Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
greyflannel · 08/09/2023 07:53

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 06:48

Yes Ive made this point several times, there is a cohort of individuals where the symptoms of trauma are being assessed as traits of ND disorders.

There is a growing awareness of this within various disciplines, some assessors are fairly skilled at recognising attachment difficulties but others are not and so dont understand the differences.

One day its likely there will be a physical/medical test for ND disorders which not only will allow for easier diagnosis but equally separate out the different cohorts.

I don't know why you think such a test will be available for autism when the absence of reliable biomarkers is one of the most striking aspects of the last 50 or so years of research?

AgnesX · 08/09/2023 07:51

People are ableist towards people who have obvious disabilities. It's not a complete surprise that they're ableist to people with hidden disabilities.

Note that I said nothing about it being right or fair.

itsmyp4rty · 08/09/2023 07:48

DoggoMcDogface · 08/09/2023 07:29

I also suspect that if we had gone down the NHS route she wouldn't have got the diagnosis.

The criteria is the criteria, whether NHS or private.

This just isn't true now, because in many areas you can't even get assessed if you don't have severe problems either at home or at school any more. They can't cope with the numbers and the waiting lists look bad so kids that don't have bad behavioural or mental health problems are just going to be left to cope without a diagnosis.

Pawpawpatrol · 08/09/2023 07:48

It's not really straightforward to obtain medication for ADHD in the UK. Bit of a myth that ADHD medication is widely over prescribed in people who dont have the disorder (perhaps in the US, but not here in the UK).

UK GPs cannot diagnose ADHD (possibly some tiny minority with a special interest and accreditation to do so, but not ordinary GPs). They make an assessment with the patient based on a standardised questionnaire and then decide whether to refer to services that do make ADHD assessments. The wait list for such services on the NHS is something like 2 years. The diagnostic process then involves face to face assessment but they are also looking for evidence from childhood such as school reports and statements from family members etc. Diagnosis is made by psychiatrists or psychologists who specialise in neurodivergence. They may then discuss medication.

You can bypass this process to an extent by seeing a private provider. People are more likely to be doing this because they want to avoid a 2 year wait than because they don't want their diagnosis to be appropriately scrutinised.

If you are then diagnosed and medication is recommended, it can be very difficult to get your GP to issue ongoing prescriptions for ADHD medication. Prescriptions recommended by secondary care which are unlicensed or unfamiliar to GPs require a shared care agreement and in general GPs may not feel adequately compensated or protected for the risk they take on in prescribing +/- monitoring these medications. If you have an NHS diagnosis then at least you can obtain NHS prescriptions from the secondary care provider. But if you only have a private diagnosis you may find yourself in the position of having to pay privately for ongoing prescriptions, which is very expensive.

Lastly there is a notion, or myth really, that ADHD medication is wonderful, improves performance in everyone, has no side effects, is a way for cheating life / exams / you name it. These medications come with side effects (affecting sleep, mood, headaches) and many people have to trial several different ones or can't tolerate them at all. Lots of people with diagnosed ADHD aren't taking medication and behavioural and talking therapies / coping strategies etc are also frequently offered.

Given the state of ADHD assessment it's not that unexpected that some people with traits recognise those traits and implement strategies for coping with them, without a formal diagnosis. I really don't see the harm. People with a self diagnosis cannot access medication for ADHD.

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 07:44

electriclight · 08/09/2023 05:43

It is actually quite difficult in schools, or certainly in those I've worked in.

Many pupils self-diagnose after seeing posts on social media. I had one pupil tell me she had ADHD because she rubs her feet together in bed, and she showed me the post. Sometimes they convince their parents on skimpy evidence, sometimes parents seize on it as a reason for their child working below age expectations or being in trouble.

I have also seen parents go to several private practitioners, who do not find their child to be ND, until they eventually get the diagnosis they want. The worst of these reports was on one sheet of A4 and written in very poor English, and was obtained in a city a three hour drive from us after the expense of three failed reports.

I think the journalist who was in the press recently for obtaining a false diagnosis has confirmed what some people already thought.

I hope I am not ablist. I support all of my pupils whether they have a diagnosis or needs suggesting they need one, and comply with the recommendations in every report I receive.

I think you probably do need to reflect on what drives you to discuss a family's private medical experiences on an internet forum, or what makes you feel entitled to dismiss the views of a medical professional? Not really for you to pick and choose the ones you see as legitimate.

