Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is it so unfair - everything stacked against her?

458 replies

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 17:31

My DD is 18, almost 19, she is smart and funny, but sometimes I feel like she is fighting a losing battle, she had ADHD, has dyspraxia and is dyslexic. I love her to pieces but really she has no 'natural' talents, she isn't creative, not particularly academic, definitely not sporty. She did her a-Levels after getting pretty average GCSEs and got BCC, not enough to do the course she wanted at uni. She has no idea what she wants to do. To top it off, she is incredibly insecure, not massively overweight but not slim, and she would say she isn't pretty (I disagree of course). She's never really had any attention from boys and this upsets her, has one friend but she is going away for uni. We have decided DD will take a gap year, get a job in supermarket or similar and take time to figure out what is next. I should also say, I'm not a high earner nor is my DH, we live in a council house etc.
In contrast, I have one niece who is the same age as DD and sometimes I catch myself being envious of her and I know my DD is too, she is smart, got A/A* at A-level, going to her first choice uni. But on top of that she plays piano, is a pretty good singer, plays tennis well. Has won awards for all sorts, debating, maths, music, writing even art. She has always been the type of person who had everything come to her naturally. She is absolutely gorgeous (like even as her auntie I can appreciate is she above average on looks), had friends etc. she basically has been able to do whatever she wants. My sister and her husband divorced, but are both decent earners. own their homes, no mortgage (small northern town so not an expensive place to buy).
I find myself crying and frustrated, I feel like DD has everything stacked against while my niece has it comparatively easy. Like why is it so unfair? Why do some people seem to be given all the worlds gifts and others all the challenges. I know my niece isn't perfect and has had her struggles (perfectionist, anorexia, anxiety), but comparatively DD seems to have nothing in her favour!!!!

AIBU to be frustrated and envious? to be upset that DD seems to find everything a struggle? What do I do to stop feeling like this??

OP posts:
herewegoroundthebastardbush · 08/09/2023 19:37

I agree with others she needs to be supported to get out of her comfort zone - failure to launch is a real risk here, she could well still be loving at home in her thirties if she doesn't start at least being open to the idea of living outside the home for a while. You don't really want her living at home for good, do you? There isn't going to come some magical point where she is suddenly happy about the idea.

I think you should make supporting her through her gap year conditional on at least trying to do something which takes her out of the home for a period of time, like PGL or a summer camp scheme or something. She needs to build up her confidence. You say she is threatening to hurt herself if she has to leave home. But she is hurting herself by refusing to contemplate leaving, she is limiting her horizons to that of a child, resigning herself to half a life. You have to decide how serious you think she is about that Vs the consequences she will definitely suffer if she stays stuck like this. Has she ever gone away for anything (school trip abroad, girl guides camp, weekend with relatives, ANYTHING)? If not she has no idea how it will actually be, how she will feel. If she tries it and can't cope that's one thing; never even trying isn't really acceptable.

Honestly. I think some time away from home could be the making of her. Not least because she is living with the general attitude of "poor DD, she's so hopeless" and unspoken comparisons between her and her perfect cousin. Kids believe the stories we tell them about themselves. She will be picking up on your attitude towards her and making it her own. You need to believe in her, OP! You need to be the one who cheerleads for her, who celebrates her achievements, who opens doors for her, opens her mind to opportunities. Not the person who says "oh well you shouldn't even go to uni anyway since you don't even know what you want to do and couldn't get the grades, a supermarket's good enough for you". Honestly I can't ever imagine having the attitude you have towards my own child.

Onionsandplaydoh · 08/09/2023 19:36

"Nothing in her favour", whether comparatively or not, is a horrible thing to say.

NunsKnickers · 08/09/2023 19:36

Your DD must have been affected massively at the loss of her brother.

Has she had counselling?

PictureConsequences · 08/09/2023 19:36

BCC is not to be sniffed at! I agree with a gap year, could she travel?

Winederlust · 08/09/2023 19:34

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 17:47

It is so difficult as DD doesn't want to go away from home, she is shy and would struggle. She also doesn't really know what she wants to do so in some ways I'm glad she missed the uni opportunity as I don't think she was actually invested in it, more just applied as she felt like she had to.

