Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That it's not my responsibility to be chasing ExH to pay school dinner money?

189 replies

DietCokeAddict19 · 07/09/2023 21:30

ExH and I split up 6 years ago, we have 2 DC who are at secondary school.

ExH is a high earner - approx £100k to my £20k.

Up until last year ExH paid child maintenance (£500 per month) but that stopped as the kids are with us each 50% of the time. It was agreed that we would each pay half of the costs associated with the children (uniform, school trips, school dinners etc) but it almost always falls to me to either buy these things, or I end up having to ask/remind him to pay for them.

Last year over the year I have just totted it up and I paid £700 for school dinners (!!!), he didn't pay anything.

He has the same school app as me so he can see when their balance is running low, but he seemingly doesn't look at it or ignores the reminders to pay. So I end up paying because I don't want the kids to go without lunch. I sent him a message before the term started to highlight that I paid for all school lunches last year and could he top up their balances, to which I got a shirty reply of "I'm sure I put money in last year" and a promise he would top up. He hasn't. So I have because DS1 has 65p in his account and couldn't buy lunch tomorrow otherwise.

Despite ExH having the kids half the time he still seems to be fucking Disney dad and I end up having to be the responsible one and sort everything out. Part of me wonders if he does it on purpose and likes me having to come to him and ask him for money, but I'm fucking tired of it. I hate asking for money and part of me wishes I could pay it all myself so I don't have to ask, but he earns so much more than me and I can't afford it all now that my monthly child maintenance has stopped.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 11/09/2023 07:44

As part of evidencing it's 50:50 nights but shared care you can demonstrate who has paid how much for school trips and lunches and how it hasn't been 50:50.

wildwestpioneer · 11/09/2023 07:26

I have 50/50 with my ex and we separate everything. We have a set of school uniforms at each house, shoes, PE kit, casual clothes etc so all she has to do is being her school bags between houses. Die any school trips I pay the school 50%, usually over scopay or something similar so my ex then has to pay the rest otherwise she doesn't go. The same for school dinners, I put 50% in and then he has to do the same. We did give her packed lunches for a while which was even easier as he 'had' to do them when she was with him.

Sometimes, as difficult as it seems you have to force the issue.

As for cms, put a claim in and see what happens. Let him kick off if he wants to, your £000's of pounds down which I can't see you getting back so again, force the issue.

catherinecooksondog · 10/09/2023 22:15

Though saying that you may have to suck up buying not just lunches but everything else, as Child Benefit is meant to pay for everything the child needs - anything extra the payee contributes is a “bonus”. Might still leave you financially better off though…

catherinecooksondog · 10/09/2023 22:12

Sorry if there are other posts on this already, I don’t have time to skim to check! But if you’re the one in receipt of the Child Benefit, you might still be able to make a claim through CMS. If he is the recipient then you can’t. Even if you earn over Child Benefit threshold you can still be the “person in receipt” without receiving any money…

If you’re 50/50 overnights with no maintenance, the point is you have “equal day-to-day care”. But it doesn’t sound like this is the case at all!! For this he would co-manage doctors, dentist, optician, recreational activities etc. If you do all this and receive the Child Benefit I think you should be able to get some. It’s out of order when he earns so much. What a prick.

Beexxxx · 10/09/2023 10:20

Gross. As someone that was constantly reminded how much we (me and brother) cost him in child support this gives the same energy. Only having them for exactly 50% so he doesn’t have to pay YOU anything. My dad believed he paid for all ours and mums holidays and anything nice we had when my mum would scrimp and save and go without to give us these experiences.

Belle001982 · 10/09/2023 04:29

Also the current partner sounds like he’s getting a free ride whilst you’re scrabbling around for pennies.
I’d be very wary of letting him stay in a home I own, even his paltry contribution a month could be considered upkeep of the home and he could potentially end up costing you a few more pennies than he does now.
A friend of mine once had a girlfriend move into a house he owned, she never financially contributed to bills in the 10 months she was there but she did tidy up and help decorate and when their relationship ended she made a claim on the house and she actually got a pay out, not a lot (think it was 8k) so either new partner needs to increase his share of the bills to make it worth the risk or he needs to get hot stepping down the road somewhere else.
He’s taking the piss and I can almost guarantee he knows it, you don’t end up with a property portfolio by being dumb but he’s stepping on your back to do it!
Don’t let it happen!

exclusion · 10/09/2023 04:22

Why can't he be responsible for paying for lunch for one of the kids and then you do the other!

PTSDBarbiegirl · 10/09/2023 04:16

Review your agreements re exH with a lawyer.

Belle001982 · 10/09/2023 04:04

He should pay and be reasonable about sharing costs, but personally I think it sounds like he’s using non payment on the school dinner app as a little power trip.
I would definitely put a claim in for CMS just do it, at least you’ll know and have an outside eye cast on the financial arrangements and give some formality to the issue. If you’re still getting lumbered with most of the costs how is this truly 50/50 I found a useful piece of info about calculating maintenance when there is 50/50 care and it’s not just how many nights you have them that makes the difference apparently.
https://watson-thomas.co.uk/help-and-advice/31-help-and-advice-children/182-child-maintenance-when-you-have-an-equal-share-in-parenting

Child Maintenance when you have an equal share in parenting

Even if your children share their time equally between you and your ex-partner, you may still be liable to pay or receive child maintenance. Find out more.

https://watson-thomas.co.uk/help-and-advice/31-help-and-advice-children/182-child-maintenance-when-you-have-an-equal-share-in-parenting

CKMc2b · 10/09/2023 03:02

CherryMaDeara · 07/09/2023 21:32

Yanbu, what a cunt. Could you take him to court? There’s such a disparity on your earnings that he should pay you maintenance even though he has 50/50.

Absolutely agree with this and I was going to write something along similar lines.

Cherrysoup · 09/09/2023 22:49

Gently, OP, you have got yourself into a relationship that isn’t beneficial for you.

I love the idea of only putting in money for your 2 days, surely your idiot ex will have to cough up. Please go back to cms, the disparity in income must count for something.

Bean83ts · 09/09/2023 22:35

I would be demanding that he pays a min of £500 a month if he wants to live there or tell him to sling his hook!

chair1960 · 09/09/2023 21:34

You were not and are not a fool. you simply did the best you could at the time with the understanding that you had at the time. Now you have more experience this is the right time to set your boundaries very firmly, he is taking advantage of you. I wish you all the best.

Dotcomma · 09/09/2023 20:14

So he states that everything should be 50/50 and then doesn't cough up - typical wanker - do as i say not as i do brigade. He's taking the piss.
Get a claim put back in with CMS & try for it backdated - even if they refuse it was worth a try.
Been in your shoes so I know exactly what it's like. I wouldn't put it on the kids to have to ask him for lunch money - he knows the score and he knows you won't let them go without food so he's just keeping his foot on your head. I'm not sure school would get involved but you could put them in the picture and see if they have any suggestions - it won't be the first time they've dealt with an arsehole parent xx

DunePeyton · 09/09/2023 18:52

Stop school dinners and do packed lunch and ex will have to fall in line and make lunches also.

Dottydol · 09/09/2023 18:44

I’m in a similar position- 50/50 (or shared overnights but I pay for uniform swimming lessons and rugby class - I’m on UC and he gives me 191£ / month - he is a senior lawyer

Rosenelle40 · 09/09/2023 18:40

Yes..it's both your responsibility that your children are clothed and roof overhead ..plus uniform...plus school dinners ...however ...getting to Disney ...life isn't like that ...is there anyway you can downsize? Like ...sadly move somewhere where it's cheaper for you to live ? A million miles away from him and his family ( this also means your links ...social life and work) ...or go to your employer and say that you work hard and at breaking point ...is there a work from home policy ? Or they could redraft you to an office further afield? If so I tell the ex parents in law that you have to move ...due to costs...you hate to do this...but it's no longer an option...maybe they talk to stupid head ..aka your ex? And advise this is not what they want...you need ppl in your corner ...it's hard ..I know single mother for 14 years ...paid for my divorce from a gambler who turned up with expensive no hin effective gifts that did not amount to food ..shoes or clothes and £12 salary with a £80k mortgage ...he was self employed so no child support ...I got there ...and 60 years of age now ..he has nothing but I have honesty and integrity that fish fingers on toast are a delicacy 🤣 he has nothing and my kids are 30 ...he doesn't have contact which is sad but they do have contact with ex grandma 👍

WhyArePiratesCalledPirates · 09/09/2023 15:58

Tell the school.
Explain its his responsibility this year.
Ask them to contact him.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 09/09/2023 12:10

Send him a statement/invoice detailing all the dinner money and who has paid what ( since this arrangement started) Note exactly how much he has paid.
Ask to be reimbursed what what he should have paid. Detail how you have to pay at the last minute because he hasn't and how this means that the kids are constantly worried about having to deal with this at school themselves or go hungry and you cannot ignore this when they contact you.
Ask why does he think its ok to constantly place this burden on the children.

In future he will be responsible for school dinner payments and should set up a direct debit and you will reimburse him. Give him the DD details or a form from the school if he hasn't already got them.

Send it by email and recorded delivery.

Send a letter to the school informing them of this situation and a copy of your statement/invoice to him. Ask them to contact him directly.

DietCokeAddict19 · 09/09/2023 09:31

BalancingTree · 09/09/2023 01:50

No advice but I feel your pain. I have begun claiming child support for first time in 10 years as I have always covered EVERYTHING. I am now being counter sued for his mileage to pick the child up from school. This is a guy who will send the child home with no shoes on so determined he is for me to not benefit in anyway from anything he has purchased for our kid. I’m entitled to $110 per month- about £50 and he has no obligation to pay, the debt is just accruing.

the system is totally broken. It relies on the decent parent doing the right thing by their kids with no accountability for a parent who is selfish and bitter.

I hear your pain.

Wow that's shocking! I'm so sorry for what you are having to deal with, and your child too. What is wrong with people?!

OP posts:
Clarie83 · 09/09/2023 08:39

Just order school meals for the days you have the kids, leave him to make packed lunches when he has them

BalancingTree · 09/09/2023 01:50

No advice but I feel your pain. I have begun claiming child support for first time in 10 years as I have always covered EVERYTHING. I am now being counter sued for his mileage to pick the child up from school. This is a guy who will send the child home with no shoes on so determined he is for me to not benefit in anyway from anything he has purchased for our kid. I’m entitled to $110 per month- about £50 and he has no obligation to pay, the debt is just accruing.

the system is totally broken. It relies on the decent parent doing the right thing by their kids with no accountability for a parent who is selfish and bitter.

I hear your pain.

Sleepyallday · 08/09/2023 22:18

There’s a difference between equal nights and shared care. If you partner is having the children 50:50 nights AND sharing care e.g. arranging and attending doctor’s appointments, dropping to/collecting from clubs, dentist appointments etc. then no maintenance is payable regardless of earnings.

However, in a case of 50:50 nights but not shared care that is where the online calculator comes in.

It would be worth calling CMS just to get advice.

DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 22:11

I used to get about £300 per month in tax credits (although some months seems to be a lot more than that, not sure why). So at a minimum it's about £14k I've lost.

OP posts:
DietCokeAddict19 · 08/09/2023 22:03

Lolapusht · 08/09/2023 21:52

“Beneficial interest”. Can be probable where the non-owner has contributed to the mortgage so not sure if he could prove it in your case.

Is the house on your name or your dad’s?

How many properties does he own and how much income does he get from them? How long have you lived together? In case he turns into a Super Wanker when you tell him what’s about to happen, maybe total up how much tax credit you’ve lost as a result of living with him.

The house is in my name.

He's got 3 properties. All have mortgages on them that he is paying. In terms of income I'm really not sure what that would total per month. At a guess, approx 3k? And his income from work is about 7k per month currently, although that sometimes changes a bit and that's the upper end of normal.

Will try and remember how much I used to get in tax credits!

OP posts: