Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
PylaSheight · 08/09/2023 14:20

@AutismProf do you assess adults as well as children? Only an adult acquaintance of mine (in UK) was recently diagnosed with ASD and all they've mentioned was a very long questionnaire, part of which their friend had to fill in (in the absence of parents). I've wanted to understand the process, yet am not able to discuss it with them really.

ClemFandango1 · 08/09/2023 14:12

I have AuDHD.

I'm beginning to think neurodiversity, especially in women, is perhaps far more common than we, as a society, realised.
Many people are realising that their quirks are actually neurological/developmental differences. Mostly these aren't enough to stop people leading productive lives, but quite often there are significant deficits that are fairly invisible to an outsider but that nonetheless can be debilitating enough to blight a life.

I think it's fair that people like me get to understand why they are struggling.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:12

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 13:20

This is precisely what I don't understand. When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults. They just didn't. I've no doubt some stuggled with ADD, ADHD - attention span/being overly boisterous.

However, the point is, their behaviour was neither uncontrolled nor accepted as being 'just who they are' at the expense of others whether that's the physical assaults or the disruption to the education of others.

Also, I was only ever aware of one child with Autism and it presented in an obvious/classical way. He was very protected by his family and he did not attend mainstream school. No-one was cruel or abusive towards him, nor he to them. He had a particular 'fondness' for me and one of my brothers. I always felt privileged to receive his fondness and the big, beaming smile he always had for me.

Now, though, it seems to me a very high proportion of children are being put forward for a diagnosis.

I fully understand why teachers are leaving in droves preferring to not be punched and spat at or, indeed, being required to change nappies whilst attempting to educate. I also hear my nieces and nephews at the end of their respective tethers due to their children's education being constantly interrupted because 'wee Johnny' had three meltdowns today ..... not to mention the trauma to their children witnessing these meltdowns.

Again, I don't recall anyone in nappies at school and if anyone did have an accident, off they went to the school nurse to be assisted. Perhaps every school should have an on-site nurse/carer to deal with toilet needs as a priority, leaving teachers to teach?

I think the answer to the massive increase in diagnoses (either clinical or self) will only be discovered by examining both physiological, familial and societal inputs. I don't believe it is solely one or the other that has caused the incredible increase.

Dont disregard that a huge number of children with what we would now know as SEN were either at specialist schools or residential settings and often never saw the light of day. You and your friends wouldnt have come into contact with children with those needs, or that level of need anyway

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 13:56

DoItAgainPlz · 08/09/2023 13:38

There is a huge difference between a cancer sufferer and someone who thinks they are autistic because they prefer their own company, or have ADHD because they work better under pressure.

Nobody gets a diagnosed because they have one of those symptoms ffs. Autism assessment is grueling and they go right back to when you were a child. They speak to a parent if possible, and another person very close to you like your partner. You are assessed for hours.
There is a triad of impairment to meet. If you don't meet it, you don't get diagnosed.

DoItAgainPlz · 08/09/2023 13:49

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:38

Why would you seek to make such a stupid comparison anyway?

Because the OP mentions it in the opening post.

Nowadays any form of bad behaviour is put down to ADHD.

If you're not a social butterfly or find it difficult to make friends, there's a push for an autism diagnosis.

Of course there are people with autism and other learning difficulties. But I absolutely do believe - along with many other medical professionals - that these things are overdiagnosed.

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 13:48

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:36

The children who did that 50 years ago would probably not have been in mainstream school - rightly or wrongly.

I don't know, maybe it's something to do with shutting down most special educational facilities and expecting everyone to cope in mainstream while providing no teacher training on it?

Maybe it's something to do with adults with ASD and ADHD being accepted in a more humane society as they are and then going on to have children themselves rather than being shut away in an asylum or otherwise excluded from society and dying at a young age?

What do you suggest - eugenics?

Yeah, obviously, eugenics is my answer.

I'm sure the closure of specialist settings is one of those chicken and egg situations. Parents demanding their children with SEN be afforded a mainstream education and rejecting the specialist setting. Now, the reality of attempting to teach children with SEN (particularly severe SEN) in a mainstream setting is not tenable but there are no longer the required number of specialist placements for parents who are not wedded to the mainstream education (designed for NT children) and accept their ND children require a different form of education to meet their particular needs. To me that's much better than attempting to shoehorn ND children into an environment pretty much designed to upset them (and the NT children around them).

But, yeah, eugenics.

Quisquam · 08/09/2023 13:48

I meant classic autism!

egowise · 08/09/2023 13:46

YANBU.

It's disgusting and so frustrating.

Quisquam · 08/09/2023 13:44

When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults. They just didn't. I've no doubt some stuggled with ADD, ADHD - attention span/being overly boisterous.

As my SIL (from East Asia) says, half the world beats those behaviours out of children!

See the other thread about a woman, shocked that her in laws as teachers, caned children! Many posters recalled the use of the cane, slipper or strap on children in schools 50 years ago!

Also, iirc children with LD and probably obvious autism, etc in those days were kept at home, because they had no right to education until 1985!

ValleyClouds · 08/09/2023 13:39

MN Thread about Ableism Generates Ableist Comments SHOCKER

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:38

DoItAgainPlz · 08/09/2023 13:38

There is a huge difference between a cancer sufferer and someone who thinks they are autistic because they prefer their own company, or have ADHD because they work better under pressure.

Why would you seek to make such a stupid comparison anyway?

DoItAgainPlz · 08/09/2023 13:38

There is a huge difference between a cancer sufferer and someone who thinks they are autistic because they prefer their own company, or have ADHD because they work better under pressure.

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:36

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 13:20

This is precisely what I don't understand. When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults. They just didn't. I've no doubt some stuggled with ADD, ADHD - attention span/being overly boisterous.

However, the point is, their behaviour was neither uncontrolled nor accepted as being 'just who they are' at the expense of others whether that's the physical assaults or the disruption to the education of others.

Also, I was only ever aware of one child with Autism and it presented in an obvious/classical way. He was very protected by his family and he did not attend mainstream school. No-one was cruel or abusive towards him, nor he to them. He had a particular 'fondness' for me and one of my brothers. I always felt privileged to receive his fondness and the big, beaming smile he always had for me.

Now, though, it seems to me a very high proportion of children are being put forward for a diagnosis.

I fully understand why teachers are leaving in droves preferring to not be punched and spat at or, indeed, being required to change nappies whilst attempting to educate. I also hear my nieces and nephews at the end of their respective tethers due to their children's education being constantly interrupted because 'wee Johnny' had three meltdowns today ..... not to mention the trauma to their children witnessing these meltdowns.

Again, I don't recall anyone in nappies at school and if anyone did have an accident, off they went to the school nurse to be assisted. Perhaps every school should have an on-site nurse/carer to deal with toilet needs as a priority, leaving teachers to teach?

I think the answer to the massive increase in diagnoses (either clinical or self) will only be discovered by examining both physiological, familial and societal inputs. I don't believe it is solely one or the other that has caused the incredible increase.

The children who did that 50 years ago would probably not have been in mainstream school - rightly or wrongly.

I don't know, maybe it's something to do with shutting down most special educational facilities and expecting everyone to cope in mainstream while providing no teacher training on it?

Maybe it's something to do with adults with ASD and ADHD being accepted in a more humane society as they are and then going on to have children themselves rather than being shut away in an asylum or otherwise excluded from society and dying at a young age?

What do you suggest - eugenics?

SoNotRainbowRhythms · 08/09/2023 13:30

But by the time they aplogised the damage is already done

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:30

charlotte361 · 08/09/2023 13:18

TikTok and shit programmes like CocoMelon and the lazy , stupid parents who let their kids watch them, are a major cause of kids having no attention span. I am sure at least some of these are labelled ADHD.

It's not just about "no attention span" either. Please stop spouting such ignorant shite, it's embarrassing.

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:28

ADHD and ASD doesn't necessarily mean spitting on and hitting adults.

