Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Willyoujustbequiet · 08/09/2023 08:51

User98866 · 08/09/2023 08:28

In the U.K. it’s fallen largely into the hands of private practice so of course it’s going to be over diagnosed. Many clinics are not well run and certainly are diagnosing people who wouldn’t be on the NHS. Look at the figures in the USA. Are you really suggested that in some areas 15% + children have ADHD? I feel sorry for those who are genuinely disabled by it. People are viewing it like the latest fashionable mental health diagnosis and forgetting it’s a serious life long disability.

This

It's not ableist to point this out.

peonies23 · 08/09/2023 08:44

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

This subject makes me so angry so I won't post my thoughts but thank you for starting this thread. I was thinking the same. What if it was a thread claiming asthma was over diagnosed- they should just get more exercise etc.
fucking bonkers.

AutismProf · 08/09/2023 08:35

My experience from friends in the USA is that ADHD is diagnosed in a single sitting based on parental report. I have been quite shocked - for example, a friend's son was diagnosed with ADHD after his teacher requested parents pursue a diagnosis because he wasn't getting on with his work. Medication had limited impact. It was some months later that same friend showed me his very poor written work - it was immediately obvious that this poor child had severe motor coordination and control issues. He could barely shape a recognisable letter. No wonder he wasn't getting on with his work!

We may not be perfect here in the UK but that child would not have had all difficulties ascribed to ADHD and his motor control issues completely ignored if he had come to us. I expect he actually had DCD.

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 08:35

Aishah231 · 08/09/2023 07:24

Sorry OP but it is overdiagnosed and over medicated. Some parents do push for a diagnosis to explain away poor behaviour. This is a problem mostly for the genuinely ND who are taken less seriously than they should be because of it.

I don't know what leads you to confidently assert this in the face of scientific evidence to the contrary (unless you happen to live in the US), but this sort of casual cultural antagonism towards the experience of autism and ADHD is definitely abelism and contributes to the misery ND people and their families experience on a daily basis in a society that is hostile to their differences and needs.

As with racism, sexism and homophobia, your views have consequences for the lives of other people.

3WildOnes · 08/09/2023 08:34

I'm actually thankful for people pointing out my grammar mistakes. How am I meant to know that I am writing something wrong if no one tells me? Someone pointed out a mistake that I was making on here years ago and now I am really conscious not to repeat that mistake when I am writing up reports at work. I may have struggled to progress at work if my reports continued to have poor grammar.

Summerishere123 · 08/09/2023 08:32

I think the general problem is people using these diagnosis as an excuse for poor behaviour. I have had a child at work continually hit a member of staff and their parent brush it off because they are autistic. And another spat at a member of staff and the parent say it is because of ADHD. I have a child with ADHD and I think it is used as a label for parents who don't parent sometimes and sometimes it is a genuine issue but then can be used as a weapon. To the general onlooker it can all seem too coincidental.

Islandsadness · 08/09/2023 08:30

I agree that the posts on that thread were awful, particularly the ignorant ones about PIP.

However
I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed.
Is a comparing apples with oranges - there haven't been exposés of private cancer diagnosees being issues without consultation, as there have with ADHD.

NDManAndWife · 08/09/2023 08:28

@Gerrataere My husband was diagnosed with ASD at 11 years old. In the days of proper CAMHS funding. He was seen by 7 'specialists', half of whom agreed he had it. half of whom did not. He is a champion masker and even now appears 'normal' to the general public but when he is with me obviously stims etc. His report as a child details obvious behaviours (inability to read social cues, sensory issues) etc but still some professionals claimed he didn't 'meet the threshold'.

I got diagnosed via insurance at work but the signs were always there, like many ADHD women everything was 'fine' until I finished uni and the demands of life and work caught up. Because I used to be great at exam (last minute hyperfocus FTW) nobody thought anything of it and let me get away with constantly not finishing my homework. forgetting stuff etc. Now I have to be 'on' 5 days a week at work and it's very draining.

Personally I think 'overdiagnosis' isn't really relevant, but the consequences, 'excuses' is a different matter. I had quite a few 'friends' who for example are always late 'teehee sorry ADHD thing' which I find offensive as I'd feel bad about keeping people waiting!

Even DH and his ND band of merry men don't want to play video games with a particular person who always insists on getting his own way, gets very angry when he doesn't, stubborn etc etc. Maybe his autism is a reason for his behaviour, but that doesn't excuses it. They are all ND and they don't want to put up with it, let alone other NT people.

