Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Martin Lewis

114 replies

Aserena · 08/09/2023 00:42

often comes across as condescending?
Especially on his podcast.

I’m no financial whizz and I’m genuinely grateful to him for breaking things down simple. It’s his manner rather than the content that I find irritating. AIBU?

OP posts:
Seashellies · 08/09/2023 09:21

You don't have to like the way he presents but this is a labour of love for him and he really cares about it.

He's also made tens of millions doing it, whilst it's clear he's passionate about it and at the end of the day he's helped many people; but he isn't doing it out of the goodness of his heart alone and he has the capacity to spend a lot of time on it as he never has to worry about money ever again.

Elphame · 08/09/2023 09:20

I have no time for him since he pushed those Icelandic banks.

I was warning my clients constantly about the risks in having their money there. He was very lucky that the UK govt stepped in to underwrite the losses. Those banks were outside the deposit protection scheme

timetorefresh · 08/09/2023 09:16

He's brilliant and he's explaining things for everyone. Some people might struggle more than others and to be honest the ones that need it simplified probably need to understand the most

SuperNewMe · 08/09/2023 09:11

@manontroppo
The UK likes to shit on people who try and help people get ideas above their station, see also Jamie Oliver. MN absolutely shat all over him, and it felt like MN don’t want the plebs and chavs to see any improvement, which would destroy their smug sense of superiority
Agree with this

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 08/09/2023 09:09

Knew him at uni. We lost touch but unless he has changed a lot he is exactly as he presents. Incredibly kind, passionate about consumer finance, naturally high-energy, generous with his time. You don't have to like the way he presents but this is a labour of love for him and he really cares about it.

Deathbyfluffy · 08/09/2023 09:03

Fairyliz · 08/09/2023 06:21

He’s clearly a clever man, seen a gap in the market and filled it.
For those who ask why he doesn’t use his financial knowledge to make money, he has! Apparently he is worth £123m so I am a little bemused by the ‘he’s just doing it to help people comments’.

If he can fill a gap while helping people, what’s wrong with that?
I can’t think of one other person that has saved people more money collectively, and I work in the financial industry.

Aserena · 08/09/2023 08:59

stickygotstuck · 08/09/2023 08:19

What is fascinating to me about this thread is the emphasis the OP (and some PPs) place on his manner/delivery.

The comments about his likely introversion and him not being a people person makes him even more admirable. His speed is so that he can cram all the info. And likely because of his relative unease in public.

And they help to explain OP's attitude of, yes, he'd helped so many people but he's not likeable like celebs are supposed to be.

That's the way of the world for many introverts and not especially sociable people. You might be a fantastic human being, but if you are not 'nice' and conventional, you're not worth some people's time.

An interesting point, so thank you.

However, just to stand my own corner here, I’m not into ‘celeb’ culture, so I don’t really have any views on how they are ‘meant to be’. I like plenty of introverted, awkward and/or unpopular people.

I form opinions about people based on the personal qualities that I observe in them (subjectively, of course). Being an introvert / extrovert is not a trait that would sway my opinion in either direction. Introverts may find it harder to relax and display their full personality, but that is on us (as I do tend to count myself in this number) I’m afraid, because nobody has a right to be liked.

OP posts:
dudsville · 08/09/2023 08:56

Easier said than done for some, but don't take the position of beig offended or condescended or patronised. If you think someone else is behavig in these ways, that's on them, the position you take in response is down to you.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 08/09/2023 08:55

YABU he’s great, never found him condescending, he’s well aware of peoples debt, limited funds- he’s never scolding he’s pragmatic

BarbaraofSeville · 08/09/2023 08:54

Can you please explain what you think is wrong with the current mortgage charter? Genuinely interested?

It looks like a pretty sensible way of helping people who would otherwise not be able to afford their new mortgage payment, which could be much higher than currently, without risking losing their home or destroying their credit rating, which generally makes life more difficult and expensive for several years.

It can also be treated as a temporary breathing space, while people explore whether more drastic options like downsizing are necessary.

What would your preferred solution be for people in this position?

indigovapour · 08/09/2023 08:45

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 08/09/2023 01:49

Martin Lewis is often trying to chunk down and simplify highly convoluted financial information which is designed to fleece people struggling on low incomes.

Yes, this. I don't think that most of us will ever really appreciate just how much lofty knowledge he breaks down so that we can understand it!

I also think that he's naturally a real introvert who isn't overly comfortable with the public profile that he has, but he realises (humbly) that he has a unique gift and he tolerates the fame for the greater good of using his gift to help the ordinary man and woman.

It is so refreshing, when you realise how very easily he could have used his 'powers' to royally take advantage of everyday folk; but instead, he uses them to stay one step ahead of the great many who DO want to do exactly that, but he can outsmart them on our behalf - they must really hate him, and be baffled as to why he doesn't just join them on the dark side!

Edited

I like him for similar reasons. You can often tell he's not comfortable presenting but does it anyway, which as another introvert I can appreciate.

I work in financial services and think he does a pretty good job of explaining what's what. He does sometimes get it wrong (the recent mortgage charter into which he apparently had input is an example) but in general he gets it right.

