Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No toys downstairs- worried

219 replies

Ceci03 · 08/09/2023 15:28

So I visited a new friend who has 2 girls 6 and 4 but there were no toys downstairs. Like none. I'm a bit worried . I did go upstairs and saw a few baby books and they had 2 cuddly toys each on their bunks. I dunno. My kids are older now but I just remember toys everywhere and def in the sitting room maybe try and keep them to a corner. There was just sofa and tv. They watched tv while we chatted . I'd like to get them some toys but am unsure I don't want to offend my friend. I know she struggles financially.

OP posts:
TenderDandelions · 08/09/2023 16:41

I agree it's unusual, particularly for the 4 year old. If the kids were otherwise playing by themselves, making up games, etc, or doing craft/drawing/colouring, etc, I'd have just assumed they preferred that than toys, but to just be watching TV is quite sad.

I don't think you can say much after one visit. As you get to know her and them a little better, you might be able to find an opportunity to mention it in some way, or fabricate a story to offer them something you've seen in a Charity shop or Marketplace ("a friend of mine is getting rid of a dolls house and wondered if I knew anyone that might like it - is it something your DC might enjoy?").

Ceci03 · 08/09/2023 16:40

Excited101 · 08/09/2023 16:18

I knew a family where the 3 children had one shoebox of toys each and they was it. The 8 year old was still in a cot bed and whichever games or books were ‘outgrown’ (think, ‘age 3-4 and the youngest child turned 4) were immediately thrown out. It was a large house and there was plenty of money, it was really really sad.

it isn’t right that in 2 hours neither child played with a toy, it’s weird and sad. Children’s house should have toys in them, in their rooms, maybe some books/games on the shelves downstairs even if most is tidied away. I agree with you, it’s disturbing. The majority of replies on here are the usual AIBU desperate to have an argument with the op.

Does she seem like a good mum? Is there a dad?

Yes this is what I was trying to say . I did feel sad. I get that people have different levels of mess they can cope with but it was odd to me. Like not a piece of Lego or a doll or a game or a puzzle. I realize I probably had too many toys but this was extreme to me. She's a lovely mum very loving and looks after the girls great they always dressed in nice clothes and very clean and hair done nice. Actually I think my own kids used to be a lot dirtier ha ha No contact with their dad . It's a small place no garden I just was curious where the toys were. No cupboards or storage that I saw. But maybe I'm just overthinking it. And I'm super sensitive that she mite be struggling financially and don't want to pass any comment

OP posts:
Flyinggeesei234 · 08/09/2023 16:38

This phrase: ‘I dunno’ is all over MN at the moment! OP if you ‘dunno’ then it’s not a major thing, just move on.

3peassuit · 08/09/2023 16:37

Maybe they’re not that into toys. One of my girls would happily draw, scribble or just potter around and wasn’t fussed about toys. Also, I was fanatically tidy and would sweep through the house before any visitors arrived.

housethatbuiltme · 08/09/2023 16:36

She sounds like a minimalist.

My family member is like that and I forever think 'where is your stuff at? like how do you actually function without things?'. People say 'oh it will be in cupboards' etc... but I have lived in her house and seen in her cupboard and really theres next to nothing. They are the kind thats understairs cupboard has a small hoover, 1 coat each and 2 pairs of shoes each and a reusable shopping bag and thats it for things they are 'storing'.

However I also know she thinks we live in a uninhabitable shithole full of stuff and she would be horrified if I bought 'clutter' for her house.

We are just very different people.

MariePaperRoses · 08/09/2023 16:36

Children don't need lots of toys.

Mine preferred the great outdoors and toys were in their bedrooms or a back room. We didn't have toys in our sitting room at all.

Legoroses · 08/09/2023 16:35

OP - I agree with you. We had neighbours - v well off - who didn't have toys for years because they didn't want untidy, ugly toys. When my kids and other neighbourhood kids were out playing, these kids didn't know what to do. They looked lost and a bit haunted. So, yeah, definitely legitimate to be concerned. Might be super tidy, or might be neglectful of the needs of children...

DoDoDoD · 08/09/2023 16:35

MarigoldMaud · 08/09/2023 15:30

Is she one of those clean freaks that has tidied them all away because they don’t like ‘mess’?

🙄or just someone who likes a tidy space rather than sitting amongst kid's junk?

Sparkleshine21 · 08/09/2023 16:33

My daughter has the largest bedroom in the house for the reason that all of her toys and bookcase are in there! She loves it, and it’s great for when her friends come over and we mums can chat in peace in the lounge and the girls can play upstairs in the huge playroom/bedroom. She’s seven. The dog would be chewing all of her toys if they were downstairs!

Backtoblack1 · 08/09/2023 16:33

Mind your own.

