Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you agree with school or the parents?

419 replies

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 16:26

Our high school has made the news because of a uniform dispute between (some) parents and the head who is recently in post.

The gist of it is that the school brought in a new rule in April that they were no longer allowing black leather trainers (eg superstars or nike air force) and instead the kids should be in smart plain black leather office shoes.

This appears to have caused ww3 with some parents, who despite having many months notice, still sent their kids in the banned trainers (100+ children apparently). The school has stuck to its guns and has isolated and then suspended those in the wrong shoes if they refused to comply.

The school has also banned girls from wearing socks, and have enforced a thick tights ruling, although socks are allowed in the summer term and if allowed by the head in any warm spells (eg the past 3 days).

Personally I think the tights ruling is worse and I have mixed views on the trainers rule.

I am interested in the real reasons behind these strict uniform rules as I feel if the real reasons were shared with parents they may be more on board with them, rather than the usual rubbish about dressing professionally eg like in an office, when my dp works in a head office in London and goes in jeans and trainers!

As this seems to have whipped up a storm locally, I am interested in other people’s views on this topic as some of the parents round here seem to have gone totally bats*it over it!!

OP posts:
picturethispatsy · 08/09/2023 20:25

Quiverer · 08/09/2023 19:55

I wish the UK would have some sense and just ban school uniforms altogether. There is no logical justification for it.

Before anyone comes out with the standard excuses, they don't work: they don't help to level up who has money and who doesn't, because schoolchildren work that out perfectly easily irrespective of uniform, and they don't cause problems with people competing because experience has demonstrated time and again that what happens without uniform is that children chuck on the nearest pair of jeans and hoodie or T shirt in the mornings. It doesn't improve discipline, and it certainly doesn't improve results; nor does anyone need practice in wearing uniform just in case they go into a uniformed occupation as an adult. All over the world schools manage fine without, goodness knows why the UK is so obsessed with it.

Came on to say just this.

It’s a particularly British obsession to want to make tweens/teens dress like mini business people in suits and ‘sensible shoes’ for school. In most of the rest of the world children are extended the courtesy to dress how they want to like us adults do. And importantly to be comfortable!

Recently it seems some schools are becoming anally retentive about uniform. It strikes me as a way to attempt to exert some control over kids when they are losing control. WHY they are losing control is a topic for another thread!

HaroldMeaker · 08/09/2023 20:15

Formal shoes are dreadful for your feet. Ds used to walk 45 minutes to school with a heavy rucksack and daft office shoes. So I'm all for supportive proper trainers.

The tights/ socks thing is sexist bollocks.

BIossomtoes · 08/09/2023 20:15

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 08/09/2023 20:10

How do most other countries in Europe and around the world cope with all these ill disciplined kids who obviously must run riot through their schools as shock horror they have on a hoodie and jeans?

What you mean apart from all these countries that do have uniform?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_uniforms_by_country

School uniforms by country - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_uniforms_by_country

Tiredmummy201 · 08/09/2023 20:14

The girls at the local secondary school all wear thick black tights too even today .. the skirts they are all in are very short I did wonder if that was the reason behind the thick tights. The trainers I’d assume is to prevent kids that can’t afford them feeling out of place .. don’t see any issue with unbranded trainers though.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 08/09/2023 20:10

BIossomtoes · 08/09/2023 20:05

This. And sorry @Quiverer but it does improve discipline, particularly if the parents don’t behave like fuckwits.

How do most other countries in Europe and around the world cope with all these ill disciplined kids who obviously must run riot through their schools as shock horror they have on a hoodie and jeans?

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 08/09/2023 20:07

Quiverer · 08/09/2023 19:55

I wish the UK would have some sense and just ban school uniforms altogether. There is no logical justification for it.

Before anyone comes out with the standard excuses, they don't work: they don't help to level up who has money and who doesn't, because schoolchildren work that out perfectly easily irrespective of uniform, and they don't cause problems with people competing because experience has demonstrated time and again that what happens without uniform is that children chuck on the nearest pair of jeans and hoodie or T shirt in the mornings. It doesn't improve discipline, and it certainly doesn't improve results; nor does anyone need practice in wearing uniform just in case they go into a uniformed occupation as an adult. All over the world schools manage fine without, goodness knows why the UK is so obsessed with it.

I fully agree! I don't know how students at college/uni manage to learn anything or behave at all without being in a uniform!

It is totally pathetic in this country and the obsession with uniforms.