It can mean things like masking like hell to fit in, behaving well in class but not being able to learn due to concentration, attention span, difficulty focusing.

Please read more about it before coming on here to make ignorant comments.

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 13:20

This is precisely what I don't understand. When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults. They just didn't. I've no doubt some stuggled with ADD, ADHD - attention span/being overly boisterous.

However, the point is, their behaviour was neither uncontrolled nor accepted as being 'just who they are' at the expense of others whether that's the physical assaults or the disruption to the education of others.

Also, I was only ever aware of one child with Autism and it presented in an obvious/classical way. He was very protected by his family and he did not attend mainstream school. No-one was cruel or abusive towards him, nor he to them. He had a particular 'fondness' for me and one of my brothers. I always felt privileged to receive his fondness and the big, beaming smile he always had for me.

Now, though, it seems to me a very high proportion of children are being put forward for a diagnosis.

I fully understand why teachers are leaving in droves preferring to not be punched and spat at or, indeed, being required to change nappies whilst attempting to educate. I also hear my nieces and nephews at the end of their respective tethers due to their children's education being constantly interrupted because 'wee Johnny' had three meltdowns today ..... not to mention the trauma to their children witnessing these meltdowns.

Again, I don't recall anyone in nappies at school and if anyone did have an accident, off they went to the school nurse to be assisted. Perhaps every school should have an on-site nurse/carer to deal with toilet needs as a priority, leaving teachers to teach?

I think the answer to the massive increase in diagnoses (either clinical or self) will only be discovered by examining both physiological, familial and societal inputs. I don't believe it is solely one or the other that has caused the incredible increase.

charlotte361 · 08/09/2023 13:18

TikTok and shit programmes like CocoMelon and the lazy , stupid parents who let their kids watch them, are a major cause of kids having no attention span. I am sure at least some of these are labelled ADHD.

ValleyClouds · 08/09/2023 13:05

As a disabled person the site has been very disheartening in terms of what people are willing to say behind fake names and keyboards

Benefit bashing is huge

It's all disability on here not just neurodiversities

I've seen some shocking comments in my time.

CaffeineAndCrochet · 08/09/2023 12:41

I'm interested in the trauma/ND crossover. I was diagnosed autistic a couple of years ago, during the tail end of the pandemic. For other reasons I've been seeing a therapist for the last while and it turns out that my happy childhood wasn't so happy after all - my ACE score would be 4 (with anything over 3 considered high). I've spent the last few months now doubting my autism diagnosis.

EmmaEmerald · 08/09/2023 12:38

LegendsBeyond · 08/09/2023 12:05

It’s true that there are huge numbers of children & adults wrongly diagnosed with ADHD. Trauma is at the heart of their behaviours. It’s very sad because the trauma often never gets addressed.

what sort of traumas might lead to this please?

I have been told I have CPSTD but don't believe it, I do sometimes wonder if I have ADHD. i originally thought I had depression and anxiety since childhood but maybe that's not it.

Tr1pleJump · 08/09/2023 12:36

LegendsBeyond

Can you send a link with evidence for that.

Mimmy352 · 08/09/2023 12:35

What I find absolutely disgusting is when someone makes a post asking for advice dealing with their ASD child, and the response is:

”My mother would have hit me”, or “5 minutes with me and child would never do that again!”

First of all, physical punishment or intimidation
tactics are never ok towards an adult OR a child. OR an animal for that matter, as I’ve seen some posts like that too.

Secondly, if you do not have firsthand experience with a child who has ASD, ADHD, anxiety, or whatever the additional need might be - DONT COMMENT. It’s nothing to you, and your opinion is often wrong and harmful. Just because you were in the same shop as someone with ASD once, or your neighbor Susan has a friend whose cousin’s nephew is ADHD, doesn’t mean you know anything about it.

LegendsBeyond · 08/09/2023 12:05

It’s true that there are huge numbers of children & adults wrongly diagnosed with ADHD. Trauma is at the heart of their behaviours. It’s very sad because the trauma often never gets addressed.