Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the chills from someone I barely know at all?

144 replies

bloopingbleeping · 08/09/2023 07:59

Had my hackles rise and a strong feeling someone I hardly know is not someone to be trusted.

(I do experience anxiety to some degree already, but it’s more of a “overthink and worry” type, not being physically cold and shaky like this). I don’t believe this person is a danger to my physical safety, but I’ve hardly ever felt this unsafe even around people I know I couldn't trust.

Please tell me about times your intuition reacted to someone and whether you were wrong or right. Preferably more mundane, everyday relationships, not the rare cases of someone encountering a serial killer.

OP posts:
Thatladdo · 08/09/2023 11:26

Always trust your instincts - you might be wrong but at least your true to yourself.

DisquietintheRanks · 08/09/2023 11:22

The "witch" woman who lived at the end of our street and her weird (mentally disabled) son. We kids all knew that there was something "off" about them.

Except there wasn't. It was sheer, unmitigated prejudice.

Beachmummy23 · 08/09/2023 11:18

I always trust my instincts as a teenager on a Saturday morning walking down a road a man walked towards me. I remember him making me feel uncomfortable so I crossed the road, he did the same, this happened twice more and then I turned around and ran to a nearby shop. He waited outside and then when I didn't come out moved slightly down the road still waiting. The shopkeeper kindly took me out the back way and drove me home.

A few weeks later a serial rapist was arrested in our area it was the same man. He's still in jail.

carrotcaketop · 08/09/2023 11:15

Myhorseishoarse · 08/09/2023 08:47

As a child he gave me the creeps. Yes I never met him, but I never understood why my friends loved his programme. My best friend wrote to him, asking if he could fix it for us to meet Danny la rue. I prayed that would not happen.

me too, as a child I felt incredibly uncomfortable watching that programme. Could watch the part with the children out and about, but the scenes where they were in the studio to get the medal gave me an absolute sense of creeping dread and fear. Years later realised it was probably the body language of the children in his presence, but also he just gave off such a horrible vibe, also on Top of the Pops. I think instincts are often spot on with evil and danger.

On another note, once I met a boyfriend's colleague for the first time, and perhaps because of some micro-expression of hers, but as we shook hands, I had a very strong instant feeling of 'I don't trust you at all, you're trouble' and was right as they ended up having an affair. Another time at a party another colleague of his I never even met gave me same feeling. I told my ex she was very interested in him. 2 weeks later she came on to him big time. He asked how I could possible have known, and I said I got that feeling because she was looking at me so closely across a large crowded room she had noticed that my dress label was sticking out and mentioned it to him. So instinct reacting to different clues, some obvious, some less so.

EverybodyLTB · 08/09/2023 11:12

I had a team of builders in years ago. All young, all Eastern European so there was no particular bias for this one individual man. All coming and going, different new guys doing different things, all just say hi and crack on, all fine. One guy came into my house for the first time with the foreman and my blood ran cold. He was like walking evil, and I have no idea why, he just made me feel like I was under some kind of immediate threat. His build/skin colour/height was no different to any other of the builders. I took the foreman to one side and told him I couldn’t have that man in my house. He was puzzled but I was insistent, and he had to relent and redirect him to another job. I think of him once in a while and shudder.

It’s not one of those things where I later found out he’s a murderer. I have no idea if my instincts were right, but he scared the living daylights out of me.

JaninaDuszejko · 08/09/2023 11:02

I went to school with a guy who was very quiet, kept his head down and sat with a couple of other boys at lunch but wasn't really popular or bullied, just overlooked by most people I think.
I didn't get creepy pervert vibes from him but I did think he was very selfish, to the extreme that I can remember looking at him and thinking he didn't care about anyone but himself. Like I could tell he had no empathy? When I didn't really know him at all.
Anyway, he turned out to be a peadophile.

He was probably an abused child when you knew him, most abusers were abused themselves. Some children are so badly abused at such a young age that they are incapable of forming attachments, their brain kind of shuts down their ability to have empathy or form relationships as a form of self protection. Others (sometimes for the smallest reason) are more robust and can overcome their experiences to a greater or lesser extent and can stop or reduce the cycle of abuse.

I was at school with someone who went on to murder someone, he was clearly very troubled at school but was OK if you treated him decently and didn't treat him like scum (which a lot of people did because of his troublemaker reputation). Really sad to see that happen to someone.

radiantorange · 08/09/2023 10:54

Yeah. I worked in a castle restaurant and a new chef started, he was introduced by the boss and I said a jovial hello but didn't take much notice… later on as I was in alone mopping the floor he appeared at the front door trying to get in, I signalled I'd get the key hanging on a hook, he thought I'd signalled to the back door so by the time I opened the front door he had started ringing the doorbell for the private apartments and about 3 different people came down at the same time I ran to the door – we were all baffled. He wanted to come say hello to me. Followed me down to the kitchen and walked all over the floor as I mopped it. He kept eye contact with me and was smiling as he asked me lots of questions about me… I was creeped out by now. Then he asked if I'd go for a drink but I said no as I was starting work at 6am next day but also… creeped out.

