Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at the ableism here on MN

290 replies

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 07/09/2023 22:40

I don't see any threads saying cancer is over diagnosed. Or used as an excuse for something.
More and more ableism is showing up here targeting the ADHD and autistic community and I'm pig sick of it.
Overdiagnosis conversations involving those who have no lived experience (your kids don't count, sorry) suck.
You have ZERO idea what it's like to be us.
And you say WE lack empathy.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
electriclight · 08/09/2023 05:43

It is actually quite difficult in schools, or certainly in those I've worked in.

Many pupils self-diagnose after seeing posts on social media. I had one pupil tell me she had ADHD because she rubs her feet together in bed, and she showed me the post. Sometimes they convince their parents on skimpy evidence, sometimes parents seize on it as a reason for their child working below age expectations or being in trouble.

I have also seen parents go to several private practitioners, who do not find their child to be ND, until they eventually get the diagnosis they want. The worst of these reports was on one sheet of A4 and written in very poor English, and was obtained in a city a three hour drive from us after the expense of three failed reports.

I think the journalist who was in the press recently for obtaining a false diagnosis has confirmed what some people already thought.

I hope I am not ablist. I support all of my pupils whether they have a diagnosis or needs suggesting they need one, and comply with the recommendations in every report I receive.

Nemesias · 08/09/2023 05:32

Soontobe60 · 08/09/2023 00:05

The issue is more complex though. Something like diabetes or breast cancer is diagnosed by scans, X-rays, blood tests, biopsies. They’re not diagnosed by patients listing unmeasureable symptoms. Evidence is anecdotal. People are very well informed - and if someone wanted to get a diagnosis of ADHD, they could easily do so by listing all the symptoms, regardless as to whether they have it or not. It’s open to exploitation especially when someone could end up with medication being prescribed that actually has value on the open market in some places.
The real skill is for clinicians to be able to filter out the fakers (for want of a better word) from genuine sufferers.
If the number of people being diagnosed with ADHD continues to rise at the rate it is currently at, then will someone with ADHD be considered to be neurotypical and those without it be neurodivergent?

Have you been through the diagnosis procedure for adhd?

Yellowlegobrick · 08/09/2023 05:30

I think the concern many of us have is the regular expansion of the diagnostic criteria creating an ever more narrow recognition of what "neurotypical" is.

It can feel like our society can only accept differences if they are labelled as a condition, rather than us looking to why so many people are struggling so much with modern life. As a society if such huge numbers of people are struggling so much, we are getting something badly wrong.

blendedfamly · 08/09/2023 05:25

Yes it's shocking how dismissive people can be of the autistic experience. I think the fact that it's become one of those "everyone has it" conditions is largely the issue. (Like ocd) I personally have no issue with self identification, I recognised myself as autistic several years before I was diagnosed. But I do recognise when a large number of people do this about themselves or their kids it gives the illusion of everyone being autistic. And with that leads to the assumption that diagnoses are chucked out left right and centre. Which those of us who have been diagnosed know is not the case.

Logically if we were the majority we wouldn't have to deal with the ablest bull shit would we.

Yellowlegobrick · 08/09/2023 05:24

Surely any doctor worth their salt wouldn't conform to parental or school pressure!

Are you kidding? Loads do. There are kids in my DC school who had to see 3 or 4 private specialists to get a diagnosis - parents sought more and more opinions because the first drs few said no.... the parents are open about this.

Opinion shopping 100% happens. A gp friend if mine commented among a group of us that if you are willing to pay privately and you want a diagnosis, you will get on eventually if you talk to enough drs.

WeWereInParis · 08/09/2023 05:15

Just a reminder for everyone that the BBC was forced to apologise for its inaccurate reporting on this issue by its own Trust, after finding the breaches in editorial standards so severe:

That's about a show broadcast 16 years ago, in 2007. It doesn't mean that everything the bbc reports about that issue is now unreliable. They didn't find a systemic issue with all the BBC's reporting on the subject.
If there are issues with the other article & programme (from this year), they should be addressed separately.

ChillysWaterBottle · 08/09/2023 05:06

@everythingthelighttouches Reread my comment

Nohero · 08/09/2023 04:48

@Masterofhappydays Thank you for posting this; It’s not my specialist area but have read a little about this due to my work and was going to post something similar but less articulate.

there are significant overlaps between complex trauma presentation and ADHD. Getting the right diagnosis and treatment should be what we focus on. In practice, in a stretched service, treating with drugs (maybe 3-4 appts total, then discharge to GP) is often going to be easier than therapies to treat trauma (maybe years of specialist follow up). My psychiatry colleagues are under significant pressure to get people through the system and discharged because the waiting lists are insane. Plus they are in a significantly under-resourced area and people need immediate help by the time they see them.

It’s also complicated by the fact that everyone responds to stimulant medication. In the US there is an acknowledged abuse problem.

