Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No toys downstairs- worried

219 replies

Ceci03 · 08/09/2023 15:28

So I visited a new friend who has 2 girls 6 and 4 but there were no toys downstairs. Like none. I'm a bit worried . I did go upstairs and saw a few baby books and they had 2 cuddly toys each on their bunks. I dunno. My kids are older now but I just remember toys everywhere and def in the sitting room maybe try and keep them to a corner. There was just sofa and tv. They watched tv while we chatted . I'd like to get them some toys but am unsure I don't want to offend my friend. I know she struggles financially.

OP posts:
Dontcallmescarface · 08/09/2023 17:48

housethatbuiltme · 08/09/2023 17:38

This seems so stifling of creativity... today my DD pushed her mega block round in her dolls pram with her brothers spiderman. Stopping to build a village for spiderman along the way then sat in the middle and read her picture book.

It took at least 4 toys (pram, megablocks, spiderman & book) for her to do that.

Didn't stifle her creativity at all. Just 1 example, she was obsessed with "the Lion King" at the age of 5 and had a tin of animals ( which I think count as 1 item), that featured in the film (although not the actual characters). The dining char became Pride Rock and she would spend literally hours conjuring up scenarios ("Scar" being told off by an elephant for eating all the chocolate was one of my favourites). When she had finished, all the animals went back in the tin, put back in the cupboard and something else would come out.

pjani · 08/09/2023 17:45

I agree it can be a bit of a red flag. It can correlate with poor parenting/a need for parenting support if there aren’t varied and age appropriate toys available. You can get the odd thing for 50p And also there is a lot given away so it is strange to have almost nothing.

However, there isn’t too much you can do, I think the offer of giving a few toys is a nice one ‘oh I saw this and thought your DC might like it’. I don’t think it’s ‘reportable’ on its own and it’s good that you’ve seen her be loving to her children.

HappiDaze · 08/09/2023 17:40

It can be a red flag OP so you're not wrong to be a bit concerned

Hopefully she's just a bit OCD

housethatbuiltme · 08/09/2023 17:38

Dontcallmescarface · 08/09/2023 17:24

I always had a "1 toy out" policy when DD was small. The house was small so once she had finished playing with something it had to be put away before she got something else out. If anyone had visited that didn't know, then it would have seemed that DD only had 1 thing to play with.

Did you check the floor based kitchen cupboards OP...that,s where DD's toys were stored.

This seems so stifling of creativity... today my DD pushed her mega block round in her dolls pram with her brothers spiderman. Stopping to build a village for spiderman along the way then sat in the middle and read her picture book.

It took at least 4 toys (pram, megablocks, spiderman & book) for her to do that.

tt9 · 08/09/2023 17:38

@HardcoreLadyType why would it be good idea to give things from a charity shop as a present? if @Ceci03 wants to give some gifts for the children, I am sure the friend would be happy. and she can buy something new within her budget- doesn't have to be expensive

cocksstrideintheevening · 08/09/2023 17:37

cocksstrideintheevening · 08/09/2023 17:36

So she hunched the house before your visit? Is she obsessed with sm?

Tbh my sister was like this, instructions that any gifts must be great and / or wooden. We don't speak anymore.

Hinched!

cocksstrideintheevening · 08/09/2023 17:36

So she hunched the house before your visit? Is she obsessed with sm?

Tbh my sister was like this, instructions that any gifts must be great and / or wooden. We don't speak anymore.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/09/2023 17:35

menopausalmare · 08/09/2023 17:19

I hated toys everywhere, especially in the evening when they were in bed. All toys were tidied away to the extension room and, once they were older, into their rooms. Far more civilized.

And there's absolutely nothing wrong with this. They did HAVE toys though. That's the point - OP is just at the stage of not knowing if there are any in the house.

housethatbuiltme · 08/09/2023 17:34

Ceci03 · 08/09/2023 16:46

There was nothing in the bedroom though. They share a room and there was a bunk bed with a couple of teddies on each and a dresser with clothes. So tidy and empty I thought compared to a usual bedroom.