As much as MN blathers on about ableism the biggest issue isn't 'NT' vs 'ND'. It's among ND people themselves, there are so many of us, we tend to make friends with similar people.

There is always going to be argument about what people deem as a reasonable adjustment, what is acceptable behaviour, because each ND person is so different you are basically having to understand all of them on their own merits. So on MN, 'people should be accommodating and understanding' I don't know IRL what that would be like depending on the behaviour shown.

User98866 · 08/09/2023 08:28

In the U.K. it’s fallen largely into the hands of private practice so of course it’s going to be over diagnosed. Many clinics are not well run and certainly are diagnosing people who wouldn’t be on the NHS. Look at the figures in the USA. Are you really suggested that in some areas 15% + children have ADHD? I feel sorry for those who are genuinely disabled by it. People are viewing it like the latest fashionable mental health diagnosis and forgetting it’s a serious life long disability.

Tr1pleJump · 08/09/2023 08:25

A agree. Some clearly enjoy upsetting ND posters on here. I think MN is scaling on thin ice as autism is a protected disability.

Some of this ableism is hugely sexist too. Women and girls have been undiagnosed and had to resort to masking for years. Diagnostics have been totally geared to boys. Now professionals and sufferers are better informed women and girls are being told that they’re not deserving of diagnostic, are attention seeking etc.

And MN just sits back and lets it happen.

atomicgecko · 08/09/2023 08:25

As hard as I’m sure the process will have been, I’m so glad for your daughter. I hope she gets the support and understanding she deserves.

I wasn’t diagnosed as a small child in the 90s, though there were ed psych, speech, etc assessments and interventions from ages 4-7. Ultimately they decided that I was “just emotionally immature”.

I struggled through school, went to university and my life promptly fell apart. I was diagnosed autistic at 20, I took those early reports as background evidence and the doctor commented that if I had been a small child in the 2010s I would have been diagnosed from those assessments. The understanding of how autism presents in girls, particularly very verbal girls, just wasn’t there.

Messyhair321 · 08/09/2023 08:25

Masterofhappydays · 08/09/2023 08:06

I don’t have a “neuroscientist friend”. I attended a trauma aware seminar for PD where a neuroscientist presented research. Not once did he say that autism is caused by parents or environment. Where did you get that from in my post? He clearly believed in autism and adhd, he just stated that not all diagnosed cases are actually due to being neurodiverse, some people diagnosed are not neurodiverse and are actually trauma impacted. For that group of people he expressed worry as they’re medicated to prevent them dealing with their trauma. The medication is unnecessary.

Schools do get funding for diagnosis to be able to be inclusive and meet the needs of those students so those students can access education fairly. Schools in the UK got LSA and government funding when I worked in England 7 years ago, whether that’s changed since, I don’t know, I’m not there. In America. Canada, Australia and many European countries, the schools get additional funding for a diagnosis. Not sure about other countries.

In the US and Aus, schools I have worked at have known students are trauma impacted but there isn’t any additional funding for trauma, therefore schools (wrongly or rightly) have pushed for an adhd diagnosis to gain additional funding to meet the needs of the student.

Someone commented that “does it matter if adhd is hereditary or caused by trauma, who cares”….or something like that. That is the thing. Trauma impacted children do not always have autism or adhd. Some do. Some don’t. The ones who don’t who are being unnecessarily medicated are cause for concern. So yes, it does matter. And for the record, not once did I say autism or adhd and trauma are mutually exclusive, you can have both.

Speaking from experience it wasn't the case for my child that school funding rested on diagnosis & the fact is that many diagnosis have lapovers to other conditions. So it wasn't important what the diagnosis was, only the behaviour. This was within the time period you mention you were working in the UK.
Ref medication, they can only do so much based on presentation & information, they can't always get it right first time. It's no business of any professional to start prodding away at 'trauma' that might not be there - or if it is, might not be the underlying cause of behaviour.

Not sure whether this might be area based or how good the professionals are at communicating this information to the LA for funding - but that was what we experienced. And I think this is right actually.

The belief that professionals always get it right is extremely misguided. Trends of diagnosis or non diagnosis seem to be common, though. Hence the current trauma based focus.
You cannot escape childhood without trauma, this I believe. We are all victims of trauma. We don't all have neurodivergent symptoms as a result though.

ruby1957 · 08/09/2023 08:23

This is an interesting slant on the likelihood of Autism

The researchers found that individuals on the autism spectrum were 2.49 times more likely to be left-handed than people without autism.