The UK PTSD charity has a good diagram of overlapping features. Complex trauma and ADHD can, of course, coexist.
https://www.ptsduk.org/can-ptsd-be-mistaken-for-adhd/

Can PTSD be mistaken for ADHD? – PTSD UK

PTSD UK - a community for everyone in the UK affected by Post Traumatic Stress Disorder

https://www.ptsduk.org/can-ptsd-be-mistaken-for-adhd/

greyflannel · 08/09/2023 04:35

There is so much bad science on this thread!

A) People should read the relevant NICE guidelines. Clinicians are prompted to consider alternative explanations and will sometimes use things like QB tests to confirm diagnoses.
B) Being neurodiverse and experiencing trauma are very far from mutually exclusive. There is peer reviewed research showing that autistic people and people with ADHD are more likely to experience trauma and victimisation.
C) People need to be careful with ACEs - the Early Intervention Foundation undertook a major review which exposed several common misconceptions.

SussexLass87 · 08/09/2023 04:29

YANBU!!

DaisyWaldron · 08/09/2023 04:28

N3philim · 08/09/2023 03:33

If you think attitudes towards adhd/ autism are bad try discussing personality disorders without being labelled a monster. That’s a free for all.

And I believe self diagnoses should and need to be challenged. It’s fair enough if someone is asking for advice or shared experiences, but this does not make up for a proper diagnosis.

You can't get an NHS diagnosis where I live. The single clinic was overwhelmed, so now the only adults being assessed for ADHD and autism are those at immediate risk of physical harm to themselves or others. Everyone else gets an automated online quiz that gives results in the form of a profile listing your strengths, weaknesses and skills to work on.

everythingthelighttouches · 08/09/2023 04:11

ChillysWaterBottle · 08/09/2023 03:17

Just a reminder for everyone that the BBC was forced to apologise for its inaccurate reporting on this issue by its own Trust, after finding the breaches in editorial standards so severe:

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/feb/24/panorama-bbc-trust-ruling

That Guardian article is from 2010 and is about a different Panorama program.

Galiana · 08/09/2023 04:06

Hey @N3philim it's life isn't it?

N3philim · 08/09/2023 03:33

If you think attitudes towards adhd/ autism are bad try discussing personality disorders without being labelled a monster. That’s a free for all.

And I believe self diagnoses should and need to be challenged. It’s fair enough if someone is asking for advice or shared experiences, but this does not make up for a proper diagnosis.

ChillysWaterBottle · 08/09/2023 03:17

everythingthelighttouches · 08/09/2023 02:57

Posted this on the other thread but posting again here.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-65534448.amp

Just a reminder for everyone that the BBC was forced to apologise for its inaccurate reporting on this issue by its own Trust, after finding the breaches in editorial standards so severe:

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/feb/24/panorama-bbc-trust-ruling

BBC Trust condemns 'inaccurate' Panorama ADHD episode

Trust rules report into treatment of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder failed to meet standards of accuracy. By Jason Deans

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/feb/24/panorama-bbc-trust-ruling

ChillysWaterBottle · 08/09/2023 03:11

YANBU. I don't know why it's allowed.

Masterofhappydays · 08/09/2023 02:56

ConnieTucker · 07/09/2023 23:04

I was on a PD last week run by a neuroscientist. He said there is a whole group of people who have been diagnosed with autism or adhd, and medicated. However, these people aren’t neurodiverse, they’re actually victims of complex trauma, where the ‘symptoms’ present similarly to autism/adhd

I had the opposite in summer. PD trauma training and I said that the symptoms were the same for ADHD, so how many children with trauma are being diagnosed incorrectly.

The amount of children with trauma is alarming.

Trauma is 'measurable'. Exposure to Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) increases the risk of being trauma impacted. Eg, studies have shown brain scans of children who were neglected as babies and the differences in brain anatomy between a trauma-impacted child's brain and a healthy child's brain are astonishing. I have a vested interest in this as I was a Romanian orphanage adoptee in the late 80's which is where it was first discovered that neglected babies' brains grow/wife differently.

There is so, so, so much emerging research into trauma and misdiagnosis of autism/ADHD. It was not just this one neuroscientist who said all this, he was referring to other people's work and he is one of the highest regarded leaders in complex childhood trauma in the world. I am about to be a co-supervisor on a PhD research paper which is about adverse childhood experiences and the prevalence of complex trauma, so I have been reading so much over the past six months, though I am not an expert in the slightest. I am just responding here to answer the questions raised from my previous post (and to thank those who agreed).
There are many research papers on google scholar for those interested in looking at the links in children who are trauma-impacted being incorrectly diagnosed with ADHD or autism. These concerns were initially raised in 2006, so it is nothing new.^^

For those of you who do not like to read journal articles, there is a good article in the Atlantic by Rebecca Ruiz titled 'How childhood trauma could be mistaken for ADHD.

And yes, doctors do give ADHD medication to children under pressure from parents who are desperate for respite who present at the doctor's office listing off symptoms. One of the videos shown during the class was a USA GP who explained how schools were pressurising parents to get their children medicated as the schools could not cope with the behaviours. The parents were desperate and believed their child did have ADHD as the schools said so.

