Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not my responsibility to be chasing ExH to pay school dinner money?

189 replies

DietCokeAddict19 · 07/09/2023 21:30

ExH and I split up 6 years ago, we have 2 DC who are at secondary school.

ExH is a high earner - approx £100k to my £20k.

Up until last year ExH paid child maintenance (£500 per month) but that stopped as the kids are with us each 50% of the time. It was agreed that we would each pay half of the costs associated with the children (uniform, school trips, school dinners etc) but it almost always falls to me to either buy these things, or I end up having to ask/remind him to pay for them.

Last year over the year I have just totted it up and I paid £700 for school dinners (!!!), he didn't pay anything.

He has the same school app as me so he can see when their balance is running low, but he seemingly doesn't look at it or ignores the reminders to pay. So I end up paying because I don't want the kids to go without lunch. I sent him a message before the term started to highlight that I paid for all school lunches last year and could he top up their balances, to which I got a shirty reply of "I'm sure I put money in last year" and a promise he would top up. He hasn't. So I have because DS1 has 65p in his account and couldn't buy lunch tomorrow otherwise.

Despite ExH having the kids half the time he still seems to be fucking Disney dad and I end up having to be the responsible one and sort everything out. Part of me wonders if he does it on purpose and likes me having to come to him and ask him for money, but I'm fucking tired of it. I hate asking for money and part of me wishes I could pay it all myself so I don't have to ask, but he earns so much more than me and I can't afford it all now that my monthly child maintenance has stopped.

OP posts:
Lolapusht · 08/09/2023 21:52

“Beneficial interest”. Can be probable where the non-owner has contributed to the mortgage so not sure if he could prove it in your case.

Is the house on your name or your dad’s?

How many properties does he own and how much income does he get from them? How long have you lived together? In case he turns into a Super Wanker when you tell him what’s about to happen, maybe total up how much tax credit you’ve lost as a result of living with him.

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 21:45

The longer the current partner stays in your “mortgage free” home the more hold he has over making anything from a split in the future .

What does that mean @Takeabreather23 ?

Does it mean there is a risk he could somehow put some claim on the house?

OP posts:
Takeabreather23 · 08/09/2023 20:48

Wow get Rid of the current user . Once he’s gone get a cms claim in for your ex.

The longer the current partner stays in your “mortgage free” home the more hold he has over making anything from a split in the future .

If either of these men cared for you or respected you this wouldn’t be happening . They are both users .

Fairymcclary · 08/09/2023 20:43

Call his bluff and say you’ll move into his house and pay him 550 and rent out yours. Old greedy money grabber will be foaming at the mouth at how you could possibly expect to pay so little each month.

Sit down partner and tell him how much worse off you are. Tell him you can’t afford x/y/x and your income dropped due to him moving in (does the 550 include his food). Ask him what does he suggest?

if he’s good egg he will apologise and seriously up his miserly contribution and you can improve your communication skills going forward, maybe explore why you were unhappy to bring it up. Why did you feel you cannot ask a man to pay his way? Why accept so little?
Or if he’s suggests nothing and looks at you as if he has no clue how to change the situation you have your answer and you can then give Mr Greedy 24 hours notice to sort out his own life. He will splutter about the cost of accommodations etc.

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 20:18

He’s up more than that, he would have had bills in the other house to pay too. Why didn’t you move in with him rent free and rent out your house? He should also be reimbursing what you lost. The whole reason you lost it is because it’s expected if someone lives with you as a partner they share their income.

His house is in a city 3 hours away and my DC are in school and settled here so I wouldn’t relocate them/us.

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 20:16

Carpediemmakeitcount · 08/09/2023 19:42

Does your partner have children of his own?

No.

OP posts:
PortalooSunset · 08/09/2023 19:59

DietCokeAddict19 · 07/09/2023 22:31

I don't understand- wouldn't your partner like to treat you and your kids to a day out?? Sorry none of my business (and off topic) but is your new partner quite tight generally?

No, he would pay half but wouldn’t pay for the whole thing. Just before we went on holiday in the summer (the cost of which we split 50/50) he got a large overtime payment which was more than the cost of the holiday. He declared at the airport “all treats are on me this holiday”. Turns out that wasn’t true when I got sent a text with the amount that he had spent (on groceries and 2 lunches out) and how much I owed him.

He claims to be saving up for “our” retirement. But that’s totally meaningless when he (or I) could walk away at any time. And clearly his words don’t mean much after the “treats are on me” incident.

Holy fuck. Out of the frying pan and into the fire much?!

You do know you deserve better right?

DungareesAndTrombones · 08/09/2023 19:52

In my recent experience the CMS are shit hot. Ring them and give them his address and phone number and they will do the rest. The will be able to look on HMRC to calculate his wage and they will calculate exactly what he owes you.