I am not aware that 'handedness' is taken into account on diagnosis and I know correlation is not causation.

Being left handed myself from an era when left-handedness was very discouraged - I am very aware of its challenges.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 08:19

curaçao · 08/09/2023 08:00

There was a documentary recently about private practice times diagnosing all comers with adhd, so it does happen.
Also I do not believe mumsnet should be de-platforming people who do not conform to their world view.Groupthink!

I dont think its that all all comers are diagnosed but the methods that are being set out here, multi disciplinary teams and panels, one criteria etc, does not apply to all assessments.

Because of the needs of the cohort we work with, there are some children we have diagnosed through CAMHS, others through various different private companies, others through different routes in the NHS.

The methods always start with screening and histories, information is gathered from SW, foster carer, parent if they engage, child if they engage, but always only involves the assessor, schools are not often (if ever) involved unless I specifically ask for the screeners to be sent to them and sometimes we dont get them back. In addition in private assessments we have had a number of assessors who explain why they are making a diagnosis even if some of the markers are not present. Thats their clinical judgement, I cant and wont question that, but there are a myriad of differences in how these assessments and judgements are taking place.

Thats not right or wrong, its just not being recognised sometimes in these discussions.

AutismProf · 08/09/2023 08:15

Wherly · 08/09/2023 07:58

Unlike cancer, diagnosis for ADHD and Autism relies a lot on self reporting and there are many online resources telling you exactly what to report to increase your chances of diagnosis.

Then you have things like the BBC reporter who got diagnosed 3 times in short video calls.

You don't need "lived experience" to read these things and understand the obvious implications.

Do you work on an NHS diagnostic team? I do.

We use QB amongst other measures for ADHD assessment, not just self reported symptoms.

We use observation, ADOS, and sometimes OT/speech therapist/ ed psych specialist assessments as well as parental report in autism.

A parent listing symptoms in a child who then doesn't score on ADOS or show any social communication differences in obs in context is not going to get a diagnosis.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 08/09/2023 08:14

ConnieTucker · 07/09/2023 23:04

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd

I had the opposite in summer. PD trauma training and I said that the symptoms were the same for ADHD, so how many children with trauma are being diagnosed incorrectly.

The amount of children with trauma is alarming.

And, of course, neurodiverse children and adults can also have trauma. No good dismissing it as one or the other when diagnosing and treating the Adhd could actually help get them into a situation where the effects of trauma could instantly lessen or can be addressed - instead of only treating a 'missing leg' and ignoring that there's also a six inch spike sticking out of their hand. Doctors need to stabilise the patient and then deal with the second issue.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 08:13

Its incredibly difficult to get regular and timely medication reviews for children on ADHD medication, you cant get appointments, you see different people each time and there doesnt seem enough recognition of the symptoms and side effects and we're often concerned that the treatment doesnt really have the oversight it should

Masterofhappydays · 08/09/2023 08:06

Messyhair321 · 08/09/2023 07:42

Schools don't generally get funded on diagnosis, they should be funding on need, what is presented. That's my understanding.

Also your neuroscience friend is doing what most non believers of neurodivergent people do, & blaming this on parents or environment. I don't think this is cool anymore.

I don’t have a “neuroscientist friend”. I attended a trauma aware seminar for PD where a neuroscientist presented research. Not once did he say that autism is caused by parents or environment. Where did you get that from in my post? He clearly believed in autism and adhd, he just stated that not all diagnosed cases are actually due to being neurodiverse, some people diagnosed are not neurodiverse and are actually trauma impacted. For that group of people he expressed worry as they’re medicated to prevent them dealing with their trauma. The medication is unnecessary.

Schools do get funding for diagnosis to be able to be inclusive and meet the needs of those students so those students can access education fairly. Schools in the UK got LSA and government funding when I worked in England 7 years ago, whether that’s changed since, I don’t know, I’m not there. In America. Canada, Australia and many European countries, the schools get additional funding for a diagnosis. Not sure about other countries.

In the US and Aus, schools I have worked at have known students are trauma impacted but there isn’t any additional funding for trauma, therefore schools (wrongly or rightly) have pushed for an adhd diagnosis to gain additional funding to meet the needs of the student.

Someone commented that “does it matter if adhd is hereditary or caused by trauma, who cares”….or something like that. That is the thing. Trauma impacted children do not always have autism or adhd. Some do. Some don’t. The ones who don’t who are being unnecessarily medicated are cause for concern. So yes, it does matter. And for the record, not once did I say autism or adhd and trauma are mutually exclusive, you can have both.

