Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cover babies pram with a muslin?

139 replies

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 16:33

My child had an appt today in a hospital clinic. I had my 6 month old baby with us too.

There were delays and we ended up in the clinic for 4+ hours, waiting for the plaster, then x-ray and consultant.

Anyway- baby was getting exceptionally fed up after all this time. I'd tried feeding the sleep, rocking, popping her in her pram and rocking but all the lights/noise/people and she was just far too distracted. She was overtired due to the wait.

I decided to try putting her down in her pram again, popped my phone on with white noise and put a muslin over the top to block out the lights/distractions while I rocked the pram.

There were gaps on both sides so I could see her. I could see she was finally nodding off when a nurse appeared and pulled the muslin off without even looking at me or addressing me (I think I was quite taken aback and thinking "oi you've just woke my baby up")

She started talking to my baby and making a fuss of her (without so much as looking at me)... and said to baby "we don't have this over you do you, you'll be far too hot"... before walking off.

I realised then that she clearly had an issue with the muslin. But as it had been working to get my baby to sleep before the nurse had come over, I just pulled it back over and continued as I was before.

A short time later the nurse reappeared and spoke directly to me this time, and told me off and how dangerous having blankets over babies are.

I'm prepared to be told I was unreasonable to do so... however we were inside, with plenty of fans and the temperature while warmer then average for this time of year was far from sweltering?

I would never cover my baby out in the hot sun. I've had four children so like to think of myself as fairly experienced, but was I wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CauliflowerBlue · 10/09/2023 09:06

TheBarbieEffect · 09/09/2023 12:47

@TiredMummma You know they’re just trying to sell their products, yes? 😂

I think it’s worse and TiredMama is trying to sell products - her link redirects to a site called “paid on results” before redirecting back to Snooze shade.

Paid on Results is an affiliate marketing network.

onebadmum · 09/09/2023 14:34

@TheBarbieEffect

From what I understand co-sleeping guidance changed as it's not actually the practice which makes it unsafe, it was the way in which some people were doing it which made it unsafe.

I feel the same with this muslin, it's the way in which it could be used wrongly or dangerously, rather than a blanket approach of "put a muslin over the pram and your baby will die"... was my point.

OP posts:
TheBarbieEffect · 09/09/2023 14:23

onebadmum · 09/09/2023 14:14

Exact same as co-sleeping used to be, which many parents did but just didn't admit it. Now the guidance has changed.

Actually as long as you’re following the Safe Sleep 7 there is no higher risk of infant death with cosleeping.

onebadmum · 09/09/2023 14:17

Out of interest because I'm actually enjoying all the info and view points and this may be helpful to people in future.

Was out with a friend this morning, she had a bugaboo (turtle?) car seat. It has a sort of extendable hood which comes over and some bits that attach to the bottom of the seat that are made of mesh.

Does this not trap the heat any more than what a loosely draped muslin would?

There was certainly more space and bigger gaps on both sides.

OP posts:
onebadmum · 09/09/2023 14:14

Ladyoftheknight · 09/09/2023 13:23

Most people, when told "This thing will kill your baby" try to avoid it. Interesting that you're not...

Exact same as co-sleeping used to be, which many parents did but just didn't admit it. Now the guidance has changed.

OP posts:
MayMi · 09/09/2023 13:56

It is really useful but it has to be done properly, as cloth does trap heat.

What I do is clip the muslin blanket to the lowered hood of the pram and only have the blanket hang down long enough to hide her face and upper chest.

I recline the seat as well so she's quite far from the blanket itself, there's plenty of airflow all round and the sides of the pram have mesh walls when in the reclined position.

If we're somewhere hot then I clip a child-safe electric fan to her pram, and I might also tie an ice pack inside a fabric pouch to the pram straps keep her cool. I check on her from time to time as well to see if she's hot or cold.

Ladyoftheknight · 09/09/2023 13:23

Most people, when told "This thing will kill your baby" try to avoid it. Interesting that you're not...

Cowlover89 · 09/09/2023 13:01

Yabu

TiredMummma · 09/09/2023 12:49

TheBarbieEffect · 09/09/2023 12:47

@TiredMummma You know they’re just trying to sell their products, yes? 😂

You know it was an independent study yes?

