Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
FeelWorthlessAndAshamed · 08/09/2023 21:48

WandaWonder · 07/09/2023 23:05

I think what I feel is the general issue is not about people who genuinely have diagnosed labels but any time a tiny thing is mentioned about someone who is 'different' or even just one tiny thing different about them it is 'they have ADHD' or whatever

I can't imagine it working 'I have a tiny spot on my chin' being 'I bet you have smallpox'

I get what you're saying and obviously it's not good for people to take medications they don't need but it's not a bad thing to raise the possibility? It's far worse for a child who is ND to be written off as bad or naughty or difficult or even "arrogant" (that was my label from my dad for so long) and not get the help they need. The worse case scenario is that someone who doesn't need meds gets an assessment which proves they aren't ND. Or sometimes it's another condition which mimics ADHD or AsD, like BPD (obviously there won't be a diagnosis of that in children or young teens) or complex trauma.

atelli · 08/09/2023 21:33

@Trez1510 I desperately want my DS to go to a special school but it’s so, so difficult to get a place.

The answer would be more funding for these types of schools.

so many parents aren’t happy with their child being in mainstream school and their child isn’t coping in mainstream, but no place available.

then the consequence is often other children in the class also suffering

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 21:28

Quisquam · 08/09/2023 15:55

This is precisely what I don't understand. When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults.

One of DD’s care workers told me, her first job in this country was to look after two adults with SLD, who had been dropped off at about age 3, at the local lunatic asylum, which in its heyday housed 3,000 people. It was closed down and its residents were put in supported living in the community - in their case, a house nearby.

How many people were put in institutions in those days, who would now be in mainstream schools?

I hear what you're saying, and the institutionalisation of people was so very wrong.

I was heavily involved when Community Care (Care in the Community) legislation was implemented. Particularly in sourcing alternative living situations for those being discharged from NHS care.

The vast, vast majority of residents had either a diagnosis of Down Syndrome, Cerebral Palsy or physical disabilities. Those people were relocated to the type of home situation you describe - houses in local communities with on-site support (sheltered housing situation) to allow them to live as independent life as they were (individually) able. Some were allocated their own tenancies (or shared tenancies) with care workers visiting multiple times per day and sometimes someone sleeping over too. We did our absolute best to meet the individual's needs/capabilities in discussion with them and their families.

The minority of residents had diagnoses of Autism. Only a handful of those people were assessed as being capable (with substantial support) of living in even a semi-independent situation. The majority (of the minority) went to a combination of private and NHS residential units where there was no expectation of independent living. Those units were (are) much smaller, much more homely than the 'asylums' in which they previously lived but retain a 'structured' ambience. Interestingly, families (where they were still involved) were very supportive of ongoing full-time care for their loved one where it was suggested to them.

I'll be honest, I have zero idea of how many of those people would be in mainstream education these days. I suspect those with Cerebral Palsy or physical disabilities would definitely be in mainstream school now without question. No-one seems to mention Down Syndrome pupils in my social sphere, so I imagine those pupils work quietly/dilligently and are not disruptive. There is, though. a lot of anecdotal evidence of pupils with Autism/ADD/ADHD in mainstream classes. Unfortunately, usually that anecdata is negative in terms of disruption to fellow pupils and the trauma experienced by those pupils when the pupil with Autism etc. has multiple meltdowns on a daily basis. I'm sure, though, many of the pupils with these diagnoses are 'quiet' in their symptoms and battle through just as they would have (back in the day) without the diagnosis but with the same feelings/anxieties/behaviours/triggers.

FWIW, I'm sad I grew up in a era when people with disabilities were, for the most part, hidden away and recognise as a society we failed those people.

However, I'll be honest, I'm also grateful that I was not traumatised by witnessing multiple violent/emotionally distressing meltdowns on a daily basis. The most 'unusual' event I/we witnessed were fellow pupils who had an accident being despatched to the school nurse, or someone crying because they'd fallen out with their best friend.

For me, that's the massively under-discussed issue - the trauma/impact on children witnessing these events - teachers/fellow pupils being punched, kicked, spat on, being hit with flying objects or the deep distress of the affected pupil - in someone who has been triggered into a meltdown due to noise/lights/not wanting to take off their jumper/sitting in their own excrement for too long etc.

Are we at risk of creating a generation of people with PTSD from being required (without option/discussion/agency) to witness these events? Living on their nerves waiting on the next meltdown and having zero inclination when/how that will occur? Having no idea if they will be in the physical firing line, receive a blow to the head or be hit with a flying chair? Isn't that how victims/the children of DV live?

