Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Jjxnxnxnnc · 10/09/2023 12:51

put

Jjxnxnxnnc · 10/09/2023 12:50

One thing that strikes me is that there is currently a thread where a woman with ADHD/anxiety is complaining about a financial circumstance and says she is unemployed. The OP was inundated with responses about how autism and ADHD do not prevent employment and she should get a job. My question would be how difficult is it for those with neurological conditions to gain employment? I would hazard a guess that the symptoms of ADHD may not be conducive to work performance so what measures can be ok in place to support those with neurological disorders to get into the work place?

My concern is that there are many (particularly boys) that are being diagnosed for laudable reasons with neurological conditions that will at a certain point have to gain employment and show their motivation and suitability to work to an employer. Stating you have ADHD will I fear in some circumstances may have a negative response from an employer that values attention to detail or attention for long periods of time. If the sufferer has a poor academic record where are the employers that are going to be providing these jobs. I think this is where the real 'ableism' starts.

I can see a proportion of children being supported through childhood but having to face a harsh reality when it comes to adulthood and the workplace. I think one thing that has to be avoided given human nature is that ADHD/autism sufferers who are poor do not get labelled as the next 'benefits street' job with a new generation of Jeremy Kyle lovers baying at these people to get off their backsides and get a job.

boxersorbriefs · 10/09/2023 10:39

As someone with no experience of autism with myself or my family

Is a meltdown like an epileptic shock. As in it's not controllable?

AutismProf · 10/09/2023 09:39

Sorry - Rett syndrome.

AutismProf · 10/09/2023 09:38

Most autism is inherited or genetic and present from birth, though obviously the symptoms may only arise and be recognised later.

Autism can also be caused by brain injury - the one we see most is after severe bacterial meningitis in a baby, but in some neurodegenerative conditions as well like Rett's disease. It's probably a slightly different "type" of autism.

Quisquam · 10/09/2023 09:27

What? Your last post stated 'DD1 was never diagnosed as having autism'. I really don't get the point you are trying to make. Autism is a lifelong condition, if it is not present at birth it is not autism.

DD was extensively assessed in the specialist education system and nobody ever thought she had autism.

The neurodegenerative syndrome reared its ugly head and she suffered massive cognitive deterioration. As an adult she went to live in a specialist centre. They just assumed she had autism and it was in the paperwork they produced. I didn’t go round asking who made that diagnosis - the SALT department, the clinical psychologist or the consultant neuro-psychiatrist.

That is the nature of neurodegeneration - changes over time.

I don’t know how you can state categorically autism is only from birth; as if the areas of the brain responsible for the symptoms of autism are immune from the degeneration which affects areas like memory, IQ, language, aggression, irritability, walking and the development of psychosis?

They also don’t seem to know much about gene penetrance or expression? DD has 2 syndromes interacting. They don’t know why one of them is pathogenic in her; but is asymptomatic in most people with it. They can’t tell us, as carriers of one of them, how much the gene variant affects us; other than to say it depends on the penetrance.

clpsmum · 09/09/2023 22:40

Agree op. Ignorance is rife

egowise · 09/09/2023 22:34

NoMor · 09/09/2023 21:15

What? Your last post stated 'DD1 was never diagnosed as having autism'. I really don't get the point you are trying to make. Autism is a lifelong condition, if it is not present at birth it is not autism.

Yep, autism is from birth.

NoMor · 09/09/2023 21:15

Quisquam · 09/09/2023 20:14

How does any of that refute what I wrote? Your daughter has not been diagnosed as autistic.

All the professionals in the specialist centre, where she lives, assumed she was, when she went to live there. So, they diagnosed her as autistic.

What? Your last post stated 'DD1 was never diagnosed as having autism'. I really don't get the point you are trying to make. Autism is a lifelong condition, if it is not present at birth it is not autism.

greyflannel · 09/09/2023 21:12

LizzieW1969 · 09/09/2023 10:29

^This. My DB was diagnosed with autism in his 50s, a couple of years ago. I don’t believe it. I remember him as a little boy, sociable with lots of friends. His issues didn’t manifest themselves until he was in adolescence.

Whereas he was sexually abused, as were my DSis and I. We’ve both been diagnosed with complex PTSD, so it’s surely reasonable to suppose that my DB has it too.

But he remembers nothing about his childhood so he’s never been diagnosed like we have. He’s badly damaged, whatever his diagnosis, and can’t function as an adult.

I'm very sorry to hear of you and your siblings' experiences.