I'm not going to comment on the comparison with your niece because PP have already said it all, but this post sounds very defeatist.
You're already writing her off going off and trying new things 'because she's shy' rather than gently encouraging her. You're happy she's not going to uni because of your own perceptions of how she'd cope.
I get you're worried about your daughter but it sounds like your own attitudes may be holding her back.

What was the uni course she'd applied for? Was it a subject she's genuinely interested in? Or is there something else she has an interest in which you can encourage her to get more into during a gap year...volunteering or something similar? Sounds like she needs encouragement to find/pursue something she can get passionate about.

Casiotoad · 08/09/2023 19:34

My original response might have come across a bit harsh in this respect, I just think that if we are getting the sense you can’t help comparing them
unfavourably I bet your daughter will pick up on that and it can be crippling. Worse still, she might think anorexia is a good solution to her weight issues…

(From a girl always compared to her supposedly smarter brother by her parents who would constantly tell me that he is naturally smart and I will always have to work harder to get the same results. However well intentioned I still resent this as an adult!)

porridgeisbae · 08/09/2023 19:34

I don't think BCC is all that bad at all @AllTheOdds . People are going to 'universities' not worthy of the name with very limited grades- she wouldn't be having to do that with those grades.

Shame she didn't feel ready to choose a different uni course yet- if she wants to do uni.

I hope she has a relaxing and inspiring year. x

MyEyesMyThighs · 08/09/2023 19:33

Part time in the supermarket and a variety of life experiences would help. If she doesn't like going, go with her or get one of her friends going.

Things like:

  • walk a neighbours dog
  • help with the gardening, growing vegetables
  • writing a funny blog about TV shows
Etc.
  • parkrun
  • listening to audiobooks

She doesn't have to quit things because she's not great at them or they are a bit hard. Once you are out of school, hobbies are for fun rather than grades/competition - it's like a weight lifted off them!

NunsKnickers · 08/09/2023 19:33

How about another year or two living at home studying something else? Such as a language, or coding, counselling, anything really. Local colleges offer courses plus there are loads online. She sounds like she needs more growing up time.

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 19:32

Sushiandunagi · 08/09/2023 19:28

FYI children are our mirror. What are you passionate about OP? Are you doing your favourite job? You’re fit and healthy? Perhaps you’re great at speaking other languages or playing piano? What can she learn from YOU? Are you the one to push past your comfort zone and find joy in the little things?

This is good point, I have a mundane life but I love it, I'm a TA at the same school I've worked at since I was 22 (28 years). I love it. DH is a bus driver. We are actively involved in our local community, organising events and love our garden and dogs. But we are happy. If DD wanted to do anything (be that working in a shop or a neuroscientist) and would be happy doing it I'd be over the moon. I just want her to be happy.

OP posts:
RamsesTheChub · 08/09/2023 19:32

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 19:28

@RamsesTheChub I'd love DD to try something like that, even if just as a hobby; but she doesn't seem overly interested. A family friend works in TV and she loves coming up with show ideas to send him but doesn't want to go down to London or Manchester to do any work experience with him.

For now, she doesn't have to. The technology is there for her (you both together, initially perhaps) to create something of her own. Nowadays many people in media/entertainment start out in their bedrooms. Make it your project for a while if you need to and ask for her help, then let her take control because she realises she's good at it?

Wasn't the Adam and Joe show born of just 2 silly teenagers in one of theirs' bedroom with a camcorder? 30+ years on, it can be done.

Pizzatrip · 08/09/2023 19:32

Have you looked at employer sponsored degree apprenticeships? I work for a water company and they provide everything from HR, to IT to civil engineering. Have a look at the local big companies and I imagine many will have similar schemes. She will get to earn whilst she learns (there will be no cost to her) and have industry experience on top of the degree when she finishes.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/09/2023 19:31

I’m so sorry for your loss- and hers - OP

Apologies, have read posts in a random order

Noicant · 08/09/2023 19:30

Has she ever had any sort of grief counselling? I’m so sorry for your loss, it must have been extremely traumatic for your daughter.

Her reaction to the idea of leaving is extreme and I would be seriously worried about an underlying mental health problem.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/09/2023 19:29

RamsesTheChub · 08/09/2023 19:26

Sounds like she's perfect for some sort of satirical TV/Radion/Podcast show about t.v. - even if it doesn't make her money, might bring her out of her shell.

