Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Cucucucu · 08/09/2023 10:24

NoMor · 08/09/2023 09:52

Unless I'm misunderstanding you, you are totally wrong about this. Autism is present from birth, the brain is literally wired differently to NT's. Autism-like symptoms brought on by trauma is NOT autism, it is trauma.

Not really . People can still be diagnosed with autism after brain injury by example ( my son and multiple children I know where ) . It was not presented from birth . This is just a misconception . You can say then it’s not really autism but the reality is all the symptoms are there a, children with cerebral palsy are diagnosed with autism too despite being related to another condition .
Since autism is nit really a illness but a spectrum there are no set parameters that it’s present from birth

Islandsadness · 08/09/2023 10:13

Actually there IS a big issue around breast cancer being overdiagnosed

Over diagnosis is not misdiagnosis. With cancer this means that the disease is being picked up when the patient would likely have died of something else before the cancer killed them. That's why the rate continues with age.

It's nothing like giving someone an adhd label without proper assessment, simply because they paid to go private.

AutismProf · 08/09/2023 10:05

shearwater · 08/09/2023 09:03

I would just point out that-

Not all private clinics are the same- yes some are better than others. Some are really good and absolute specialists in their field.

The NHS is NOT the standard by which all other providers should be measured. They are fucking shit at providing mental health care to children and young people. It is in a proper fucking state. Schools and local authorities SHOULD NOT be holding up a NHS diagnosis as a gold standard.

Usually assistance is not provided at all - the waiting list if you can get on it is 5 years - older kids would be adults and too old to receive help from CAMHS by the time they get an appointment. Parents go to private clinics not to seek a false diagnosis but to seek any help whatsoever because there is none to be had whatsoever from any other route.

No, the NHS criteria are evidence based and set out by NICE.

Any other issues you are having are relating to underfunding, understaffing and complete overwhelm. We have had a total flood of referrals (a quadrupling in my area) post COVID, on top of a 65 percent increase 2017- 19.

Our service is staffed for 90 referrals a month. We get over 300. Of course the waiting list is growing.

The effect might be a shit service (you don't want 5 years in my area though) but it's not because we are shit. The more professionals trained at NHS expense who go off and offer private assessments charging parents a fortune the worse it gets, frankly.

Summerishere123 · 08/09/2023 10:04

@greyflannel You are misunderstanding my point. Of course their struggles mean they hit out more but as a parent you can gently correct their behaviour and model appropriately. I am not talking mid meltdown here, when we are past rational discussion. Many parents I see at work totally brush off behaviours with "yeah but they are autistic" rather than "my apologies, I will try to talk to them about it but this is difficult as they are autistic."
It really does impact peoples views and how they interact in the future. We are incredibly accommodating for families with ASD but not at the expense of our staff being assaulted.
As an example - A young member of staff was running a workshop and a child kept hitting them. The staff member approached me about it and I went to speak to the parents. They told me he is autistic and likely trying to get their attention. My reply was in that case to ask them to have to have a word with them and suggest another way that they could get someones attention as I cannot explain to a 17 year old that they have to accept being hit. Or if they wanted they could supervise the child to make sure they got the attention required.
I am sure what they really needed was a coffee and a break but if I let my staff get physically assaulted I could be liable in the future.

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 10:03

The point is that there aren't posts on here every day saying that. Nobody on here is telling breast cancer victims that their diagnosis probably isn't real.

babbscrabbs · 08/09/2023 10:01

Islandsadness · 08/09/2023 08:30

I agree that the posts on that thread were awful, particularly the ignorant ones about PIP.

However
I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed.
Is a comparing apples with oranges - there haven't been exposés of private cancer diagnosees being issues without consultation, as there have with ADHD.

Actually there IS a big issue around breast cancer being overdiagnosed

www.bmj.com/content/382/bmj.p1823#:~:text=They%20found%20that%20potential%20overdiagnosis,those%20aged%2085%20and%20over.&text=Overdiagnosis%20can%20be%20defined%20as,symptoms%20in%20a%20person's%20lifetime.

stbrandonsboat · 08/09/2023 09:58

I'm autistic and have ADHD. The ADHD has ruined my life. It's the cause of my depression - due to low dopamine levels - I can't study, focus, concentrate, take in instructions if they're not written down, I eat too much and crave sugar - to boost dopamine presumably - I'm overweight, but can't force myself to exercise because it gives me the rage, my dh has to help me make phonecalls, I can't deal with bureaucracy, it affects my communication, people assume I'm stupid. The list is endless.