Of course, all of that, is before we look at the impact on their education due to so much time lost with the teacher doing their best to mitigate/handle the meltdowns. I often wonder if there is correlation between declining mainstream educational standards and the time teachers have to spend handling pupils who are ND?

I don't know the answers to any of it, but I certainly hope those with the appropriate qualifications/research ability are looking at the situation with a wide-angled lens and not focused solely on what is best for the ND child/ren.

atelli · 08/09/2023 21:06

I think some parents of NT kids will observe an ND child with challenging behaviours (violence, disobedience etc) and like to think that their child doesn’t have these issues because they can be bothered to PARENT, they are proactive and instil firm clear boundaries and utilise proper discipline techniques. The ‘misbehaving’ child is a perfect example of their superior parenting.

So they don’t want to hear if that child is autistic and all those techniques have zero effect, and their NT kids are just easier and they wouldn’t do a better job than the other parent and they are not superior in any way. So then you get all people spouting about ‘Well I just see autism/adhd used as an excuse by lazy parents !’

Tr1pleJump · 08/09/2023 20:51

Gingerkittykat

Absolutely my kids and I have both. My children were diagnosed as autistic whilst suffering from trauma. A skilled diagnostician will be well able to correctly diagnosis somebody with autism who is struggling with trauma Their autism has lead to extremely traumatic experiences that have impacted all of us.

curaçao · 08/09/2023 20:28

shearwater · 08/09/2023 13:30

It's not just about "no attention span" either. Please stop spouting such ignorant shite, it's embarrassing.

Attention deficit isn't about inability to pay attention Ookkkaaay.I think you are the one embarrassing yourself!

Gingerkittykat · 08/09/2023 19:20

Masterofhappydays · 07/09/2023 22:59

Bit of a tangent post here, sorry!

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd.

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

So I do think there are some people in some places who are diagnosed incorrectly.

I suppose it’s difficult as I guess some parents have blamed neurodivergence for their poor parenting 🤷‍♀️

I am neurodiverse so I do find this interesting.

I have CPTSD and the psychologist who diagnosed me initially refused to do an autism assessment because of the trauma.

I then got started on my special interest and couldn't stop talking about it and she rethought and agreed to assess me for autism too. I did all the rating scales and then had a further 6 sessions going through autism stuff and I was found to be autistic too. There is an overlap on some areas of PTSD and autism but also some differences.

I know people who have PTSD who have been totally refused an autism assessment without even meeting them.

It is possible for people who have had a trauma history to also be autistic, in fact trauma is really common in autistic people because of bullying and higher levels of abuse.

AutismProf · 08/09/2023 17:40

RobertaFirmino · 08/09/2023 15:00

It feels to me as if a vast amount of people with a whole range of symptoms/behaviours are all lumped in together under one umbrella. People who, despite an ASD diagnosis, are highly functional with those whose autism is profound.
IIRC, Asperger's Syndrome was 'discontinued' because Dr. Asperger was a Nazi and the term ASD was brought in to cover this. I wonder if there is still a need for a less general classification as it seems as though those with a very profound presentation are at risk of being taken less seriously (as in 'Oh, everyone has that these days...' or 'Well plenty of people with autism still manage to work...) whilst those who are highly functioning risk being dismissed ('Oh, she won't amount to much, she's autistic...).
Then there are all the mothers (because it's always the women) who are told that autism is a 'superpower' whilst cleaning shit off the walls for the fifth night running.
I'm not sure that the term ASD itself does anyone any favours really.

No, Asperger's was discontinued because the distinction between autism and Asperger's was arbitrary (to do with speech delay - no speech delay= Asperger's, speech delay = autism) and because people interpreted Asperger's to mean "mild autism", which it isn't.

Whoever asked - no I don't do adult assessment.

Quisquam · 08/09/2023 15:55

This is precisely what I don't understand. When I was a child, 50 years ago, children simply did not punch, hit or spit at adults.

One of DD’s care workers told me, her first job in this country was to look after two adults with SLD, who had been dropped off at about age 3, at the local lunatic asylum, which in its heyday housed 3,000 people. It was closed down and its residents were put in supported living in the community - in their case, a house nearby.