Everyone loved him. And he continually asked me to hang out and I continually made excuses. I had told my sister about a bad feeling but she though I was being dramatic and he was just a nice guy who didn't know anyone.

So one weekend when my fiends and work pals (and my sister) seemed to be off island it was just me and him and I though maybe I was being harsh and got it wrong and I asked if he wanted to come over for a drink after work (what was I thinking!). He did. I made snacks and drinks and we chatted and I tried to put the niggle to the back of my mind. It got late and I hinted I was off to bed soon. He lingered so long I had to just eventually ask him to leave. At the door he asked me out and I said no… he laughed it off, threw some compliments at me and asked again, I said no. Laughed it off again and started talking about work and stuff and I was like 'goodbye!' and went to close the door and he put his foot in the door, forced it open and asked me if I was sure it was a no. That really frightened me but I somehow stayed calm and said 'no hard feelings, yeah?' and he agreed, said goodnight, blew me a kiss and wandered off. I literally threw the door closed, locked up and sagged against it!

Next day at work he was in when I started and I said hello and he ignored me, was in a raging mood and this went on from there in. Spread lies about me to other staff who believed him and generally made work hell for me. He'd put roasting hot pots in the sink when I was washing up and not tell me so I'd scald my hands, he'd look at me and throw a dish on the floor when no one else was around then blame me, he started a relationship with a friend who then ghosted me, he did it in such a way that no one would see what he was doing. To the point where my sister though I was over-reacting because all he was was nice to her and she never saw him being horrible to me – because in front of people he was so lovely to me. And I was frustrated because if I reacted badly to that it made me look childish and petty.

Early one day I was on kitchen duty and it was just him and me. I was ignoring him and making sandwiches while he was telling me I was an ugly bitch, everyone hated me, I was useless, I should kill myself etc… I walked through to the front to put the sandwiches out and there was my sister in tears. She had come to start her shift and went to the kitchen to get the keys and we hadn't seen her but she stood and listened to what he was saying to me. She was devastated that she hadn't believed me. We took it to the managers and they chose not to escalate it any further… other than give me and my sister matching shifts and days off. I worked out my last few weeks there with my sister by my side and we would just laugh at him and call him 'master baker; and other shit names to wind him up. Last I heard of him he was in jail!

Now I always listen to my instinct.

msmonstera · 08/09/2023 10:48

I had it twice. One really sticks- a man on a busy shopping street who seemed to radiate evil like a force. It was like a push away, even just passing on the street. Later that day, he shoved someone under a bus and killed them.
The second was a therapist I saw only once, there was something off and cruel about her. She turned out to be scamming money from vulnerable people under her 'care'.

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 08/09/2023 10:39

I had a new work colleague and hated them on sight. Hackles rose everytime she came in for a shift.
We've now been great friends for 18 years. Sometimes, you have to give people a chance.

sgtmajormum · 08/09/2023 10:29

There may be something just a tiny bit off in their behaviour that you are picking up on. Not massively noticeable, but enough for your senses to pick up on it. Rational brain then goes oh you are being silly, but I never ignore that gut reaction. I've had it a few times over the years, once ad a child with a family friend, again with a random stranger, a work colleague and a friends husband.
I just instinctively didn't feel safe around them, perhaps something predatory about them.
Nothing ever came of it that I know of, but I made sure to never me alone with those individuals and just trust my gut. Who knows what could have happened. Possibly nothing but I always trust my instincts.

fizzandchips · 08/09/2023 10:27

A friend who is a police officer told me about a case of sexual assault in a lift. When it went to court and the man was convicted more woman came forward. Using a lift was his ‘method’ of being alone with woman. All of them said, in hindsight, they immediately felt uncomfortable when they saw him/got in the lift, but when asked why they didn’t just get out or not get in and they all said they didn’t want to appear/be rude.
My police officer friend told me to always follow my gut instincts and be ‘rude’ if I needed to (he was in no way blaming the woman for not). He suggested you say, oh I’m waiting for a friend, she’s on her way down, oh I’ve forgotten my umbrella - whatever. Always, always trust your instinct.

readingismycardio · 08/09/2023 10:24

Definitely trust your gut and stay away from that person!

Outnumberedbyboys2 · 08/09/2023 10:22

I went to school with a guy who was very quiet, kept his head down and sat with a couple of other boys at lunch but wasn't really popular or bullied, just overlooked by most people I think.
I didn't get creepy pervert vibes from him but I did think he was very selfish, to the extreme that I can remember looking at him and thinking he didn't care about anyone but himself. Like I could tell he had no empathy? When I didn't really know him at all.
Anyway, he turned out to be a peadophile.

ManateeFair · 08/09/2023 10:19

For every person who was creeped out by someone who turned out to be a wrong'un, there are about 50 people who were creeped out by someone who turned out to be perfectly harmless. A lot of people got the creeps from Christopher Jefferies, and as a result the poor guy's life was wrecked when he was suspected of murdering Joanna Yeates even though he'd done literally nothing wrong.