I can't take ADHD medication either.

People have no idea of how damaging and debilitating ADHD is.

PylaSheight · 08/09/2023 09:55

@Yellowlegobrick I've wondered why so many people are struggling mentally and I think a lot of issues are caused by the fact most humans in the western world are living unnatural lives. By that I mean we are going against what we, as animals, should be doing. Our environments tend to be full of stimulation, eg too many people crowded in particular areas, lots of noise, surrounded by stuff vying for our attention. Most work in sedentary jobs and have to make a conscious effort to be active and, on top of that, we are surrounded by food that our grandparents wouldn't recognise. Many are living unhealthy lives using medication to keep "well", eg those with metabolic conditions. We've lost the plot.

NoMor · 08/09/2023 09:52

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 08/09/2023 07:40

Does it matter if it's not "pure" ASD/ADHD if it's caused by trauma rather than genetics.

It's like comparing someone born without a leg to someone who lost their leg in an accident - they'll still need crutches or a prosthetic and accommodations. There's still something going on.

Unless I'm misunderstanding you, you are totally wrong about this. Autism is present from birth, the brain is literally wired differently to NT's. Autism-like symptoms brought on by trauma is NOT autism, it is trauma.

ohfook · 08/09/2023 09:51

ConnieTucker · 07/09/2023 23:04

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd

I had the opposite in summer. PD trauma training and I said that the symptoms were the same for ADHD, so how many children with trauma are being diagnosed incorrectly.

The amount of children with trauma is alarming.

I think the issue here is we actually are very early on in our understanding of neurodiversity and specifically ADHD. I've heard an expert on the subject compare our current understanding to when we were still using leeches to treat physical illnesses.

Trauma, particularly trauma experienced at a your age, can cause symptoms the same as those shown with adhd, as can poor or chaotic parenting and dopamine inhibition. I think in the future we'll see adhd as a collection of behaviours or symptoms with an incredibly wide range of causes and the onus will be on the doctor to identify the cause and prescribe accordingly even if that means social prescribing rather than medication.

There was a terrible case a while ago of a child who was acting out and was diagnosed with adhd medicated. He later committed suicide and it transpired that his behaviour was a trauma response due to ongoing sexual abuse.

Quisquam · 08/09/2023 09:43

Evidence is anecdotal. People are very well informed - and if someone wanted to get a diagnosis of ADHD, they could easily do so by listing all the symptoms, regardless as to whether they have it or not. It’s open to exploitation especially when someone could end up with medication being prescribed that actually has value on the open market in some places.

Spend a day with DH or DGD and it’s like being with a human whirlwind! It’s exhausting just to watch! Nobody could fake that level of activity for long! (DH’s idea of a break isn’t to sit down with a cup of tea - instead he paces round the whole house. He paces around with his bowl of cornflakes. He only sits down to eat, when he needs to use a knife and fork; then he’s up like a jack in a box, the second he’s finished)

Its no good someone, going into an appointment saying I have got all these symptoms; but then they turn up on time; they could understand the formal letters and forms; they sit there normally with no constant fidgeting; with appropriate turn taking in the conversation; no talking over the psychologist/psychiatrist nor going off at a million tangents; no climbing the walls; remembering all their possessions as they leave…..

When I took adult DD for her assessment, first of all, I had to apologise for being late due to her messing about, after the time I had told her, we had to leave!

Pawpawpatrol · 08/09/2023 09:40

There are also plenty of physical conditions for which diagnosis is based on self assessment or description of symptoms. Asthma for example. I have a diagnosis and prescriptions for asthma which are almost entirely based off of self reported symptoms and self reported peak flow. Never had spirometry. Young children can't have spirometry or peak flow so they might often be appropriately prescribed medication based on parent description of nocturnal or exercise related cough or wheeze. If a parent relentlessly seeks escalation of management with no objective evidence of disease that's a different matter and this is partly why regular assessment is part of the management. But still, the distinction isn't as clear cut as people make out.

