Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get the chills from someone I barely know at all?

144 replies

bloopingbleeping · 08/09/2023 07:59

Had my hackles rise and a strong feeling someone I hardly know is not someone to be trusted.

(I do experience anxiety to some degree already, but it’s more of a “overthink and worry” type, not being physically cold and shaky like this). I don’t believe this person is a danger to my physical safety, but I’ve hardly ever felt this unsafe even around people I know I couldn't trust.

Please tell me about times your intuition reacted to someone and whether you were wrong or right. Preferably more mundane, everyday relationships, not the rare cases of someone encountering a serial killer.

OP posts:
Blanketpolicy · 08/09/2023 13:36

I've had the chills where someone turned out to be a nasty piece of work (he is now in prison).

I've also, more often, had the chills for no apparent reason. Perhaps I just don't know what they have done, or they haven't stepped over the line yet. Or perhaps there is no reason other than subconsciously they remind me of someone else.

Whatever the reason, even if it is just because you don't like something about someone, you don't need to overthink or dramatise it. Just keep your distance.

CLC22 · 08/09/2023 13:30

The shop near me ,a guy worked there and he always gave me the creeps . A few months later a post was put on social media that this guy had wrote disgusting fantasies involving children aged 5& 7 , only got caught because he accidentally put the disgusting material through someone’s letter box instead of a form he was supposed to print out 🤢

Bringbackniles · 08/09/2023 13:25

I've worked with lots of different people over the years, colleagues and the public.
I met plenty of unstable, volatile people but always felt OK.

There was just one young woman I had to train who I felt uneasy around. I couldn't put my finger on it. She was really nice to me and we chatted a lot and she said she thinks I have 'the gift' - in a spiritual way. It's not the first time I've been told this but I didn't like it this time.

Anyway, one day, a lady came to talk to me from the place where this young woman had worked previously. She was emphatic that we should get rid of her and that if we didn't, we would be very sorry. It was all very weird. I responded professionally but felt unsettled.

She left shortly after anyway. No idea what happened to her.

TotalOverhaul · 08/09/2023 13:24

Gillstuck · 08/09/2023 12:33

@TheDogthatDug I remember feeling uncomfortable as a small child, when I was watching him on his fix it programme. A girl wrote in asking to be a dancer in a pop band. He fixed her up to dance with with Gary Glitter and his band. The poor girl looked like a haunted animal sitting on the sofa between them. I've never forgotten it. It didn't feel right to me then and I'm horrified for her now. I hope she's OK.

I remember a boy on Jim'll Fix It asking to dance with Lyndsey de Paul. He seemed really reluctant to do it when the time came, and had tears in his eyes. Saville was bullying him and saying, 'Look like you're enjoying it more!' I remember not understanding at all but think Saville was horrible and couldn't he see the boy was very upset about something. Now I can only imagine what that was.

ScaredOfMonsters · 08/09/2023 13:21

I don’t think there’s anything magic or woo about it but we are definitely capable of instinctively discerning threats - some are not dangerous, such as with British house spiders and we can educate ourselves out of our phobic reactions and get help to understand them. It’s an evolutionary thing that no longer serves us. With certain men it’s the other way, we are socialised so hard to overrule our instincts for fear of making them uncomfortable that we distrust our unease. There are probably dozens of nonverbal hints that we read in an instant without being aware of the process.

Lots of men make me uncomfortable but every so often I have that visceral, intense fear, a sort of revulsion, and the last time that happened it subsequently transpired that he was a literal monster, a respected professional in a position of trust for the sole purpose of abusing the most vulnerable children of all.

hookiewookie29 · 08/09/2023 13:18

Catsarego · 08/09/2023 09:43

And me. He visited my place of work in the 1980s. I didn’t want him anywhere near me

He gave me the creeps just watching him on TV!

Ascendant15 · 08/09/2023 13:12

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 08/09/2023 08:04

You are going to get a load of posts telling you about how they’d felt chills, and identified a serial killer following a 10 second meeting. Some will even insist they knew a person was a wrong’un, even though there’s no evidence to back this at all.

Before getting tied up with all these, just look up confirmation bias.

That may be true, but it also doesn't invalidate instinct - we are animals like any other and our instincts developed to help keep us safe just like any other animal. What we need to be able to do is to examine whether there are other factors at play that lead us to unfairly trust instinct above reason - which is the thing that other animals cannot do.