Apologies if I'm mistaken, but you seem to only respond to suggestions that you can easily bat away.

She sounds a lot like my DS with ADHD in this later post - and I’d be delighted if he eventually got BCC at a level (he’s only 9 now so who knows what path he’ll take). Funny and kind aren’t to be sneezes at. He will also quote you whole TV show episodes…

EsmeSusanOgg · 08/09/2023 19:29

OnAMidnightTrainToGeorgia · 08/09/2023 17:40

She will come into her own

Could you find something better than retail for her gap year, it's honestly the most soul destroying environment

I'd suggest anything else but that!

Or work towards something? I finished uni a bit at sea, I worked part time in a supermarket whilst staying with my parents to save up and travel. I then spent a month solo traveling around Europe with an interracial ticket. It really helped with my confidence and understanding of the real world (sort of!) I wish I had done it before going to uni.

TripleDaisySummer · 08/09/2023 19:28

She isn't independent at all.

Well that what needs focus on - slow steps to get her independent - work should help there but lots of scaffolding also needs to be done - get her used to ideas of leaving - open days at uni - with those grades there will be options for her.

Sushiandunagi · 08/09/2023 19:28

FYI children are our mirror. What are you passionate about OP? Are you doing your favourite job? You’re fit and healthy? Perhaps you’re great at speaking other languages or playing piano? What can she learn from YOU? Are you the one to push past your comfort zone and find joy in the little things?

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 19:28

@RamsesTheChub I'd love DD to try something like that, even if just as a hobby; but she doesn't seem overly interested. A family friend works in TV and she loves coming up with show ideas to send him but doesn't want to go down to London or Manchester to do any work experience with him.

OP posts:
RamsesTheChub · 08/09/2023 19:27

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 19:25

She isn't independent at all.
She's been an 'only child' most of her life as our younger son passed away from cancer when he was 3 and DD was 7.

Bless you, that's terrible for you all. Seriously, you both need some help to raise the bar.

LoveItaly · 08/09/2023 19:27

I don’t usually comment on threads, but this one made me feel so angry I felt compelled to.
Your daughter, like many other people, has her personal struggles, but overall she has nothing standing in the way of her having a happy, fulfilling and successful life.
However, your causal disregard of the struggles of your niece (anorexia, perfectionism and anxiety), as though these are minor inconveniences in the grand scheme of things, shows a complete lack of understanding and empathy on your part. Had you experienced a close family member fight their way out of anorexia, deal with various accompanying conditions, and then work tirelessly to remain healthy on a hour by hour basis, perhaps you would be a little less envious.
That being said, I wish your daughter all the very best. Her A level grades are perfectly acceptable, and as others have said many young people take a while to work out what they want to do. Some kind of volunteering work alongside a gap year job will probably do wonders for her confidence, and help her make new friends.

Copperfoz · 08/09/2023 19:27

Sometimes I think we spend too much time worrying about what to do with our lives and worrying about what we don't have that we waste so much time and let it all pass by us and we don't embrace what we do have. That's not a slight at you by the way, as I include myself also.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/09/2023 19:27

Her A levels aren’t bad though! Really good in fact with those barriers to learning - sounds like she’s done brilliantly and could get a great place through clearing or reapply for next year.

My youngest brother got CCD in his a levels (compared to AAB and BBC for the other two of us). He earns by far the most out of the three of us and has a brilliant career, lives in California ans will be able to retire early very comfortably. I’ll be working til I’m 70 probably!

A level results aren’t the be all and end all

isadoradancing123 · 08/09/2023 19:26

Not much help but if she has got B C C in A levels with dysphraxia, adhd and dyslexia i think thats an amazing result

RamsesTheChub · 08/09/2023 19:26

AllTheOdds · 08/09/2023 19:17

As I've said she is funny, no one makes me laugh like she can. She is kind and helpful, her memory is great, she could tell you what happened in most episodes of her favourite shows off the top of her head. She is very very loving, truly sees the best in everyone she meets. I do love and adore my DD I think she is incredible.

Sounds like she's perfect for some sort of satirical TV/Radion/Podcast show about t.v. - even if it doesn't make her money, might bring her out of her shell.

Apologies if I'm mistaken, but you seem to only respond to suggestions that you can easily bat away.