably missed the memo about being the grown up, parenting involving boundaries and not giving in to whatever a child demands.

I wouldn’t buy my kids expensive designer stuff for school or otherwise. But I was pretty miffed when my very well-behaved, very hardworking daughter got a massive telling off for wearing a purple hair tie which I hadn’t noticed before she left for school and she didn’t know wasn’t allowed. I don’t doubt some rules are there for a good reason, but sometimes it’s just control-freakery.

LolaSmiles · 09/09/2023 20:50

It sounds like a similar way of thinking to parenting. If you have a grip of discipline over the mundane bits of life - bedtimes, meal times, personal hygiene etc then it's easier to get a grip over the more rebellious stages. Put that into school terms of uniforms and it sort of makes sense
Agree with this.

I may be wrong, but I strongly suspect that the parents who buy their 11 year old children expensive designer shoes that are outside the uniforms probably missed the memo about being the grown up, parenting involving boundaries and not giving in to whatever a child demands.

It's normal for secondary aged students to push at the rules. Twas ever thus.

We rolled our skirts and modified the uniform as students, were reminded what was expected, and then got on with life. It's an age old dance between students and teachers.

The new addition is that there's now a group of permissive parents who cave to their children's demands AND then get annoyed and have a tantrum when other adults don't facilitate a permissive approach.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 20:44

@DistantSkye Totally agree. No-one ever answers me either. Everyone talks as though relaxing dress codes in schools inevitably leads to the collapse of civilisation even though most of Europe seems to be totally fine without uniforms at all. And you’re absolutely right, kids will find something to pick on about someone, uniform or no uniform.

ZebraDanios · 09/09/2023 20:38

MimsyBorogroves · 09/09/2023 20:23

Ex pastoral lead here.

These shoes were a nightmare. Often rubbed, cause blisters so then the wearer "had" to come to school in trainers.

On busy staircases only took someone to catch the back of them with their foot and the wearer would be out of them and potentially stumbling down concrete stairs.

In rainy weather there would be wet feet. Late to lesson because they were "drying their feet" under the hand dryers. Or "couldn't" go to lesson because of wet feet, then parents complaining because we wouldn't let them go home to change their shoes. Or wouldn't let them wear the pair of non-policy fitting trainers that were always in their bags.

Etc.

Maybe if SLT explained the rationale behind uniform rules - like you have here - then there’d be less pushback?

As it is I regularly have pupils saying stuff like “if we can’t wear jewellery because of health and safety then why are we allowed to wear a necklace with a religious symbol on?” and “do you actually think I’ll learn better without eyeliner on?” and I can’t help thinking they have a point…

Swipe left for the next trending thread