Some 20 years ago a friend of mine asked if I would do some photography for a family event (it's a hobby but I am quite good). It was alrage event. Her fathers 90th. There was one person there that everyone wante to chat to an was flitting around like a social butterfly. I had an "instinct". I really couldn't understand it at the time. He was a lovely chap, friendly, outgoing and above all really pleasant. I still don't know what it was that I was feeling or why I was so uncomfortable because there genuinely was nothing at all about him to cause this. His name was Jimmy Saville.

anotherthrowawayname · 08/09/2023 13:09

I hated a friend's partner on sight. There was nothing obviously bad about him, but my gut told me he was awful.

Over a decade later, she finally left him because of DV. I wish I could have spared her that decade, but there is nothing you can do to make someone leave a partner unless they are ready.

For some reason, I think it's easier to identify a bad'un when it's someone else's partner. We all have a blind spot when it's our own.

PS I don't usually hate my friends' partners - this was a first!

Darkdiamond · 08/09/2023 13:06

Yes. While talking to the new guy in work, who everyone liked and who I did too, I was just chatting to him one day and got a sense of something. It stopped me in my tracks and I suddenly knew he was dangerous. It was like a coldness emanting from his eyes. I told my good friend in work who said I was mad as he was so nice.

Soon after, she came to me and said she had noticed him doing and saying things she didn't like. She found him sneaky. One things after another happened, until we discovered that he had been sacked from his last job for inappropriate behaviour with a teenager. It sounded like grooming. More and more people started coming out of the woodwork with things they'd heard about his past and more and more people started to drop him.

Eventually he moved on. He was a total creep and I knew it before I knew it.

TomatoSandwiches · 08/09/2023 13:05

I've felt this quite a few times in my life, unfortunately from a very young age but the strongest sensation was in a shoe shop. It was very busy so I have no idea what my brain picked up but one man with a wife and 2 boys set this absolute sense of dread and animal like fear off. I couldn't keep my eyes off him, I felt like I needed to know exactly where he was at all times, I probably looked like a nut but I essentially was stalking him around the room visually because I was frozen on the spot, my heart was pounding by the time they left.

FOJN · 08/09/2023 13:04

Trust your instincts. Better to be wrong than find out why someone put you on high alert.

SeminalAlbum · 08/09/2023 13:01

I had it with a local woman I met a few months ago. A voice entered my head saying, " don't tell her where you live! Don't let her in your home!" I sense she is rather chaotic. Others agree.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 08/09/2023 12:56

Read the gift of fear by Gavin de Becker

Dramatic · 08/09/2023 12:51

Yeah I've had it, and I get it more frequently nowadays. My ex was very abusive and as soon as I get similar vibes from someone I instantly think they're a wrong'un.

Tapasita · 08/09/2023 12:48

Yes, we used to work in a big open-plan office with another team sat near us. Combined together the head count of both teams must have been 150, and all fine except for one man in the other team (he must have been around early 30’s at the time.) He was so friendly and amiable with everyone, got on with his job etc. But for some inexplicable reason I disliked having to go over to his desk to talk to him if I had a query - he gave me really uneasy vibes. I even remember saying to a friend once that he was a ticking time bomb waiting to go off.

And then……one day, just before lunchtime we were all heads down, involved in our work & we just heard this almighty crash, then a man screaming and shouting in fury at the top of his voice. Then more heavy crashes. He had just flipped and we could see him shoving people, throwing punches, picking up file boxes and launching them into the air. Tables and chairs were going over. Four big burly security men rushed in and pinned him to the floor, one had blood running down his face, in the fracas but he wouldn’t let go.

We literally ran out of that place down the back flight of stairs and understood later than police had been called and he’d been taken into custody.

I have honestly never been so frightened in my life, I think we were all traumatised by that. I remember standing in the car park and a group of us just sobbing with fear. So terrifying

WellPlaced · 08/09/2023 12:43

I had this with someone I randomly saw in the street at times. Eventually circumstances arose that we engaged in conversation and they seemed normal and lovely, for about 10 minutes, and then they weren’t ….

SingingSands · 08/09/2023 12:40

Not chills, but I did meet someone at a sports club event recently who gave me "off" vibes. He seemed too interested in me, I was getting an undercurrent of him trying to dig for information and align himself with something, it was weird and I suddenly felt I had to walk away.