Alleycatz · 08/09/2023 08:06

The problem with ND or I guess other mental health issues is that they do not just affect the person who experiences them. I have a father with ASD eventually diagnosed which being honest in retrospect is very hard to distinguish from a personality disorder when you are a child dealing with the consequences of his emotional dysregulation, his utter self absorption to the detriment of everyone else in the family. We walked around on eggshells as children trying not to set him off and his behaviour affected every member of the family. We were all traumatised in different ways by the lack of connection with our father and trying to deal with his moods. As a child you simply don’t have the skills to deal with that.

I have siblings with ND and children with ND and even though I don’t have ND myself I definitely have lived experiences of ND.

Sporkle99 · 08/09/2023 08:03

itsmyp4rty · 08/09/2023 07:56

I would guess what confuses people is that the H in ADHD stands for hyperactive but you say you're not classically hyperactive. But surely being hyperactive means you're always moving and struggle with sitting still? What's non classical hyperactivity? A lack of attention? Wouldn't that just be ADD or is that not a diagnosis anymore? Does it mean your brain is hyperactive rather than your body as it jumps around so much? Genuinely interested as all my reading is on ASD

The hyperactivity in ADHD refers to physical hyperactivity.

curaçao · 08/09/2023 08:00

There was a documentary recently about private practice times diagnosing all comers with adhd, so it does happen.
Also I do not believe mumsnet should be de-platforming people who do not conform to their world view.Groupthink!

Pawpawpatrol · 08/09/2023 07:58

Really useful report (published 2022) which helps to understand the impact of underdiagnosed autism in girls:

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=autisticgirlsnetwork.org/keeping-it-all-inside.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjj-JjKtpqBAxUfT0EAHfVKC7EQFnoECB4QAQ&usg=AOvVaw3UWdvS2fnXQD28Hq8cm6-u

For children and girls particularly, underdiagnosis is still a much more prevailing problem than overdiagnosis in my opinion.

Anyone who has a child with SEN will know how impossible it can be to get the right support at school. There is a lengthy diagnostic pathway and getting the right cooperation from sometimes misinformed school staff (I'm sure there are many well informed professionals in schools but there are others who view masking behaviour at school as proof the child doesn't have autism) upon which referral for assessment frequently depends, can be an absolute uphill battle. It's then the icing on the cake to hear that loads of normal kids are being diagnosed with autism these days... Again this is not a diagnosis you can get from the GP but requires a lengthy multidisciplinary assessment process by specialists using strict objective criteria.

Wherly · 08/09/2023 07:58

Unlike cancer, diagnosis for ADHD and Autism relies a lot on self reporting and there are many online resources telling you exactly what to report to increase your chances of diagnosis.

Then you have things like the BBC reporter who got diagnosed 3 times in short video calls.

You don't need "lived experience" to read these things and understand the obvious implications.

itsgettingweird · 08/09/2023 07:57

4 year waiting lists in most places for diagnosis.

Yet it's over diagnosed 🙄

People just spout shite because they're illinformed and in educated about such matters.

itsmyp4rty · 08/09/2023 07:56

Sporkle99 · 08/09/2023 07:22

That was my thread, where a few posters came on to tell me my symptoms aren't indicative of ADHD (they are, it's just because I don't have the 'classic' hyperactivity). It was mainly supportive with a few people saying that ADHD is used as an excuse for laziness. I know myself and know that the fact that I have lots of symptoms, have beeb diagnosed with OCD but then told by a specialist in OCD that I should have an ADHD assessment, paired with my struggles throughout childhood to adulthood warrant an assessment. Hopefully ADHD specialists know what they're doing, I'm sure some aren't great, but I'd argue that the vast majority of people who have an ADHD diagnosis have ADHD. Many will be like me with a misdiagnosis when it's something else (aka my wrong OCD diagnosis). And a very tiny amount of neurotypical people will be diagnosed. But that's the case with a lot of things.

I would guess what confuses people is that the H in ADHD stands for hyperactive but you say you're not classically hyperactive. But surely being hyperactive means you're always moving and struggle with sitting still? What's non classical hyperactivity? A lack of attention? Wouldn't that just be ADD or is that not a diagnosis anymore? Does it mean your brain is hyperactive rather than your body as it jumps around so much? Genuinely interested as all my reading is on ASD