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 08/09/2023 09:39

I had to step away from this discussion last night as I was so angry/upset. Apologies if I left anyone hanging and disappeared. A few points to follow up:

  1. The BBC documentary on the private clinics has been very damaging to the ADHD community, particularly those with private diagnoses. Yes, there are some shysters out there and these clinics should be investigated, regulated and shut down. There are also highly professional companies offering private assessments that operate properly.
  2. I don't totally discount the opinions of NT parents with ND children, but when it comes to complete understanding of the issues that we face not just in childhood but adulthood, including the inherent ableism they don't have lived experience of what it's like with a brain like ours. Not from the inside. They don't know how it FEELS.
  3. I think there are some posts on here that do skate on thin ice. It's important these discussions are had, but slurs and ableist language has to be shut down or posters asked to edit such posts. It's the only way people will learn.
  4. Finally, you can be a good parent with a challenging child. You can be a poor parent with a challenging child. You can be a poor parent of a child with no diagnosis, behavioural issues or anything else. You can be a good parent of a child with no diagnosis, behavioural issues or anything else. You can't make a generalisation about "people" using such diagnoses as an 'excuse' for poor parenting. Who are these "people"? Do you know them, their home situation, the challenges they and the children they're parenting inside and out? I very much doubt it.
OP posts:
greyflannel · 08/09/2023 09:38

Summerishere123 · 08/09/2023 08:32

I think the general problem is people using these diagnosis as an excuse for poor behaviour. I have had a child at work continually hit a member of staff and their parent brush it off because they are autistic. And another spat at a member of staff and the parent say it is because of ADHD. I have a child with ADHD and I think it is used as a label for parents who don't parent sometimes and sometimes it is a genuine issue but then can be used as a weapon. To the general onlooker it can all seem too coincidental.

Do you not understand what autism and ASD are? Both are associated with difficulties in social interactions and with problems with emotional regulation as a result of cognitive differences. 25% of autistic young people behave in violent and challenging ways towards care givers. They do this not because they are choosing to be 'naughtier' than other children, or because they have feckless parents, but because they lack the developmental capacity at this point to behave more adaptively. No amount of punishment, including the physical chastisement cheered on by a grim chorus here on MN, will change that.

These children and families need specialist support and resources that are routinely denied due to funding issues, and instead endure constant public shaming by judgemental types who appear to get their jollies by deciding they can be the arbiter of what is a genuine disability. I guess it helps them feel better about themselves in some way, but it is both the height of arrogance and a fairly abhorrent form of bullying of a group who could do with social solidarity for the challenges they live with. It has real life consequences for disabled people and their families, just like racism.

BeautifulGnome · 08/09/2023 09:32

Masterofhappydays · 07/09/2023 22:59

Bit of a tangent post here, sorry!

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd.

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

So I do think there are some people in some places who are diagnosed incorrectly.

I suppose it’s difficult as I guess some parents have blamed neurodivergence for their poor parenting 🤷‍♀️

I am neurodiverse so I do find this interesting.

Do you know the neuroscientist's name by any chance?

shearwater · 08/09/2023 09:29

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 09:15

This
Absolutely this

An organisation with the influence of Mumsnet could make a real difference here. I'd love to see a campaign to get all teachers trained in how to teach children and teens with ND and to stop parents being fined for emotionally based school avoidance.

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 09:20

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/09/2023 08:51

This

It's not ableist to point this out.

The clinical situation and diagnosis rate in the UK and US are not at all similar. If you want to keep spreading this nonsense, don't bother with your expressions of sympathy to 'the genuinely disabled'. You are casually stoking discriminatory attitudes.

ProudToBeANorthener · 08/09/2023 09:17

I can’t really comment on the reality of the diagnosis statistics but I’d be interested to see what the evidence is. However, there is a comparison with antibiotics. For those who say, “surely doctors wouldn’t be swayed/diagnose/prescribe medication due to pressure from schools or parents”think about the over and incorrect prescribing of antibiotics and the problems that are stemming from their over-use. Doctors are wonderful in so many ways but they are also human and we are all flawed in one way or another.
I’d like to see more support for anyone who deviates from the perceived perfect norm (which doesn’t actually exist anyway) whether it’s a parent, child, adult. It matters not who they are but that society as a whole expects high standards of behaviour from all but within what each of us is truly capable of.
Poor standards of behaviour and a lack
of empathy with being anarchy.

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 09:15

Tr1pleJump · 08/09/2023 08:25

A agree. Some clearly enjoy upsetting ND posters on here. I think MN is scaling on thin ice as autism is a protected disability.