One of the things that makes this difficult is that a lot of us have a poor understanding of what autism actually is, or of the range of presentations.

Even professionals will sometimes lapse into assuming that if a child can hold eye contact or is sociable, then autism can probably be ruled out. This is incorrect. Plenty of autistic kids are socially-oriented and just about manage until adolescence, when social relationships become more complex, and they are required to manage them without adult supervision, at which point their differences in social understanding and communications become very much more visible and problematic.

Quisquam · 09/09/2023 20:14

How does any of that refute what I wrote? Your daughter has not been diagnosed as autistic.

All the professionals in the specialist centre, where she lives, assumed she was, when she went to live there. So, they diagnosed her as autistic.

NoMor · 09/09/2023 20:10

Quisquam · 09/09/2023 18:48

Unless I'm misunderstanding you, you are totally wrong about this. Autism is present from birth, the brain is literally wired differently to NT's. Autism-like symptoms brought on by trauma is NOT autism, it is trauma.

This not true. DD1 was never diagnosed as having autism; and she had countless assessments by NHS and independent SALTs, OTs, EPS and a consultant child psychiatrist. One SALT told me, she knew DD had a congenital brain abnormality because she was so sociable for a child with a developmental language disorder.

She has a neuro-degenerative disorder and now has autistic traits, including hand flapping. Nobody has assessed her cognitively recently, so I don’t know to what extent; but she is presenting with PDA!

How does any of that refute what I wrote? Your daughter has not been diagnosed as autistic.

Quisquam · 09/09/2023 18:48

Unless I'm misunderstanding you, you are totally wrong about this. Autism is present from birth, the brain is literally wired differently to NT's. Autism-like symptoms brought on by trauma is NOT autism, it is trauma.

This not true. DD1 was never diagnosed as having autism; and she had countless assessments by NHS and independent SALTs, OTs, EPS and a consultant child psychiatrist. One SALT told me, she knew DD had a congenital brain abnormality because she was so sociable for a child with a developmental language disorder.

She has a neuro-degenerative disorder and now has autistic traits, including hand flapping. Nobody has assessed her cognitively recently, so I don’t know to what extent; but she is presenting with PDA!

chaosmaker · 09/09/2023 16:15

Galiana · 08/09/2023 00:29

@chaosmaker, speak to me??

Hi Galiana

LizzieW1969 · 09/09/2023 10:29

NoMor · 08/09/2023 09:52

Unless I'm misunderstanding you, you are totally wrong about this. Autism is present from birth, the brain is literally wired differently to NT's. Autism-like symptoms brought on by trauma is NOT autism, it is trauma.

^This. My DB was diagnosed with autism in his 50s, a couple of years ago. I don’t believe it. I remember him as a little boy, sociable with lots of friends. His issues didn’t manifest themselves until he was in adolescence.

Whereas he was sexually abused, as were my DSis and I. We’ve both been diagnosed with complex PTSD, so it’s surely reasonable to suppose that my DB has it too.

But he remembers nothing about his childhood so he’s never been diagnosed like we have. He’s badly damaged, whatever his diagnosis, and can’t function as an adult.

greyflannel · 09/09/2023 10:06

This study is not about the distribution of ADHD across social classes but considers the impact of families experiencing financial difficulty or stress on the expression and severity of ADHD symptoms in children with a diagnosis. There is a small effect detected, which is described as interesting but not clinically significant.

In terms of SEN and disability more generally, we live in a country with very significant health inequalities. All sorts of long term health conditions are associated with poverty, this runs the gamut from poorer perinatal outcomes to reduced adult life expectancy. People who are the most socially and economically deprevied also receive the poorest healthcare. You are right about the complexity in how this plays out, including in terms of patterns of referral and diagnosis.

Tr1pleJump · 09/09/2023 09:53

Why are we surprised that a disability which hugely impacts education, relationships, handling money, mental health etc is going to be more prevalent in lower social
economic groups?🤷‍♀️Just one parent having it will impact household finances hugely let alone the impact of children who have it too. It can be hereditary.

NoMor · 09/09/2023 09:50

Jjxnxnxnnc · 09/09/2023 09:08

@Tr1pleJump

I absolutely agree that ND exists and there is a whole raft of diagnostic tests that can brought into play. For those with an ND child it must be extremely challenging and as a society we need to lend that support.

However for continued societal support I think there is a genuine debate about the reasons and consequences of increased prevalence of ND and in particular how it impacts our educational system. I don't think it is necessarily ableist to discuss schooling in general and sometimes discussions about school environment do touch upon ND.