Therealjudgejudy · 08/09/2023 19:46

Your current partner sounds like a total leech

Mumof4plusbonus · 08/09/2023 19:43

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:35

So current partner pays half of the monthly outgoings (actually just over half, currently he pays £550 and I pay £450 - we needed more money per month but I couldn't increase it by as much as him so we settled on that). The house was bought by my dad, so I don't have a mortgage. He rents out the house that he lived in before we got together, in a city 3 hours away, and I'm somewhat ashamed to say that his income from that is £1800, but I don't see a penny of it. He pays no rent here, just the £550 as above.

I know reading it back it's awful. He previously was letting the house on an ad hoc basis so it wasn't always occupied so I never knew how much he was bringing in from it. Then he agreed a longer term let which is when I found out how much he is benefitting by living with me. On the flip side I lost my tax credits when he moved in, so I'm down by about £300 a month, maybe more, and he is £1250 up.

The "retirement" is the properties that he owns and rents out. So it's not money in an account, although he has lots of those, or anything I have access to. And (stupidly) I only twigged fairly recently that if income from those properties is our/his retirement income, then he is expecting to still live in a house paid for by me when we retire.

I sound like a total mug and complete idiot. I don't even know how it's got to this point. But I completely agree it's not ok, and to whoever asked about what I find attractive in someone who treats me and my kids like this, the answer is not a lot.

He’s up more than that, he would have had bills in the other house to pay too. Why didn’t you move in with him rent free and rent out your house? He should also be reimbursing what you lost. The whole reason you lost it is because it’s expected if someone lives with you as a partner they share their income.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 08/09/2023 19:42

Does your partner have children of his own?

ellie09 · 08/09/2023 19:23

Contact CMS and put in a claim again. I am pretty sure you can still get payments even with a 50:50 arrangement based on his earnings.

Is the arrangements you made outside CMS in writing? About the payments etc? If not, I would seek legal advice to try and get this written in family court. It means if he doesn't abide by it, there are consequences.

There's always an excuse for the other parent. It doesn't take much to calculate a rough estimate of what is required and then set up a monthly standing order straight to you.

Its financial abuse realistically and his children are the victims.

Barblarble · 08/09/2023 19:13

My dad did this, or the equivalent at the time. Never 'remembered' to have the cash on him for a bus pass and lunch every other week when we started for school from his house, and even when he did he budgeted £1 a day for lunches. £1 bought you the cheapest sandwich and nothing else when I started secondary. Didn't even buy that a couple of years later. Got furious with us and accused us of lying if the bus company put fares up even by pennies. So we had barely enough money for lunches his weeks when he had remembered cash, (weirdly he did always have enough cash for the bus, I think a couple of times he actually stopped at a cashpoint and got out bus money, but not lunch money...) and nothing like enough the weeks he didn't remember. We ended up 'smoothing', eating less than we needed the weeks mum paid to get more the weeks dad paid and we'd have to get lunches and bus out of barely enough for the bus. Didn't tell mum because we didn't want to stress her, no reason for it as he definitely had enough money he just resented paying for us. I remember the absolute joy if I'd been really careful and had collected up 9x5p to buy a millionaire shortbread, they're still my favourite.

As adults we barely have a relationship with him. This is financial abuse of them, and of you by proxy. Don't trash talk him, but I'd let you children help make him responsible as pp suggested. It will help them in the long run to know who their dad is.

Ridemeginger · 08/09/2023 18:55

@DietCokeAddict19 Good job. Pack up his stuff, so when he returns, he can either go straight away and stay in one of his properties, or use his considerable income to get an AirBnB. Get your tax credits claim sorted asap - get it all filled out now, and send it as soon as he has gone. That's fantastic that you have secure housing, it sounds like you have a supportive wider family who have helped you. Don't squander that advantage. You don't need someone who behaves no better than a shitty roommate taking advantage of your goodwill and passivity, and paying you the bear minimum while they rake it in on their own properties.

Chris002 · 08/09/2023 18:51

Maybe just do them a packed lunch everyday ?

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:41

Have you actually sent the ex your figures to show that you have paid more? If you haven't, do it. And either way, contact CMS. So what if he goes ballistic? What difference will it make? He's used you and your family and more or less stolen from you, and lied to you and continues to lie to you. What are you afraid of? Where is the woman that started off with her own house and a supportive family? She must have had something about her. You need her to come out from wherever she's been hiding - because your kids need her.

Thank you for this. I really needed to read it.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 08/09/2023 18:41

What a prince he is!

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:37

Ridemeginger · 08/09/2023 18:26

What is to stop you telling your current partner tonight that it is over, and he has 7 days to move out?

He is travelling abroad for work for 2 weeks tomorrow so I can't do it tonight. But I will put plans in place for when he gets back.

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:36

N27 · 08/09/2023 13:59

Could you just top up on a Tuesday evening enough for your days on Wednesdays and Thursdays?

I really like this idea, thanks for suggesting it. I think it could really work.

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:35

Lolapusht · 08/09/2023 13:20

Please rethink your current situation.

