Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with school or the parents?

419 replies

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 16:26

Our high school has made the news because of a uniform dispute between (some) parents and the head who is recently in post.

The gist of it is that the school brought in a new rule in April that they were no longer allowing black leather trainers (eg superstars or nike air force) and instead the kids should be in smart plain black leather office shoes.

This appears to have caused ww3 with some parents, who despite having many months notice, still sent their kids in the banned trainers (100+ children apparently). The school has stuck to its guns and has isolated and then suspended those in the wrong shoes if they refused to comply.

The school has also banned girls from wearing socks, and have enforced a thick tights ruling, although socks are allowed in the summer term and if allowed by the head in any warm spells (eg the past 3 days).

Personally I think the tights ruling is worse and I have mixed views on the trainers rule.

I am interested in the real reasons behind these strict uniform rules as I feel if the real reasons were shared with parents they may be more on board with them, rather than the usual rubbish about dressing professionally eg like in an office, when my dp works in a head office in London and goes in jeans and trainers!

As this seems to have whipped up a storm locally, I am interested in other people’s views on this topic as some of the parents round here seem to have gone totally bats*it over it!!

OP posts:
Bergamotte · 08/09/2023 17:56

JustFrustrated · 08/09/2023 17:12

Christ it sounds like my kids school.

The girls aren't allowed belts.

Also to a Pp docs aren't allowed either.

Shoes - neither are right. I understand the logic of the school and they gave plenty of notice, but I really fail to see how it impacts learning.

Tights is stupid. It's hot. Why can't they wear trainer socks with shoes?

Now banning ballet pumps, fully support. They should be banned in general 😂

The girls aren't allowed belts? Is it an all-girls school or are boys allowed belts?!

Surely with the wide variety of waist to hip ratios which teenage girls have, making it difficult to find perfectly fitting skirts or trousers, girls are much more likely than boys to need belts. As a lot of secondary schools don't allow pinnafores, surely the no belts rule is just asking to have girls with trousers falling half down to show their bums- neither smart-looking nor adequately covered-up.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 08/09/2023 17:56

I really dislike the use of detention, isolation etc for punishing students for something which is likely completely out if their control.

Teacher here, and I totally agree.

GnomeDePlume · 08/09/2023 17:54

I really dislike the use of detention, isolation etc for punishing students for something which is likely completely out if their control.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 08/09/2023 17:51

Heavy office shoes go against keeping young people active and healthy.

new heads bring in meaningless but enforceable rules when they feel the things that count (behaviour, results etc) are out of their control.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 08/09/2023 17:50

We are in the NE, the tights issue is just madness.

The shoe issue is also however it’s the rules.

My issue is the children having to carry empty school bags, their books are kept in the school and they have lockers for their pencil cases…. However detentions are now being given for those not carrying school bags….

Resulting in the children now carrying a plastic disposable Lidl shopping bag 😂🙄

GnomeDePlume · 08/09/2023 17:49

GasDrivenNun · 08/09/2023 17:47

Actually a lot of children don't get places at a school their parents have chosen. Sometimes they submit 3 choices and get none of them. Parental choice is often very limited.

Small town then you likely get no choice at all. We didn't.

Anonymouseposter · 08/09/2023 17:49

If children are walking a long way plain black trainers or trainer type boots are going to be more comfortable than leather brogue type shoes. I think the tights rule is also silly. Can't girls wear trousers?
Schools could be more flexible but can understand not allowing very short skirts and coloured branded trainers.
What I really disagreed with was a year 7 pupil being kept in a room on her own on her first day at secondary school for wearing ballet flats.
I agree that they aren't the most suitable shoe for school but it was OTT and was probably a bit frightening for her.
Contacting the parents to tell them lace up shoes were required would have been more proportionate.
I don't like the trend for dressing up kids like office workers or making schools like the army.
I prefer the more relaxed polo shirt and sweatshirt with plain black trousers. More comfortable.

GnomeDePlume · 08/09/2023 17:48

New heads bring in new uniform rules as a way of stamping their 'authority'.

Office shoes are fine for an office, not fine for students walking to school in all weathers, playing football in break times etc etc.

Thick tights for girls? Really?

SparkyBlue · 08/09/2023 17:47

I totally agree with uniforms but I find the footwear rules crazy . Luckily none of the schools around here care too much about what shoes the children wear. My daughter is currently wearing converse hi tops. I never buy school specific shoes. That tights rule is also crazy.

OfTheNight · 08/09/2023 17:47

As a teacher and a parent I totally agree with @CaramelicedLatte , @Starlightstarbright2 and others.

My DS’s school allow black trainers and they are so much more comfortable and practical than formal shoes. Last year he had some Nike Air Force and they outlasted Clark’s, Geox etc.

Uniform is so outdated. When I worked in secondary schools, the amount of time wasted on checking kids were wearing their ties the right length and forcing them to wear blazers was ridiculous.

I wish this obsession with stuffy old fashioned uniform was put to bed. Kids learn so much better when they are comfortable and it would cut out so much unnecessary aggro for all concerned.

We have a duty to nurture young people to be themselves and embrace their uniqueness, but then we force them to all dress the same.