Some of this ableism is hugely sexist too. Women and girls have been undiagnosed and had to resort to masking for years. Diagnostics have been totally geared to boys. Now professionals and sufferers are better informed women and girls are being told that they’re not deserving of diagnostic, are attention seeking etc.

And MN just sits back and lets it happen.

This
Absolutely this

Bumpitybumper · 08/09/2023 09:12

I think this is such a complex issue.

My frustration is that there is now such an obsession with having a formal diagnosis and label that this is used as a way to gatekeep compassion, help and resources from those that need it. Using a physical disability example, if you were in an accident that meant that you were temporarily disabled and needed to use disabled parking spaces to be able to access places, there would be a contingent on this forum that would see you house bound or in severe pain rather than allow you to use an official disabled space without a blue badge. The fact that you are factually in need of the space makes no odds to them, all that matters is the badge.

The same goes with ADHD/ASD. If someone is self reporting that they have traits of these conditions that are causing all sorts of problems and carnage in their lives, why must we check if they have a formal diagnosis before we seek to offer support and help? This is especially true for condition where there isn't really a definitive way to 'prove' someone has the disorder in the first place and the extent to which it might impede their lives.

I also think parents and carers for ND people get a really hard time. It is really really hard to look after a ND person and there seems to be an unrealistic expectation that everything is done to accommodate the ND person's needs without questioning the toll this will take on the people around them. It has been proven time and again that there is a strong genetic factor for many of these disorders. It is therefore highly likely that these expectations are being placed on people with some Neurodivergence themselves

DiscoDragon · 08/09/2023 09:09

I've had a family member tutting and eye-rolling when I've told them about my sons autism and ADHD diagnosis. Apparently it's "trendy" for all parents to get a "label" for their children these days and those conditions didn't exist in their day, just an excuse for bad behaviour blah blah blah.

My son isn't in the least bit badly behaved, I never had ANY concerns about him at all. It was his KS1 teacher who approached me with concerns when he went into Year 1 and was massively struggling with completing school work and staying focussed. She recognised certain traits that could be indicative of autism and suggested that I went to the GP to request assessment for him. It was a very long, drawn out process with Educational Psychologists observing him in school, lots of forms for us and his teachers to complete. There were assessments by paediatric consultants, specialist nurses, speech therapists etc and it took years! This family member speaks as if I just popped into the GP's one day and said "hey my kid is naughty, give me a label and some pills". It boils my blood.

shearwater · 08/09/2023 09:04

Are you really suggested that in some areas 15% + children have ADHD?

I think 15% is very low. Why do you think it's so much less?

shearwater · 08/09/2023 09:03

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/09/2023 08:51

This

It's not ableist to point this out.

I would just point out that-

Not all private clinics are the same- yes some are better than others. Some are really good and absolute specialists in their field.

The NHS is NOT the standard by which all other providers should be measured. They are fucking shit at providing mental health care to children and young people. It is in a proper fucking state. Schools and local authorities SHOULD NOT be holding up a NHS diagnosis as a gold standard.

Usually assistance is not provided at all - the waiting list if you can get on it is 5 years - older kids would be adults and too old to receive help from CAMHS by the time they get an appointment. Parents go to private clinics not to seek a false diagnosis but to seek any help whatsoever because there is none to be had whatsoever from any other route.

shearwater · 08/09/2023 08:55

Masterofhappydays · 07/09/2023 22:59

Bit of a tangent post here, sorry!

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd.

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

So I do think there are some people in some places who are diagnosed incorrectly.

I suppose it’s difficult as I guess some parents have blamed neurodivergence for their poor parenting 🤷‍♀️

I am neurodiverse so I do find this interesting.

DD2 had two lots of counselling where no trauma was found before ADHD and ASD was diagnosed causing her anxiety and emotionally based school avoidance.

The issue was unmet need in secondary school, a combination of medication and reasonable adjustments by the school has helped.

We are so lucky that we were able to find and pay for good private help. Schools almost always blame parents- we have been threatened with fines and court action. Schools are so often only interested in attendance figures and not making sure that school provides the best environment for everyone to be able to learn.

Certainlyreally · 08/09/2023 08:53

Jamjarcandlestick · 08/09/2023 00:01

I have diagnosed ADHD and i get fairly annoyed with the amount of people say they have ADHD (but aren’t diagnosed) or say it flippantly I.E. doesn’t like paperwork so must have ADHD.

Along the same lines as "a bit OCD" ?