Your current partner earns what, x5.5 times what you do and he insists on 50:50 then somehow manages to rename on that? Does he also insist on paying for just what he uses as there’s more of you and you’d be paying it anyway and you have somehow ended up thinking he’s got a point?

You are allowed to have boundaries and terms in a relationship, as is he. You are both free to accept the other person’s terms or to decide you don’t want a relationship on those terms.

The absolute minimum I’d be asking for is that he makes up the shortfall he’s responsible for since he moved in. How much does he contribute and how much is he saving? Does he think of cheaper things to do so you can afford your 50% share or does he still want to do the expensive activities that you find financially difficult?

Him saving for both of your retirements is a nonsense.

How is that being managed? Do you have access to the account it’s in? How was the calculation done to work out how much would be saved each month. Are there any necessary expenses that are being overlooked in order for him to squirrel away his money? Do you get a say in how it’s invested or when it will be used? Are you similar ages?

50:50 for expenses isn’t always fair, especially when one of you is earning over £100k compared to a PT mum.

Tell your EXDH that he is now responsible for paying for school dinner (and any other out of pocket expenses) and to let you know when they’re paid and you’ll transfer him your share. He’s got the spare cash lying around so won’t actually miss £700 (I’d pay him my 50% weekly, but that’s just me 😬).

He is a selfish arse, completely lacking in decency. Take his arse to CMS. He can cry about it in his million pound house 🙄

So current partner pays half of the monthly outgoings (actually just over half, currently he pays £550 and I pay £450 - we needed more money per month but I couldn't increase it by as much as him so we settled on that). The house was bought by my dad, so I don't have a mortgage. He rents out the house that he lived in before we got together, in a city 3 hours away, and I'm somewhat ashamed to say that his income from that is £1800, but I don't see a penny of it. He pays no rent here, just the £550 as above.

I know reading it back it's awful. He previously was letting the house on an ad hoc basis so it wasn't always occupied so I never knew how much he was bringing in from it. Then he agreed a longer term let which is when I found out how much he is benefitting by living with me. On the flip side I lost my tax credits when he moved in, so I'm down by about £300 a month, maybe more, and he is £1250 up.

The "retirement" is the properties that he owns and rents out. So it's not money in an account, although he has lots of those, or anything I have access to. And (stupidly) I only twigged fairly recently that if income from those properties is our/his retirement income, then he is expecting to still live in a house paid for by me when we retire.

I sound like a total mug and complete idiot. I don't even know how it's got to this point. But I completely agree it's not ok, and to whoever asked about what I find attractive in someone who treats me and my kids like this, the answer is not a lot.

OP posts:
Ridemeginger · 08/09/2023 18:26

What is to stop you telling your current partner tonight that it is over, and he has 7 days to move out?

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:25

Mumof4plusbonus · 08/09/2023 10:08

Try to claim cms. I’m usually in disagreement with cms when it’s 50:50 but in this case I would be all for it. You shouldn’t need to beg for money, it’s not for you it’s for his children and it shouldn’t even need said, let alone begged. Do your children want 50:50? This whole fair thing- fair on who? Because it’s not about you or ex but the kids. I wouldn’t be leaving them without lunch though. I get where people are coming from but I just couldn’t and I suspect your ex could and would.
Secondly get rid of the 2nd using ah you have tied yourself to. And then claim your top up benefits. Then look into why you choose these people (not judging, I need to do the same myself, this things are easier to see on the outside). You need to start doing what best for you and the children.

I'm not sure my eldest wants 50/50, my youngest prefers his Dad (can't see past the Disney stuff, the fact his Dad won't say no to stuff, he gets to eat whatever he wants etc etc) so youngest wouldn't want more time with me. Youngest very easily influenced by his Dad, and because it's me who ended things he's been fed a sob story by his dad about me splitting up the family and it not being what ExH wanted. I'm the bad guy. Probably why I'm still being punished by ExH.

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 08/09/2023 18:25

So stop, OP. Stop being the safety net. You are taking on responsibilities that are his.

Let your kids have no lunch money - it won't kill them for one day and they can complain to him about it, not you. Maybe warn them to take some extra fruit in or something during the transition but make it clear that you won't be continuing that way.

He sounds like a useless twat. A useless twat with, unfortunately, enough money to throw around to please the kids.

They'll see through it, sooner or later. Hopefully sooner, if they come home from school starving!!

CapEBarra · 08/09/2023 18:24

OP, your ex is a tight dick. Your current partner is a tight dick. Go to CMS for money from your ex, and bin that freeloader you’re living with now.

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 18:21

Tinkerbyebye · 08/09/2023 09:44

Why haven’t you learnt your lesson?

Just get some self respect and dump him you can do much better

I know. I'm annoyed with myself. But it just trickled in over time and then suddenly I'm sitting here selling old clothes online to make a few extra pence and he is setting up another 10k savings account.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread