Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cover babies pram with a muslin?

139 replies

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 16:33

My child had an appt today in a hospital clinic. I had my 6 month old baby with us too.

There were delays and we ended up in the clinic for 4+ hours, waiting for the plaster, then x-ray and consultant.

Anyway- baby was getting exceptionally fed up after all this time. I'd tried feeding the sleep, rocking, popping her in her pram and rocking but all the lights/noise/people and she was just far too distracted. She was overtired due to the wait.

I decided to try putting her down in her pram again, popped my phone on with white noise and put a muslin over the top to block out the lights/distractions while I rocked the pram.

There were gaps on both sides so I could see her. I could see she was finally nodding off when a nurse appeared and pulled the muslin off without even looking at me or addressing me (I think I was quite taken aback and thinking "oi you've just woke my baby up")

She started talking to my baby and making a fuss of her (without so much as looking at me)... and said to baby "we don't have this over you do you, you'll be far too hot"... before walking off.

I realised then that she clearly had an issue with the muslin. But as it had been working to get my baby to sleep before the nurse had come over, I just pulled it back over and continued as I was before.

A short time later the nurse reappeared and spoke directly to me this time, and told me off and how dangerous having blankets over babies are.

I'm prepared to be told I was unreasonable to do so... however we were inside, with plenty of fans and the temperature while warmer then average for this time of year was far from sweltering?

I would never cover my baby out in the hot sun. I've had four children so like to think of myself as fairly experienced, but was I wrong?

OP posts:
fairyfluf · 08/09/2023 19:10

Mariposista · 08/09/2023 18:41

Me too. Ridiculous and brainless thing to do. Makes my blood boil and I wouldn't be afraid to say something. I'd rather have an offended adult on my conscience than a dead or very unwell baby.

No one had told me. I'd have been glad if they did. First time mum, no one around to guide me. Health visitor literally phoned me and that was it. I was lucky I thought about it after a couple of trips and baby was ok. They drill it into you ro keep baby out the sun.

bakewellbride · 08/09/2023 19:10
fairyfluf · 08/09/2023 19:08

maltesermagnet · 08/09/2023 17:46

The nurse was right.
Try and imagine what it's like to be a nurse who may have seen children who have become ill or worse because of this. It's been so hot today.
She's a very busy person, she stepped in to ensure a baby was safe, she explained why.

Exactly who knows how many overheated babies she'd seen that day

TellySavalashairbrush · 08/09/2023 19:06

I’ve never understood the fixation of covering prams with cloths of any description. Twenty odd years ago you’d never have seen this. We used parasols that attached to the pram or just pulled the hood of the pram up.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/09/2023 18:46

Alstro · 08/09/2023 18:23

Interestingly this blog post from snoozeshade claims a loosely draped muslin is ok:

“Muslins are generally made of thin cotton which, although not as air permeable as synthetic mesh, have air-permeable qualities.

A loosely draped muslin will not trap heat and will give around 80% UV protection (which is better than none). The key thing is to never use anything that stops air from circulating as per The Lullaby Trust guidelines.”

https://www.snoozeshade.com/blogs/news/please-dont-be-scared-by-the-its-dangerous-to-cover-your-pram-story

Well, they would, wouldn't they? Their entire business model is dependent upon convincing parents to cover their children in the heat.

Puffwiththegreeneyes · 08/09/2023 18:42

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 16:41

Can I ask, if I was breastfeeding my baby in the exact same scenario with a Muslim draped over us would that also be dangerous and unacceptable?

Would anyone have said anything to me if that was the case? Just a thought

No it wouldn't be, because you'd be able to feel the baby overheating and also being next to your body helps them regulate their own.

Babies struggle to regulate their own temperature and can easily overheat. In this heatwave covering the pram, even with gaps in the sides can be fatal.

Mariposista · 08/09/2023 18:41

namethoughts · 08/09/2023 18:07

My toes curl when I see a pram covered by a muslin.... even worse when it's a blanket!

Me too. Ridiculous and brainless thing to do. Makes my blood boil and I wouldn't be afraid to say something. I'd rather have an offended adult on my conscience than a dead or very unwell baby.

Alstro · 08/09/2023 18:23

Interestingly this blog post from snoozeshade claims a loosely draped muslin is ok:

“Muslins are generally made of thin cotton which, although not as air permeable as synthetic mesh, have air-permeable qualities.

A loosely draped muslin will not trap heat and will give around 80% UV protection (which is better than none). The key thing is to never use anything that stops air from circulating as per The Lullaby Trust guidelines.”

https://www.snoozeshade.com/blogs/news/please-dont-be-scared-by-the-its-dangerous-to-cover-your-pram-story

Please don't be scared by the 'it's dangerous to cover your pram with blankets' urban myth

Is It Dangerous to Cover Your Pram? The TRUTH Behind This Urban Myth

We give you the FACTS and science about the urban myth - Is It Dangerous to Cover Your Pram?

https://www.snoozeshade.com/blogs/news/please-dont-be-scared-by-the-its-dangerous-to-cover-your-pram-story

Anonymouslyposting · 08/09/2023 18:13

My understanding is that covering babies is dangerous in pretty much any circumstances and I wouldn’t do it. I don’t think the breastfeeding covered by a muslin analogy works as in that circumstance you’d be more conscious of a change in the baby’s breathing/behaviour.