In my experience, strict uniform had naff all impact on bullying or behaviour either.

GasDrivenNun · 08/09/2023 17:47

Thementalloadisreal · 08/09/2023 17:07

Ultimately though, the parents chose to send their kids to that school, they were made aware of the rules (whether or not they think the rules are stupid) and they should stick to them.

But it’s not teaching the kids anything about being professional, most office workers can wear what they want and offices certainly cannot dictate tights and shoes to their staff!

Actually a lot of children don't get places at a school their parents have chosen. Sometimes they submit 3 choices and get none of them. Parental choice is often very limited.

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 17:46

That was yes, they are allowed to wear trousers, for some reason the reply didn’t work

OP posts:
Embarrassednamechangeadoddle · 08/09/2023 17:45

I don’t see the point in either rule. Smart ish black trainers should be fine for school. If a family is struggling financially a pair of black trainers can do for school and home and PE.

The tights rule for girls is surely sexist, I thought most schools had unisex school uniform policies now?

From my mind uniforms should be comfortable, fairly smart and affordable.

Have they actually isolated and excluded 100 odd kids?!

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 17:44

Yes

OP posts:
PhantomUnicorn · 08/09/2023 17:43

my kids school only allow black, unbranded smart shoes. No canvas, no trainers, no boots.

I think the boots rule is dumb, but its not that hard to find shoes, so i think the parents are being stupid quite frankly.

However the socks/tights rule is awful and i would challenge that vociferously.

MushroomQueen · 08/09/2023 17:43

Plus tights = thrush increase-

towriteyoumustlive · 08/09/2023 17:42

No issue with the shoes rule but the tights one is ludicrous! (Teacher here)

BIossomtoes · 08/09/2023 17:42

As far as I can see the real purpose of uniform is to teach kids that sometimes in life you have to do as you’re told, regardless of your personal views on the matter. In an increasingly undisciplined world I can only see that as a good thing.

Lovelynames123 · 08/09/2023 17:42

School make the rules, pupils should follow them. Our school is the same, also NE if it's the school I'm thinking of. It was made very clear several times at meetings for new starters, plus in letters, plus on their website. Plain, polishable black.shoes, no trainers. Girls must wear tights if choosing the skirt option. Blazers worn at all times unless a teacher says you can take off in a lesson. No jewellery apart from a watch, and no makeup, nails, lashes etc

I don't necessarily agree with all of it but I chose to send dd there so she'll adhere to the rules

MushroomQueen · 08/09/2023 17:41

Honestly it's all ridiculous- it gets worse every year - they are children- not office workers, wear comfortable clothes/ branded unbranded it doesn't matter- I live in Portugal/ state schools have no uniform. Kids will always bully for any and any reason. I personally think forcing parents to shell out obscene amounts of money on uniforms every year is awful. Short skirts I get- make a length limit - they always did when I was at school in late 90s/early 00s. I look at my secondary school now with awful blazers on trying to make the kids look like they are from a posh school- just stupid. Kids and families need to be supported not thrown into isolation or exclusion for clothing - utterly ridiculous

Redebs · 08/09/2023 17:40

Can't see a problem with plain black trainers.
And shorts under skirts would solve the modesty issue.

LlynTegid · 08/09/2023 17:38

Random thoughts.

I think some schools are zealous about uniform because they are unable for whatever reason to be strict about much else, and hope it sets a tone. Partly because of the influence of those parents who for whatever reason engage in what MN calls lazy parenting.

Skirt lengths I agree have become ridiculous and girls/young women having to sit awkwardly or be forever adjusting their skirt is not good for concentration, never mind anything else.

The observation about choice in reality not offering much choice I agree with, as often all schools in an area have similar policies. Not the only area where choice in schooling in theory is little in practice, for example almost all have the same start and finish times, not only adding to traffic congestion, but different hours suit different people.

Starlightstarbright2 · 08/09/2023 17:35

I wear a uniform to work over half the staff wear sketchers as they are on their feet most of the day .. they are comfy like trainers …
people talk about preparing children for the workplace - very few will be required to wear a formal uniform ..

schools waste time on what are real issues

Stokey · 08/09/2023 17:35

CaramelicedLatte · 08/09/2023 17:10

I think all uniform is antiquated and pointless. Kids seem to learn at college, and indeed throughout schooling in just about every other western country, without uniform.

It's high time we got rid of it. It's not the social leveller people make it out to be, quite the opposite in fact.

Exactly this. It's antiquated and most of the world doesn't adhere to it.

Children who are comfortable in what they're wearing will be much less distracted.

And the posters saying "don't send them to the school if you don't like the uniform rules", seem to think we all have a huge choice in where our kids go to school. My DC had no uniform at primary but every secondary in our area has a uniform - although thankfully no silly rules about tights.

DivingForLove · 08/09/2023 17:32

I don’t know what schools are supposed to do about skirt lengths nowadays - they are beyond ridiculous. And so many parents of girls don’t seem to think it’s a problem. It’s embarrassing - you can see literally everything and it’s just not appropriate.

If only parents could come up with some sensible solutions instead of constantly berating schools 😞

Swipe left for the next trending thread