NotMyFinestMoment · 08/09/2023 16:33

She probably just tidied up because she knew you were visiting. She probably has a toy cupboard or toy box in the kids room and besides not everyone let's their kids play in the front room, some parents insist kids play and keep their toys in their room.

Goldbar · 08/09/2023 16:31

If your kids are older, could you tell her you're clearing out their old toys and would she like any before they go to the charity shop?

I don't see how she could take offence at that. It's quite common to offer used clothes/toys to friends with younger children, regardless of their financial situation.

Sallyh87 · 08/09/2023 16:29

My house is a mess of toys! But that doesn’t mean it’s right.

Unless there is a massive drip feed and you have other concerns, then I think you are being a bit unreasonable in your concern.

TawnyLarue · 08/09/2023 16:24

WedRine · 08/09/2023 16:16

I don't allow toys downstairs. Bedrooms are for playing in, not my living room.

aw this is a bit miserable. How old are your kids?

My house is a bit messy through the day but I’m keen that the kids are relaxed in their home. As long as their toys are taken back upstairs and put away at bedtime then I don’t really care if they bring them downstairs to play during the day.

my sister in law has the same rule as you. Her three year old spends a lot of time alone in her bedroom with her toys. Which, knowing my sister in law, is the reason she has rule in place (not saying that’s your reasoning!)

Stravaig · 08/09/2023 16:23

Maybe they're neatly tidied away, or in the kitchen, or garden, or in their bedrooms. Maybe they prefer not to drown their kids in an ocean of beeping flashing plastic tat. People have dramatically different ideas about number of toys and what play looks like.

If you are genuinely concerned, then wait for the next birthday, or Christmas, and ASK your friend if you can give a present, and what she'd suggest for them. Then do as she asks.

EatYourVegetables · 08/09/2023 16:20

When I meet friends with kids for a coffee, there is often a small toy exchanged. Either you haven’t seen each other for a while so you bring a present, or someone’s birthday was a month ago, or your kid outgrew a toy so you thought the other kid would like it… not every time but it happens and it’s never a cause for an offence. So I’d bring a small gift next time you see the kids. Don’t say anything patronising. Can’t imagine them being upset about it.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/09/2023 16:19

Maybe next time you go, take something like Connect 4 or something "I've been dying to play this shall we take turns while I have a cuppa" then if they enjoy it you can ask to leave it with them. If you don't think leaving it would he welcome then take it home when you leave (and bring a different game or toy next time)

WhatWouldMrMannersSay · 08/09/2023 16:19

I think the OP is being fair enough.

Yes it's entirely possible they've been tidied away but also entirely possible they've no toys.

In your shoes I'd probably ask some questions. I'd be asking where the toys were and how it was so tidy out of genuine curiosity as our house is full of toys everywhere and never tidy. I'm always amazed at how well some people manage the inflow if toys and manage storage.

Excited101 · 08/09/2023 16:18

I knew a family where the 3 children had one shoebox of toys each and they was it. The 8 year old was still in a cot bed and whichever games or books were ‘outgrown’ (think, ‘age 3-4 and the youngest child turned 4) were immediately thrown out. It was a large house and there was plenty of money, it was really really sad.

it isn’t right that in 2 hours neither child played with a toy, it’s weird and sad. Children’s house should have toys in them, in their rooms, maybe some books/games on the shelves downstairs even if most is tidied away. I agree with you, it’s disturbing. The majority of replies on here are the usual AIBU desperate to have an argument with the op.

Does she seem like a good mum? Is there a dad?

Puffed · 08/09/2023 16:17

I’m really not sure why everyone is thinking this is an odd thing to worry about.

Im a professional who sees children for home visits and having age appropriate toys available is something we look out for and potentially provide support and advice about if there’s not any. It would definitely raise alarm bells for me if a house with small children had no toys.

WedRine · 08/09/2023 16:16

I don't allow toys downstairs. Bedrooms are for playing in, not my living room.

MimiSunshine · 08/09/2023 16:14

There are no toys in my living room either and very few in bedrooms (why were you nosing in bedrooms?). I just keep them elsewhere, where a casual visitor wouldn’t see.

Cas112 · 08/09/2023 16:13

Unless my child is playing with them toys are put away in my house. Especially when I have guests. Hope no one thinks I'm struggling for toys ahha

Hufflepods · 08/09/2023 16:13

@Letsgocamping67 Is it a grey “insta” house with no visible toys as they are too messy. That would be my worry and yes very damaging

Of course it’s not damaging for children to put their toys away when not being used.
A generation ago children had a much smaller amount of toys.

Lelophants · 08/09/2023 16:12

Have you asked her what kind of stuff the kids like playing with and what they do?