TiredMummma · 09/09/2023 12:49

rickandmorts · 08/09/2023 20:53

I've used both a snooze shade and a muslin as you described (ie draped over with the sides open) and a muslin definitely allows more air in. Yanbu op I'd be bloody furious if I were you! My baby fights sleep a ridiculous amount so I've had to do similar and I'd be so pissed off if she'd just got to sleep and someone whipped the muslin off her pram!

Thank you for being the voice of reason! The guidance refers to people leaving their babies in unsafe places. There is clearly just as much misinformation out there about this as cosleeping and expressing. I personally would have put a formal complaint in about the nurse!

TheBarbieEffect · 09/09/2023 12:47

@TiredMummma You know they’re just trying to sell their products, yes? 😂

TiredMummma · 09/09/2023 12:43

modgepodge · 08/09/2023 16:35

I think all the advice is that covering the pram with anything, even a muslin, js an exceptionally bad idea. Even inside. She handled it badly but I think she was right.

Complete rubbish. A study to challenge critics with zero scientific background with the snooze hood and shows the temperature was lower than an outside temperature.

Suggest OP invests in one - but a muslin is absolutely fine. What a rude nurse and completely out of order

blendedfamly · 09/09/2023 06:28

@onebadmum it's the material that holds the air in so it can't circulate

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 22:30

Hollyisalrightactuallysorry · 08/09/2023 21:54

OP, I'm not really sure what you want from this thread. You say you don't mind being told you were unreasonable but have continued to be defensive with 'what about rain covers', 'what about breastfeeding under muslins', 'other people do it'...

The study I linked to earlier was one of many which you say isn't relevant as it wasn't for 30 mins (you don't mention a time in your OP) and there were fans and gaps.

You were inside in a warm room with fans but no air conditioning (I'm sure you'll now say there was air conditioning) where it was warmer than average but 'not sweltering'

So were you unreasonable to restrict the airflow around baby in any way in these conditions? In my opinion yes

Was the nurse also unreasonable in her approach? Also yes

But from your responses I reckon you would have posted about this even if she had approached you directly rather than pulling it off the pram

@Hollyisalrightactuallysorry I accept I was unreasonable, I was asking questions as I'm trying to understand the difference...

Surely it's not wrong to ask how plastic covers with a few holes in are deemed to be okay, how covering a babies head and sometimes whole body with a blanket while breastfeeding is socially acceptable, but how a muslin cloth partially covering a pram indoors is not?

You've provided your evidence. I was unreasonable.

I never said there was air conditioning. But there were fans coming from every direction (at least 4 along every wall- it wasn't a massive room either). Never seen anything like it, impressive for the NHSGrin the temperature as I said was warmer than normal for this time of year (clearly!) but it was actually rather pleasant in there.

I'm sure I'm not the other one who understood the guidance to mean outside in the hot sun.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 08/09/2023 21:59

AlltheFs · 08/09/2023 16:37

She is right, you shouldn’t ever do it. It goes against all the guidance.

Ultimately it’s your choice as a parent but she was right to point it out.

She would have loved the mozzy nets then! Guidance isn't law.

Hollyisalrightactuallysorry · 08/09/2023 21:54

OP, I'm not really sure what you want from this thread. You say you don't mind being told you were unreasonable but have continued to be defensive with 'what about rain covers', 'what about breastfeeding under muslins', 'other people do it'...

The study I linked to earlier was one of many which you say isn't relevant as it wasn't for 30 mins (you don't mention a time in your OP) and there were fans and gaps.

You were inside in a warm room with fans but no air conditioning (I'm sure you'll now say there was air conditioning) where it was warmer than average but 'not sweltering'

So were you unreasonable to restrict the airflow around baby in any way in these conditions? In my opinion yes

Was the nurse also unreasonable in her approach? Also yes

But from your responses I reckon you would have posted about this even if she had approached you directly rather than pulling it off the pram

blendedfamly · 08/09/2023 21:40

The Muslim traps the heat and puts baby at risk of over heating

Nurse was clumsy on her approach

Rounee · 08/09/2023 21:19

YABU.

Seriously.

No point in comparing it to a raincover,or breastfeeding a baby.

It's been really warm the last few days. So even where you were was slightly cooler than other places it was still warm.

Unless it was winter or I was trying keep my kid warm because it was cold. A muslin covering the pram is dangerous.