How many people were put in institutions in those days, who would now be in mainstream schools?

shearwater · 08/09/2023 15:22

DD2's ADHD/ASD twice yearly private one to one appointments last one hour, so not only did she have a thorough assessment at the start but she has very thorough check ups each time.

I think the only time I've spent a whole hour with a medical professional in the NHS is when I was having surgery!

It's just lovely for her to speak to a specialist who completely understands her and I wish everyone could have this.

Willyoujustbequiet · 08/09/2023 15:21

shearwater · 08/09/2023 09:03

I would just point out that-

Not all private clinics are the same- yes some are better than others. Some are really good and absolute specialists in their field.

The NHS is NOT the standard by which all other providers should be measured. They are fucking shit at providing mental health care to children and young people. It is in a proper fucking state. Schools and local authorities SHOULD NOT be holding up a NHS diagnosis as a gold standard.

Usually assistance is not provided at all - the waiting list if you can get on it is 5 years - older kids would be adults and too old to receive help from CAMHS by the time they get an appointment. Parents go to private clinics not to seek a false diagnosis but to seek any help whatsoever because there is none to be had whatsoever from any other route.

I don't disagree with any of your points.

We were very lucky and only waited approx 3 - 4 months for each from referral to diagnosis. Its definitely a postcode lottery.

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 15:17

RobertaFirmino · 08/09/2023 15:00

It feels to me as if a vast amount of people with a whole range of symptoms/behaviours are all lumped in together under one umbrella. People who, despite an ASD diagnosis, are highly functional with those whose autism is profound.
IIRC, Asperger's Syndrome was 'discontinued' because Dr. Asperger was a Nazi and the term ASD was brought in to cover this. I wonder if there is still a need for a less general classification as it seems as though those with a very profound presentation are at risk of being taken less seriously (as in 'Oh, everyone has that these days...' or 'Well plenty of people with autism still manage to work...) whilst those who are highly functioning risk being dismissed ('Oh, she won't amount to much, she's autistic...).
Then there are all the mothers (because it's always the women) who are told that autism is a 'superpower' whilst cleaning shit off the walls for the fifth night running.
I'm not sure that the term ASD itself does anyone any favours really.

Yes that's why it is described as a spectrum.

The diagnostic criteria require evidence of persistent deficits in three areas and significant enough challenges to require support.

Mental-health co-morbidities are very common, as is ADHD.

Even without intellectual disabilities this can result in 'profound' disabilities including not being able to participate in everyday life things like employment.

Skinthin · 08/09/2023 15:05

YANBU

Punxsutawney · 08/09/2023 15:02

PylaSheight · 08/09/2023 14:20

@AutismProf do you assess adults as well as children? Only an adult acquaintance of mine (in UK) was recently diagnosed with ASD and all they've mentioned was a very long questionnaire, part of which their friend had to fill in (in the absence of parents). I've wanted to understand the process, yet am not able to discuss it with them really.

My adult autism assessment last year consisted of lots of questionnaires, an ADOS assessment appointment with a occupational therapist and a clinical psychologist. A separate appointment for my husband to answer questions without me there. And then finally a feedback session. This was private not NHS.

RobertaFirmino · 08/09/2023 15:00

It feels to me as if a vast amount of people with a whole range of symptoms/behaviours are all lumped in together under one umbrella. People who, despite an ASD diagnosis, are highly functional with those whose autism is profound.
IIRC, Asperger's Syndrome was 'discontinued' because Dr. Asperger was a Nazi and the term ASD was brought in to cover this. I wonder if there is still a need for a less general classification as it seems as though those with a very profound presentation are at risk of being taken less seriously (as in 'Oh, everyone has that these days...' or 'Well plenty of people with autism still manage to work...) whilst those who are highly functioning risk being dismissed ('Oh, she won't amount to much, she's autistic...).
Then there are all the mothers (because it's always the women) who are told that autism is a 'superpower' whilst cleaning shit off the walls for the fifth night running.
I'm not sure that the term ASD itself does anyone any favours really.

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 15:00

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:20

Not all assessors meet with the child for hours and not all assessors adhere to the triad. I posted earlier in the thread to say that as we access lots of different providers and assessors we see how varied it is.

Its not wrong or right but its misleading to state as fact that there is only one way the assessments take place.

So tell us who in the UK make autism diagnoses without using the criteria set out in either DSM 5 or ICD 10/11?

AncientQuercus · 08/09/2023 14:57

He spoke of doctors who claim parents come into their office begging for an adhd diagnosis for their child in order to get them medicated, and the pressure these doctors are under to conform to those pressures. He spoke of some schools too who push for a diagnosis of their ‘difficult’ students in order to obtain funding.