There is unfortunately cynicism in our local community about ND prevalence at some of the poorer performing schools and I think honest debate is needed to counter it and shutting down voices that may appear offensive may actually be counter productive.

The proportion of pupils at some of our area's poor performing schools who are ND is really quite significant and there also would appear to be some correlation with socio economic status in some cases. You do actually get ableism in the fact that classes are unfairly being labelled as the ADHD/ASD class when academic setting is applied and children (sometimes being cruel) will highlight this.

You do make interesting points. The reason for more diagnosis is better understanding, the consequence goes onto you next paragraph. Poorer performing schools are often in deprived areas. Currently, only 22% of autistic adults are in work in the UK. The consequence will be more ND children (hopefully) getting the help they need to get a proper education and helped into work improving social mobility so when they have their own ND children, they will not so be concentrated in deprived areas.

Jjxnxnxnnc · 09/09/2023 09:27

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00127-017-1453-2

A study looking into links between finance and ADHD.

I think if you do look at the research there is also a social element to this as well as an individual and discussions about how neurodivergence fits in with general social models is interesting.

There are some reasonablle correlations between %FSM at schools and %children with SEN. The reasons between the interplay of parental economic class and disability is probably really quite complex but is of academic interest.

The relationship between financial difficulty and childhood symptoms of attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder: a UK longitudinal cohort study - Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology

Purpose Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is associated with socioeconomic status (SES), in that children who grow up in low SES families are at an increased risk of ADHD symptoms and diagnosis. The current study explores whether differen...

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00127-017-1453-2

NewName122 · 09/09/2023 09:12

I have a friend that will often say 'well we are all a bit autistic, we could all fit on the spectrum somewhere'. I obviously disagree with her but as a parent with an ASD/adhd child I see my friend does have many traits and I think that's her way of saying she is like that but has no diognosis. Next time I might suggest she gets assessed to see if it clicks in her brain.

Tr1pleJump · 09/09/2023 09:10

Jjxnxnxnnc

Links to your data supporting this please.

Jjxnxnxnnc · 09/09/2023 09:08

@Tr1pleJump

I absolutely agree that ND exists and there is a whole raft of diagnostic tests that can brought into play. For those with an ND child it must be extremely challenging and as a society we need to lend that support.

However for continued societal support I think there is a genuine debate about the reasons and consequences of increased prevalence of ND and in particular how it impacts our educational system. I don't think it is necessarily ableist to discuss schooling in general and sometimes discussions about school environment do touch upon ND.

There is unfortunately cynicism in our local community about ND prevalence at some of the poorer performing schools and I think honest debate is needed to counter it and shutting down voices that may appear offensive may actually be counter productive.

The proportion of pupils at some of our area's poor performing schools who are ND is really quite significant and there also would appear to be some correlation with socio economic status in some cases. You do actually get ableism in the fact that classes are unfairly being labelled as the ADHD/ASD class when academic setting is applied and children (sometimes being cruel) will highlight this.

Tr1pleJump · 09/09/2023 08:50

Jjxnxnxnnc

If has been explained over and again why there is an increase. It isn’t parents pushing inaccurate labels. You need a shed load of evidence just to get a referral and then there is a massive waiting list.

So I’ll say it yet again. We are far more informed now particularly with girls as to how autism can present. Diagnostics are better. Before it was geared towards boys. With better knowledge less girls are going under the radar for years, with it has come siblings and parents being picked up. It’s a good thing. Covid caused a massive backlog.

As for schools struggling to support those with a ND diagnosis. A diagnosis gets you zilch.All SEN is massively underfunded and that is why schools struggle. In our setting ND hadn’t been discussed once as an issue re us “ coping”.🤔I’d be very surprised if any school did. We have a massive range and variety of SENs and we just get on with it and prove good interventions and a happy environment for all. It is ableist to discuss this.An increase in children getting an ASC diagnosis is neither here nor there, you wouldn’t suggest more visible disabilities be under scrutiny.

I think there is a fair bit if sexism with this too. Women and girls don’t fit the stereotypical picture of ND and to many should just get on with it.

Jjxnxnxnnc · 09/09/2023 08:31

I don't think as well as should try to reject the experience of parents whose children at MY but are in classes with children whose behaviour disrupts their learning. This must be horrible for the parent.

Independent on whether disruptive behaviour is associated with ND these voices should have a forum and shouldn't be necessarily about s down as being 'ableist'. These are genuine concerns many face.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 09/09/2023 08:24

I doubt it’s black and white.