Of course the real scandal is the lack of funding for SEND provision and the practice of LA's disputing independent medical evidence in order to reduce the cost of EHCP provision. This seems to have led to a culture in some schools where teachers feel able to reject medical evidence, for instance where a child is masking. it's an appalling situation for children and families who are already struggling and are being let down by organisations with statutory responsibilities to provide support.

Messyhair321 · 08/09/2023 07:42

Masterofhappydays · 07/09/2023 22:59

Bit of a tangent post here, sorry!

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd.

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

So I do think there are some people in some places who are diagnosed incorrectly.

I suppose it’s difficult as I guess some parents have blamed neurodivergence for their poor parenting 🤷‍♀️

I am neurodiverse so I do find this interesting.

Schools don't generally get funded on diagnosis, they should be funding on need, what is presented. That's my understanding.

Also your neuroscience friend is doing what most non believers of neurodivergent people do, & blaming this on parents or environment. I don't think this is cool anymore.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 08/09/2023 07:40

Does it matter if it's not "pure" ASD/ADHD if it's caused by trauma rather than genetics.

It's like comparing someone born without a leg to someone who lost their leg in an accident - they'll still need crutches or a prosthetic and accommodations. There's still something going on.

DaisyWaldron · 08/09/2023 07:33

I'm seeing some comments about some kids not having ADHD, just feckless parents looking for an excuse, and I think that it's worth pointing out that ADHD is y heritable. Many of the people I know with ADHD and autism diagnoses were diagnosed as a result of their children's diagnosis.

So when you see a child who is showing signs of ADHD AND whose parent is regularly late, loses bits of their child's uniform, doesn't fill in permission slips or pay for trips, doesn't show up to parents evening and forgets to make a lunch for their child, it's certainly possible that a feckless parent is looking for excuses for their child's bad behaviour, but it's also very likely that the parent also has ADHD and is struggling with parenting as a result.

This is one of the reasons why adult diagnosis is actually very important - plenty of people can just about manage with ADHD until they have children, and then everything just collapses.

DoggoMcDogface · 08/09/2023 07:29

I also suspect that if we had gone down the NHS route she wouldn't have got the diagnosis.

The criteria is the criteria, whether NHS or private.

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/09/2023 07:28

Yabu

Coming from a family severely impacted by it, its actually the genuine sufferers that face ableism when it's pointed out that that there is a tidal wave claiming to have ADHD that don't.

People are desperate to self label with many not having a bloody clue how it destroys lives. When you dare to question their self diagnosis based on a few tik tok videos you are shouted downland called ableist. Utter nonsense.

It's disingenuous to pretending it isn't happening.

Aishah231 · 08/09/2023 07:24

Sorry OP but it is overdiagnosed and over medicated. Some parents do push for a diagnosis to explain away poor behaviour. This is a problem mostly for the genuinely ND who are taken less seriously than they should be because of it.

AutismProf · 08/09/2023 07:23

Part of a multidisciplinary autism diagnostic team here.

Correcting one or two misapprehensions:

We always consider attachment and trauma as an alternative hypothesis. The presentations are often subtly different in fact. It's also true that unpicking ND and trauma isn't always easy as being ND in an NT world can be traumatising, but again, slightly different presentation.

We do not diagnose, ever, just based on a list of traits that a parent has made. We always triangulate. We always work directly with the child.

Sporkle99 · 08/09/2023 07:22

FOJN · 07/09/2023 23:01

I thought the point of he thread you are referring to was about posters attributing all and any behaviour to ADHD/ASD which I would have thought was insulting to anyone who actually is affected.

That was my thread, where a few posters came on to tell me my symptoms aren't indicative of ADHD (they are, it's just because I don't have the 'classic' hyperactivity). It was mainly supportive with a few people saying that ADHD is used as an excuse for laziness. I know myself and know that the fact that I have lots of symptoms, have beeb diagnosed with OCD but then told by a specialist in OCD that I should have an ADHD assessment, paired with my struggles throughout childhood to adulthood warrant an assessment. Hopefully ADHD specialists know what they're doing, I'm sure some aren't great, but I'd argue that the vast majority of people who have an ADHD diagnosis have ADHD. Many will be like me with a misdiagnosis when it's something else (aka my wrong OCD diagnosis). And a very tiny amount of neurotypical people will be diagnosed. But that's the case with a lot of things.