2 weeks later I've found out that he's scammed a young woman from my club out of a substantial sum of money and disappeared. We're now trying to establish if anyone else has been scammed. It's sensitive because some people will be too embarrassed to say they have.

When I found out I did remember how I felt uneasy and was glad I walked away!

jlpth · 08/09/2023 12:38

My granny once met a notorious serial killer in the course of every day life - before he was caught. He was a pleasant local man and she made him a cup of tea. You can never tell. In your case though, I would not ignore the awful vibes you get from this person though. Can you keep away from him?

Gillstuck · 08/09/2023 12:33

@TheDogthatDug I remember feeling uncomfortable as a small child, when I was watching him on his fix it programme. A girl wrote in asking to be a dancer in a pop band. He fixed her up to dance with with Gary Glitter and his band. The poor girl looked like a haunted animal sitting on the sofa between them. I've never forgotten it. It didn't feel right to me then and I'm horrified for her now. I hope she's OK.

54isanopendoor · 08/09/2023 12:24

Trust your gut - the only times I haven't I've later regretted it.
Read: 'The Gift of Fear' by Gavin de Becker.

Nottodaty · 08/09/2023 12:23

I was sat on a train recently and a group of 3 men got on and sat down. Within their group chatting and laughing - nothing they were doing was intrusive or wrong. Chatting about mundane things.

But one of those men made me very uncomfortable- just something about him. I can’t remember what the other two even looked at but his face is burnt in my brain and still gives me chills.

No idea why, but months later it still makes me shudder.

travelogue · 08/09/2023 12:15

A bloke who lives down the road from me - I once posted about him on here as I thought his behaviour was strange and slightly scary. He was friendly enough, seemed intelligent and had a plausible backstory but was weirdly over familiar - clearly wanted to come in despite the fact I was trying very hard to give off "we are really busy, it's Sunday lunch and I don't know you please go away" vibes.

I avoid him now and don't engage. However... I also think it's possible he's completely harmless and there's a perfectly acceptable reason why he seemed odd to me. I feel a bit guilty every time I go past his house in case I've unfairly judged him, but then I give myself permission not to be friendly to a stranger if I don't want to be. I don't want to is a valid reason.

A time I was definitely right about a gut instinct was when I thought a guy on the train was very "off"- although he didn't do or say anything - I left it to the last minute to get off the train at my stop on the basis that if it was his stop he'd get off first as he was by the doors, and sure enough he followed me. (I then went the wrong way / doubled back on myself at which point he gave himself away so I know I wasn't imagining it - had to ditch him by going into my local newsagent) then phoned the police who said I should have called them earlier / as it was happening 🧐hardly going to start fumbling with your bag and phone if you think you might be about to be mugged, but anyway.

amlie8 · 08/09/2023 12:03

DisquietintheRanks · 08/09/2023 11:22

The "witch" woman who lived at the end of our street and her weird (mentally disabled) son. We kids all knew that there was something "off" about them.

Except there wasn't. It was sheer, unmitigated prejudice.

This is clearly not at all the sort of thing other posters are talking about.

Women need to trust their instincts, not have them undermined.

heartdog · 08/09/2023 12:02

You can definitely get a gut feeling but it's nothing more than an early warning that often will be wrong. You unconsciously picked up on some small signs that could have indicated danger, so your brain warns you but it's more than likely it was a one off and they are not a threat. Think of all the people you immediately like , who you may not be so keen on a few months later, our immediate gut feeling is nothing to be relied on. I think there are some true stories here mixed with some fabrications. I wish the number of posts stating a person was later convicted of rape was a true reflection of conviction rates for rape in this country.

toucaninjapan · 08/09/2023 11:38

Yes, it did happen to me once. My boyfriend drove me to my block of apartments and I walked 3m to the entrance door, noticing that there are 2 guys walking about 30m away in my direction. There was something about them I sensed that I didn't like.
I've opened the door with the code, made sure it closed after me and heard my boyfriend driving away. I didn't go for the elevator though, nor did I take the stairs, instead I stood near the security room with my mobile in my hand, and sure enough, I've heard the entrance door open immediately and these two guys sprint inside in full speed. They've stopped when they saw me standing where I was and we stared at each other for several seconds, after which they've slowly headed towards the elevator. I was lucky that day...

Swipe left for the next trending thread