However, it's not really about what's 'reasonable' or 'unreasonable'. You feel what you feel. Sometimes we do pick up on small signals and behaviours that indicate that there's something wrong. Sometimes, a totally normal person might just make us uncomfortable because of subconscious memories or unconscious biases associated with other people or situations that we probably aren't even aware of.

Either way, it's OK to have boundaries in place and it's OK to avoid someone you feel uncomfortable with.

Toomuvhonot · 08/09/2023 10:16

I remember as a kid watching TOTP2 and seeing Jimmy saville. Didn't know who he was. But he made me feel sick and creepy vibes! Wasn't suprised years later he was a peado

KohlaParasaurus · 08/09/2023 10:03

My instinct isn't at all reliable in this regard although I'd still remove myself from a situation in which I felt actual danger rather that waiting for more trustworthy evidence to emerge.

brisedusoir · 08/09/2023 09:48

There is a guy in my office building ( different company). No idea why, he gives me the chills, feel almost breathless if by accident I'm in the elevator with him. He's perfectly polite, good eye contact, appropriate small talk but just really really makes me uneasy.

Building is on a big campus that's pretty empty ( to say say totally dead ) post 8pm ish - it's about a 6/7 minute walk to get off campus and back to a road.

Let's say I work for company A and he works for company B. One evening quite late getting ready to leave I was in the lobby and there was a woman from company C who I'd never spoken to who was obviously faffing around. I asked her if she'd lost something and she just replied actually guy from company B phyiscal description has just left and I just want to give him a head start. I asked her why and she had exactly my feeling about him but no proof at all. He might be totally normal. In which case I feel sorry for him.

billy1966 · 08/09/2023 09:45

Jimmy Savile made my skin crawl too, but I didn't think about why.

He just presented as a freak to me.

Beangrove · 08/09/2023 09:43

@Gabiabbi I watched that programme too, it was Rodney Alcala I think wasn't it? He was very 'off' despite being good looking and seeming quite personable and charming, its weird how some people just have a vibe that they can't hide.

Catsarego · 08/09/2023 09:43

TheDogthatDug · 08/09/2023 08:07

I've only ever met one person who made the hairs raise on the back of my neck and that told me that I needed to get away from them. Thing is they were extremely high profile and it eventually came out that they were a wrong'un. I know I'm not going to be believed but it was Jimmy Savile. Trust your instincts.

And me. He visited my place of work in the 1980s. I didn’t want him anywhere near me

Beangrove · 08/09/2023 09:41

Not chills as such but I used to live in quite a rough area, lots of 'proper' gangs of young men hanging about etc. Never bothered me, always just used to smile and say hello as I went past, never had a problem. Until one night I was walking home from the bus stop, saw 3 lads walking towards me, and I just knew from quite far away I was going to have an issue with them even though there was nothing obviously different to all the other times I'd walked past a group of lads at night.

And I did, they surrounded me, all talked at me at the same time and started trying to shepherd me towards a dark alleyway. I faced off to them, started shouting and swearing at them as loud as I could. They decided I was too much trouble I think and walked off eventually but I was so shaken about what could have happened if I had been too frightened to react.

Gabiabbi · 08/09/2023 09:39

There was a serial killer in the 60s/70s that even went on a televised dating show. Apparently the girl who 'won' the date with him then refused to go as she got that strong intuition that something wasn't right with him.

Saz12 · 08/09/2023 09:34

IMO we're probably pretty good at subconsciously picking up things that aren't quite "right" in someones demeanor.
But Im not sure this is always accurately "hes a threat" as opposed to "pretending not to be incredibly anxious" or "really depressed but wanting to seem 'normal'" or "eye contact difficult" or whatever.
So if you feel threatened then dont stay in that situation. Because maybe you're right, and it definitely isnt worth a risk. But really if it is your subconscious is reacting to tiny cues, then you,re quite likely to be wrong, too.

SuddenlyOld · 08/09/2023 09:25

Only once - I met a bloke through OLD and first meeting was in a shopping centre. Meeting was fine, no issues. Arranged to meet in a pub local to me (he still didn't know my real name or address as this was over 20 years ago and I was still wary about the whole Internet thing).

I waited outside for him. Saw him drive past looking for the car park. He hadn't seen me but I got a very strong feeling that I should quickly go home and go nc.

I ignored the feeling and we started dating. He was a predator and did all the classic stuff of alienating me from friends and family etc. I was vulnerable at the time but kept my wits. Within 3 months I knew he was a wrong un but it took me another year to get him out of my life. In the end I changed my name and moved 400 miles away. This guy never hit me or anything but he was the worst person I've ever let close. Very scary man.

Vegetus · 08/09/2023 09:17

I mean you should definitely get out of a situation you don't feel comfortable in but I wouldn't trust your gut instinct to discern between a good/bad person.

We're pattern forming creatures and we often see and perceive things that aren't really there due to this.

So be guided by your gut but don't bet the house on it!