MajesticWhine · 08/09/2023 07:11

My DD was recently diagnosed with autism via a private clinic. We were not especially chasing a diagnosis, but we were being encouraged by school.
On being told of her diagnosis I was told that 20 years ago she would probably not have met the criteria but that now, more is being understood about autism and how it presents, especially for girls. So the definition of autism is effectively getting broader.
I also suspect that if we had gone down the NHS route she wouldn't have got the diagnosis. This is anecdotal but I work in psychology and come across young women who did not apparently meet the threshold but seem more obviously autistic than DD.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 07:03

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 08/09/2023 06:54

A trauma informed model can be quite helpful, but people - including professionals - also need to remember that like with neurodiversity (especially undiagnosed neurodiversity) in a NT world is a pretty traumatising experience in itself. It doesn't mean that a child is being misdiagnosed as autistic or with ADHD. The two are not entirely exclusive. And this is a massive misconception that parents, families and those who are autistic/ADHD have to fight. It is so easy to slip back into parent blaming rather than just supporting the child and family.

The 2 are not exclusive at all, and my experience wont be the same as many people here, I have a sibling with autism, but know that there was a high likelihood of an attachment disorder cross over, or misdiagnosis for that

In terms of my work, I see quite a specific cohort where trauma and attachment are a huge feature and I have been involved in several assessments where even though the child does not live with the parent anymore, the parent, rightly, is still part of the assessment. Parents in those situations will either not understand or actively minimise the child's exposure to trauma/violence/neglect in the past and no matter the history that we as professionals have provided there seems to be a minimising of those issues once the assessment takes place.

Ive had several assessors, years on, who are still working with the child that we are working with reflect that they may not have made that diagnosis all those years ago because as the child has developed its clearer that the issues were trauma/attachment based.

Gerrataere · 08/09/2023 06:57

Oh gosh doctors just give in for ASD diagnosis? Gosh I wish they had with my eldest, we wouldnt have lost 2 years fighting for his needs to be recognised. I probably would have given up if his school hadn’t been absolutely adamant and over those years his ASD and adhd traits did become very evident. I even had one doctor draw a straight line and say ‘if we look at autism, your son is here at the closer end of normal so not much point looking for a diagnosis’. Any parent of a ASD child will read that and know how awful that train of thought is.

Children like him who are (seemingly) fully verbal and academically able are at huge risk of being let down or misdiagnosed - and it would have been worse if he’d been born female.

As for myself, yes I am very convinced I have ADHD and very likely ASD. It’s not just the little ‘I’ve seen it on TikTok’ silly symptoms people come out with. I first said ‘I think I have adhd’ at 15 years old over 20 years ago and nobody listened then. My mother even said she thought I was autistic and did nothing about it. Now have to wait an infinite amount of time for an NHS diagnosis of adhd but in the meantime I can start healing from the colossal amount of shit and abuse I went through due to not having the condition/s recognised my whole life.

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 08/09/2023 06:54

A trauma informed model can be quite helpful, but people - including professionals - also need to remember that like with neurodiversity (especially undiagnosed neurodiversity) in a NT world is a pretty traumatising experience in itself. It doesn't mean that a child is being misdiagnosed as autistic or with ADHD. The two are not entirely exclusive. And this is a massive misconception that parents, families and those who are autistic/ADHD have to fight. It is so easy to slip back into parent blaming rather than just supporting the child and family.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 06:48

Masterofhappydays · 07/09/2023 22:59

Bit of a tangent post here, sorry!

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd.

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

So I do think there are some people in some places who are diagnosed incorrectly.

I suppose it’s difficult as I guess some parents have blamed neurodivergence for their poor parenting 🤷‍♀️

I am neurodiverse so I do find this interesting.

Yes Ive made this point several times, there is a cohort of individuals where the symptoms of trauma are being assessed as traits of ND disorders.

There is a growing awareness of this within various disciplines, some assessors are fairly skilled at recognising attachment difficulties but others are not and so dont understand the differences.

One day its likely there will be a physical/medical test for ND disorders which not only will allow for easier diagnosis but equally separate out the different cohorts.

spanieleyes · 08/09/2023 06:46

Schools do NOT get additional funding for a diagnosed child. We too are under pressure from parents for a diagnosis ( in my county, we gather the evidence for the paediatricians to diagnose), we have been back to school 2 days and I've had my first request- we usually get a few after the summer holidays. Some may be ADHD/ASD, some may be trauma induced and some are just six weeks of behaviours!