BIossomtoes · 08/09/2023 20:05

LizardLizard · 08/09/2023 20:02

I’m with the school. I don’t necessarily agree with some of their decisions, but there’s a way and a means of raising it and it’s not secret WhatsApp groups (I mean, who actually has the time for that shit?). I’m not sure what example it sets for kids when their parents, faced with a rule they don’t like, chuck their toys out of the pram and go to the press to do a “sad face” interview.

This. And sorry @Quiverer but it does improve discipline, particularly if the parents don’t behave like fuckwits.

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 20:04

pinklemonade84 · 08/09/2023 19:06

@Watermelon44 are you based in Cheshire? If so, I think I know which school you mean. My friend's daughter goes there and said it's been horrible this week

Yes

OP posts:
LizardLizard · 08/09/2023 20:02

I’m with the school. I don’t necessarily agree with some of their decisions, but there’s a way and a means of raising it and it’s not secret WhatsApp groups (I mean, who actually has the time for that shit?). I’m not sure what example it sets for kids when their parents, faced with a rule they don’t like, chuck their toys out of the pram and go to the press to do a “sad face” interview.

Watermelon44 · 08/09/2023 19:59

Holly60 · 08/09/2023 17:20

@egowise

'They can wear socks in summer term'

Yes because they aren't dickheads. They get that it's not fair to ask girls to wear thick tights in the summer but are trying to mitigate the minuscule skirt situation for the rest of the year.

It can be hot in other terms though. It was hot this week (autumn term) but socks were only allowed on day 2. On day 1 girls in socks were offered tights to put on or put in isolation allegedly, despite being over 30 degrees.

OP posts:
Quiverer · 08/09/2023 19:55

I wish the UK would have some sense and just ban school uniforms altogether. There is no logical justification for it.

Before anyone comes out with the standard excuses, they don't work: they don't help to level up who has money and who doesn't, because schoolchildren work that out perfectly easily irrespective of uniform, and they don't cause problems with people competing because experience has demonstrated time and again that what happens without uniform is that children chuck on the nearest pair of jeans and hoodie or T shirt in the mornings. It doesn't improve discipline, and it certainly doesn't improve results; nor does anyone need practice in wearing uniform just in case they go into a uniformed occupation as an adult. All over the world schools manage fine without, goodness knows why the UK is so obsessed with it.

Ponderingwindow · 08/09/2023 19:54

Chunkyspunkymunkey · 08/09/2023 19:03

This post really shows the problem. Parents. If you don’t agree with the uniform, don’t send your child there. It’s really simple. Have you any idea how much time is wasted on this unnecessary nonsense?

Old, old teacher here who cam remember the days when parents supported teachers’ and school authority. Children came to school ( by and large) and did what teachers asked. They worked hard, took exams and passed or failed, and usually left remembering even the strict teachers with affection.

I wonder how many of you have taken note of those who have commented about the shortness of girls’s skirts. Genuinely shocking how short some of them are. If you don’t want the girls to wear tights, send them to school in trousers or do us all a favour and send them elsewhere!

I can’t imagine parents anywhere else in the world reacting the same way as some English parents.

In much of the world, students are allowed to wear comfortable clothing or their own choice. Somehow they manage to come to school in appropriate attire. There seems to be less drama about inappropriate girls clothing too. Perhaps because girls can do things like where skirts with built in shorts or comfortable, baggy pants which make the modesty police happy but really are just worn for comfort.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/09/2023 19:53

grass321 · 08/09/2023 19:42

Earringsandlipstick fair enough, we'll agree to disagree respectfully.

Perhaps it's because my parental peer group is mega competitive and hyper critical of school that I'm determined not to create unnecessary fuss. After all you don't have to buy Oxford brogues, there's lots of sporty and flexible school shoes that aren't trainers.

I also want my kids to follow rules unless there's a good reason not to. I think having respect translates into better behaviour in lessons; others may disagree. There's ample free time after the school day in which you can wander around in your 1980s massive 1980s jeans and limited colour edition Air Jordan's if you wish.

I agree with everything you've written here 💯

I'm a very strong suppprter of my DC's schools. Sometimes I've had to accept some consequences that they decide on which I might feel are a bit tough, but like you, I recognise their authority & their point of view.

Where it differs is that, so far, even if I've possibly disagreed with something, the approach and rationale has been sound. They explain it, they're courteous & engaged, and the process is respectful.

Where some of the rules set by English schools seem to fall down is in this regard.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/09/2023 19:49

I think school uniforms should move to be simpler and more casual (I.e. polo shirts and sensible practical trousers like many workplaces). They could then have more reasonable grounds to enforce them strictly. I work in education and agree with the general principle behind uniforms but some have become excessive!