I was given an asthmatic inhaler as a child by a doctor because I had a cough. This was when I was in England. Literally everyone in my entire class had an inhaler. I do not for one second believe we were all asthmatic. I cannot see why you think it is not easy to be given medication that you do not need.

The really horrific thing is: children who are trauma impacted are being given medication to suppress any feelings they have so they are "more manageable" for the adults in their lives, thus therefore never addressing the trauma they are impacted with.

So yes, I do still believe that MANY children are diagnosed worldwide with autism or ADHD and then medicated, when all they needed was positive relationships to assist them with overcoming their trauma. The prevalence of trauma is astonishing, Approximately 92% of children have been exposed to at least one adverse childhood experience (ACEs) and 76% more than one ACE. The more exposure to ACEs, the higher the chance of being trauma-impacted. Being exposed to ACEs in early childhood can change the structure of the brain, thus the behaviours mimic behaviours presented in ADHD/Autism, thus the misdiagnosis. This is worldwide.

Hopinghonestly · 08/09/2023 02:47

Yes..i was misdiagnosed for PD and ED for years when it was Autism and ARFID, I did have Trauma which confused things..but people with Autism still feel Trauma, they can be more sensitive to it.

I was forced on medication which caused seizures, then another caused drug induced parkinsons. Since diagnosed been off meds for years but still struggle with hand tremors, Very annoyed about it all.

I get the..you dont look Autistic..(apparently people in my community assumption is your either mute or einstein)

Then there is the trickery of always doing wrong. Apparently you have to disclose your Autism as people tell me people need to know to understand, but at the same time get told if i do disclose it that it is annoying as it looks like i am using it to excuse myself..i cant "be" like it as people get uncomfortable and shouldnt have to deal with it. Totally confusing..

Galiana · 08/09/2023 02:14

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 08/09/2023 00:34

I agree with this

That is interesting.

It's also probably right/correct.

But also it's a bloke on the old 'women be mental' trip.

I've seen three generations of ND women just get on. We've done ok. More than ok.

We are middle class and privileged women.

It's not easy to navigate though.

Trez1510 · 08/09/2023 02:06

The article posted by @Namechange666 is interesting.

Hopefully those findings can be used to confirm diagnoses. That should put an end to the arguments/ambiguity over who has, and who hasn't, ADHD (or whatever it ends up being called).

Namechange666 · 08/09/2023 01:51

I think you're massively over blaming yourself here.

Being ND can be hereditary. It's likely nothing you did could change it.

Gently, it sounds like maybe you were the traumatised one. Did you ever have counselling?

I think going with the medical professional is your best bet and help your children with reasonabe adjustments. Wish so much someone would have seen it in me when I was a child. I've never been moving to the same beat as other people....

ChallengeAnneka · 08/09/2023 01:50

LordSalem · 08/09/2023 00:47

The vast majority of people today are not decent human beings. They're cruel, critical, judgemental, selfish, ignorant, rude, loud and cold. This applies to any given situation. The semantics or variables rarely matter or make a difference.
Imagine where we'll be in ten years when middle aged people are acting like this now without a second thought and we're already suffering from gangs of teenage and younger kids daily as well. And they find it funny, big and clever to intimidate and attack adults as well as other kids, and vandalise as they see fit because they are getting zero comeuppance in any way whatsoever.
This isn't civilisation, it's who can shout the loudest and get away with anything.
Historically it's fucking pathetic.
ND? No one gives a shit. NT no one gives a shit. You're a target for abuse either way.
People aren’t people, they're vicious bastards who jump at any excuse to discriminate against whatever they decide (on a whim) is different to them,

I wouldn’t say the vast majority but a significant minority of human beings are not decent. The veneer of humanity is slipping.

Namechange666 · 08/09/2023 01:46

By the way, I aren't a victim of trauma. I also have other people in my family diagnosed. It's massively under diagnosed in women. Which is why the most newly diagnosed are women in their 30s like me.

The lockdown saw to that.

Namechange666 · 08/09/2023 01:44

I agree. I got diagnosed at the weekend and I'm in my late 30s! I've struggled all my life and finally have answers. I'm inattentive adhd.

It makes me laugh that people accept hearts, lungs, skin going wrong but never the brain! There are definitely more neurodiverse people than everyone realises. It is a neurotypical world but for some reason, they don't like adjustments being made for us. Luckily most of my family and friends have been supportive and work thankfully!

You can actually see adhd on scans. Even though diagnosed mainly by symptoms. 7 Ways ADHD Can Be Seen in the Brain | Psychology Today United Kingdom
https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-reality-gen-z/202112/7-ways-adhd-can-be-seen-in-the-brain%3famp

7 Ways ADHD Can Be Seen in the Brain

In the amygdala, the cerebellum, and elsewhere.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-reality-gen-z/202112/7-ways-adhd-can-be-seen-in-the-brain%3famp