I also think it's notable that he's retained his passion for what he does despite having long since made his own millions, so I believe he really does want to help people.

stickygotstuck · 08/09/2023 08:19

What is fascinating to me about this thread is the emphasis the OP (and some PPs) place on his manner/delivery.

The comments about his likely introversion and him not being a people person makes him even more admirable. His speed is so that he can cram all the info. And likely because of his relative unease in public.

And they help to explain OP's attitude of, yes, he'd helped so many people but he's not likeable like celebs are supposed to be.

That's the way of the world for many introverts and not especially sociable people. You might be a fantastic human being, but if you are not 'nice' and conventional, you're not worth some people's time.

BringMeTea · 08/09/2023 08:03

Really OP, you admit he does 'great' things yet still you started a thread to shit on him. Can you not think of ANYONE else in the public eye in the UK that might be more deserving of your ire? Puzzling.

Seashellies · 08/09/2023 08:02

He does good work but his flouncing from social media after the Christmas song controversy instead of owning it showed he's human like the rest of us. Perfectly fine to recognise someone does stuff that benefits others and can be condescending/annoying/ego driven etc.

grass321 · 08/09/2023 08:00

I just find myself getting annoyed without fail when I listen to him, and, seeing as I have never heard anybody say anything even slightly negative about him in any way whatsoever, I wondered if I am literally the only one who feels this way. Clearly the answer is that I am very much in the minority

You're not the only one. You can appreciate his crusade without necessarily liking him personally.

Good for him, he's earned his millions on a good cause and he deserves it. But I gather he wasn't easy to work for and prone to shouting at people (friend of a colleague stuff so perhaps should be taken with a punch of salt).

I think he's just quite full of himself, and his blog comes across that way too, 100% support the cause he's pushing and he's done a tremendous job making personal finance more accessible.

VanGoghsDog · 08/09/2023 07:59

Aserena · 08/09/2023 07:37

Some people have asked for examples, I could give plenty but I’m not going to because, contrary to accusation, I’m not out to ‘bash’ him and am not trying to persuade anyone. I was just putting out feelers to see what you all had to say.
If you’re curious, then listen to his podcast a few times and decide for yourself.

Actually, I felt he was slightly condescending to Nehal in this week's podcast.

I don't have any issue with him, and I know he has to simplify complex issues, so that side I'm fine with. And the audience has a wide base of understanding.

Funnily enough, most of my financial knowledge came from a website he's not very keen on.

Redlarge · 08/09/2023 07:57

No hes fab

SauronsArsehole · 08/09/2023 07:55

He’s trying to serve the lowest common denominator whilst also appealing to the masses and giving the right information.

so yeah he’ll come across as condescending, a bit rude etc it’s a tricky place to navigate.

for those who think he talks fast. YouTube his shows and slow the replay speed down 😜

LadyEloise1 · 08/09/2023 07:54

I wish we had someone like Martin Lewis in Ireland.

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 07:52

@determinedtomakethiswork I agree his show should be longer and he has so much to impart to us. It's a me thing rather than a him thing I guess. ☺️

Inkpotlover · 08/09/2023 07:49

I think you are mistaking condescension for abrupt delivery. He talks super fast, because he wants to impart as much information as he can in the amount of air time he's given. Frankly, the man deserves all the medals. Unlike politicians, he actually gives a shit about people living in poverty and does everything he can to help. It's thanks to him we as a family dodged the soaring energy bills and mortgage rise crisis because we fixed well before on his advice.

I couldn't care how he comes across, as long as he keeps doing it.

determinedtomakethiswork · 08/09/2023 07:44

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 01:34

I've never heard his podcasts, but I do enjoy his website/articles.

However, I cannot bear to watch his tv show - it's frenetic and irritates me beyond measure.

I think the problem with that is that he has so much information to pass on and the program isn't long enough. He could do with a much longer program. You can tell that he is desperate to tell you everything that he knows.

Marmalade71 · 08/09/2023 07:39

@BarbaraofSeville that's the point, the advice wasn't caveated - what you've described is the nuanced message he gives on mortgage rates but on this he was quite clear that we shouldn't fix, which is why I was so gutted I had just done so. And then very soon afterwards people lost the ability to switch as the market effectively shut down.

I'm only mentioning this because his advice is normally so strong, it's noteworthy only because it's unusual. But as you say, the circumstances were fairly unprecedented.

midgemadgemodge · 08/09/2023 07:38

Criticism of his manner seems particularly petty especially when it's your applying an arbitrary negative interpretation to his intent

I mean why not critique his dress sense whilst you are at it

Both completely irrelevant to what he does ( brilliantly ) which is communicate clearly and accurately

Loadedbydeath · 08/09/2023 07:38

Aserena · 08/09/2023 07:27

Ah, there we go then. IABU.

Not trying to ‘launch a character assassination’, and as you read in my OP I don’t deny that what he does is great.

I just find myself getting annoyed without fail when I listen to him, and, seeing as I have never heard anybody say anything even slightly negative about him in any way whatsoever, I wondered if I am literally the only one who feels this way. Clearly the answer is that I am very much in the minority.

Ignore the mob especially the "how can I make you out to be an ableist bigot" effort. If you find his manner annoying you find it annoying. It's neither reasonable nor unreasonable.