Bollocks.

We knew there was something wrong with DS1 when he was 1 year old. He finally got a diagnosis of ASD at 31. You only have to look at him to see he is Autistic.

DS2 was dx with ADHD as a 7yo back in the 90s. Had he not been medicated he would probably have ended up as a young offender. He now works with such people and has been shocked how many of them did not have a dx of ADHD but should have done.

I was dx with ADHD in my 50s and DH with Autism at almost 60, so it isn't really surprising that half of our DC are similarly affected. After 30 years of arguing with Know-Alls who decide that ADHD is made up or down to bad parenting I'm not impressed at the wave of celebrities who are suddenly being diagnosed.

C1N1C · 08/09/2023 14:42

@AuDHD4Me

While I DO agree with you and support you... I feel you have to be careful not to gatekeep 'suffering'. To say in your first post that people don't understand, even if they have kids that suffer from this, is a little unfair. It may not be first-hand experience, but the trauma is real. I see it like depression, which my wife has... yes, she suffers, but I suffer with her. I not only live her pain, but also my own as a result of her depression, anger, and the constant slog to be happy, trying to make her happy, and not to be dragged down too.

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 14:34

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:29

Im not sure I said that anywhere?

Or even implied it?

My post that you commented on was in response to a pp who said that. I responded to her saying that nobody is giving out diagnosis based on a singular symptom.

deepdepth · 08/09/2023 14:33

FOJN · 07/09/2023 23:01

I thought the point of he thread you are referring to was about posters attributing all and any behaviour to ADHD/ASD which I would have thought was insulting to anyone who actually is affected.

That happens all the time and it's often insulting. It was even on the Letby threads.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:29

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 14:24

Surely nobody is getting a diagnosis because they 'don't like noise' for example?
I don't believe that any teams are giving diagnosis out to anyone based on a few random symptoms.

Im not sure I said that anywhere?

Or even implied it?

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 14:28

LegendsBeyond · 08/09/2023 12:05

It’s true that there are huge numbers of children & adults wrongly diagnosed with ADHD. Trauma is at the heart of their behaviours. It’s very sad because the trauma often never gets addressed.

Perhaps show us the peer reviewed evidence from a GB context?

Having been through two assessments with different family members, due regard and weight was applied to the question of trauma on both occasions, and co-morbidities identified. Lots of people have both. The experience of trauma in life is very common.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:28

PylaSheight · 08/09/2023 14:20

@AutismProf do you assess adults as well as children? Only an adult acquaintance of mine (in UK) was recently diagnosed with ASD and all they've mentioned was a very long questionnaire, part of which their friend had to fill in (in the absence of parents). I've wanted to understand the process, yet am not able to discuss it with them really.

For my sister who was diagnosed as an adult, she went via the GP, the assessor contacted my parents and me.

What help that would have given her talking to my parents I do not know, my parents have zero insight into their parenting and the trauma we as children exprienced. Im not sure my sister also understands or recognises it either but the assessor certainly was thorough enough to speak to the whole family. My sister had 2 sessions with the assessor and that was nearly 25 years ago.

I dont know what it looks like now and I would be interested to know for adults because I strongly suspect my partner is on the spectrum and as ADHD, living with him I can tell and he scores highly on the screening tools.

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 14:24

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:20

Not all assessors meet with the child for hours and not all assessors adhere to the triad. I posted earlier in the thread to say that as we access lots of different providers and assessors we see how varied it is.

Its not wrong or right but its misleading to state as fact that there is only one way the assessments take place.

Surely nobody is getting a diagnosis because they 'don't like noise' for example?
I don't believe that any teams are giving diagnosis out to anyone based on a few random symptoms.

bellac11 · 08/09/2023 14:20

WanderingWitches · 08/09/2023 13:56

Nobody gets a diagnosed because they have one of those symptoms ffs. Autism assessment is grueling and they go right back to when you were a child. They speak to a parent if possible, and another person very close to you like your partner. You are assessed for hours.
There is a triad of impairment to meet. If you don't meet it, you don't get diagnosed.

Not all assessors meet with the child for hours and not all assessors adhere to the triad. I posted earlier in the thread to say that as we access lots of different providers and assessors we see how varied it is.

Its not wrong or right but its misleading to state as fact that there is only one way the assessments take place.