I agree with this too though - just keep it really simple!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/09/2023 19:47

Shoes/ trainers - absolutely fine and the parents are ridiculously unread

The tights rule for girls is appalling, and I’d have thought possibly unlawful. Schools can have different uniform policies for girls and boys, but one can’t be more onerous than the other, ie having to boil in thick tights, possibly get thrush if they’re prone to it etc, when trousers are a perfectly sensible option. This is assuming girls can’t wear trousers instead.

cansu · 08/09/2023 19:43

All these stories are a load of rubbish. I have seen facebook posts from parents which are blatantly untrue. The parents are all told very clearly what is acceptable. They choose to ignore the rules and then kick off when they are called out on it. The schools buy shoes, socks, ties and god knows what else to help out kids whose families can't or in some cases won't buy what is required. Some parents buy expensive black shoes or trainers that they know do not meet the school rules. They then spend their days doing sad faced pictures or posting ridiculous stuff on facebook. Ridiculous.

grass321 · 08/09/2023 19:42

Earringsandlipstick fair enough, we'll agree to disagree respectfully.

Perhaps it's because my parental peer group is mega competitive and hyper critical of school that I'm determined not to create unnecessary fuss. After all you don't have to buy Oxford brogues, there's lots of sporty and flexible school shoes that aren't trainers.

I also want my kids to follow rules unless there's a good reason not to. I think having respect translates into better behaviour in lessons; others may disagree. There's ample free time after the school day in which you can wander around in your 1980s massive 1980s jeans and limited colour edition Air Jordan's if you wish.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/09/2023 19:29

@grass321

I didn't mean it that way. I meant they couldn't properly even casually (as I said) kick a ball around or whatever relevant sport. Mine would find that really frustrating.

I don't agree with you about parents not buying shoes just to be oppositional. I'm a big supporter of my DC's schools & do what's asked, within reason.

That's the point: neither of these rules are within reason & are instead just designed to assert authority.

grass321 · 08/09/2023 19:24

Ah come on! They can't be all that sporty then 😂

They've played five sports at county level between the two of them but that's irrelevant. They play football and basketball happily in their school shoes in the playground, as do the other pupils at their secondary school. Serious sport during games lessons, obviously not.

I just don't understand why parents make such a big deal of buying compliant shoes. They'd seemingly rather take up teachers' time by pushing the boundaries.

LakeTiticaca · 08/09/2023 19:18

Instead of having a thick tights only rule for the girls, why not introduce a minimum skirt length, like no higher than knee-length, to save the rest of the population having to avert their eyes from young teenage girls buttocks on full view

That would be a start

EarringsandLipstick · 08/09/2023 19:18

grass321 · 08/09/2023 19:16

It will if they enjoy being active at lunch break, kicking a ball, playing basketball, running around. My secondary DC do all of this.

Yep, my kids also love sport and have always done this in their school shoes.

Ah come on! They can't be all that sporty then 😂
No way can you play even a casual game of soccer wearing school shoes, rather than runners. No grip, no purchase on the ball.

grass321 · 08/09/2023 19:16

It will if they enjoy being active at lunch break, kicking a ball, playing basketball, running around. My secondary DC do all of this.

Yep, my kids also love sport and have always done this in their school shoes.

EarringsandLipstick · 08/09/2023 19:14

The skirt thing is mad. Where I am, the girls wear kilt-style skirts, about knee-length or trousers.

No issue with length.

JohnNolan · 08/09/2023 19:14

Im all for a sensible school uniform policy, as I assume most people are.

The problem is the extreme rules contained within some of them. The no socks and tights rule is absolutely ridiculous and I can't believe any parent would agree with it. I also assume that girls therefore aren't able to wear trousers - again nothing something I would support.

The shoe things is also far too extreme. At my DCs school they are allowed to wear polishable black leather shoes with no different coloured logo. So black Air Forces are fine so long as the silver tag has been removed - again sensible. Forcing anyone to wear 'work wear' shoes when every adult I know doesn't wear this style of shoe to work is frankly stupid and that's why its gets peoples backs up.

Have a sensible uniform policy and everyone would agree for their child to wear it - simple.

Mumofsend · 08/09/2023 19:14

Thess is the shoes the school deem unacceptable. There's a few on there which are but the vast majority are absolutely ridiculous on part of the school.

Do you agree with school or the parents?