But yeh mind my own business seems to be the general sense on this thread

I'm guessing it was like A to Zens kids bedroom (see link below, yes that massive white room with just 2 plain back to back beds and a chest of draws is her kids actual bedroom)... I find it soul sucking but people do CHOOSE to live like that.

https://atozenlife.com/family-minimalism/

Family Minimalism: 20+ Pros, Cons, and Tips for Simple Living as a Family

What is family minimalism and is it right for you? Here are the pros & cons from a REAL minimalist family, as well as ideas on how to start.

https://atozenlife.com/family-minimalism

CurlyhairedAssassin · 08/09/2023 17:32

Matchinglipsandfingertips · 08/09/2023 17:10

I am just clearing away the last of my DC toys and books and they are 20/24!
If you are worried I would ask her if she would like to come to the library with you after school. They often have toys that can be borrowed. Otherwise have a sort out and say I am taking some bits to the charity shop. Do you want to have a rummage first?
I am a ex charity shop employee and toys are super cheap in the stores as they get given so many. You could take the kids before a play date and give them a pound each. Then their tea.
You risk being told to bog off but what if she needs help? She who does nothing, changes nothing.

Yes, it's the first thing you're taught in safeguarding. You have to get out of the habit, if something you see concerns you and wondering what to do about it, of thinking "what if I'm wrong?" and instead think "but what if I'm right?"

It's not a judgement, as some posters seem to think. It's not even an assumption. It's someone with half a brain seeing something and thinking "There is the slightest chance this MAY indicate something more." Of course there may be a whole box full of toys stored somewhere out of OP's sight. It would be fairly easy to bring the conversation around to toys/tidiness or asking if they could use x/y/z toy that their sister was giving away etc and see what this mum said. She may well say, "oh there is a cupboard upstairs on the landing FULL of toys. They really don't need any more but thankyou." As OP gets to know the family more she will soon get to know if the children sit there all the time during each visit, or if they disappear upstairs to get something to play with and bring it down to show OP.

Even in cultures which don't have plastic tat, or in poor countries where they couldn't afford it anyway, they usually make toys out of whatever materials they have to hand. In years gone by in Western countries, parents made dolls out of rags, or pegs, and encouraged imaginary play. Pull along toys made out of cotton reels for wheels, string etc etc. A mini army of soldiers made out of bits of wood with the figures painted on etc. Boats made out of an empty coconut shell or walnut shell, cocktail stick and paper for a sail. Dolls houses made out of cardboard boxes or orange crates. Lots of boys had home made gokarts.

It really is very unusual for children not to have playthings. I would definitely try to establish, sensitively, if there was SOMETHING for the children to play with in the house, even if it were hidden away on your visit. Children's books are also easy to come by from the library or for pennies, or passed on by friends and relatives. A house with no children's books whatsoever is a bit sad.

ManateeFair · 08/09/2023 17:24

I had loads of toys when I was a kid, but they got put away into a cupboard when I wasn't playing with them and when I wanted to play with something I just went to the cupboard and got it out. My toys weren't just left piled up in the living room. To be honest, my friends' toys weren't either. We got things out to play with and then they got put back at the end of the day. And they would definitely have been tidied up visitors came round.

I still had non-stop access to them and I still made a hell of a mess when I was playing with them. I'm sure your friend's kids are perfectly fine.

Dontcallmescarface · 08/09/2023 17:24

I always had a "1 toy out" policy when DD was small. The house was small so once she had finished playing with something it had to be put away before she got something else out. If anyone had visited that didn't know, then it would have seemed that DD only had 1 thing to play with.

Did you check the floor based kitchen cupboards OP...that,s where DD's toys were stored.

solice84 · 08/09/2023 17:20

If you came into my home after I've tidied up you wouldn't even think I had a kid
If you came in before I tidied you wouldn't be able to move for toys
Clever storage

menopausalmare · 08/09/2023 17:19

I hated toys everywhere, especially in the evening when they were in bed. All toys were tidied away to the extension room and, once they were older, into their rooms. Far more civilized.