MidnightOnceMore · 08/09/2023 06:41

LordSalem · 08/09/2023 00:47

The vast majority of people today are not decent human beings. They're cruel, critical, judgemental, selfish, ignorant, rude, loud and cold. This applies to any given situation. The semantics or variables rarely matter or make a difference.
Imagine where we'll be in ten years when middle aged people are acting like this now without a second thought and we're already suffering from gangs of teenage and younger kids daily as well. And they find it funny, big and clever to intimidate and attack adults as well as other kids, and vandalise as they see fit because they are getting zero comeuppance in any way whatsoever.
This isn't civilisation, it's who can shout the loudest and get away with anything.
Historically it's fucking pathetic.
ND? No one gives a shit. NT no one gives a shit. You're a target for abuse either way.
People aren’t people, they're vicious bastards who jump at any excuse to discriminate against whatever they decide (on a whim) is different to them,

This is a distorted perspective.

Our society has great challenges but in schools, workplaces, streets and other places most people are decent.

If you go into my local city centre, most people are fine.

Dragonwindow · 08/09/2023 06:41

I my experience, a lot of people confuse executive dysfunction with ADHD. One of the main indicators of ADHD is executive dysfunction, but there are many many reasons for this that aren't ADHD.

As mentioned above, it can be hard even for doctors to pick apart. I don't believe doctors are handing out diagnoses just because parents are being tricky, but they are sometimes too quick to reach for the most socially understood and accepted diagnosis. This was seen clearly on the panorama documentary. I don't think it's ableist to recognise this.

Spottypineapple · 08/09/2023 06:19

Something interesting I heard in a podcast yesterday (it was the latest episode of the Better Birth podcast about neurodiversity in pregnancy/birth/midwifery if you're interested)

'there are more left handed people than there used to be' well there aren't. Left handed people are accepted now and we don't try to change them or force them to conform to the right handed majority. But we aren't up in arms about how many left handed people there are now!

Same for neurodiversity. There aren't 'more' neurodiverse people. There is more awareness and self awareness. They also said it's likely that 20% of the population experience some form of ND and that it's woefully under diagnosed in women, who don't receive a diagnosis on average until the age of 18. (Due to the stereotype of ND only affecting 'naughty little boys' )

MaggieBsBoat · 08/09/2023 06:16

on the other side of the coin, my aunt traipsed her two kids round seemingly endless doctors and clinics and to specialists to get her two totally NT kids diagnosed with ASD until she found one (private) who would.
I have 3 autistic children and it always seemed so ludicrous to me that a person would do this.

ChillysWaterBottle · 08/09/2023 05:49

As I said, BBC has poor form for reporting on this issue. Panorama's last attempt resulted in an on-air apology forced by its own Trust. The fact that Carson lied to the private clinics and did not disclose he was doing an 'investigation' for the BBC to support the narrative that ADHD was overdiagnosed, but DID tell the NHS Dr (who conveniently already had a bee in his bonnet about private assessments), is indicative of the quality of the 'research' this article is based on. Carson claims he was honest in all his assessments but gives no more details including how he controlled for his own internal biases - ie he was looking for a specific outcome from the beginning, otherwise he wouldn't have a story. There was no reporting on how long Carson would've had to have waited to have a proper assessment in the NHS (instead of the sham one for the article), and obviously no way of telling what they would've said.

This off the back of numerous reports finding that ADHD 'is under-identified, under-diagnosed, and under-treated. Many seeking help for ADHD face prejudice, long waiting lists, and patchy or unavailable services' (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8017218/) confirmed by the later cross party debate where the poor provision on the NHS and the harm it was causing was discussed and confirmed. It's such dishonest, superficial and agenda-driven journalism but it makes some very unpleasant right-wingers happy I guess.

Failure of Healthcare Provision for Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in the United Kingdom: A Consensus Statement

Background: Despite evidence-based national guidelines for ADHD in the United Kingdom (UK), ADHD is under-identified, under-diagnosed, and under-treated. Many seeking help for ADHD face prejudice, long waiting lists, and patchy or unavailable services,...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8017218

Dolphinnoises · 08/09/2023 05:45

Getting diagnosed with ADHD / autism isn’t like getting a virus diagnosed. You don’t just go into the GP with some symptoms off the internet and come out with your Ritalin prescription. It’s an all-day series of tests with a clinical psychologist. Or it certainly was for DD…