TeddyBeans · 08/09/2023 21:03

Legoroses · 08/09/2023 16:40

So are snoozeshades also unsafe? I thought they were a godsend to be honest. Esp in bright sunlight.

I took my DD to an adventure playground with us last weekend and she napped under the snooze shade for a good few hours. When I put my hand in to check she was okay, it was cooler in there than out in the sun even though it's black. Blows my mind but I'm glad it works! I wanted to climb in with her 🤣

Cas112 · 08/09/2023 20:58

It's very unsafe. Please don't do it especially in this heat

Mariposista · 08/09/2023 20:55

fairyfluf · 08/09/2023 19:10

No one had told me. I'd have been glad if they did. First time mum, no one around to guide me. Health visitor literally phoned me and that was it. I was lucky I thought about it after a couple of trips and baby was ok. They drill it into you ro keep baby out the sun.

At least you seem to have a mature attitude about it and are willing to learn from what you’re being told. OP just seems determined to be right!

rickandmorts · 08/09/2023 20:53

I've used both a snooze shade and a muslin as you described (ie draped over with the sides open) and a muslin definitely allows more air in. Yanbu op I'd be bloody furious if I were you! My baby fights sleep a ridiculous amount so I've had to do similar and I'd be so pissed off if she'd just got to sleep and someone whipped the muslin off her pram!

Dreamhols · 08/09/2023 20:34

Annaishere · 08/09/2023 16:36

No you know your own baby

Yeah you know your own baby BUT it is dangerous, so whilst you know your own baby you don’t know if they are overheating when covered. Get a parasol or a sunshade but don’t cover the pram, it’s deadly.

the nurse was abrupt but she was right

onebadmum · 08/09/2023 20:33

Ihmeolento · 08/09/2023 20:20

Covering the pram with a muslin /designed shade (that we call a “pram curtain” in Finland) is very very common in Scandinavian countries. But obviously you should use common sense regarding direct sun and other conditions. I don’t know why is it so frowned upon in the UK 🤷🏼‍♀️

I agree...

I'm actually not from the UK originally. I'm from a very, very hot country.

When I had my first two children who are 10 and 12 (the others are born here), I'd say most prams sold had a "snooze shade" type cover. There were also many "universal" type shade/mesh/uv covers for prams on the market.

If you were taking your baby/child outside without one of these on, it would definitely get a tut-tut from others. I did a lot of baby groups and everyone used these.

I remember when my eldest was born my mum telling me "you never cover the baby with a blanket" which seemed like silly advice to me because I thought who would do this anyway, it's common sense!

It seems from this thread even the snooze-shade covers are frowned upon here? I don't know what's used in my home country now as I've been away for some years so advice could have moved on?

@fairyfluf I'm not adamant I'm right. My point was that it's not the item that causes harm, it's the use of it. I was using my common sense, and I appreciate the nurse didn't know why/for how long etc that I'd had that muslin there. She could have spoke to me politely and had the conversation.

I think the blanket approach to guidance is because they cannot trust people to use common sense. I don't think there are any parents that set out to do something to hard their baby, it mostly starts with good intentions without realising the danger.

I haven't said anywhere that I was going to complain about the nurse Confused

OP posts:
Daisybuttercup12345 · 08/09/2023 20:29

Brightandshining · 08/09/2023 16:47

Yanbu she was a rude bitch
She might have a point if you'd wrapped the muslin right round with no gaps and were in direct blazing sunlight. That can be an issue. But inside with clear gaps either side? She's just being an officious idiot.
I know the risk of overheating from wrapping up a pram but I've still used a muslin as a shield from visual stimulation to get my baby to calm down.you just need to make sure there's adequate ventilation, that there's large gaps for the air to circulate.

I hate people that just interfere like that... I once had an old woman just yank a stick out of my toddler daughters hand without asking me.. and she was muttering 'she could poke her eye out with that so dangerous'
I took the stick back out of her hand and gave it back to my daughter whilst glaring straight into that woman's eyes... and she stropped off cursing me under her breath.
Guess what, my daughter has not yet once poked her own eye out or had any kind of injury due to playing with a stick whilst closely watched.

There's a certain kind of stupid. I have just seen a great example.
As for covering prams look on the Lullaby Trust .