Batalax · 08/09/2023 17:19

It sounds as if you are right to be worried. It can’t be financial as you can pick up toys cheaply second hand or even free. It’s not good developmentally to have nothing. That’s not the makings of a good parent.

Maybe she’d tidied them all in her room because you were coming?

DinnaeFashYersel · 08/09/2023 17:19

😳😳😳

Tidy up your house and next thing your 'friend' is on the internet flapping about whether your children are neglected or you are poverty striken because they can't find the toy stash.

Maireas · 08/09/2023 17:18

I think the OP has looked through the ottomans.

Wonkypumpkin · 08/09/2023 17:17

My son has absolutely loads of toys - boxes and boxes of Lego, playmobil, action toys, hotwheels, but you wouldn’t know this by just judging from downstairs as they are all in very organised storage or up in his bedroom.

I work mainly from home so downstairs needs to be quite orderly and chaos free (apart from at weekends where anything goes!)

Please don’t judge other Mums - In the nicest possible way, I think you’re poking too much into her business. The toys could be stashed under the children’s beds in storage, or kept in ottomans, anything.
If she was indeed struggling financially, she would be able to get toys from Facebook marketplace or freecycle etc.

Some people prefer minimalist living, so maybe that’s another thing to consider.

Cosycardigans · 08/09/2023 17:17

I have a friend who refuses to buy toys for her child. She says she wants him outdoors most of the time, and toys would distract him from wanting to go out with her.

I find it weird and controlling.

ASGIRC · 08/09/2023 17:14

My best friend in primary school had no toys, either.
She literally had one drawer in her room with a few toys, but that was it.

However, she did have games and books. All tidied away as well. Her room was absolutely spotless.

It wasnt lack of money or concern. The family just wasnt big on toys.

Childrens rooms dont need to be overflowing with toys.

Matchinglipsandfingertips · 08/09/2023 17:10

I am just clearing away the last of my DC toys and books and they are 20/24!
If you are worried I would ask her if she would like to come to the library with you after school. They often have toys that can be borrowed. Otherwise have a sort out and say I am taking some bits to the charity shop. Do you want to have a rummage first?
I am a ex charity shop employee and toys are super cheap in the stores as they get given so many. You could take the kids before a play date and give them a pound each. Then their tea.
You risk being told to bog off but what if she needs help? She who does nothing, changes nothing.

Caspianberg · 08/09/2023 17:09

Ds has a fair amount of toys imo. Not loads though, but a variety of each category ie train track, building blocks, puzzles, art stuff. When he is playing it’s everywhere, but when he’s finished and it’s tidy you could also say no toys in sight. Brio and duplo live in wicker baskets under the sofa.
The footstool and long ottoman are extra seating when guests around but they are both lift up storage and hold lots of toys like animals, cars, puzzles, books. If you didn’t know they lifted up, you wouldn’t see toys.

Ds also wants me to help play train track and paint, and pretend play with him all day. So if I had a friend coming around without other children, I would also be tempted to just let him watch a film so I could chat, and have coffee in piece without him wanting me to play every 5 mins when guest visiting. I entertain him the other 14+ hours a day he’s awake

RiverRed · 08/09/2023 17:07

Evaka · 08/09/2023 15:51

OP, I don't know why everyone is laying into you. I think you sound sincere and it is very unusual to visit a house with little kids and not see any toys/play stuff.

This

Dustybarn · 08/09/2023 17:07

Growing up we never had more than about 2 toys at a time. At Christmas and birthdays we got a present - one present. As soon as we could read we went to the shops every weekend and could each choose a book. Great childhood in that respect - we read, made up games and hid in the compost heap. By contrast my DB’s DC get about 15 presents every birthday. Just different ways of raising kids. Nothing wrong with either.

Maireas · 08/09/2023 17:04

FrenchandSaunders · 08/09/2023 15:37

You were having a proper snoop 😁

I know! She seems to know what's in the cupboards as well!