However, I wouldn’t have approached it the way the nurse did. Talking to the baby about it rather than you is unnecessarily passive aggressive and taking the muslin off without your consent is intrusive.

Barbiesback · 08/09/2023 18:10

I used a Muslin it's fine. It's blocks the sun out. I was always present pushing my pram. I bought this other thing too to clip onto the pram. I would know if my baby was distressed.

namethoughts · 08/09/2023 18:07

My toes curl when I see a pram covered by a muslin.... even worse when it's a blanket!

Eleganz · 08/09/2023 18:06

Common sense is needed here.

I can't be the only mum on here who thinks that a lot of advice about babies and children is taken by health professionals to be absolute when it is actually situational. When it is hot don't cover your baby's pram, but in a cool space a partial light covering to reduce light is totally fine.

As for the nurse's behaviour - how rude! Sadly I suspect most of us have experienced such high-handed behaviour from health professionals when we had babies. I know I did.

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 17:58

@madeleine85 and I totally agree. I'm sorry about your friends baby.

My point was I bet if I was sitting there in the same room feeding my baby under a Muslim blanket nothing would have been said about it to me... because that is deemed acceptable by society, if not polite by quite a lot of people who don't feel women should feed uncovered.

OP posts:
onebadmum · 08/09/2023 17:56

I like to think I do have some common sense and tbh.

My baby had been crying for what seemed like hours at that point. She was far hotter with me holding her and trying to rock her/feed her etc against my body.

She didn't make me feel like a bad mum because I know I am a very good one.

I just thought this an interesting topic given the weather!

OP posts:
madeleine85 · 08/09/2023 17:55

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 16:41

Can I ask, if I was breastfeeding my baby in the exact same scenario with a Muslim draped over us would that also be dangerous and unacceptable?

Would anyone have said anything to me if that was the case? Just a thought

My friend was BF her baby (prob 6 months) in the sun under a muslin blanket, the baby overheated and stopped breathing which thank god they noticed and got an ambulance and all was ok. It was a "sudden unexplained breathing event".

I'm sorry, because I do see your point, and I understand how difficult it is with over tired, grouchy infants. I'd guess a lot of us have done things that go against the guidance (and it that, guidance not rules) just once to get a resolution to a situation. However, the nurse was right to say this to you, especially in this situation. She has probably seen babies who passed from not following those guidlines and is trying to help, in a slightly awkward manner.

SummerHouse · 08/09/2023 17:52

Sounds fine. But god forbid a mother applies some common sense. 10 minutes loosely covered in a slightly warmer than average room with fans. The nurse was not right at all. But on top of not being right, she was rude.

It's like when people tell you you can't eat blue cheese or sit in a hot tub when pregnant. Fucking watch me. There's a chance of dying in a car accident with every trip you make. I don't come up and whip your car keys off you. FFS.

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 17:51

Thoughtful2355 · 08/09/2023 17:50

sorry but put your self somewhere hot with a muslin over your self and see how much hotter it gets, i tested it myself before as i wanted to check whether it would actually help or be bad, before long the air had got super stuffy and much hotter

It wasn't hot.

It was the coolest place I've been today.

OP posts:
Bbq1 · 08/09/2023 17:51

You're totally wrong. It's common sense surely to understand that covering a pram with anything - especially in this heat - is a really bad idea? The temperature of the pram would have intensified so much. Babies can and do overheat and sometimes with tragic consequences. The nurse was right, you were very unreasonable even replacing the sheet back over your baby. Hopefully you're learnt a valuable lesson from the nurse.

Thoughtful2355 · 08/09/2023 17:50

sorry but put your self somewhere hot with a muslin over your self and see how much hotter it gets, i tested it myself before as i wanted to check whether it would actually help or be bad, before long the air had got super stuffy and much hotter

bridgetreilly · 08/09/2023 17:48

The reason that all the advice mentions doing it to block sun or silimilar is because that’s when people generally do it. It doesn’t mean it’s suddenly safe to do it at other times for other reasons.

eandz13 · 08/09/2023 17:48

I'm fully with the nurse, too. YABU, not even remotely worth the risk

Vallmo47 · 08/09/2023 17:48

The nurse was right but handled it badly.

Lavender14 · 08/09/2023 17:47

I've done this before actually to keep the sun off my baby as well as to help him sleep. I think it's fine provided the entrance to the pram isn't completely covered so I'd make sure the Muslin is folded up to keep the sides completely open for air flow to pass through. Keeping it completely covered will raise the temperature inside your pram. You could invest in a snooze shade instead, they're very breathable with gaps in the side and zips so you can open sections. It was a gift when we were on holiday in hot weather.

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 17:47

@fairyfluf I think she did have time, she was talking "at" my baby for quite a while.

Hence why my first thought was to be annoyed that she had disturbed baby when she was almost asleep and started oooing and ahhhing at her and telling her she was a pretty girl.

From what I could see she didn't have a patient and was setting up equipment in another bay (fracture clinic plaster room).

OP posts:
maltesermagnet · 08/09/2023 17:46

The nurse was right.
Try and imagine what it's like to be a nurse who may have seen children who have become ill or worse because of this. It's been so hot today.
She's a very busy person, she stepped in to ensure a baby was safe, she explained why.